21 ms·
Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul
- crabasa 11y agoI have lived in Seattle since 2009, first working at Microsoft and now working remotely for a Bay Area company. For people who aren't familiar with the Seattle area, it is cleaved into 2 parts: 1) The city of Seattle or the "west side". This area is increasingly dominated by Amazon, local startups and engineering offices for Bay Area companies like Facebook and Google. 2) The cities to the east of Lake Washington (Redmond, Bellevue, Kirkland) or the "east side". This is the domain of Microsoft, Expedia, Concur and a smaller set of startups. Most of the intense change has occurred in Seattle and specifically in the South Lake Union area where Amazon is located. Yes, there has been change and growth elsewhere, but nothing that I would consider alarming. I'm personally optimistic that Seattle will find a balance between growth and continuing to have an enviable culture and cost of living.
- nicpottier 11y agoI think Capitol Hill is the most glaring change to me in the past 5 years. One of the neatest and most unique neighborhoods in the city, in a way iconic to how Seattle was seen is now filled with brand new condos and multi-use buildings. For god sakes there have been gay-hate crimes on Broadway. Yes, tons of new development has happened in SLU, but that area wasn't much of an established neighborhood to live in before, so it doesn't bother me as much. Seattle is quickly losing any remaining "grit" and that as someone who has always called it home that is seriously depressing. I'm in the Central District which to some degree feels more like a Capitol Hill (except with black people!) but I imagine it is only a matter of time before the condos invade here as well.
- sushisource 11y agoI still have yet to have anyone explain to my why "grit" is a desirable trait in a neighborhood. I can understand wanting diversity, unique cultures, but that absolutely does not conflict with a general quality of life increase.
- xxpor 11y agoI think it's less 'grit', and more getting annoyed that absolutely EVERYTHING is brand new. I like new stuff, but places in Seattle have signs like 'Est. 2010', and that makes them 'old', which would be absurd anywhere on the east coast or in the midwest. I live next to Cal Anderson, fwiw.
- zardo 11y agoYou can think of "grit" as meaning mixed wealth. It's desirable because people are more likely to use their wealth pro-socially, rather than buy a new BMW every other year, if they don't live in an enclave isolated from the economic struggles of the rest of society.
- drewrv 11y agoGrit is something I used to like about Seattle. This was a city of lumberjacks and fishermen and dock workers.
- txru 11y agoIt seems to me that the fact that Capitol Hill was the unique, Bohemian, and affordable neighborhood that it was in your memories was just an accident of the 20th century. It's: * Right next to downtown * Has great views and * Has very easy access to a major road, I-5. Why on earth wouldn't having credentials like that make it prime property, even if a certain retailer didn't exist? But from 1950 - 1990, nobody wanted to live in a city, they wanted to drive in from their suburbs. So cities became refuges for the interesting and weird, while the rest of America had their half-acre. That trend is reverting now, and the real value of property in major cities is being reevaluated, and at something closer to what it probably should be. Also, I really liked this Wonkblog[1], not just for highlighting the differences in densities in world urban areas, but also because he talks about the mentality of "Well, I've moved here now, but the development can stop now!" [1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonkblog/wp/2015/10/06/there-is-no-such-thing-as-a-city-that-has-run-out-of-room/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonkblog/wp/2015/10/06/th...
- seathrowa 11y ago> * Right next to downtown * Has great views and * Has very easy access to a major road, I-5. > Why on earth wouldn't having credentials like that make it prime property, even if a certain retailer didn't exist? Crappy transit (49 is your only bus route for many parts of the hill and is slow and only runs on Broadyway; 10/11/43 serve very specific areas); I wouldn't call the I-5 access great (the intersection at Denny is frequently really slow and backed up because people run lights and block the intersection).
- txru 11y agoBus routes can be fixed, that's a months-years problem. I'm sure the city will adjust at some point, probably before 2018, to give Capitol Hill really amazing service. I was exaggerating a bit... but the highway basically runs right beside the length of the neighborhood. It's pretty convenient to get on, even if Denny is totally packed.
- tripplethrendo 11y agoCan I post this comment to Facebook without retribution?
- seathrowa 11y agoFor those unfamiliar with Seattle, SLU is adjacent to Capitol Hill. So, some Amazon employees inevitably live in Cap Hill, which is for some reason a desirable place to live (lots of night life activities, crappy transit options). Cap Hill used to be a gay / artist / low income district of Seattle but is increasingly wealthy tech workers. I don't see this as a bad thing but obviously some people do.
- bndw 11y agoCap Hill used to be a gay / artist / low income district of Seattle but is increasingly wealthy tech workers. I don't see this as a bad thing but obviously some people do. I think this comparison misses the point. The think the main complain with the change is just that, change. Capitol Hill used to feel much more eclectic and diverse. Today, personally, I don't feel that sentiment. FWIW, I've lived in the neighborhood for ~7 years.
- aaronbrethorst 11y agoI'll echo this, and I've lived in the neighborhood for 23 days shy of 10 years.
- breadbox 11y agoWhile the changes to Capitol Hill alarm me as well (having lived there for 25 years), there have always been gay hate crimes on Capitol Hill.
- ulysses 11y agoGood description but I would categorize it as "Seattle" vs "East Side", when people say "West Side" I tend to think of West Seattle down through Burien.
- smithkl42 11y agoIt's worth pointing out that Google has offices in both Seattle and Kirkland - and I believe that the Kirkland office is larger, and is coming to be as important to Kirkland as Amazon is to Seattle (obviously Kirkland is much smaller than Seattle).
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoEast side also has a big Google presence in Kirkland. The Google office in Fremont is small in comparison. There are also north (Bothell-Everett) and south (Renton-Tacoma) sides to consider, which are also changing rapidly. Everytime I go back (I grew up there), I'm shocked by some change. The Amazon one was huge (hey, Apple is at South Lake also now!).
- cdcarter 11y agoThe alarming concern is that by creating 70k new jobs in the South Lake Union, that's roughly 70k units of housing near SLU that are going to primarily higher earning white tech workers. This is raising rent in all of the central city (including many historically considered neighborhoods of color) and pushing lower-earners further and further away from their jobs, their churches, and their communities. Yes, eventually the latter two will move with them, but to separate these communities is painful and their labor is still needed in the inner city.
- captrh 11y agoSeattle is not for young people. The dude pool is 2:1 in a market where beer is regularly 6.50 a pint.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tacos 11y agoMarrying young and endless dinner parties where first-time homeowners proudly declare "granite countertops!" like checking that box on a list of materials is some major achievement. A bit painful. But there's a dirty, edgy, interesting indoor culture there caused by the shitty weather. It sprouts up around everything from sex to music to art on occasion. Go find it.
- edgyswingset 11y ago> "granite countertops!" Funnily enough, most of the time it's not made of granite at all.
- Kluny 11y agoIs that the only option available for married life? Surely it's possible to marry someone who is interesting and continue doing interesting things after you're married?
- placeybordeaux 11y ago> everything from sex to music to art on occasion.
- LLWM 11y agoMost of us don't see any reason to continue doing interesting things beyond making ourselves look appealing during courtship.
- Kluny 11y agoReally?
- darmok 11y agoWhile growing up in the Seattle area in the 70's & 80's, I always thought Seattle was the coolest city in the world. It's still fun for me to visit and I do miss the trees, lakes, and Mt. Rainier, but to me it has completely lost its charm. All that was once cool and unique has been monetized and whitewashed.
- kelukelugames 11y agoWhitewashed? I think this is the most diverse Seattle has ever been. Just a smudge above Portland.
- monknomo 11y agoI think darmok is using whitewashed to mean "sanitized" or "cleaned up" not "has a greater percentage of white people". Like when congressional testimony whitewashes a friendly fire incident, it generally means that they are covering it up or making it look better.
- kelukelugames 11y agoOh I agree. I was in Seattle in 2005. My girlfriend was here in the 80s to 90s.
- sburrito 11y agoOut of curiosity, where have you lived after you left Seattle, and how did you like those places? I've been to a few places and liked Seattle a lot :)
- darmok 11y agoMy earlier comment is definitely clouded by nostalgia :-) I loved the Seattle of the past, but the Seattle of today to me seems more about horrible traffic, ridiculous home prices, and omnipresent materialism. But that's a perspective based on my unrealistic expectation of the past. Seattle truly is a beautiful city and people who see it for the first time will probably fall in love with it. So I'm glad you liked Seattle!
- geebee 11y agoIt's fascinating and sad to read these articles, about some cities struggling with the effects of tech wealth while other cities would see it as an almost unqualified boon. We constantly hear about a desperate shortage of software engineers from tech companies, as well as talk of "six figure" salaries. But the median price for housing in SF is well over a million now, and if you're hoping to have kids and raise a family, trying to buy a SFH or 3br apartment, even in the remaining unfashionable and mildly blighted areas south of 280 (not really unsafe, but a bit depressing in spots, lots of dumping, garbage, paved over front yards with abandoned cars), even that you'll be lucky to get in for much less thank 900k unless the house needs a lot of work or is very small with no expansion possibilities. A shortage of young people who are willing to work for salaries too low to put down real roots is not a shortage of workers, it's a wage vs cost of living problem. SF needs to build (certainly the bay area needs to build), but I don't see construction in the bay area as more than part of the solution. We will eventually have to accept that it isn't desirable or possible to cram all the programmers into a 7x7 grid and a narrow corridor down the peninsula. Truth is, there are a lot of interesting old cities in the US that are pretty much neglected. I thought Patti Smyth said it best: "The Godmother of Punk recalled coming to New York in 1967 when she was broke and the city was "'down and out,' and you could get a cheap apartment and 'build a whole community of transvestites or artists or writers.'" But today, she says, "New York has closed itself off to the young and the struggling. But there are other cities. Detroit. Poughkeepsie. New York City has been taken away from you. So my advice is: Find a new city." I don't think that it's realistic to expect a coordinated effort from the tech "industry", which doesn't really speak with one voice or have one opinion. Market forces may eventually create the change we'd like to see, but for now, the tech industry really has obtained a subsidy in the form of control over the immigration system that prevents these market forces from working as they should. The first step is to stop taking claims of a worker shortage seriously, and don't give tech companies a crutch that allows them to avoid making the adjustments that will help everyone in the long run (in other words, don't allow tech companies to control visas that force workers to work in San Francisco or the valley, make sure all members of the workforce are free to chose their job, field, educational and career path, and where they live, in response to market signals). Just to be clear, as I have in the past, I feel positively about general immigration, I believe that immigrants must be free to choose their own path in live, including what they study, where they live, who they will work for.
- mattress 11y agoTook a job in Bellevue in April and moved from Philadelphia to Seattle. So far it's a been an interesting experience. I've encountered many people hostile to software engineers in general. A bunch of people immediately ask if I work for Amazon with a hint of disdain after I state my occupation. So it hasn't felt super welcoming so far. I get it, even in some neighborhoods in Philadelphia the same thing is happening. Although to a much lesser extent, but there is tension between locals and newcomers. I was initially sympathetic to the locals, but now it just seems people will complain about the change no matter what. But you have no right to complain about this gentrification when you are operating newly built apartment complexes, charging a premium to tech workers. And then go on to say you have Amazon prime. Screw you, Owen.
- hyperbovine 11y agoOwen is the worst.
- theophrastus 11y agoA brief elaboration on "many people hostile to software engineers in general": the major source of this are the employers who have done a deal with the apartment owners to all but exclude anyone who doesn't work in the tech industry. The apartment owner simply doesn't rent to anyone who doesn't work for Amazon, Microsoft etc[1]. This makes people grumpy at the folks who apparently do the deal with the devil for this advantage. By the bye, there is a difference, at least politically, between Seattle and Bellevue, much like between San Francisco and Oakland [1] http://www.thestranger.com/news/feature/2015/09/09/22831041/heres-how-the-city-could-stop-those-special-move-in-deals-for-tech-workers http://www.thestranger.com/news/feature/2015/09/09/22831041/...
- mattress 11y agoOh, I wasn't aware this was happening. Totally makes sense, although this is not the case in my instance.
- pinewurst 11y agoReading this, the employers have nothing to do with it. The apartment owner/managers are deciding who is a "preferred" tenant on their own and should take the heat rather than some arbitrary employer.
- pm90 11y ago>John Criscitello placed posters in Seattle's Capitol Hill neighborhood proclaiming “Welcome! Rich Kids,” and “Wish you weren’t here.” Its hard not to feel angry at people like this. "Rich Kids" really? These "Kids" spent years developing their engineering skills to get to the point where they are now. Are engineers paid a lot? Of course. But we're certainly not in the same category as those who inherit wealth. Most engineers that I know come from incredibly humble backgrounds.
- joesmo 11y agoIt's also ridiculous that these same people benefit greatly from a growing economy that's directly influenced by (and these days also partially propped up by) the boom in tech while deriding it like it's some kind of negative force. It sounds to me a lot more like envy than any nostalgia for artistry and run-down neighborhoods, as they claim.
- ondrae 11y agoThis article is about Seattle trying to slow the rising number of families being gentrified out of their homes and long standing communities. The nostalgia of not taking your kids out of their current school? The nostalgia of not having a new crazy commute? There is real pain happening to real people. Who is getting this great benefit that is so ridiculous?
- s73v3r 11y agoMoney isn't everything to a lot of people. On top of that, how much do they benefit if they end up chased out of their neighborhood?
- sushisource 11y agoThese signs piss me off every time I see them. Always make me think "Oh, I know, it's so horrible that we're helping to bring fresh life into your local economy, with new amenities and attractions". Sure, high paying tech jobs certainly contribute to housing crunches, but they also help solve them by making high-density buildings with affordable housing in them possible. The street goes both ways.
- peatmoss 11y agoI've only lived in Seattle for about 6 years, but have seen / felt a rise in rents over that time. When we moved here, lots of rentals were offering one or two months free rent as a move in special. Now, not so much. Because he was sick of friends moving away, a friend of mine made his rookie run for the city council this past year. He didn't survive the primary, but he had some good ideas about housing that have in part been taken up by other candidates going forward. The first was a mandatory inclusionary zoning policy, which would give developers building incentives, such as allowing additional height, in exchange for a fixed percentage of units being affordable. Affordability here was defined in terms of HUD's guidelines for percentage of income spent on housing (in this case assuming someone earning Seattle's decidedly not-livable minimum wage). Some form of that first idea seems to have survived my friend's candidacy to live on in other proposals / candidate platforms. Another that I thought was clever, but hasn't seen much uptake, tried addressing the problem from the demand side. Here the idea is that Seattle would run its own voucher program to subsidize rents for low-income people. This one was a little more ambitious and would require new revenues, but is a nice alternative to supply side options. And of course a purely supply side solution doesn't entirely solve the problem. New units tend to command higher rents in general. Also, a glut of condos might not reduce prices so much as encourage speculation from non-resident owners. Certainly more units need to built, but new construction doesn't entirely solve affordability in the near term.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThis is a severely under-appreciated point about housing costs. I live in a college town and rents have been climbing to the degree where the ratio of income to housing expenses is the highest in the nation, leaving New York and San Francisco in the dust. Every once in a while there will be more proposals to build condos over existing houses or apartments. We've been here before: housing stock is considerably increased while rents around town are given an implicit "go" to be raised across the board. If you're a financially struggling student at an Ivy League school you're not just gonna up and leave cause your rent went up another $100-$200. You're just gonna take out more debt. It doesn't help that aside from campus housing there are like 3 landlords in the whole city Building housing in a bull market is almost always the right choice, but let's not pretend rents are going to magically fall. Or stop rising. Housing is one of the most elastic goods one can find. Everyone has to sleep somewhere.
- zw123456 11y agoI moved to Seattle in 1980 and fell in love with the city and it's unique culture. Seattle has grown up for sure but in my view the growth has been handled overall pretty well and we have kept a lot of the coolest part of the culture here(music, beer, coffee, movies check out the SFF, outdoor festivals every weekend during the summer, great outdoors, the sea and mountains and so on). I have been tempted many times by offers from the Bay area and the valley but I still love this place and just can't bring myself to leave, although my second love is SF :) In a lot of ways I see Seattle and San Fran as sister cities.
- mosquito242 11y agoThen what would Portland be?
- chrisdbaldwin 11y agoThe middle child.
- edgyswingset 11y agoI recently moved to the eastside and haven't been experiencing much disdain for being a tech worker. Most of my spare time is spent heading into the cascades to hike the amazing trails, though.
- seathrowa 11y agoThe eastside is less obsessed with preserving an image of itself as a "gritty" place. Parts of the eastside (I'm looking at you, downtown Bellevue) are sort of obsessed with the opposite — shows of ostentatious wealth. The Cascades have a lot of great hiking and are reason enough to live on the eastside :). If you don't already, get an "America the Beautiful" pass (http://www.nps.gov/findapark/passes.htm http://www.nps.gov/findapark/passes.htm) which will get you into National Forest areas as well as National Parks (Rainier, Olympic National Park). And of course the state Discover pass gets you into a few areas (Tiger Mountain is not super wild, but very close).
- Splines 11y agoAlso if you have a 4th grader don't forget about https://www.everykidinapark.gov/ https://www.everykidinapark.gov/
- jonknee 11y agoMy take on the East Side (coming from a Seattle POV) is the perception is that it's full of well off NIMBYs who work for Microsoft and that the area never had any culture to lose. Amazon's move into the city has changed things that were there for decades. I'm new to Seattle though so technically part of the "problem".
- Scuds 11y agoState has zero funding for the mentally ill, so they all congregate in the downtown, many around the largest tourist trap here, the Pike Place Market. There are Maseratis driving by parks full of tents here.
- Kalium 11y agoAny time I see a line about a city "keeping its soul" or a company "coming for its soul", I have a reasonable expectation that "soul" is going to be defined myopically. The recent past will be regarded as perfection, not to be tampered with. Sadly, this article continues that pattern. The past is privileged and the future is to dance only to its tune. No wonder people are upset that things are changing - privilege is being challenged.
- derrickdirge 11y agoBut I have so many great memories of the past! I literally don't have any great memories of the future.
- sakopov 11y agoI'm a software engineer with a great job in midwest but I have never been happy here and have been contemplating about just packing my stuff and moving to Seattle for the past 3 years. I don't have any job leads but I have enough in savings to get a place for 6 months. Does anyone think it's sane to just move without job offers?
- smithkl42 11y agoProbably so, if you've got good technical skills. At the very least, you ought to be able to land a couple of contracting gigs to tide you over until you find the right long-term position. There's a lot more demand here in the Puget Sound area for good technical skills than there is supply, so unless you're just not a very good developer, you ought to be able to find something reasonable.
- voltagex_ 11y agoA week of rejected job applications has me wondering if I'm not a good developer at all...
- smithkl42 11y agoDon't worry too much about that. Apply for a ton of jobs, for weeks, if not months. Assume that for 80% of them, your resume will get tossed immediately, for no good reason whatsoever. Not your fault. Similarly, for reasons beyond your control, you'll probably fail half of the phone screens, and when you actually get called in, you won't get past 90% of the interviews. Don't worry about it: that's just how it goes. Those numbers will vary substantially with the market, your experience, your innate horsepower, and your asking salary, but the fact is, although there are a lot of developers out there, and employers are careful who they hire, there are also a lot of job openings. Play the numbers game: my rule of thumb is to apply for 100 jobs to get one that you want.
- arjunnarayan 11y agoSpend a month learning to interview with a book like Cracking the Code, and yeah, you'll get a great job.
- oberstein 11y agoSeattle is a godless soulless husk of what it once was, attitudes that spawn things like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keep_the_Bastards_Out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keep_the_Bastards_Out didn't win out. Try living in Utah for a while (as a real or pretend Mormon of course) if you want to see what real culture and community tastes like even in 2015. I work in Seattle but I'll never live in the city proper. The rest of King County, excepting the south side, is at least a decent and modestly priced ($900/month single bed apartment) place to live even if it has no soul. Unfortunately it won't last, Bellevue is in the same place Seattle was not too long ago. (This is more hyperbolic than it probably needs to be.)
- bluedino 11y ago>> John Criscitello placed posters in Seattle's Capitol Hill neighborhood proclaiming “Welcome! Rich Kids,” and “Wish you weren’t here.” Don't hate them, cash in on them. Start a high-end or artistically product and sell to the 'rich kids'.
- gaius 11y agoExactly as Banksy has done in London
- kpennell 11y agoI don't know if I ever really saw Seattle's 'soul' when I lived there for 3 years. Granted, I lived in the North part. I saw a lot of white and asian people (mainly dudes) looking at their feet or looking at their phones. Seattle is one of the most difficult places to strike up a conversation with strangers or get people to actually want to hang out (worse if they are locals). South Seattle, on the other hand, truly has 'soul'. Rainier Beach at one point was the most diverse zip code in the entire USA. You got to a coffee shop there and you'll see groups of east africans, latinos, all mixes of asian, white, african american, you name it. It's got gritty parts, nicer parts, and all sorts of interesting restaurants and grocery stores. The Amazon people don't tend to live or congregate down there as much. As far as cap hill, fremont, wallingford, u-dist, you can keep it. A bunch of bland ass wealthy white/asian dudes looking at the ground. I moved to SF and lived there for a couple years. The gentrification and rent is bad but the diversity and mix of people across most of the neighborhoods still beats north seattle hands down. It was a way more eclectic interesting experience than anything my Seattle time could offer.
- beatpanda 11y agoI have a question for all you unrepentant capitalists out there -- why is it that massive concentrations of wealth pretty consistently tend to lead to a decrease in the overall quality of life? Because if the boosters of capitalism are to be believed, the path to making society better on balance is to enable people to accumulate unlimited amounts of personal wealth and then sort of let that wealth diffuse through the people around them. This isn't actually happening in places where wealth from the tech industry is concentrated. The rising tide is mostly just sinking everybody, and obliterating everything that isn't explicitly about making money in its path. So what gives? How can you argue anybody is better off for all this?
- twblalock 11y agoEvery one of your paragraphs contains a strawman.
- capkutay 11y agoThe west coast has a liberal population less receptive to change than Bush/Cheney era Republicans. SF has a lot of misguided anger towards tech workers.
- redwood 11y agoThe gender imbalance is a bummer got almost everyone
- spudlyo 11y agoI've lived in Seattle since the late 80s when I got the hell out of Olympia WA where I grew up. I remember when it was nearly impossible to find a decent tech job in the city, and you had to cross a bridge to Bellevue or Redmond, which is non-optimal for so many reasons. I for one am happy as hell that tech is booming here. If you are thinking of coming here, do it, lots of us are welcoming to transplanted tech nerds.
- CheckeredBook 11y agoAnother born-and-raised Seattleite here. Grew up there, went to UW, etc. Seattle lost its "soul" a long time ago. For me, Almost Live! going off the air was really the bookmark that Seattle was quickly becoming a homogenized west-coast city (no different really than SF or Portland). I don't really think Amazon is worth singling out, either. Amazon doesn't help, but Microsoft's a monolith that's been around for quite some time. They used to (and still do) pull a shitload of the UW CSE graduating class straight into MSFT, and nobody wants to live in Redmond or Bellevue until you're starting to think about a family, a house, etc. It also goes totally unmentioned here, but biotech was/is huge in SLU. My point being, money's been flooded into Seattle for quite some time now. If they wanted to keep Seattle "Seattle", i.e. different from the other west-coast cities, the time to plan that out was 15 years ago. I also think it's hilarious to hear people bemoan the death of the hill, and even more hilarious to see signs like "rich kids leave" and shit like that. I bet they weren't around a decade ago when the gay community used to say the exact same thing to hipsters that were flooding into the hill (myself included), even down to the insinuation that all hipsters were rich kids. Hilarious to see history repeat itself.
- rconti 11y agoYep. Born and lived there all through the 80s and 90s before moving to the Bay Area. I still read the Seattle Times online, and the gripes about Californians coming in and ruining the place in the past few years are hilarious; it's been the same story for decades. Blame someone else. Boeing engineers. Microsofties. Whatever, it's always somebody else. Thanks for mentioning Almost Live. Every few years I search for DVDs, search torrents, etc. Truly one of the saddest days in Seattle when it went off the air.
- multinglets 11y agoThe people who (allegedly) don't perceive Seattle's shitty attitude are almost guaranteed to already be card-carrying turboleftist hipsters + standard uniform, pretty much every single time. edit: OK, sometimes they're attractive college-aged women. Because progressives have such deep respect for their cultural contributions and intuition, I'm sure.
- kyleblarson 11y agoI lived in First Hill / Downtown from 2001 until 2011, and from the perspective of an engineer who is into outdoor sports, I can't think of a better place to have lived. I averaged 3 nights a week of skiing at the pass after work during the winters, and 2-3 nights a week of climbing at various locations (Index, 32, 38, Gold Bar) in the summer. There are also dozens of equally accessible mountain biking locations, sailing, fly fishing, hiking, etc. Sure there are more tech bros and self important hipster douches now, but it's still an awesome place to live. (I moved out to the mountains and live in a remote town of about 200 people in North Central WA now.)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- idibidiart 11y agoHere is an idea for the FTC: break Amazon into 3 companies: cloud infrastructure, online merchant, and logistics company.
- pnathan 11y agohey HN, I'm a happy software writer in Seattle, am happy to get coffee or exchange emails about Seattle culture from my perspective. I love meeting other programmers and talking about our field (or other stuff too. :3 ). Email & twitter in profile!
- malandrew 11y agoYay, yet another city trying out the horribly naive and misguided "Below Market Rate" housing model that only serves to distort the local housing economy further. I had a front row seat to experience the process because someone I date got into a BMR house about 1.5 years ago. For those that don't know, BMR housing programs usually work like this: - In order to build a new building, the builder must agree to allocate X% of the units in a building to be below market rate. In SF, I think it's currently 15% of units, or 20% equivalent of a building in another project that is located within 1 mile of the original project (I might be off a bit here or the requirements might have changed, but that's the gist of it) - To qualify to be able to buy one of these units, someone needs to be an SF resident and make between 70% and 110% of the median income, with most units limited at 90% of the median income. - The price of the unit is tied to the median income in the city forever (i.e. you can't sell at a "profit" like with regular housing). The only way you make money is if the city experiences real income growth above and below the median income (remember: median income, not mean income) - From what I saw, units are ~ 1/3 of their fair market value. The unit my partner got into was a 1061 square foot, 2 bedroom, 2 full bath in a Hayes Valley luxury condo. The price was about $330k with a $60k down payment. - There is a down payment assistance program and special lenders approved. This means it's possible to come to the table with like $10k, since the assistance program covers the other $50k. This down payment can be paid any time during the length of the mortgage including at the end of the 30 years. The mortgage is a safe fixed rate loan. - Getting into a unit involves going through a class, filling out some forms, getting an approved lender and then applying to available units you qualify for. This puts you in a lottery to be selected. From the lotteries I saw, few enough people either know about the program or qualify that you probably have a 1/10 chance of getting into a unit. If you apply to 10 buildings, over 1-2 years, you're almost certain to get in. Once you're selected, your application goes through additional scrutiny to check if you qualify. If you do, you close on the home. - Overall, on the unit my partner got she's paying about $2100 for a super nice two bedroom that would probably rent for $5000-5500. - You can't sell the house except through the BMR program at a price relative to the median income when you decide to sell. There are two formula for calculating the price, you choose whichever is higher. You cannot leave the home to anyone in your will unless they also qualify through the BMR program (you don't really ever own the home except legally because of all the restrictions). - Although you can't sell the home at a real profit in the future, the discrepancy between the current rent and the mortgage is essentially "profit" earned today. The $3000 saved per month every month (or whatever amount the person would be paying otherwise to stay in a market with great economic opportunities) is essentially profit earned off the housing now instead of from a future sale of an asset. This applies to rent control as well. Having rent control from 15 years ago and 1x the median income means you're probably doing as well economically as an engineer paying market rate today and earning 2x the median income (or something like that. I haven't done the exact calculation. It's even more if you have rent control on a multi-room unit and charge market rate like most people I know with rent control) My biggest beef with this program is that it creates an asymptotic condition (hard limit on who qualifies based on specific percentages of median income). In economic systems, asymptotic conditions basically always great pathologies and boundaries that people try to game. One of the biggest pathologies I see has to do with how much of the market is still excluded from affordable housing. In SF, I've read that it's estimated that you need to earn about 4x the median to be able to afford a home. The reality is that it's worse than that because homes are now being sold in all cash deals above asking before homes even hit the market officially (i.e. put in MLS). This means that basically everyone between 90/110% of the median income and 400+% of the median income are excluded from the market for no reason whatsoever. The better non-asymptotic way to create affordable housing that is accessible to all is to change how much assistance based on a calculation that compares your current income (or better, your income in SF over the past three years averaged to make it harder to game) relative to the current median income. The other issue I have with programs like this (and rent control) is that it conveniently satisfies the housing needs for a large percentage of voters without actually addressing the underlying problem of supply. By definition, 50% of voters are below the median income and 50% are above it. There will be roughly some bell curve like distribution around this central value and I would imagine that skewness trends towards the lower bounds, meaning that a huge chunk of voters are satisfied and no longer care or participate in solving the real problem, which is supply. Taking rent control as the example, the 172,000 rent controlled units probably impacts 3/8s of San Francisco voters. These people vote in their short term economic interest which is protecting rent control and tenants rights and lets them be an ostriches about long-term economic interests, which is affordable housing availability as their housing needs change. That rent control studio that worked with you when you were 25? What happens when your partner moves in when you're 30? How about when you and your partner get married and decide you want a kid? By the time you need to go back to the market to find appropriate housing, there is a massive stepwise jump between the $ per person on your old rent control and the current rent control rates. The only thing that solves this problem is a moving supply and demand curve. Since demand is only going up in the area, only rising supply will actually solve the problem. Rent control also creates another perverse asymptotic condition which is that effectively becomes a mutex on housing units preventing development and increasing supply, especially when a tenant is a member of a protected class. By the time that member of the protected class moves on or passes away, it's likely that another tenant will be protected in any building with enough units, meaning that building will likely always have a mutex on it. Anyways, back to BMR since this isn't about rent control. It's a bad program based on no understanding of economics that doesn't really solve the underlying problem (supply) and the good intentions don't magically make it a good idea. The only good thing about Ed Lee's proposal is that it paves the way for taller units. That proposal wouldn't be half bad if it weren't for the asymptotic condition of a specific % of median income and financial assistance relative to your income.
- paulsutter 11y agoPeople in Seattle very friendly. They are unhappy about rising rents. There is an eerie consensus that Amazon is to blame, but I haven't heard negative remarks or attitudes towards individuals, just towards Amazon the company and the tech boom in general. I'm really impressed by the city government. Seattle is much more pro growth than San Francisco. There's much more construction. Like SF, people also blame construction for rising prices, but it's pretty normal for people to reverse causality (developers build because of expectations about demand, demand doesn't happen because developers build. But like most professions, if you aren't a property developer, it may not be obvious).
- gozo 11y agoI don't think it's that simple, especially when talking about things like "luxury" development that changes the city's housing standard.
- paulsutter 11y agoImagine you're the loan officer in a bank. A developer comes in and says "I need a loan to build a luxury building. There's no projected demand, but that doesnt matter, becuase luxury buildings /cause/ demand for luxury units". Seriously, would you loan him the money? When you view it from the perspective of a property developer or bank, it's pretty clear that projected demand is the /cause/ of building construction and not the other way around. Amazon moving downtown will create a lot more demand for higher end units. And that demand is the reason higher end units are being constructed. Amazon's plans for their downtown campus (it's huge - all the way over to Denny) /caused/ many residential developers to buy and develop lots downtown. Think about those 45 minute waits to get on I5 right now. Imagine what it will be like with thousands more Amazon employees in line. All those people waiting in line will be thinking "I need to move downtown, this commute is crazy". That mental image is projected demand. If you picture that, you too will want to build apartments downtown.
- baobabaobab 11y agoThe true soul of Seattle is complaining about the new people moving here. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79SF7UoO1pI&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79SF7UoO1pI&feature=youtu.be