10 ms·
"This was a couple of software engineers who put this in for whatever reason," - I'm not buying it. What would be their motive compared say to VW's motive? VW h
by taylodl 11y ago
"This was a couple of software engineers who put this in for whatever reason," - I'm not buying it. What would be their motive compared say to VW's motive? VW has a heck of a lot more motive for falsifying emissions than do "a couple of software engineers." Even if you were to argue the engineers were somehow fearful for their jobs that's still VW's problem because they're the ones who created that work environment instilling that fear.
I really expected VW to do better in handling this. Some business analysts are saying VW may be out of business within five years time. Based off this testimony I say good riddance.
- funkyy 11y agoThey will blame some small man to avoid prosecution of higher staff. I bet this was done off the records - so the Software Engineer manager have no proof this was ordered or suggested by upper management. At worst they will get 1-2 engineers arrested while they will move quietly to other companies that will be willing to use their experience and connections.
- bro-stick 11y agoOf course. Fall guy 101. Not some tinfoilness, but expedient politics of surviving corporate death pits. The sort of shops where most every discussion is double top-secret: happens in-person, quietly, behind closed doors and the email trail is kept to strictly vague coordination details, at most, since it's subject to discovery. Oh and information is hoarded, because details create weaknesses.
- usrusr 11y agoArrested? Remember that cars don't pollute, drivers do or something like that. At the end of the day, what the engineers in the trenches did was design a device that is illegal to sell in some other country. It is correct that the blame goes to a place higher up, where the decision to sell was made. Which is what is actually happening at Volkswagen proper. The surprising part is that the VW USA CEO seems to be completely out of the loop about this.
- somebodyother 11y agoAlso, it implies a couple of engineers could slip through arbitrary code to be executed under selective conditions. That's terrifying.
- Laaw 11y agoBut also probably true, regardless of this specific situation.
- twblalock 11y agoFrom what I know of the car industry, coding standards are very low. I don't think any car companies would look good if their code was audited by professional software engineers in other fields.
- dogma1138 11y agoThen you don't know the motor industry very much as it has very strict coding standards like ISO 26262, the code has to be audited internally and by certified 3rd parties with every release to meet the development cycle requirements of the standards. http://www.ldra.com/en/software-quality-test-tools/group/by-industry-standard/automotive-iso-26262-misra http://www.ldra.com/en/software-quality-test-tools/group/by-... The industry also has specific coding standard for every language that is used in embedded systems like MISRA-C https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MISRA_C https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MISRA_C Today every thing you do with your car from using breaks to deploying air-bags is done through the computer, there's no way in hell that the motor industry would be releasing poor code "intentionally" because it would cost them billions in liabilities.
- joezydeco 11y agoAnd you're not familiar with what happened when a 3rd party (Michael Barr) was allowed to FINALLY look inside Toyota's engine code and determine the cause of the "Unintended Acceleration" problem: "Barr checked the [Toyota] source code against MISRA’s 2004 edition and found 81,514 violations." http://www.safetyresearch.net/blog/articles/toyota-unintended-acceleration-and-big-bowl-%E2%80%9Cspaghetti%E2%80%9D-code http://www.safetyresearch.net/blog/articles/toyota-unintende...
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> I really expected VW to do better in handling this. Ignore whatever comes out of the VW USA guy. The investigations in Germany will most likely be more fruitful especially because police is involved.
- nmrm2 11y agoExactly. The most devastating part of all of this for me (a US citizen) is that the German CEO resigns in disgrace and there are ongoing criminal investigations in Germany, but in the USA the CEO holds fast and blames engineers. It seems like the German government is more competent that the US at enforcing laws against corporations, even when those laws are USA laws... *EDIT: This comment is poorly worded. What I mean to say is, Germany is doing a better job at holding PEOPLE AT THE TOP responsible, whereas the USA is predictably allowing CxOs to plead ignorance and hide behind the corporate veil. Meanwhile in Germany, http://www.wsj.com/articles/german-prosecutors-open-investigation-into-former-volkswagen-ceo-martin-winterkorn-1443439708 http://www.wsj.com/articles/german-prosecutors-open-investig...
- rconti 11y agoYou realize this is the exact opposite of what the rest of the world is saying, right? Is this the first article you've read on the matter? I've been following it with great interest, and many others have expressed shame that it's the US that is catching a European company cheating, and threatening prosecution. This all happened because of the work of the West Virginia lab, plus CARB and EPA's investigation, and the EPA's refusal to issue an emissions certification to 2016 diesel VW passenger cars which has led to likely tens of thousands of un-sellable cars sitting on US dealer lots. The German government has been shown to have looked the other way repeatedly and to be complicit in fighting on behalf of the automakers instead of the environment. The European emissions and mileage tests have been shown to be an utter and complete sham. The story you're peddling is really the exact opposite of reality. Take a look around at the other stories that have been posted on HN on the matter.
- LoSboccacc 11y ago
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoExactly. I don't buy this one bit. If those engineers feared for their jobs because the cars wouldn't pass, I bet those engineers could have left VW and found better jobs. Nobody needs that kind of stress. I think it is cowardice to blame them.
- dayjah 11y agoThis is probably a little reactionary, but can we just stop for a second and admire the difference in American CEO's versus his European counterpart? The latter resigns immediately as a way of accepting he is ultimately responsible, the former points fingers. This is a blatant example of why the tide of opinion is turning against those with the most wealth.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoAgreed. However I do feel that the European CEO got off easy by simply being able to walk away.
- jdmichal 11y agoAFAIK the German government is still investigating the issue. He may have walked away, but that's not necessarily the end of the story.
- madez 11y agoThe Staatsanwaltschaft Braunschweig is leading the criminal investigation and they said specifically that they are not after Martin Winterkorn, the press reports.
- caskance 11y agoIt's pretty close to the end. Fines will be levied against the Volkswagen company, not to him personally. His stock options will become worthless but he's still set for life. I think in this area, at least, China does it right. Shoot the guy as a warning to the others.
- PaulAJ 11y agoNo way could it be just a couple of software engineers. The engine is a system, and its the engine that has to pass the emissions tests. So that means the whole engine development team had to be in on it, including their technical management. They in turn would not have done such a thing if they had not believed that senior management wanted it, and it is the responsibility of senior management to make it clear what they want.
- johansch 11y agoWhen this CEO of a company with 600k employees says "it's some software engineers", I assume he might actually be honestly referring to what we would call engineering managers, perhaps with hundreds of indirect reports, 2-3 levels down from the CEO. I find this plausible... (Particularly since these hearings seem designed to score political points rather than to find out what actually happened.)
- jsprogrammer 11y agoHowever plausible it may be, it is still not excusable. The company should have processes in place that can verify the claims it makes. Plausible deniability is really just a claim of neglect. Edit: I'm being rate-limited, so I'll respond to the points below right here: >What processes should be in place, exactly, to do what? How about driving a vehicle in the manner most of their customer's do and examining the emissions? >Quarterly polygraph tests performed by all engineering managers How would that help exactly? Polygraph is demonstrably unreliable. >to assure top management they haven't broken any laws? It's mostly irrelevant how assured top management is about anything. What matters, in this case, is how far out of spec the vehicles Volkswagon produced are. That is what needed to be verified: specs vs. facts.
- johansch 11y agoWhat do you mean? Let's assume the individial he is talking about is a manager of a group of hundreds of engineers working in this area. This means this guy's direct manager most likely would not be in a position to inspect the work of people 2-3 levels down for any irregularities. What processes should be in place, exactly, to do what? Quarterly polygraph tests performed by all engineering managers to assure top management they haven't broken any laws?
- eridius 11y agoJust because VW might have more motive to do this doesn't automatically mean that they're lying when they say it was the fault of individual engineers. Guilt is not determined by "who has the most motive", it's determined by who actually did it. Now it may very well be true that VW is lying and it was a corporate decision. But it's not completely implausible that this really was the decision of a few individual employees. Other commenters here are expressing surprise that engineers could "slip through arbitrary code" to do this. But isn't that kind of the job of software engineers, to write code to do things? I would hope they have code review going on at VW, but code review doesn't always catch everything, or maybe several engineers who were working together would review each other's code.
- karlkatzke 11y agoIf there's three or more engineers, said engineers could have colluded to put the code in.
- randcraw 11y agoLike NASA, auto companies like VW produce a TON of documentation on all phases of design and engineering. This is especially true when it comes to regulation-sensitive processes like emissions testing. As someone who has worked in a comparably highly regulated industry (pharma) I can state with full confidence that Mr Horn is a lying bastard.
- sheepmullet 11y ago> Like NASA, auto companies like VW produce a TON of documentation on all phases of design and engineering. This is especially true when it comes to regulation-sensitive processes like emissions testing. Bingo! A lot of HN is acting like "it could slip through the processes we have at work so I can see how it could happen here" without realising that the processes, documentation, and independent review requirements are 100x more involved and thorough for critical car firmware than they are for a basic software shop.
- billforsternz 11y ago
- toddmorey 11y agoRight. And those tests and regulations exist in the interest of public health, not product benchmarking. So the issue is bigger than lying about some performance metric to compare more favorable to competitors. And it's also not a domain that's auxiliary—this is engine technology, the very heart of the company and the product. And good god, they built an entire brand campaign around it. I really do feel this is analogous to some large pharmaceutical finally admitting that they cheated clinical testing on an important drug. You can't just pin that back to a couple of "rouge scientists".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lighthawk 11y ago"...for whatever reason" is the part that got me.
- dclowd9901 11y agoEven if you look at it from a corporate politics standpoint, a software engineer will much sooner say "car's not passing emissions? Not my problem -- take it back to engineering".
- ams6110 11y agoVW will not be out of business in 5 year. Nobody will remember this in 5 years. All the major automakers have manufacturing scandals in their past that resulted in actual deaths, not just fudging some arbitrary emissions standard. They are almost all still in business.