6 ms·
Sad as it may be, it's pretty clear at this point that XMPP won't be the communication protocol of the future. Everyone who ever seriously worked on it seem to
by scrollaway 11y ago
Sad as it may be, it's pretty clear at this point that XMPP won't be the communication protocol of the future. Everyone who ever seriously worked on it seem to have come out of the experience a broken man. Setting it up requires pretty deep knowledge and the promises of compatibility with most XMPP servers break down pretty fast unless you know which extensions to support.
All these problems are fixable but I don't see the tide ever actually changing direction and "hey suddenly XMPP is cool again, we should all use it".
One thing is for certain... humanity needs standard, open and widely-used protocols for communication. And there's a lot of ground to cover: Text, audio, video; single and multiuser; topical (IRC-like); social (invite-based/people I know); Synchronous (IM) and asynchronous (email/offline messaging)...
XMPP tried to do a lot of that. Maybe it tried to do too much. Maybe you just can't do all that in one protocol. I don't know, I just hope we'll get there soon - if nothing else, I'm tired of maintaining those "best way to reach me" charts JoshM33k is talking about.
- fletchowns 11y agoWho might be the right entity to take on creating a replacement for XMPP?
- scrollaway 11y ago¯\_(ツ)_/¯ One of the best things that could happen today I think is Google open sourcing the Hangouts protocol. It's a reasonable alternative to XMPP and has a massive userbase. The clients are pretty horrible but that might be completely unrelated to how good the protocol is (Note: I have no idea how good it is. Because it's closed source.). I was hopeful for a while but I don't really see it happening anymore :( Oh well... Edit: Oh and the worst part: Communication is just one side of that coin. The other side is identity and it's one hell of a side. OpenID was a disaster. Mozilla got it mostly right with Persona but completely botched the marketing and has all but given up on it now. There is no decent foss protocol for identity/authentication today other than Persona, and nobody is working on one. There was a time indeed where I could've pictured Google working on solving this just for the hell of it. Just because it would improve the world. That Google is gone, and there's nobody with the appropriate reach that seems willing to do it now.
- lstamour 11y agoIdentity is a separate problem. So far, https://www.accountchooser.com https://www.accountchooser.com and OpenID is winning -- if by winning you mean maintaining a list of very popular email providers and using their APIs. ;-)
- StavrosK 11y agoI will forever mourn and be angered by Mozilla giving up on Persona so easily.
- fletchowns 11y agoWhy is Persona dead? Visiting the site doesn't seem to give any indication it's dead...
- notatoad 11y agoIt's been "given to the community" or something like that. They didn't kill it, but they aren't paying any staff to work on it anymore.
- StavrosK 11y agoWhat notatoad said, plus I don't think they're maintaining things very well any more. Last time I tried to use the ecosystem, various non-core things were breaking. Huge pity, it's a very well-designed protocol.
- lukeh 11y agoPersona was great and it's a bit sad to see it dead after investing a lot of time in it but - one big architectural problem was there was no way to support delegation (the problem OAuth was originally designed to solve).
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoYeah, I can't see Google ever either open sourcing Hangouts, or making it possible to federate it. Google's opinion seems to be that everything that is a service or protocol should be a Google API.
- vbezhenar 11y agohttps://matrix.org https://matrix.org is a promising candidate.
- scrollaway 11y agoI remember reading about matrix when they first announced. Was pretty excited about it, haven't heard anything since. I It's just tech though; even if it's mind-blowingly great, won't do much good if no large-scale userbase picks it up somehow.
- ara4n 11y agoWe're still alive and going strong - currently supporting glossy client development like Vector.im and building out bridges to as many other networks as possible (IRC, Slack, HipChat etc) using http://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-appservice-bridge http://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-appservice-bridge and similar. In terms of being picked up by a large user base... yes, we need it if we are to be really relevant. And that means relying on folks like those commenting on this thread to try using it, contributing to it, and help us make it better.
- scrollaway 11y agoWell I'll do my part on mindshare, I do like what I see :) Maybe you guys should do another Show HN.
- sitkack 11y agoI don't know who will do it, but it will be in-band, meaning inside http and using html5.
- ara4n 11y agoWhilst we're not trying to replace XMPP, Matrix.org does provide an entirely different architecture (decentralised and evetually-consistent history, high baseline feature set, HTTP-based, etc) that can be used for group chat/VoIP/etc.
- rdtsc 11y agoYap. Agreed. XMPP looked good on paper, if you read just the mission statement. Thinking back, I tried to dive into it once and nope-d out of it quickly. I guess I just blocked that experience out of my mind for some reason.
- catern 11y ago>Setting it up requires pretty deep knowledge Not even remotely true! Prosody on Debian works out of the box, including federation. You just have to configure the domain name. It's not hard to set up an XMPP server. It's hard to set up Ejabberd. Ejabberd is not the only XMPP server. Prosody is very easy to set up. Honestly, people, think before you speak...
- scrollaway 11y ago> Honestly, people, think before you speak... I didn't just make this up on the spot, I've been dealing with these issues for years. So yes, I've thought about them a lot. I used to run a prosody server on my home box. It is great software and a fantastic daemon compared to ejabberd (edit: Configuration-wise that is) but fat lot of good that does if you don't know what XEPs to set up when dealing with other servers. I shut it down because it was pretty much useless and I wasn't able to talk to my gtalk buddies from it anymore.
- catern 11y ago> fat lot of good that does if you don't know what XEPs to set up when dealing with other servers. I have no idea what XEPs to set up when dealing with other servers. I did not have to set up any such thing. Like I said, federation (server to server communication) works out of the box, at least on Debian.
- sanderjd 11y agoYour comment is informative, but the last sentence is unnecessary and inflammatory.
- catern 11y agoYou're right. I would delete it, but it's past the edit deadline.
- dorfsmay 11y agoI've been using OpenFire, no problem there either. I had never heard of Prosody, any major difference cons/pros between the two?