9 ms·
If IP addresses are scarce, why does it not seem to cost me anything to get one? I've had a bunch of online servers that came with a static IP, and an ISP servi
by lordnacho 11y ago
If IP addresses are scarce, why does it not seem to cost me anything to get one? I've had a bunch of online servers that came with a static IP, and an ISP service that came with one, at various times. It seldom seemed to be explicitly priced, and when it was the price was not really something worth considering.
- organsnyder 11y agoStatic or dynamic, the cost to the ISP is basically the same (perhaps a bit more for static if it's harder for them to manage the allocation); therefore, it's already built in to the cost of the service. Have you tried getting additional IP addresses? One ISP charges me 50 cents/month per address for my colo box, while Comcast Business charges around $2/month (IIRC).
- lordnacho 11y ago>Have you tried getting additional IP addresses? Yeah. The price doesn't suggest scarcity. I guess the thing with the routing tables makes sense. I wonder if there's a way to rationalize that without it getting too messy. IIRC ipv6 thought of this and split up its address space in a roughly geographical way.
- vidarh 11y agoThe price doesn't yet suggest scarcity because most ISPs have not yet had to start buying IP addresses because going to e.g. ARIN has been an option, and so they've not been pricing in acquisition costs. It will rise, in proportion to the pain people experience in reducing their usage and/or switching to IPv6.
- msbarnett 11y agoBecause address allocation is inefficient and it is impractical to address this inefficiency in IPv4. ARIN is out but your ISP has extras. Why doesn't your ISP sell its extras, since a scarce resource should have monetary value? Routing tables. Selling individual IPs off piecemeal isn't practical because routers simply do not have enough RAM to handle the enormous routing tables that would resultantly be necessary in order for packets to find their destinations.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoI have a hard time seeing how IPv6 solves this problem. If we allocate them all individually, we have a world-shattering routing table problem. If we allocate them in gargantuan blocks, we have the same problem we have now with IPv4 -- we can't reallocate because routing becomes an impossible task. What am I missing? We're certainly not going to get the allocation right by doing it all at the beginning.
- drdaeman 11y ago> If we allocate them in gargantuan blocks, we have the same problem we have now with IPv4 The problem with IPv4 is that when ISP can't get more, so they have to put some unlucky users behind a NAT. The company I worked for got /21, but we had way more than 2K simultaneously connected users. And, well, we failed the timing to get another allocation, and (I had left since then) is even more unlikely they'll get one those days. IPv6 solves that by making all the blocks giant. With IPv6, when ISP is allocated /48 and allocates /64 per client - comparing to IPv4, it's like everyone gets a mighty /16 block right from the start, so even a tiniest company can grow to 65K users. And if they grow more, there is no problem in getting another subnet, those are not scarce, too.
- ghshephard 11y agoWith IPv6 the smallest allocation an ISP gets is a /32 (and it's pretty easy to get more as the ISP starts to fully utilize that /32). And even a small business can get a /48 from an ISP with almost no questions asked. That means, starting out, a company can grow to 65K networks (each network with effectively unlimited number of nodes on it). And, just as you said, getting another /48 won't be a problem.
- drdaeman 11y agoOuch. Yes. Sorry, you're absolutely right, it's /32, not /48. Was sleepy writing that comment and got numbers messed up in my head :) The logic still stands, it's just that problem's solved by just making everything giant.
- memracom 11y agoBecause IP addresses are NOT scarce. They are so plentiful and so cheap that a single residential user will get a /54 block containing 18 billion billion IPv6 addresses. There is no catch. All you have to do is use IPv6 (which you are already using unless you have explicitly turned it off). Many people have IPv6 network traffic running on their networks without even realizing it because it is included by default with every operating system. The article that was posted only refers to the old-fashioned simplistic IPv4 addresses and they are only still in use because too many graybeards want to stick with what they learned 30 years ago. Learning new technology is not that hard. Run with it.
- bluehazed 11y agoMost consumer ISPs still do not support native IPv6 (at least here in Canada, pretty sure it's about the same in the US). OS support is one thing, but actually having network access is another.
- marme 11y agoComcast, the largest isp in the US, already claims to have ipv6 support in all markets since 2014. AT&T the next largest also claims full support. I would guess the majority of US residential internet users have ipv6 support from their ISP but they are just not using it because they have old modems or routers that dont support ipv6
- simoncion 11y agoI can confirm that in San Francisco, I've had a DHCPv6-PD assigned allocation for far longer than a year. When Comcast claimed to throw the switch to enable IPv6 for all of their residential customers a while back, something wonky happened to my IPv6 service (and stayed happened for several days) that required me to reboot my cable modem (which then proceeded to download a new config file and reboot several times) in order to resolve it.
- teraflop 11y agoI actually think this is less true than it used to be; the problem now is mainly on the server side. A substantial fraction of US residential customers can get IPv6 access as long as their network equipment supports it. But aside from a few prominent names -- like Google, Wikipedia, and Facebook -- the vast majority of the internet is only accessible if you have a v4 address. From the latest statistics I could find, about 7-8% of Google visitors are connecting via IPv6 [1], but only about 1% of the Alexa top 10,000 sites are v6-enabled. [2] [1]: https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html [2]: https://www.vyncke.org/ipv6status/allgreen.php https://www.vyncke.org/ipv6status/allgreen.php
- userbinator 11y agoThe price of an IP is usually included in the price of the service. Note that in some parts of Southeast Asia, you can pay for a cheaper "web access" which is not a full Internet connection with a public IP, but essentially puts you in a huge LAN behind a NAT.
- jkyle 11y agoBecause while those IPs have been allocated it does not mean they're being currently used. So, ARIN can't allocate any more to providers but many providers are not yet feeling the pinch yet so they're not passing the cost onto you. Give it a time and you'll start seeing IPv4's coming at a premium and IPv6's being free. edit Also interesting, check out whose holding the /8's. [1] Some of them make sense like AT&T, but others don't...like MIT. Why's a university holding 224 ip addresses? Well, they just happen to be one of the first network holders. HP has 2 /8's which sounds pretty absurd (unless there's some reason I don't know that HP needs over 32 million ip addresses).
- gaadd33 11y agoOne of HP's allocations is from DEC I believe.
- jkyle 11y agoYeah, it is. But that's a hell of a lot of real estate for a single vendor whose not even providing significant network services.
- pilif 11y ago> Why's a university holding 224 ip addresses? 224? A /8 leaves 24 bits for the hosts. That's 16.7M addresses
- joepie91_ 11y agoIt does cost you, it's just calculated into the price of the service. Try looking at for example a service like LowEndSpirit[1], which offers NATed VPS services for 3 euro a year(!) - it would be literally impossible to offer this service with a dedicated IPv4 address, and indeed the dedicated IPv4 VPS services typically start at $12-$15 per year. Most of that $12-$15 is IP costs. [1] http://lowendspirit.com/index.html http://lowendspirit.com/index.html EDIT: Oh yes, no Markdown. Right.