11 ms·
America's newest nuclear plant shows why nuclear power is dying in the U.S
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Shivetya 11y agowell four new reactors are being built in the South East, two in South Carolina and two in Georgia. They are scheduled to be online in 2018 and 2019 adding about 1200mw per reactor. Far from dead they do however show that we aren't even trying to be at the forefront of the technology anymore. While the AP1000 reactors are more modern they are still old school in many senses. We still need a good solid base power source, renewable sources tend to be highly weather dependent and cover a large area to generate power. It is not reasonable to claim we can store it through batteries to replace the power currently provided by coal, gas, and nuclear. Unless some breakthrough storage means comes out its not going to happen
- afterburner 11y agoBatteries are improving all the time though. https://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-that-battery-energy-density-improves-5-8-per-year https://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-that-battery-energy-density... Not only that, batteries aren't the only way to store renewable energy. There's dams, thermal salts, and others. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_storage#Renewable_energy_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_storage#Renewable_energ... Renewable energy is an area that is constantly at the forefront of technology, unlike nuclear. That is one of the reasons it is so much more promising.
- fludlight 11y agoThe way the regulatory and economic winds are blowing, renewables have become the new baseline generating capacity, with fast-spinup combined cycle natural gas as marginal capacity. Renewables may be weather dependent, but it is hard to argue with a 20+ year lifespan, minimal maintenance, and, most importantly, zero marginal cost. Nuclear and coal are starting to fade, with vastly more retirements than new construction, outside of the deep south for nuclear (because let's do the opposite of the liberals) and coal producing states (because jobs).
- mikeyouse 11y ago> They are scheduled to be online in 2018 and 2019. Unfortunately as is universally the case with nuclear construction (see the debacle in the UK as well), both reactors recently announced significant delays of ~18 months and at least an additional billion in cost overruns. There may be an economical way to build nuclear but we clearly don't have it. http://www.power-eng.com/articles/2015/05/delays-at-vogtle-v-c-summer-still-not-threatening-nuclear-ptc.html http://www.power-eng.com/articles/2015/05/delays-at-vogtle-v... http://www.bizjournals.com/charlotte/blog/energy/2015/03/utility-says-latest-delays-to-georgia-nuclear.html http://www.bizjournals.com/charlotte/blog/energy/2015/03/uti...
- burnte 11y agoI'll keep saying nuclear is one of the best technologies we can use for power generation. In addition to the fact that the falures at Fukushima, TMI, and Chernobyl were all caused by HUMANS interfering with engineering plans and systems, or not being trained proeprly (Fukushima designers called for higher seawalls, overrulled; TMI was human error massively compounding a simple mechanical failure which could have been recovered from; Chernobyl had key safety systems disabled). There are several newer, much safer designs that when used with proper training and engineers being listened to, can provide us with very clean power with stability and land use that solar and wind can't match. You combine that with wind/solar/water during the day, and you have yourself an amazingly clean power grid that works 24/7. I was 1, living in Pittsburgh. My father was called in among many others to help determine how to recover.
- afterburner 11y agoThe human problem will never go away, though. Ultimately, someone is going to want to cheap out on something, and will be unable or unwilling to consider very-low-probability catastrophic events, probably partly because people are so bad at thinking about very-low-probability events.
- redblacktree 11y agoEven relatively high-probability, catastrophic risks are under assessed. Witness all the tailgaters on the highway.
- oroup 11y agoThe problem is we don't even know what it means to deal with waste for 10,000 years. If the Romans had used nuclear power, we'd still be guarding their waste. And they likely would have put it somewhere really out of the way - like London. If some of the technologies that can transmute waste intro shorter lived stuff come to fruition, fantastic. But until then nuclear power is just the worst kind of deficit spending, kicking the unknown and huge costs way into the future.
- 11y ago
- DennisP 11y agoLast week I sat in a meeting with representatives from half a dozen startups attempting GenIV fission reactors, along with a public utility that's investing in that type of work. They said their main problem was the NRC. It has regulations designed for large light-water reactors. If you're attempting, say, a small modular molten-salt reactor, you have to pay several hundred million dollars up front for an extensive, detailed design and regulations to fit. Then the NRC makes one binary decision: if you're lucky they approve you, in which case all you have so far is a piece of paper that allows you to build something. If you're unlucky they deny and leave you with nothing. Not surprisingly, it's hard to find investors in this environment. They said if we at least had a phased approach, so they can get some assurance for investors, it'd be an improvement. Even better would be a more flexible regime similar to Canada's.
- musesum 11y agoBill Gates is investing in LFTR, as per http://www.the-weinberg-foundation.org/2013/07/23/bill-gates-nuclear-company-explores-molten-salt-reactors-thorium/ http://www.the-weinberg-foundation.org/2013/07/23/bill-gates... They are tweaking the process. I wonder if that has anything to do with the NRC?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI admit I'm someone who has asked the NRC to come up with shutdown plans for every existing commercial reactor, considering most are already unable to compete on cost with renewables. Disgustingly enough, the US taxpayer is going to be on the hook for cleanup costs for each and every one of these sites.
- DennisP 11y agoI think you'd be happy with the cleanup procedures for some of these newer reactors. For example, ThorCon and Terrestrial Energy use sealed units they can just ship back to the factory after a few years for decommissioning.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago
- musesum 11y agoIt's not dying: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9M__yYbsZ4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9M__yYbsZ4
- vernie 11y agoCool, when can I look forward to a power plant using such a design?
- toomuchtodo 11y ago10 years and $2-4 billion later, if nothing goes wrong. Which is exactly why nuclear is dead.
- chc 11y agoThat's what worries me. This "dead" technology still contributes a lot more to the United States' energy budget than solar and wind combined, despite strong resistance to nuclear and everybody pushing renewables like crazy. It looks like the winner of this fight — between a technology people are eager to declare "dead" and other technologies that are apparently stillborn — is fossil fuel.
- toomuchtodo 11y agohttp://www.npr.org/2015/09/10/319535020/coal-gas-nuclear-hydro-how-your-state-generates-power http://www.npr.org/2015/09/10/319535020/coal-gas-nuclear-hyd... Coal has been replaced by a combination of natural gas and renewables in every state. As more renewables come online, natural gas plants will run even less. I'm tired of humanity throwing money down the well that is the nuclear power industry. Pay for the damn turbines and panels already and be done with it (the US alone has enough wind energy potential for 10x its current energy use). Note: Wind is already so cheap, Exelon's CEO (who manages the largest commercial fleet of nuclear generators in the US) is threatening plant closings if they don't get a bailout. http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2013-02-08/business/ct-biz-0208-exelon-div--20130208_1_exelon-nuclear-plants-power-plants http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2013-02-08/business/ct-bi... The former Exelon CEO? Says that shutting down struggling nuclear power plants is the right thing to do. http://www.eenews.net/stories/1060022403 http://www.eenews.net/stories/1060022403 Do I care that natural gas is going to pick up the slack? Of course not. The natural gas boom won't last forever, prices will rise, and with coal no longer meeting EPA emissions requirements and nuclear plants decommissioned, there will only be one power source to pick up the slack: renewables.
- helper 11y agoThis is my favorite book on the state of atomic energy: http://www.amazon.com/Atomic-Accidents-Meltdowns-Disasters-Mountains/dp/1605986801 http://www.amazon.com/Atomic-Accidents-Meltdowns-Disasters-M.... The book looks at the history of atomic accidents from an engineering perspective right up to Fukushima. The author is a nuclear engineer and understands the systems he talks about. Interestingly I came away from a book about atomic disasters being pretty pro nuclear, at least more so than I was before reading the book. Here are my main take aways: - The US needs to start back up the waste reprocessing program. Jimmy Carter banned this in the hopes of setting a good example for other countries (one of the byproducts being plutonium). But everyone else continues to process nuclear waste except for the US and it just makes the waste storage problem that much harder. 95% of the fuel that comes out of a rector is harmless U-238. We should only be burying a tiny fraction of what we currently bury. - We need to start innovating beyond PWR and BWR reactors. Things like liquid metal fuel reactors have the nice property of not having to worry about them melting down because they are already melted.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoNot a very well informed article, but it starts from a bad premise and just follows it along. The big reveal of "But flaws in the program were becoming clear: nuclear plants were expensive to build, produced waste that was impossible to dispose of safely and generated power far more expensive than had been projected." Is not even wrong, but I don't expect the author to do any research about the costs of nuclear power, nor to track down cost inflators (regulatory delay, post start regulation changes) or disposal methods (reprocessing, vitrification, incineration) or cost per megawatt.
- douche 11y agoYou know, if we hadn't had such a "Nukes are bad, m'kay" moment in the 70s, we wouldn't be limping along with so many old, past-their-prime plants now, and there'd have been more incentive to continue refining designs for nuclear power. What plants we have are less efficient than they could be, and are pushing up against their designed lifetimes. Damn hippies
- Theodores 11y agoWrong. The Cold War was why we built the nucular power stations we did. The uranium in those tens of thousands of nucular weapons came from somewhere - nucular power plants. Electricity was a mere by-product. None of those power plants were viable without there being the aspect of the Cold War imperative. So it is the war-mongers and not the hippies to blame for whatever happened to nucular power.
- douche 11y agoYeah, the breeder reactors in the first generation were terrible and not good for much other than making A-bomb material. That doesn't really have anything to do with the dozens of nuke plants that were canceled in the 70s, at the height of the Cold War, and the virtual (and in some countries, legal) moratorium on new construction that was pushed by anti-nuclear activists. Well-intentioned people dedicated to saving the world made things worse us and held back technological progress at the same time.
- Simulacra 11y agoI keep hoping we'll try a thorium or non plutonium producing reactor design.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 11y agoMeanwhile in the UK, Hinkley Point C is in trouble for requiring far too much subsidy (guaranteed price of £90/MWh): http://www.businessgreen.com/bg/news/2420378/report-hsbc-raises-concerns-over-hinkley-point-nuclear-subsidies http://www.businessgreen.com/bg/news/2420378/report-hsbc-rai...