10 ms·
The Thucydides Trap: Are the U.S. And China Headed for War?
- steve19 11y agoThere were so many proxy wars between the USA and the Soviets I would not class that as a bloodless "no war" conflict. I don't think there will be a war for the same reason Europe did not go to war with in the past few decades ... it would be like shooting themselves in the foot. there is little incentive for war when economies are so reliant on each other.
- arethuza 11y agoNiall Ferguson's The War of the World: History's Age of Hatred, which looks at the 20th century, starts by pointing out how comfortable and settled everything looked at the start of the 20th century and as Keynes put it that this state appeared "normal, certain and permanent". For all we know the historians of the 21st century may look back at our time in similar ways.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoLet's hope not. For the first time ever we have something we need to protect - our technological civilization, on its way to reshape the fundamentals of human life. Ending aging and death, colonizing other worlds, really learning something about ourselves and the universe - those things are now actually reasonable concepts. It would be a real shame if we lose it over some stupid issue like political bickering leading to a world war. Because if we halt now, if we roll back to before the industrial revolution, we won't likely achieve this level for several more millennia, as we've pretty much used up all easily accessible, low-tech energy sources and materials. I really wish our leaders would realize that for the first time in the whole history, humanity is greater than the sum of its parts. However important your local issues seem to you, they're not worth endangering the future.
- tomchristie 11y ago"For the first time ever we have something we need to protect" Humanity has always been worth protecting.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYes. I didn't mean to devaluate human life. My point is, for most of the history, societies have been replaceable, fungible. A tribe would die off to be replaced by another one, with different language and maybe culture, but otherwise the same. A civilization would fall, and next one would took the place, replacing the lost works of art with something superficially different, but generally the same. The world didn't change much with the centuries, people had the same illnesses, same problems. Same capabilities and the same perspectives. We were as far from the stars in 2000 BC as we were in 2000 AC. You could restart a civilization any time, and it wouldn't be significantly different. Not so now. The last three centuries gave us the means and capacity to significantly improve the human condition. We started to ride on a self-amplifying feedback loop and we can't give up or fall off until we stabilize it, or we may never get on it again. Humanity has always been worth protecting. Human lives has always been worth protecting. But for the first time ever, we now have a civilization worth protecting. All the problems it has, we have to fix. We can't afford to try and start over.
- ajuc 11y agoYou significantly underestimate the last 20 000 years of progress. It's easy, because progress was very slow, but it was still nessesary for the later stages, and there's no reason to think it will take less time the next time around. Domestication and farming alone took tousands of years, if you restarted the culture in year 0 - we wouldn't have to wait 1600 years for industrial revolution, but more like 10 000 years.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIt's true that what we have today was built directly on the last 20 000 years of progress, but there is still a significant difference - those previous 20 000 years will live in the memories of survivors of the next great war, as well as in any books that will last. Domestication, farming, basic health care, etc. are things that can fit in one's mind. In the entire known history, we've never really restarted from scratch. Even from our times, a some of knowledge would probably survive - from the ideas behind industrial revolution or modern medicine that can fit in one's head, to knowledge of physics, chemistry and biology that is stored in books. No matter how hard we try, we won't nuke every single book out of existence. But then again, not that much knowledge will live, given our increased dependence on volatile storage media. Even if a hard drive would survive a century, we won't have anything to read it with. The reason last 300 years were special is because our progress started to depend on enormous and ever increasing amounts of power. We've used up most of the sources that could be mined, and most renewables are not viable without high-precision manufacturing. Solar power is out of the question; we could start rebuilding hydro and wind power capacity but it will be a slow and very painful process, without easy coal and petroleum to help build the infrastructure. We simply may not have enough easy fuel left to restart the technological civilization.
- tr352 11y ago"Norman Angell, a famous author and Nobel Prize winner in the 1930s, published a brilliant book in 1909. In 'The Great Illusion', Angell argued that war in Europe had become impossible due to the intense level of interdependence between European countries in investment and trade. He postulated that a war would devestate Europe simply because of the economic disruption it would cause. Therefore, war was impossible." George Friedman, Flashpoints.
- xlm1717 11y agoPerhaps it will be a different kind of war. With the economies so reliant on each other, one side can tweak their economy to cause negative effects in the other side's economy. There are politicians in the US who consider China to be engaging in economic warfare for artificially lowering the value of their currency. There is also the possibility of cyber warfare. Steal some secrets here, bring the stock market down for a few hours there. Actual shots don't need to be fired, just enough disruption to reach agreements that one side wants.
- cylinder 11y agoSo what was QE then if not artificially reducing the value of the dollar?
- gadders 11y agoNot sure if I agree with the article, but I'm always fascinated with how the classics can relate to modern times. I'm also old enough to remember 30 or so years ago when Japan was the rising power that terrified everyone (watch the film Rising Sun). We all know how that played out. I'm a Brit, but in matters like this I would never bet against America.
- pjc50 11y agoCan we deal with the war with Russia first? You know, the one with the Russian proxy forces in eastern Ukraine and the other one in Syria with the US proxy forces attacking a Russian ally? The future is probably more of this sort of deniable medium-intensity conflict.
- umanwizard 11y agoThis isn't a new phenomenon; the Cold War was full of similar things.
- kalms 11y agoI agree this is much more prudent, and China excels at playing a role more confined to the shadows. For now at least. In some sense, the US and EU has already accepted China's new found dominance - and place - in the international community. Russia has a much bigger problem accepting their current role, and are almost defiantly demanding respect; putting their forces into situations that could (or probably will) escalate into a full scale war. Personal opinion and all, but Russian foreign politics is reminiscent of Lebensraum, and all that it entailed.
- dmichulke 11y agoWell, as always it depends on "who started it". There are people who say that the current regime in the Ukraine is a US puppet installed via a coup. And up to today several unknowns persist (MH370, the Maidan shootings, the Odessa fire..). Same holds for Syria. In reality, IMO, there is never only one guilty, neither in politics, nor in marriage, nor in war. So I will refrain from blaming someone for all of it and I tend to disbelieve people who "know that it's the other one's fault".
- kalms 11y agoI wasn't blaming anyone. Merely observations. (Although, are you seriously insinuating that MH370 were caused by the US?)
- 11y ago
- Jdfmiller 11y agoSounds like someone's read Ghost Fleet http://www.forbes.com/sites/williampentland/2015/07/15/ghost-fleet-military-geeks-imagine-the-next-world-war/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/williampentland/2015/07/15/ghost...
- pdkl95 11y agoWar? Not while we depend on China for rare earth elements. ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dih30mUexrA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dih30mUexrA ) edit: So I guess the people voting this down believe our failure to maintain a local source of rare earths makes war with China more likely? Our military (and GDP) depends on these elements, and China likes the profit they make selling them. These both make war much less likely.
- hga 11y agoOne reason is that "rare" earths aren't really that rare, what's rare is First World countries that are willing to tolerate the mess of refining them, which roughly entails boiling the ore in acid a thousand times. What was even rarer was a willingness to sell them at a loss when the PRC was selling them cheaply, before they established export quotas and the world market prices for them reversed. See e.g. this article from 2011 which looks accurate to me: http://fortune.com/2011/11/18/molycorps-1-billion-rare-earth-gamble/ http://fortune.com/2011/11/18/molycorps-1-billion-rare-earth... As far as I know, the PRC doesn't have a long term monopoly on anything but the largest concentration of Han Chinese in the world, which is of course rather worthwhile.
- pdkl95 11y ago/sigh/ - I suppose I shouldn't have assumed that I could skip over the details of China's rare earth strategy. Of course they aren't "rare"; I'm obviously referring to China's cornered market on refinement. I also didn't claim anything about the future trends of the rare earth market. We could (and should) rebuild domestic sources, but that takes time and requires fighting regulation. I'm simply saying that I find it extremely unlikely that we would go to war with China when they are de facto a necessary part of military and industry supply chains. China wants the profit, and it would be stupid for us to start a war when reopening domestic mining and refinement industries would be cheaper.
- hga 11y agoExcept they didn't corner the market, aside from when they're willing to sell them cheaper than anyone else. E.g. the company that Fortune article focused on, Molycorp, stumbled in various ways and for various reasons, including lower prices because the PRC's initial restrictive actions were of course followed by counteractions, including recycling. On the company's web site, they say they're putting their US facility in maintenance mode, ready to resume if market conditions warrant it, and are fulfilling customer demand from the PRC and Estonia. So, no, in terms of rare earths they aren't a necessary part of our military and industrial supply chains. A trade embargo between us would hurt us both, and it would be devastating if they could interdict shipments from Taiwan, Japan and South Korea (one of the reasons we maintain an expensive military, although fab lines have to be exquisitely vulnerable), but otherwise at 0th approximation it's hard to distinguish your argument from those made just prior to The Great War AKA WWI. I'd also note that if we even had a complete trade embargo between the US and USSR I don't remember/remember reading of it. In 1980 Reagan campaigned on lifting Carter's grotesque grain embargo to the USSR, one of many pinpricks he made after they invaded Afghanistan and mightily embarrassed him.
- rwmj 11y agoI think nuclear weapons are the wildcard here. They make it difficult to extrapolate from wars in the last 500 years to wars in the future. In 1914-18, although the outcome was quite a lot more terrible than what everyone expected going in, it wasn't as if Europe ended up as a radioactive wasteland for hundreds of years.
- smt88 11y agoI don't know if "wildcard" is the right word. Nuclear weapons were developed with the explicit purpose of preventing wars as terrible as the World Wars. With the help of economic sanctions, they've succeeded so far.
- caf 11y agoThis is revisionist thinking, applying current knowledge to the motivations of those 75 years ago. Nuclear weapons were developed because they could be. More specifically, it was feared that Germany was already researching them. During the Manhattan Project and for the next several years after Hiroshima and Nagasaki they were thought of as just another weapon of war, different perhaps in scale but not in essential character (certainly by the US Army brass, anyway). It wasn't until later in the Cold War that the deterrent value of nuclear weapons was emphasised.
- douche 11y agoIt did take quite some time for the full power and destructiveness of atomic weapons, let alone the later fusion bombs, to be appreciated. At one point, it was a serious idea to fire atomic shells from the standard 155mm field howitzers. Or, for even greater insanity, from over-sized crew-served bazookas. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_artillery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_artillery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Davy_Crockett_(nuclear_device) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Davy_Crockett_(nuclear_device)
- dragonwriter 11y agoThis wasn't because the power of nukes was unappreciated, it was because Soviet conventional superiority in the European theater was seen as an existential threat to Western Europe for which the cost of using that kind of nukes was acceptable in order to mitigate.
- littlewing 11y ago'As Xi Jinping himself said during a visit to Seattle on Tuesday, “There is no such thing as the so-called Thucydides Trap in the world. But should major countries time and again make the mistakes of strategic miscalculation, they might create such traps for themselves.”' That's scary. What do you think he means by that, specifically? It seems like a threat to me.
- nikatwork 11y agoIt's beautifully layered. In one sense he's saying that war is not inevitable if we make the effort to get along. In another sense he's saying don't prod the panda.
- redwood 11y agoI think he's saying that we should be wary of seeing everything China does as a threat since that kind of one dimensional thinking puts us on a trajectory toward the trap. Instead we should aim to rise both our boats.
- Derpdiherp 11y agoPerhaps it's irrelevant, but I wonder what effects the single child policy will have in the next few decades to Chinas ascendancy. The ratio of adult males to females is going to be very lopsided. Will the excess males join the military to make up for the family life they cannot have? Will there be vast emigration to search for wives? It's impossible to say in my opinion, but it's interesting to think about.
- bgibson 11y agoAsked a Chinese friend of mine about this once, she said the Chinese males with means will either find Chinese wives, or will exploit a (comparatively) strong yuan and "raid" neighboring Asian countries (Vietnam, Thailand, Phillipines, etc) for wives.
- lordnacho 11y agoOne thing I think might be interesting is how the history of economic thought affects the war/peace calculus. For much of history, people thought of wealth as a sort of zero-sum (or near) game. If one country gets richer, another will get poorer. If Athens get rich, Sparta gets poor. If Britain has colonies, France and Germany need colonies. Everyone wants to be an exporter and hoard gold. The economic thought about this started to change around the time of David Ricardo (comparative advantage overturning mercantilism), but I would not be surprised if mainstream politicians took some time to understand this idea. These days it's pretty clear the US and China benefit from mutual trade, and anything upsetting that would require quite some compensation. Aside from economics, there's also the fact that we've seen massive global wars already, and we have weapons that could make the world unliveable for generations. Particularly if you look at Chinese history, there's an enormous amount of bloodshed. The party leadership will understand this.
- staticvar 11y ago> These days it's pretty clear the US and China benefit from mutual trade Yes, that is probably the current perception even with most people never hearing of competitive advantage. I wonder how climate change in the next couple of decades will change this war/peace calculus. I fear we may realize that benefits that the U.S. and China receive from trade partnerships is from extracting natural capital and replacing it with negative externalities. When that natural capital runs out and negative externalities come back to bite us in the form of climate change, what will the U.S. and China think of each other then? Will we still believe in competitive advantage then?
- exelius 11y agoChina has made a huge about-face in the last 2 years on energy. Their policy is currently to invest heavily in green energy for domestic use, and to become the global green energy technology leader. I think they will be successful - advances in energy tech take superpower-level resources, but they also tend to sustain those superpowers for a long time. China will build their dominance on 'clean' energy. No doubt about it.
- 11y ago
- csomar 11y agoBut. If we look at the recent history (the last three wars), then the probability drops (suddenly) to 0% for a new war to happen. If we look at the last 7 wars, it is 42%. Not 0, but certainly not as high as 75% (12/16). So maybe things are changing (and I guess they are). War now involves nuclear weapons, which I think they are a great detractor from getting the countries directly involved. It might be the reason why they are resolving instead to proxy wars on "innocent" countries.
- jqm 11y agoSo, why do people want to fight in the first place? Is any natural inclination all bad? If we level up in perspective from that of personal tragedy, is war an important force of evolution and largely responsible for the place we are at now? I realize technology changes the equation. And human suffering and destruction are never pleasant. So hopefully we are wise enough to find other ways and I think we will eventually. But I think in order to do this, we have to honestly admit that war has had an important role in human relations and development and the some of the outcomes of war have been for the betterment of humanity.
- hajile 11y agoThe biggest takeaway from their chart is that culture clash leads to war and bigger, more powerful countries have more noticeable wars. In addition, their chart of things that didn't result in war is mostly inaccurate. Japan vs USSR was never actually a real idea because Japan didn't have an army. USSR knew the actual battle would be against the USA. USA vs UK never existed because there wasn't a culture clash (and their focus of power was a bit different). UK, Germany, and France don't clash today because their cultures are closer than they've ever been and because they perceive a shared foreign threat in Asia. Thus we're left with the only war that never happened being USA vs USSR -- a war that didn't happen due to self-preservation. It seems most probable that USA vs China fits into the same category as USA vs USSR where self-preservation will keep war from actually happening. I don't think any reasonable person trusts a losing government to NOT use weapons of mass destruction -- especially when the first one to use them wins. It's easier to get forgiveness than permission (that happens when you're the last superpower standing).
- caf 11y agoThere certainly was USA/UK friction in the aftermath of WWI. The Washington Naval Treaty was written to stop an incipient naval arms race, in which the USA and UK were two of the major competitors.
- norea-armozel 11y agoWasn't there battle plans for invasion of Canada and vice versa around the same time? I thought it was something that could have easily occurred if Germany didn't spark WW2.
- douche 11y agoThere are generally battle plans developed for any conceivable conflict. I would not be terribly surprised if the Pentagon has war plans on file for an invasion of Canada today. That was also in the heyday of the Prussian General Staff school, which emphasized the whole concept of war plans, with things like mobilization timetables, logistics and troop movements choreographed like chess openings.
- ilaksh 11y agoWars are largely for profit and supported by propaganda. To be safe we must fight propaganda and unethical bankers. Anyone advocating for mass murder forfeits their authority. Oil and resources in general are still a big issue that could cause conflict. We should conserve and recycle much better. Mandate 1- or 2- passenger lightweight vehicles for individuals. Mandate telecommuting to some degree. Need a massive development push to replace oil-based industrial processes with bio-renewable-based processes. Also can improve land and energy use. https://runvnc.github.io/tinyvillage https://runvnc.github.io/tinyvillage
- thebakeshow 11y agoIt is interesting to me that 3 of the 4 non-war outcomes were all within the last 50 years.