6 ms·
France's Government Aims to Give Itself Carte Blanche to Spy on the World
- raindev 11y ago> The United States makes an improper division between surveillance conducted on residents of the United States, and the surveillance that is conducted with almost no restraint upon the rest of the world. > Treating two sets of innocent targets differently is already a violation of international human rights law. It was bothering me for quite a while. I'm not an American. So what? I have lesser privacy rights?! Am I lesser human? Is spying okay as long as it's not spying on you?
- yenda 11y agoAccording to the US, yes. This is an empire, it's citizen have more rights than those of the colonies.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoFrom the Constitution of USA: >"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." // This does not put a geographic limit, so all citizens (I think "the people" here is clearly a reference in context to citizens) should be excluded from having their data seized without warrant. That's got to be hard with USA citizens appearing in most populations and internet data not being clearly from any particular citizen or other person [they'll need an "isCitizen" bit so that all data packets from USA citizens can be dropped before inspection!]. Moreover the 14th Amendment to the USA Constitution appears to extend protections to all "persons", viz: >"No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws." // If the internet is under USA jurisdiction then persons there should be extended the "equal protection of the laws". One such law being that you need a warrant to search their "papers, and effects" [which clearly purposes to protect private correspondences]. Not sure how it works in the USA - to bypass this Federal operations could be considered to be outwith the jurisdiction of any state?? That would seem to require the people involved to not be citizens of the USA though, as they would then fall under the requirements for their State of residence to ensure the protection of the laws extends to people [everywhere].
- dragonwriter 11y ago"People" in the 5th Amendment means "people", not citizens; 5th Amendment protections are not limited to citizens. But note that it has no explicit warrant requirement; just a reasonableness requirement and a limit on when warrants shall issue. It's read as implicitly requiring warrants in most cases for reasonableness, but there are plenty of exceptions.
- solotronics 11y agoFor many (all?) situations the federal government considers itself the district of columbia which is not a state and is a federal territory. The Fed is thus not a state but a supra-state entity that operates outside what states would consider acceptable. They routinely trample individual and states rights. It is ironic considering the history of why the U.S. was founded that we have given in to a domestic version of the same tyranny.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bad_user 11y agoThis has been bothering me too. Biggest problem from my point of view is that the US also happens to be the steward of the Internet. This public screwup represents the perfect opportunity for governments of the world to balkanize the Internet, as in further splintering it in geographic and commercial boundaries. Countries like China now have valid arguments in the eyes of the Chinese for blocking foreign websites and services. And more and more national firewalls will happen, firewalls that will crush freedom of speech and that will end the free trade. I'm not sure if the age of the free Internet we've been enjoying is coming to an end, but you can bet your ass that governments are trying to end it. And the US government doesn't even seem to comprehend how big their screwup is.
- x5n1 11y agoAll countries should create their own facebooks and invite Americans to join theirs. It's sort of stupid to allow Facebook into any country unless all of its business operations and servers are based in the said country with proper controls. Even then that does not preclude the US government forcing Facebook to turn over data on Non-US citizens to itself. Facebook is the #1 vector of US government's indiscriminate spying on everybody's else's citizens. Google comes a close second, but you don't generally give Google as many personal details as you give to Facebook. At least not by your own free will. And that's really the problem that France has, everyone uses American services so America can basically create a dossier on everyone. No one uses French services other than French citizens, and perhaps a few other souls.
- pjc50 11y agoNext week's EU data protection "safe harbour" decision may require exactly that: Facebook may no longer be allowed to export personal data from the EU. Edit: data protection would also have a huge effect on the "peeple" app, discussion of which seems to be banned on HN.
- tempodox 11y agoNobody should be allowed to export personal data from such jurisdictions except for the owners of that data themselves. A U.S.-ian should be allowed to decide to trust their personal data to a company inside E.U. jurisdiction but that company shouldn't be allowed to trade that data anywhere else (especially, back to the U.S.). Of course, that's a complete pipe dream, and I'm just hallucinating.
- cm2187 11y agoHow do you define "export"? Does that mean any website needs to have a server located in every single country in the world?
- kuschku 11y agoIf a German user shares data with Facebook, Facebook should not be allowed to give the data to any entities in the US. You may never give userdata to anyone else or give anyone else access to userdata. Embedding tracking scripts from third parties is equally problematic. Google Analytics should be globally forbidden.
- snowwrestler 11y agoThis a structural problem; even if the language of the Constitution confers protection on foreign citizens (which I believe it does, to some extent), there are only certain situations in which foreign citizens have standing in U.S. courts. If they don't reside in the U.S. they basically have no venue to ask for relief. Even if the parent is right that it is a violation of international law, enforcement of international law is essentially voluntary.
- TurboHaskal 11y agoThat explains the cheese and wine ads.
- tajen 11y agoDisclosure: I'm French. The EFF is complaining that we are lowering what amounts to be the Human Rights, and they are right. However the EFF hasn't succeeded in taming the US standard. What may be happening here is pressure for an international agreement. We'll only have leverage to make a deal with the US if we (the rest of the world) practice the same disrespectful spy acts against innocent American citizen. Then we can agree on stopping our activities in a bilateral or UN agreement. Of course what is funny about threats from my country is that we are quite powerless. We don't have the world's Facebook records, neither do we manage the world's largest email. With this kind of law, chances are we won't. I, for one, host my email neither in France nor in US. For this threat to be leveraged against US, a lot of other countries have to do the same, until there's a major uprising against surveillance methods. The world has changed. 20 years ago, the right to not be searched when traveling within a country was enough to protect most citizen. Now all citizen cross boarders once a year or use remote Internet websites, which in both cases dismisses their rights as citizen. We need a global protection against unwarranted searches.
- dannyobrien 11y agoHi, I'm the author of the piece. What you describe, while astute, isn't what's going on here, because at the level these agreements are being made, the French intelligence services don't care that the NSA is spying on French nationals. There's no negotiation to be made: they simply want to maintain their existing capacity, but have been required to give it legal cover by the greater recent visibility of mass surveillance. In fact, among intelligence services of putative allies, having another friendly nation spy on your nationals grants you a potential advantage, since it means you can bypass domestic restrictions by simply trading intel with them. (It's also one of the reasons why bilateral agreements would be undermined, and difficult to initiate. They would also preserve the idea that some classes of innocent users are fair game for mass surveillance, while others deserve protection.) France's surveillance advantage comes from its access to submarine cables rather than local servers. That's the information it will be collecting, and potentially trading with others. Much of the problem here, I'd note, comes from not separating the defensive and offensive components of the intelligence services. Whatever you belief is the proportionate level of surveillance of a population, it's clear that an institution whose job was to protect the assets and personal data of a nation's population would have a very different attitude to letting others spy on its comma traffic than one which was primarily concerned with aggressively investigating other nations. Politicians are therefore hearing policy proposals from only one side of a debate. That's why they think that backdoors would help and not harm national security, and why they think spying on the rest of the world without oversight won't erode their own citizens' privacy.
- KaiserPro 11y agoDon't worry, here in the UK we just went ahead and spied on everyone and ignored the legal ruling. Everything is secret, using laws lets the terrorist and paedophiles win. (to summarise what the home secretary says on the matter.)
- tomtoise 11y agoTheresa May (PBUH) is the best thing to happen to the UK. (Just covering my back, who knows what lists I'm on).
- richmarr 11y agoWell at least we shit on everyone's privacy equally. So that's a nice silver lining.
- nmc 11y agoActually this is the same thing in France. The bill is simply aimed at "legalizing" practices that have been going on for years. Also, since the Snowden leaks, some actors have started to question the legality of some practices, and this bill would address those concerns. For instance, French secret services used to be able to get phone records for someone by simply calling the phone company; now, phone companies are feeling uneasy about the lack of legal frame for these practices.
- mtgx 11y ago> The original surveillance law included limits on data retention when spying on French nationals (30 days for the content of communications, four years for metadata, six years for encrypted data). The new international limits are much longer—one year, six years, and eight years respectively. I can't imagine any of that will be allowed by the EU Justice Court. Now who's going to sue the French government? The EUCJ is also going to rule on Europe vs Facebook case next week, which will affect the EU-US Safe Harbor agreement as well, and possibly some of these new spying laws in the EU. I can't wait (I think it will be a positive ruling).
- ivanhoe 11y agoI think it's pretty safe to presume that all countries are doing it already, within their technical capabilities. I'm also pretty sure they will continue to do it, regardless of any local or international laws, simply because today information means power, and I can't imagine that any government would be ready to just let it slip out of their hands.
- vlehto 11y agoAll countries are doing it sure. The important point: is it the police or the military? If only military gathers data and everything is arranged in civilided manner, then there is no way civillian could go to jail for writing the wrong sentence on facebook.
- geomark 11y agoYep. And some are dumb enough to announce they are doing it, http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/general/714432/single-gateway-protest-halts-government-websites http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/general/714432/single-gatewa...
- bsaul 11y agoI know it's easy, but i can't help remember that every single terrorist that striked in the last years in france were already identified by security services, and for a very long time. For what i know, the problem in France seems to be much further down the data pipe, aka not enough (competent) humans analysing the threat data. I very much doubt flooding those services with an even bigger stream of information will help in any way.
- wahsd 11y agoHell, why shouldn't they. The USA has already done it, why not them too. Maybe there is actually even some sort of kind of MAD principle in that concept. I don't really see how it would end up well, but it at least has a chance of a positive outcome relative to the USA dominating and spying on the world unilaterally. I guess the ideal situation would be a transglobal civil intelligence corp that hacks and publicly publishes the secrets of governments their officials and corporations. A crowd-sourced intelligence organization that tracks public figures and agents and activities across the globe.
- Intermernet 11y agoI love the EFF, but honestly, I'm not sure what they can do about this, other than educate and inform. The US, the rest of the Five Eyes, France, China, Russia, along with every state that has the ability has been, and will continue to spy illegally on the rest of the world. Passing laws to either allow or prohibit this activity is nothing but political posing so long as the laws have no determination on the penalties applied to breaking said laws. Did Clapper get imprisoned for lying to congress? Did Litvinenko get a fair trial for "exceeding the authority of his position"? Does anyone believe that Snowden would get fair treatment from an unbiased jury? This is the theater of international espionage. Without transparency, honesty and consistency, complaining about the laws, or lack thereof, is pretty much a waste of time. Or maybe I'm just overly cynical and we'll eventually get an Erin Brokovich of international espionage to blow the lid off the whole deal and hold the bastards accountable. I'm not holding my breath.
- JoachimS 11y agoAt least somebody is charging the windmills and making a fuzz even though it quite probably will lead to nothing. Not quietly follow the hearder into the darkness like most of us do. In fact, even if it is virtually hopeless we need to at least try. Otherwise we have truly lost. So all cudos and support to EFF, journalists and others that keep up the work despite all odds.
- rihegher 11y agoFrench here, I've been a web developper for more than 15 years now and I try to follow what's going on with digital laws in France and Europe thanks to "la quadrature du net". I try to inform people around me but most people don't have any interest in digital laws, because 1) most medias don't talk about it or in a caricatural way. 2) People and most member of parliament don't undestand these laws. 3) Lobbys knows 1) and 2) The results is that any digital law bills can be passed along easily as long as it doesn't disturb any strong lobbys in place as media won't talk about it and people and member of parliament won't speak up anyway. Those who understand why these laws could turn very bad are a really small minority, and small minority without lobby means can be very badly represented in a democracy. Honestly I lack imagination to think of something more to do that could make significant change here.
- 1024core 11y agoThe US, UK, etc. are doing this anyways; why not the French? Let the spying race begin.