5 ms·
Scientists say dolphins should be treated as 'non-human persons'
- grellas 17y agoMarino and Reiss will present their findings at a conference in San Diego, California, next month, concluding that the new evidence about dolphin intelligence makes it morally repugnant to mistreat them. It is morally repugnant to mistreat animals regardless of the intelligence of the animal and being a scientist has nothing to do with making such a judgment, since it is not a scientific judgment but an ethical one. Thus, the new-found evidence discussed in the article serves only to dramatize something these scientists want because of their philosophical predispositions, not because of their special knowledge as scientists. If the logic suggested in the article were true, the converse might be up for consideration as well (e.g., that we can be cruel to deer because they are so dumb). Science and advocacy are distinct and should be kept that way. There is nothing wrong with scientists acting as advocates but, when they do so, their views as advocates should normally carry no more weight than do those of others.
- DarkShikari 17y agoThus, the new-found evidence discussed in the article serves only to dramatize something these scientists want because of their philosophical predispositions, I don't think this is entirely true here. You've loaded the question by making an assumption, "It is morally repugnant to mistreat animals regardless of the intelligence of the animal" which not everyone will agree with. In fact, I suspect the vast majority of people do not: every day millions of people knowingly eat meat produced from animals that were horrifically mistreated, despite the fact that they could have eaten something else, often for a lower price. Why? Because it tastes good, and a lot of people don't care about the suffering of cows. Suppose the following moral axiom that some hypothetical person might hold: "Mistreating any sapient being is equivalently morally wrong as mistreating a human." Therefore, if scientists can prove that an animal is sapient, those who follow such a belief will agree that such an animal should not be mistreated. I don't see the problem with scientists arguing that an animal is sapient.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- NathanKP 17y agoI totally agree and after reading the article I was going to post this exact same comment but you beat me to it. I would say that it is just as morally repugnant or in fact more morally repugnant to mistreat an animal that is not intelligent. It is not like lack of intelligence makes it alright to mistreat an animal.
- niczar 17y agoIs it morally repugnant to mistreat a plant? Is it morally repugnant to mistreat an animal with just one (1) neuron? Is it morally repugnant to mistreat an animal with just 100 000 neurons? Well that's how many lobsters have. My PC has billions of transistors. Granted, that's not the same as neurons by a very long shot, but it's not unreasonable to think that we could emulate a neuron with a few tens of thousand of transistors. Is it morally repugnant to mistreat a PC? I'm not concluding anything here. Just asking. (Besides there's the other issue of defining "mistreat.") I'm just annoyed by empty, generic statements like this. They don't say mean much of anything, and do not make us understand the issue any better.
- barrkel 17y agoHow well do you treat mice that have invaded your home? How about cockroaches? How do you avoid mistreating worms while doing your gardening?
- itistoday 17y agoThe article is not discussing the ethical question of "mistreatment", but rather that of legal rights. This is an important distinction. Anyone can advocate for dolphin rights, but, as scientists who have done research on dolphins, they are in a position to make ethical arguments against keeping dolphins in a zoo for public entertainment. The rationale behind these arguments are grounded firmly in science. You have to be able to show the research that proves that one animal has no sense of self, while another (a dolphin) does, etc.
- CapitalistCartr 17y ago"Anyone can advocate for dolphin rights, but, as scientists who have done research on dolphins, they are in a position to make ethical arguments against keeping dolphins in a zoo for public entertainment." "The rationale behind these arguments are grounded firmly in science. You have to be able to show the research that proves that one animal has no sense of self, while another (a dolphin) does, etc." We are all in a position to make ethical arguments; I often do. But its not science. They are obviously in a position to know more about dolphins than most, but whether we change our policies regarding them might be grounded in science (for a change), but it is not, in and of itself, science, and they aren't experts in that. As for a sense of self, I don't treat animals humanely because they have a sense of self, but because I do.
- warfangle 17y agoThis is more about not treating dolphins as animals, not whether or not we should treat them humanely. There's a subtle but distinct difference.
- grellas 17y agoThe legal rights distinction, in my view, does not alter the basic point - ethics determines how are laws are shaped and, while science can furnish the data points, it goes no further to help us determine the ethical outcome. For example, the researchers are said to argue that it is "morally unacceptable" for dolphins to be killed by accident by humans while fishing. Of course, laws might be passed making it a misdemeanor to kill a dolphin accidentally in such a context and perhaps make the perpetrator pay a fine. Or they might make it a felony and impose jail time as well. Or they might say that mens rea or evil intent is a required element of the crime. Or any one of many other variations. Or the laws might simply state that there is no culpability if a human who is fishing happens to kill a dolphin. The above represents a broad range of potential judgments on a legal issue that is ultimately an ethical question (what we ought to do) affected by a scientific truth (what is empirically verifiable) whose discoverers are in no better position than is any other intelligent person to opine. Scientists may opine but no special deference ought to be paid to their ethical judgments simply because they are scientists.
- dazzawazza 17y agoThe opinion of a scientist with a deep understanding of the biology of intelligence is worth more then my shallow understanding of biology. Everyone's opinion does not have equal weight. I agree though that no one group has a monopoly on ethics and everyone can have an opinion of some worth.
- Locke1689 17y agoWe make moral judgements to the contrary every day. Our implicit acceptance that humans are "worth more" than other animals acknowledges both an innate desire to defend one's own species over all others, but also that a heirarchy of superiority. For example, you would object to a massacre of puppies but would not over a massacre of bacteria. The question lies in how you decide superiority. Thr religious tend to believe that we are "made in gods image" and thus superior. I am not religious, so I define my heirarchy by the ability of the species to comprehend the universe and its disruptiveness to other species. This is probably equally arbitrary, but it has at least some logic behind it. I view knowledge of the universe as humanity's ultimate goal as a species and thus judge species based on their ability to complete said goal. When it comes to a choice between harming another species and the alternative I make a moral judgement based on the species "intelligence". I obviously never justify senseless violence and tend to abhor any purposeful torture. The scientists' information is thus very important to my moral system. P.s. Sorry for any typos or similar, this is posted from an iPhone.
- davepeck 17y ago> I define my heirarchy by the ability of the species to comprehend the universe and its disruptiveness to other species. This is probably equally arbitrary, but it has at least some logic behind it. I have a very similar view of the world, and when a friend tried to get me (last night!) to put it on firm logical footing, I was unable to. Why should our ability to comprehend the universe be the yardstick by which we measure ourselves? I feel that it is a reasonable measure, but I can't give sound reasoning for it. Somehow, I think this property (which appears to be unique to us, at least in our own biosphere) is deep in a way that, say, the ability to swim gracefully in water is not.
- jimbokun 17y ago"Why should our ability to comprehend the universe be the yardstick by which we measure ourselves?" The movie Avatar (obviously on my mind because I recently saw it) tries to bring the audience around to the opposite conclusion. The movie makes clear that the humans better comprehend the universe (star ships, ability to create bodies to control remotely, etc.) but then unequivocally roots for the aliens who demonstrate no interest at all in the scientific method. Which I guess is a long winded way of saying, the ability to comprehend the universe is certainly not accepted as the most important yardstick of worth by all your fellow human beings.
- nudist 17y agoIt's not a scientific judgement? How can you say it's OK to kill plants but not "animals," considering they are made of essentially the same thing? Where is the line? It's fairly easy to trace the evolution of the nervous system from simple single-celled organisms to modern animals. Moral repugnance is a purely human invention.
- hyperbovine 17y agoPlants and animals are made of essentially the same thing? Plants have no nervous system and absolutely no capacity for suffering. It is impossible to inflict pain on a plant. By contrast, most animals are capable of experiencing physical and even mental anguish. Once you admit this, good luck trying to build a coherent moral argument for why human suffering should be abhorrent while all other forms of animal suffering are fair game. This is "speciesism," a term introduced by the philosopher Peter Singer in his famous book Animal Liberation. I have never read a convincing refutation of the argument therein. There is a line. It simply requires some thought to elucidate it.
- nudist 17y agoPain? When you poke a Euglena[1] with a pin while looking at it under a microscope, its sensors detect an intrusion and immediately start flapping the flagella (the thing it uses for locomotion, analogous to a leg) to get out of the way. That's a super-simple nervous system. Many plants do this as well, using a slow production of chemicals which move branches and leaves. As you get more advanced, going up the biological totem pole, every creature uses that exact same sensor => action mechanism. Pain is the brain's complex interpretation of the pin prick, and an animal attempting to remove itself from the source of the pain is the same as activating the flagella. My brain has mirror neurons which make me literally feel your suffering as you experience it, which is why humans are so against "pain" and "suffering". It's also why I personally will never injure another human, or even another animal, purposefully. Is it more "wrong" in any scientific way to injure a human instead of a dolphin or a bear or a chimp or a plant -- or even to break a window? Absolutely not. This is why science should never be used to prove or disprove human "morals" and morals should never dictate the functions of science. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euglena http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euglena
- pkulak 17y agoThe ethics of mistreatment are tied to inteligence of the species, however. Stepping on an ant, or cutting down a tree is not the same as killing an animal. Who knows where the lines are, but the distinctions exist.
- miles 17y ago"What is it that should trace the insuperable line? ...The question is not, Can they reason? nor Can they talk? but, Can they suffer?" -- Jeremy Bentham
- amichail 17y agoAre dolphins intelligent in a different way than chimps? This is an example of somewhat parallel evolution after all.
- andrewljohnson 17y agoThe article is interesting and has lots of actual facts about dolphin neurology that kept me reading. I could do without the political crusade though.
- niczar 17y agoThe "crusade" is a good way of raising awareness to the issue. I don't care much for generic animal right activists. In fact, I think most of them, and in particular Peta, are complete morons and deserve to DIAF. But proto-sapient animals are another issue altogether. And there's not just mammals. Corvids are damn smart. Attenborough had a documentary showing Japanese crows dropping nuts on roads at traffic lights. They wait for cars to run over them and break them, and wait for the red light to go pick them up. Well, here's some original research: I've witnessed this happen in Europe, too. There is also research showing that crows can recognize faces, AND pass the information to other crows that some particular person is bad. Watch it here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XNuQURJJBlE&feature=youtube_gdata http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XNuQURJJBlE&feature=youtu... Edit: this is in the 4th video, not the 5th that I linked here.
- rms 17y agoI strongly recommend the movie The Cove. It's much more entertaining and less depressing than you would expect. Available via DVD or bittorrent. http://www.thecovemovie.com/ http://www.thecovemovie.com/ (flash site so I can't link directly to the trailer)
- pmichaud 17y agoThe movie is actually quite depressing, but I was happy to find out after watching that the practice has, at least temporarily, stopped.
- rms 17y agoYeah, I know, my point is that there is less footage of dolphins being killed than most people expect after hearing the description. And yes, it's absolutely amazing that an activist film such as this worked. How often has that happened in the history of documentary filmmaking? I think it's a shoe-in for the best documentary Academy Award this year.
- elblanco 17y agoGood, we should then start making them liable for violations of laws as well. Dolphin researchers know for example that some dolphins like to form gangs and go around harassing other dolphins and forcing themselves sexually on female dolphins. Should we also send out the police patrol and lock them up?
- jacquesm 17y agoNo, you should leave that to the Dolphin police. To force human norms and laws on Dolphins would be to anthropomorphize (sp?) and that is exactly what the article warns against. If you start of from the assumption they are non-human persons then you'll have to admit to their right to self govern their society.
- elblanco 17y agoWhat about when dolphins violate human laws? Like breaking undersea cables or eating fish hauls still in net, or attacking a human or some other such violation? This would seem to be most closely analogous to an international border violation.
- jacquesm 17y agoNo, you are still trying to treat Dolphins as human persons. Dolphins could not violate human law since they are not human. International implies nations, Dolphins probably would not recognize nations. For an encore, with a wink to Douglas Adams, they might not even recognize humans as particularly intelligent.
- elblanco 17y agoOf course we both know that mice are in charge. :) I think though, what this shows is that there is the potential for a very interesting and lively debate as to how far something like "non-human person" extends. If we don't hold them liable to any kind of responsibility for particular extensions of rights beyond what we'd show any other animal, then are we not just treating them like another animal -- and thus the new classification as a "non-human person" is simply superfluous?
- JulianMorrison 17y agoI'm far from convinced. On the one hand, their shape and their environment explains why they never copied the concept of technology from us. On the other, it does nothing to prevent them having art, literature, math, or creating a pidgin and talking to us. And on the third hand, we anatomically modern humans spent our first 150,000 years doing essentially sod all, so we can hardly complain. I would want evidence of bidirectional conversation before calling them "people". Otherwise, I think they're "almost-people". Maybe near-future science can uplift them the rest of the way.
- jacquesm 17y agoBy your standards plenty of disabled people would not qualify as people.
- JulianMorrison 17y agoAbsolutely the opposite - disabled people are a perfect illustration of why humans are definitely "people". We work around our difficulties. Can't hear? Use sign language. Can't speak? Write it down. Human minds in dolphin bodies would quickly work out similar hacks. The fact that dolphins don't is what makes it hard to qualify them as people.
- jacquesm 17y ago> I would want evidence of bidirectional conversation before calling them "people". There are plenty of people that are not capable of that in any way that most people would recognize. The dog analogy comes to mind: Dogs are smarter than people because they understand us but we do not understand them. edit: We seem to place the onus of proving your intelligence and your ability to communicate on others before giving them the moniker 'sentient' or 'intelligent'. By laying an arbitrary ('good enough for you') marker and saying 'jump over that and I'll accept you) we judge everybody by our own norms, whereas that is not a good way to look at any of these issues at all. A nice example from the animal kingdom would be the ant, the bee or the termite. As a single individual they're not going to pass an intelligence test by human standards any time soon. But as a collective they exhibit very complex behaviour that could possibly qualify as intelligent. To put up a barrier for Dolphins to prove they're intelligent makes intelligence a linear affair, cross the threshold and you're 'in'. But plenty of people exist that could not cross that same threshold, even by employing the tricks you mentioned. For instance, there is a state of being called 'locked in'. A person is 100% aware of their environment but also 100% paralyzed. By your standards these people would not qualify as people because they are wholly incapable of communication. see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locked-in_syndrome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locked-in_syndrome
- jacquesm 17y agoPersonally I think it would be great if humans started treating other humans categorically in an ethical way. That's a ways off I'm afraid though. It's important to see that these are obviously non-related issues but I don't have much hopes for our stance towards Dolphins as long as we haven't learned to do this with each other.
- brl 17y agoTo me this is quite obviously a very related issue. As long as people refuse to recognize the moral interests of animals, it is not logically consistent for them to respect moral obligations to other humans. The moral distinction between animals and humans is a completely arbitrary prejudice and should be immediately identified as such by anybody with even a basic understanding of evolutionary biology. Humans are animals.
- jacquesm 17y ago> Humans are animals. I wished that was a universally accepted truth, alas that is very much not the case (not in the least in the US). Somehow we seem to have gotten it in to our heads that we are special instead of simply evolved. And then there are subsets of all humans that think that they in turn are even more special. Go figure...
- Devilboy 17y agoI would think Bonobos are first in line for 'non human personhood'
- cabalamat 17y agoWhy can't cats be persons? They certainly have personalities. And they can recognise themselves in mirrors; at least, my cat reacts differently to seeing himself than he would do to another cat. They are also a lot cuter than dolphins.
- elblanco 17y agoWhy not? We've tried to abuse test like IQ and apply them to dolphins and apes and such. Dogs and cats also seem to have a measurable IQ and they certainly have personalities and emotions. And outside of a few notable areas, eating any of these animals is generally considered taboo.
- kingkawn 17y agoReminders me of this time article about whales: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/12/magazine/12whales-t.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/12/magazine/12whales-t.html An elegant piece on them.
- kingkawn 17y agoDoes non-human person make them better than us?
- scotty79 17y agoFinding about dolphins not mentioned in article: Dolphins have names in dolphin speech. Sequence of sounds unique for each dolphin by uttering which other dolphins that know him might call him.
- kaitnieks 17y agoWe certainly don't need to fear that dolphins could try to dominate or exterminate us. So why bother treating them in any special way? The reason for morale and ethics is to maintain society and minimize risk of revenge. In case of dolphins there's hardly a society, the risk of revenge is none. To keep natural balance we should restrain ourselves from killing them all off or domesticating all of them and that's it. Maybe this is too brutal opinion for modern times but I think people have gone too far in their foolishness. We should remember our real place and our real power, so that we can learn to use it more responsibly, instead of playing silly Ramen (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concepts_in_the_Ender%27s_Game_series#The_hierarchy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concepts_in_the_Ender%27s_Game_...) games out of the boredom.
- rms 17y agoIt's an emotional argument, not a logical argument.