14 ms·
> But there’s an important line to draw between that and using an SPR for ad hoc manipulation of the world’s markets. On this point, Martin Young is emphatic: “
by jacobolus 11y ago
> But there’s an important line to draw between that and using an SPR for ad hoc manipulation of the world’s markets. On this point, Martin Young is emphatic: “The oil stocks are not there for price management as such,” he explains, “they’re there to correct a shortage in the market because of a supply disruption.”
Strategic reserves can absolutely also be used as an offensive economic weapon, however. As one example, when Salvador Allende became President of Chile in the early 1970s and nationalized Chilean copper mining, the US dumped >250,000 tons of copper from its strategic reserves onto the world market, crashing the price, in a (quite successful) attempt to destabilize the Chilean economy, which was heavily reliant on copper exports. Of course when that still didn’t lead to Allende’s downfall, plan B was a CIA-sponsored military coup.
- Shivetya 11y agoI am not beyond believing that the current gutting of oil prices was done at the US's behest to damage Russia. It wouldn't take too much in the way of guarantees to Saudi Arabia to have them swamp the markets. Far more effective than military intervention.
- retube 11y agoSorry but that's nonsense. It's a well known and indeed publically admitted strategy by the Saudi's to drive US shale producers out of business. Google "saudia arabia united states oil price" for many authoritive hits on the subject. Russia was collateral damage.
- Scarbutt 11y agoCome on, are all those US shale producers really that dumb? they knew that if they started flooding the market they just wouldn't be able to compete, the U.S doesn't care much about all those small shale producers when it has bigger fish to fry.
- ghshephard 11y ago"Small Shale Producers?" We're talking about 49% of total US crude oil production. http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=847&t=6 http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=847&t=6
- wehadfun 11y agoYou can google "Russia united stated oil price" and find authoritative hits supporting the other argument.
- api 11y agoWhether intentional or not, Russia's economy is something like 40% oil and gas so the effect was certainly severe.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoWhy not both? Gives a better reason for the Saudi's to go along with the plan. They help the US political side and get paid in political good will and getting to damage the US competitors.
- rancur 11y agobecause we don't care that much about Russia. This isn't the 80's. OPEC got greedy, that created room for shale, and Russia got hurt.
- elektromekatron 11y agoHello, there's a fairly warm little proxy war going down right now in Ukraine and an increase in Russian forces in Syria. The 80's were the nice hopeful bit.
- rancur 11y agoyes, those were the days when Russia could at least hope they would win a war with us
- elektromekatron 11y agoFrom my understanding the dump was started from financial companies that had loads of oil sitting around in tankers and the Saudis then followed and met the price, but didn't set it.
- ckozlowski 11y agoA bit of both. I wouldn't characterize as being quite so malicious, but it's business for sure. The Saudi's need to maintain market share, even if they are selling it cheaper. They're banking on the price going back up, and if it does and the world has switched to US suppliers, then they're out even more. But there's another country they're looking to disrupt, one who's primary source of income is through oil sales due to sanctions. Their biggest enemy. Iran.
- Shivetya 11y agoFigure it this way, Obama killed two birds with one stone.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoIt's certainly not beyond conception! As Assange mentioned in this interview, a wikileaks cable showed how the US departments all work together to achieve a Foreign Policy aim, for example when a a country needs to be isolated by the they work together to apply pressure in the economic, diplomatic, military and public relations realm. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3HWiydFlJc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3HWiydFlJc
- dogma1138 11y agoThat's how a functional nation works. When the executive branch decides on a policy all of the departments muster to achieve it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cylinder 11y agoAnd why shouldn't they cooperate together?
- Synaesthesia 11y agoNo, nothing wrong with that, but there is sometimes a perception that there is some competition between the branches of government, or a conflict of interest.
- icanhackit 11y ago> US departments all work together to achieve a Foreign Policy aim My interpretation wasn't that they're working together, i.e. coordinating, more like acting in unison where they are each given a different pressure-point to attack suited to their innate abilities or field. So a central goal would be established at the highest level and you give a task to each entity that can contribute in their own separate ways to that goal - e.g. a newspaper leaks something that will destabilize something. An NGO will support a particular group with food, AID, legal advice, protection. A diplomat will call in some favors. They're all doing different things with different effects that will hopefully contribute towards the greater goal, which would also explain how things can go pear-shaped if it doesn't all lock together into a cohesive outcome.
- cloakandswagger 11y agoGeopolitics are rarely so simple that they can be boiled down to a single cause-and-effect like this.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoThis is fairly conspiratorial. SA was looking at all this fracking and realizing fracking could easily invalidate its oil wealth. All it has is oil wealth. If the regime wants to survive it must compete with fracking. I'm not sure why this is suddenly a surprise as HN and other popular sites have had fracking articles for years and those articles specifically mention the threat fracking is to SA's oil wealth. That's on top of the upcoming electric car revolution, which is very much depress oil prices futher as demand plummets. And that's on top of China's oil demand going down as its slowing down its mega-building projects and entering an economic slowdown. It probably doesn't help that Putin is messing around the mideast and trying to get all sorts of oil/gas pipelines running through it. On top of Putin cozying up to Iran, which is SA's regional rival. I imagine there's a realpolitik angle here and probably a dozen other angles, but the idea that the US called up SA and made them drop prices solely to hurt Putin laughable. Putin is already hurting Putin by forcing sanctions on himself with his various annexations. Even without the oil drop, Russia's economy would still be in the shitter. They can't get the loans they need to beat the recession that's been brewing for years. They can't modernize their economy, can't diversify, etc. They scared off foreign investors with their annexations, civilian targeting, corruption, and nationalization of wealth. What country did the founder of VK flee to, for example? The oil price drop is just the icing on Putin's incompetence. The ruble is now 0.015 US Dollar, which is half its historic price. We didn't get here by oil price drops alone. Putin is digging his own grave here, and by proxy, the Russian people's.
- irq-1 11y agoI Googled this yesterday thinking the same thing, but the real increases in production came from Iraq (nearly doubling yearly output) and the extra US production. Saudi Arabia didn't seem to have any substantial change in production. Maybe I'm wrong, but that's what I found. Politically, if Saudi Arabia can't be counted on to fix prices when faced with a threat like Russia and Ukraine, then why does the US keep them as an ally, since they're clearly involved with terrorism?
- adventured 11y agoSaudi Arabia has only added about a million barrels per day during the supposed attempt to weaken US frackers. By contrast, the US added about three million barrels per day in three years ('12,'13,'14). Most of the oil price damage was caused by the dollar. Oil had been running at significant global oversupply for years before the dollar began to crash the price back in June/July 2014. That same dollar effect threw Canada into a recession, cut Australia's growth rate in half, and crushed emerging markets including Brazil. Long before Saudi Arabia boosted production, the dollar took off on its greatest run in decades. Oil immediately began to crash from there forward. The USSR also collapsed due to the strong dollar 30 years ago, which dropped the price of oil substantially. Oil went from $140 inflation adjusted, for three years, to plunging off a cliff to $35 or so, courtesy of Volcker's strong dollar move. And then again Russia nearly imploded during the cheap oil days of 1997-2000, also caused by an extremely strong dollar (gold hit around ~$250).
- JTon 11y agoHow exactly does a strong USD decrease the price of oil?
- ci5er 11y agoOil contracts and futures are priced in USD. This is what the phrase "Petro-dollar" refers to. And this is why everyone needs a big slug of dollars in their respective reserves - to buy oil. This scheme as been pretty good for the US, but other players are not quite so enamored with it. When the dollar is strong, it takes fewer of them to buy a barrel of oil. ITT there is a lot of talk about the production side of the equation, but the effect of the strong dollar and weaker Chinese demand have played a role too. China is talking with Russia, Saudi Arabia and Iran about RMB denominated contracts, so that'll be fun. Currency risk will have to factored into contract prices.
- frandroid 11y agoSaudi Arabia has its own interest in crippling the Iranian economy further. If we're looking at a geopolitical goal beyond Saudi's own need to keep oil cheap to undermine renewables and U.S. shale oil, that would come way before the American desires to undermine Russia. Saudi Arabia is strongly allied with the U.S. but doesn't feel particularly threatened by Russia.
- mediumdeviation 11y agoThat's interesting, but how is any commodity able to have it's price pushed down by a single seller dumping from a fixed reserve? If the market notice that the extra supply is coming from a fixed reserve, then they'd rightly be able to infer that at some point the supply will run out, and prices will return to market value, which would in turn drive up prices again. It probably won't go back to the previous equilibrium price because of the cost of storage and interest, but it should be close.
- learnstats2 11y agoBut this does work in practice - it basically describes OPEC's current strategy, and perhaps relates to Starbucks' ongoing market strategy, etc. The price may return to the equilibrium price at some point, but the single seller is able to hold it low for as long as they have reserves to dump. If other sellers are dependent on sales, then they must compete.
- refurb 11y agoit basically describes OPEC's current strategy Not really. OPEC's strategy is one of production. Based on their reserves, OPEC could keep it up for decades. If you're dumping a strategic reserve, it has a limited time span and likely the market can estimate how long since the reserve was public info.
- pjc50 11y ago
- refurb 11y agothe US dumped >250,000 tons of copper from its strategic reserves onto the world market Do you have a source with more details? 250,000 tons of copper doesn't really sounds like much. Wikipedia says annual WW production is 18M tons, so the US dumped 1.4% of one's year production on the market. Sure, enough to depress prices, but for how long? It would seem like you'd need to keep dumping over a long period of time otherwise the price would dip for a few months, then recover.
- minikites 11y agoWas that the annual production now or in the 70s?
- jacobolus 11y agoThat’s today, which seems to be about 3x higher than in ~1970. Overall (according to google sleuthing) the price of copper was down by about 25% in 1971–1972 compared to 1970. Keep in mind: (1) Copper made up something like 2/3 of Chile’s exports at the time, so every incremental price drop was a severe blow; (2) The US simultaneously cut Chile off from international credit and aid; (3) The CIA helped organize industrial sabotage, protests, strikes, etc., so there was also some disruption to Chilean production at the time. You can read the White House memo here: http://fas.org/irp/offdocs/nsdm-nixon/nsdm-93.pdf http://fas.org/irp/offdocs/nsdm-nixon/nsdm-93.pdf
- ChrisArgyle 11y agoThe number you really want is the size of the market that Chile sold in. More than likely this is much smaller than the total worldwide production.
- theworstshill 11y agoIts whats on the margin that matters.
- Spooky23 11y agoWell, yeah. They are "strategic" after all, which is a word that is meaningful in the global political sense. Consider that strategic weapons are the ones that could destroy life on earth.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoThis. I don't know why people think the US should be in love with every anti-US regime and any attempt to hurt that regime is suddenly "OMG EVIL USA" when we see the same realpolitik everywhere else without protest. Most well off nations have strategic reserves of things, offensive trade policies, protectionist economic policies, etc that can be used offensively. How many sanctions, targeted import taxes, bans, and tariffs and such are active right now between nations? Hundreds? Thousands? Tens of thousands?
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoBecause what's fair for most, is not fair for the gorilla. The USA dominates the world in so many ways, when it takes action it is viewed very differently than when, say, Sweden takes action.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoMaybe leadership in those countries should take that into account before proudly declaring themselves against US interests, nationalizing US wealth, blocking US ships, kidnapping US citizens, proxy warring against US allies, exporting terrorism, spreading anti-US propaganda, radicalizing its citizens to be anti-West, etc. Jesus man, the US isn't some charity, its a nation with its own self-interests and it will move to protect those interests. Not to mention, its obligations of defense in regards to being part of NATO and its post-war relationships with Korea and Japan and Israel. Also, its a moral hazard, and frankly stupid, to make non-US nations above criticism just because they're small. Assad is mass murdering his people in Syria, for example. He deserves that criticism, and more. Hell, Allende's downfall had everything to do with running a radical administration hell bent on nationalizing everything and pissing off business owners, the workers, congress, and the military. Of course, people like you shout, "OMG THE USA OVERTHREW HIM... somehow" and here we are. Sadly, this is further anti-US propaganda. Allende dug his own grave yet the US gets the blame. It is possible to be disliked by the US and also be a domestic fuckup on a level where your own people get rid of you. How nice to always have someone else to blame for your troubles.
- samstave 11y agoI'm sure that the Plan A was also advised very closely by the CIA... It's basically CIA jackles all the way down... (still is, Ahem Bush)