12 ms·
There's No DRM in JPEG – Let's Keep It That Way
- togusa 11y agoWebP anyone?
- Spivak 11y agoWouldn't this DRM require every implementation of the JPEG standard to honor the DRM or am I missing something?
- TD-Linux 11y agoYes it would - but that's how all DRM systems work, plus an attempt to make the image unreadable to "unauthorized" JPEG implementations.
- bediger4000 11y agoHow, if some Future JPEG (FJPEG) is a standard, does one make a standard FJPEG image unreadable to unauthorized FJPEG implementations? Either the standard itself has to be kept secret or the FJPEG implementation has to contain some secret, right? If the standard is kept secret, by maybe charging a tidy sum for it, and getting all buyers to sign an NDA in blood, we'll all have fewer implementations of FJPEG viewers. There would probably be no "open source" implementations of FJPEG. We would all loose, as the market for FJPEG viewers has barriers to entry, and therefore would serve buyers poorly. That's standard, Free Market economics. If FJPEG viewers have to contain some secret (an algorithm or a key both come to mind as things that have happened in the past) the same sorts of things happen - barriers to entry to sell in the market, higher costs, fewer options to consumers. Of course the 3rd option is to legally mandate some kind of overall DRM at the operating system level, which would have much the same effects, except that we'd have a narrow choice of Windows or Mac OS, with maybe a larger choice of FJPEG viewers. All of these options should be repugnant to Free Market believers such as myself. I predict the Republican Congress will laugh this out the door.
- airza 11y agoJust like they did with the DMCA, right?
- bediger4000 11y agoI'm sorry, but could you elaborate on this? I'm not understanding the connection with DMCA.
- TD-Linux 11y agoYeah, those are the only options. The second option is what Blu-Ray and EME currently do, for example. But yeah, basically no one is going to use this ever.
- nickodell 11y agoNo, that would be unenforceable. If your implementation doesn't honor the DRM, they won't provide you with the encryption keys in the first place.
- MichaelGG 11y agoThen you end up with a key distro problem. And unless the idea is to do it with hardware-protected keys, it's pretty much DOA for such low-bandwidth, simple-format as a still picture. Otherwise, as an example, Firefox wouldn't be able to decode these images without some plugin. And that plugin would be just as subject to key-dumping.
- ekimekim 11y agoYes, all DRM systems are inherently impossible to make fully secure with only local data. However, several other options exist: * Needing to contact an external server to view an image (of course, you could always take the opportunity to save the now-viewable image then share it) * Charging a large fee / legal contracts for the information on how to decode (security through obscurity) * Making circumvention illegal and enforcing this with fines or jail time. This is probably the only option that "actually works" as you've turned the technical problem into a social problem. People would still break it, but you could simply arrest them if they try to help others do the same.
- MichaelGG 11y agoI'm not sure these approaches work for images. Certainly web comics could require special clients even now, yet they don't. I'm guessing they want the ability for their pictures to still work normally, but "without saving".
- ekimekim 11y agoYes, that none of these systems will ever actually work is the point ;)
- 11y ago
- mzs 11y agoNot necessarily, for example a few MSBs of Y, Cr, and Cb DC and AC could be encoded with the current JFIF markers and new ones used the for rest in an encrypted representation. In that manner a current decoder could produce a lower fidelity version still: http://www.jpeg.org/items/20150910_privacy_security_summary.html http://www.jpeg.org/items/20150910_privacy_security_summary....
- anon4 11y agoThis seems like a technical solution to what's a political problem. Those don't usually work out as one would like, or worse, get enshrined in some standard that doesn't solve anything and which makes things worse for the few people that have supporting programs.
- tinalumfoil 11y agoJPEG DRM is not a political problem. It's more of a copyright problem although, more accurately, it's a digital content management problem, because content doesn't have to be copyrighted to use DRM. For something to be political it can't just be related to government (because everything is related to government in some way), or even managed by government. For that word to have any meaning at all, it needs to be a more direct reference to government and politics. And technical solutions to actual political problems have worked great. The recent revamping of government websites has made information more accessible to the public than ever. I can't imagine Obamacare holding much value if it wasn't possible to make healthcare.gov so people could actually navigate through the complexities.
- idlewords 11y agoPolitical problems are any that involve issues of power and control. The issue of who gets to decide what you view on a computer is an eminently political one.
- oxide 11y ago>For that word to have any meaning at all, it needs to be a more direct reference to government and politics. wait...what? politics are everywhere: at home, at the office, in your local bowling league. it doesn't apply exclusively to government.
- angersock 11y agoMore attempted fencing off of the commons. Yay.
- angersock 11y agoMore attempted fencing off of the commons. Yay.
- Nadya 11y agoWould this stop me from screenshotting the image, saving it as a .png, and distributing that? Because I and many people would do just that. Sure, the DRM might work for my grandparents and a few other non-techies but over time I can teach my grandparents how to screenshot an image and others would catch on. People would even make chrome apps to "click a picture and resave it in a shareable format". I'm not sure what this DRM would solve, if anything, other than pissing off users and giving photographers and other digital-sharing artists a false sense of security.
- murbard2 11y agoAh, but the JPEG displayer would only run on a Trusted system, whose screenshot function honors DRM. You could try to snap a picture of your screen with your digital camera, but the camera manufacturer also embedded DRM inside the camera. I'm not convinced he analogue hole won't ever be plugged.
- lfam 11y ago> I'm not convinced he analogue hole won't ever be plugged. The analogue holes for visual media are the two holes in your skull where your eyeballs sit. The analogue hole won't be plugged until you can implement a secure path into the human brain.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 11y ago"Until" being the operative word here. Electronic implants are an active area of development, and it's only a matter of time before media companies see them as a way to further advance DRM protections.
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoYou just reminded me of a properly funny UnNews story from back in the days: http://uncyclopedia.wikia.com/wiki/UnNews:RIAA_CEO_discusses_the_analog_hole http://uncyclopedia.wikia.com/wiki/UnNews:RIAA_CEO_discusses... (Probably needs a trigger warning in this day and age.)
- atom_enger 11y agoCouldn't we just stop using JPEG? I realize this is a can of worms, but it's an option, right?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vvpan 11y agoBut why? It seems to be a decent format. And what's the other option?
- pmalynin 11y agoPNG and WebP
- scrollaway 11y agoFLIF is very promising too: http://flif.info/ http://flif.info/
- dyladan 11y agoFLIF is not really a format so much as an experiment. There isn't a spec that I can find, nor is there any sort of formal description of the format. Right now, the only available spec is the source code and that leaves a lot of open-ended questions about what to do about inconsistencies in implementations. I hope it develops into something good, but for now it doesn't seem a viable option.
- dasfasf 11y agoIf we're going to use WebP anyway, we might as well drop PNG too in favor of the lossless mode. I don't know of any downsides to this. But mandatory chroma subsampling means WebP can't completely replace JPEG.
- atom_enger 11y agoSure it's a decent format and it's quite widespread. However, if the committee decides to make the format worse by incorporating DRM, we can easily decide to move away from that format. Easier said than done, but still an option.
- scotty79 11y agoIf we could get rid of copyright there'd be much less resistance toward embedding information about who created the work. I'd very much like that we could abolish fines for copying but keep fines for stripping author signature from work, or not propagating original author signature to works that are derived. This way you could have a trail to reach actual author of the part of work that you find awesome to commission some new work from him. This could be much more valuable for way more people than current copyright schemes that only seem to benefit fatcats.
- atom_enger 11y agoBut your proposal doesn't help the archaic business models stay afloat. They're fighting us and the progression of technology to stay relevant :(. Great idea though.
- graeme 11y agoI write books. I publish the contents for free online, too. But I still want copyright. If there were none, someone else could take my work, attribute it, put it on some SEO'd site and outrank me. What recourse would I have? Very few people are going to find the original source, search it, get past the SEO and find my site. And zero readers have commissioned a work. I make money, but not that way. Trust me, copyright isn't just for fatcats. Though I suspect it's mostly fatcats who propose unreasonable applications of copyright.
- anonymfus 11y agoFor public domain content first search results are usually non-profit online libraries like Wikibooks and Project Gutenberg. In Russia where illegal book sharing is widespread most popular piracy libraries now are non-profits like Flibusta and Library Genesis.
- graeme 11y agoHow does that help the original author monetize their work? I don't care whether the first result is non-profit or not. I care whether it's me. If I can't monetize works, I won't make them, I'll do something else. Are their Russian authors making money with working business models under their system of non-enforced copyright?
- endgame 11y agoI'm so glad I grew up in an era where people's only concern was making things work AT ALL. Trying to make things work for licensed users only, or only for certain devices, or anything else is just bullshit.
- sliverstorm 11y agoA different way of looking at this is, we figured out how to make things work at all. Now people are trying to figure out how to get paid for the work they do on those cool new things. Struggling to make sure you get paid is nothing new, either.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIt's not struggling to make sure you get paid that's the problem - it's people fighting to get paid more, and people who starts expecting to get paid for things they weren't being paid before. Both of those problems, reluctance to accept that not everything you do will bring in monetary compensation, are greed that drives invention of things like DRM. The only worse thing is people who notice something is cool and decide to come in and monetize it.
- chii 11y agoThe choice I see they have is either stop doing it anymore, or enforce payment. Continuing to do it with out pay, whether they were originally paid or not is no longer viable.
- Pxtl 11y agoTo be fair, ask webcomics guys and photographers about piracy - they get the worst of it. Big companies that would never dream of encouraging you to pirate videos and songs functionally encourage you to swap images around constantly, stripped and re-watermarked and whatnot. So yes, I do feel a bit bad for small independant artists who watch the standards bodies work themselves into a fury to protect video and audio content while they have to deal with Google Image Search and 9gag.
- MichaelGG 11y agoProtecting a single image is far more difficult. Video and audio are "protectable" to the extent they are because there is a really low expectation of how they have to work. Start playback, stop playback - that's about it. No one expects to pre-render, use video as a buffer for other things, etc. You can realistically render video direct to the screen via hardware, in a protected path. Doing the same for still images adds a ton of work for little payoff. And it still doesn't prevent anything. At least in video if the system remains uncracked, it's hard to make a copy. You can't just point a video camera at a screen and get good results. Whereas for a still image? Pretty easy to reconstruct the exact pixels, 100%. Anyways, this is doomed entirely. They provide the case of social media sites stripping off metadata. Well guess what, if your DRM is gonna prevent them from modifying the image, it's gonna prevent them from loading the image in the first place. Even if the JPEG folks add it, it has zero chance of going anywhere. You'd need support from the hardware, OS, and on up. (Like video has.)
- makira 11y agoA video is just a succession of images. An image is a video with only one frame. You could use the exact same system that protects videos to protect an image, by making a video with one frame of very long (infinite) duration.
- zapt02 11y agoWhich was incidentally a technique used by early blu-ray rippers. (Making a screenshot of each frame.)
- EvanAnderson 11y agoHow long until this is used to lock down the independent "publishing" of images? This seems like a great foundation upon which to build software ecosystems that discourage user-generated content w/o the imprimatur of an authorized publisher attached.
- walterbell 11y agoEspecially when combined with new copyright/DRM laws from TPP/TTIP/TISA, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10363500 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10363500
- throwaway2048 11y agocountdown until mozilla folds like wet cardboard
- bytesandbots 11y agolike it did for Adobe Primetime CDM
- gue5t 11y agothis comment is too real
- LoSboccacc 11y agoIsn't this problem better solved by watermarking anyway? People want their work distribute publicly but want attribution to attract users. Buyers need a redistributable license most probably as they are interested in the media most probably as part of some communication effort. Drm is not going to help after buyer redistribute the purchased work in any way, especially if there is a medium conversion involved - i.e. printed issue.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoWatermarking is either too easy to cut out or damages the image. I can understand the reason they want to look for other solutions, for the same reason I would pay for a tool that reliably cleared watermarks out of pictures - not because I want to steal content, but because I want to consume it in high quality.
- impostervt 11y agoOne of my side projects is a photo water marking SaaS. I was surprised when people actually started paying for it years ago, as I figured, "there's a ton of watermarking apps out there". But it turns out there's a lot of demand from amateur and semi-pro photographers who believe, rightly or wrongly, that they're being ripped off (and want a simple way to watermark their photos). For pros, There are other services out there that actively scan the internet looking for infringers and send DMCA takedown, or similar, notices. These services are generally two pricey for the type of customers my side-project has. I guess my point is - there is a pretty big demand to protect images online. I suspect DRM will end up being implement in some form or another.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYeah, some amateur photograhers are silly like that (source: I know a few), they behave like little children - shoot some photos, put a big watermark on them to both show pride and make sure nobody "rips them off", and then get mightly annoyed anyway when somebody reposts their photo on Facebook without linking back, because they thought it was cool. Only few later realize that nobody really cares who made a photo (unless they're known to make more quality photos) - a work created has social value on its own, and holding it to yourself only because you're an author is actually little antisocial (also, if you don't fight, people tend to appreciate the work as a gift and will often happily attribute it to you themselves; but I digress).
- bytesandbots 11y agoDRM is protection of content from the consumer itself. The consumer is going to consume the data through an analogue channel. This channel will always be the source of extracting redistributable content. The very premise of DRM rules out any 100%-solution and sets it as obfuscation. I feel it might be stupid idea but it is not impractical. The effort of extracting content should be less than the maximum value that can be generated by redistribution. Thus, returns from piracy diminishes as you go from softwares to video to image to text. The effort of extracting an image is too easy via analogue hole. This is assuming an open technology ecosystem not exactly the RMS world but at least Linus or perhaps Mozilla. The enforcers of the DRM do the sensible thing of spreading their proprietary black boxes to as much people, until, they can shut down their doors to the rest of community. That is precisely when certain open source foundations too had to back down. That is how you can enjoy netflix only within your chrome browser. What bothers me is why are they trying to make it into the standards. If it is built into the standards, it will be built into the downloaders as well. Remember what happened with HLS AES encryption, it is now built into the video downloaders itself. While I understand benefits of standardization, how it has given shape to tech, it might not be true with something so un-technical as DRM. If you do want obfuscation, at least do not make it standard procedure. You know very well that the strongest DRM can not be technically secure.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> The very premise of DRM rules out any 100%-solution and sets it as obfuscation. > I feel it might be stupid idea but it is not impractical. They are willing to fuck everything up to extract more royalties. Don't worry that you can't have a 100%-solution DRM now. When we get to the level of advanced optical implants or even brainchips, I'm willing to bet MAFIAA will be one of the biggest investors, in order to sneak in a DRM processor directly into your head and then force you to consume content only through legal and paid-for MAFIAA-certified brain chips.
- GhotiFish 11y agoThat's increadibly cynical, but if cybernetics ever become a thing, I think it's painfully obvious what will happen. Humanity is going to learn some very hard lessons if that class of technologies ever pans out.