5 ms·
Japan orders universities to end education in social sciences, humanities, law
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- guard-of-terra 11y agoI guess the intention is that they need doers, not thinkers. And would also like to cut some expenses. What they don't know is that it won't work.
- toyg 11y agoYou assume they don't know. I assume the opposite: after all this is an unpopular government, who just passed a law necessary to wage war. Humanities students are traditional adversaries for most established governments, a perennial hotbed of dissent. Imho someone is just trying to get rid of potential troublemakers when that war eventually comes along. If something else falls apart in the process, too bad
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoDoing and thinking not two ends of the same spectrum but two spectrum of the same individual. We need those who do and think. Those who think but do not do are harmless, as are those who do not think and do not do. But the worst of all are those who do without thinking.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> not directly science - they base on human social behavior, which is inconsistent over time, location and culture Social sciences are sciences. They study different things to the 'hard sciences' but this doesn't mean they're not science, and doesn't mean they're not important. > Bloomberg give that story a negative spin, and i'd like to know the intentions behind that. Why do they need to explain themselves for defending education?
- logicchains 11y ago>Social sciences are sciences. They study different things to the 'hard sciences' but this doesn't mean they're not science, and doesn't mean they're not important. Something's a science if it adheres to the scientific method, not just because it calls itself a science. Given findings like http://arstechnica.com/science/2015/08/100-psychology-experiments-repeated-less-than-half-successful/ http://arstechnica.com/science/2015/08/100-psychology-experi..., social science may not be doing a great job of following the scientific method.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoAll the sciences follow the scientific method. There's irreproducible papers in every field, this isn't a problem exclusive to Psychology. Also, Psychology is but one of the social sciences.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoSocial sciences have some significant flaws, but they are not fundamental enough to invalidate them as fields of science. For starters, requiring a really good statistical knowledge to get a degree (nor merely teaching to plug numbers into some analysis program) and less focus on the history of the sciences that is replaced with learning the modern science.
- nwatson 11y agoWhen you corrupt society and industry with social sciences and arts you eventually come to egg girls (https://www.google.com/search?q=egg+girls&prmd=visn&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0CAgQ_AUoAmoVChMIxuuVz4eKyAIVSjg-Ch1F-grT#tbm=isch&q=egg+girls+Japanese https://www.google.com/search?q=egg+girls&prmd=visn&source=l...), tamagotchi, and hikikomori (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hikikomori https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hikikomori ), and lots of bad comics.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoQuite the contrary, what you list seems to me a result of lack of serious culture, certainly not of cultural boom. Can't fight with lack of culture by destroying culture.
- Daishiman 11y agoNice bit of cultural fascism there. They should go a step further and start banning the bad comics. I heard they burn very well.
- A_COMPUTER 11y agoThe UN's been pressuring Japan for years to ban child porn comics and cartoons, which it's a leading world producer of. Japan also finally outlawed possession of actual child abuse porn last year, do you consider that fascism?
- nwatson 11y agoI can't take HN very seriously when people take my comment at face value.
- Daishiman 11y agoDid you even read the comment on the original post? It's impossible to tell the real trolls from the small but vocal minority of people who really do believe the humanities are a bastion of the liberal elite and Illuminati. Not to mention that there is a huge amount of disdain for the humanities in some hardcore engineering circles.
- jkot 11y agoThis is just public schools, those subjects can be still studied at private schools. Czech Republic has similar system. Education is free, but number of places in public university is set by number of jobs available. We have lot of engineers and doctors, a bit less lawyers and very few artists and sociologists. As a side effect those become elite subjects with really bright students.
- guard-of-terra 11y ago> with really bright students My misanthropic self suggests they're more likely really well-connected.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- emp_zealoth 11y agoThe good thing about post-commie unis is that we have entrance exams,period. Not a fuzzy opaque admission system from UK/US where they do 'hire talks' And no grade curving nonsense You study,you score points and you either get in or not. The only way money can help is by hiring extra tutors to prepare you for exams - but a lot of my classmates at top polish polytechnic were poor as fuck,just brilliant. The admission system works (the unis themselves have a lot of issues though)
- orf 11y ago> Not a fuzzy opaque admission system from UK/US where they do 'hire talks' And no grade curving nonsense We don't do 'hire talks', you get in based on your grades and essentially a letter you write about yourself and your interests. The latter being important because there is more to you as a person than your UCAS points.
- jazzyk 11y agoYou have not applied to college recently, have you? The times when colleges applied reason/merit to the admission process are long gone. These days they are racketeering, politically-correct, quota-driven businesses where educational excellence is less and less important. Other "important" factors which impact your admission chances are: - your race (Asians usually discriminated against), - your gender (both females and males can be discriminated), - your state of residence (quotas for local residents), - your country of residence (overseas students typically are rich and parents pay full tuition), - your athletic prowess in a particular sport (if you are a semi-pro, you are golden). Harvard does not make it a secret that a significant number (30%, I think) of slots is reserved for "legacies" and athletes. The rest are very good students (who managed to impress the admissions with some unusual after school activities), who make up for the legacies/athletes.
- Daishiman 11y agoWhenever I see this happening I find it hard to not think up of unlikely but satisfactory conspiracies where this is all a plot to make the educated middle class less aware of social issues and the similarities in the themes of human struggle of all societies. In a context where Japan's conservative government seems to be contemplating future conflict with its neighbors as a more likely outcome, it would help to shield the populance from the fact that their "enemies" are human too. Mind you, this isn't just about the Japanese conservative government, but I just can't see what purpose this could possibly ever serve.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoWhy would Japan seriously conflict with neighbors? It has shrinking population and this is going to get worse. Can't sacrifice people, can't make use of what you conquer. Of course we can imagine drone wars but what's the point exactly?
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoAreas that experience significant population loss due to war or disaster often have baby booms afterwards, and wind up with more people than they started within a very few decades. Hey, maybe that's the plan! Kill a bunch of citizens in foreign wars, and the survivors will surely breed a strong new generation!
- guard-of-terra 11y agoTo bet your country's demographic future on "often have" is a bold move. It depends. After WW2, USSR seems to have recovered its numbers (until late soviet birth rate and life expectancy slow dive). Germany never actually recovered, it seems to me - their population numbers are flat for decades and they're bringing a lot of immigrants in. France, I don't know - I guess they sidestepped this issue by repatriating people fleeing from ex-colonies.
- ekianjo 11y agoYeah,looks like you don't remember that Japan was razed to ground almost everywhere in the last war they fought. It did not work too well for them.
- paulojreis 11y agoYeah, lovely - I can't wait to see this world where everybody's an engineer... We're already paying the price of producing engineering-driven business and products en masse- check e.g. the Internet of Things irrelevance and lack of real known use-cases. When the boom of all-things-IT end, we will regret not being user and customer driven. And we will definitely regret ignoring the guys who know (knew?) something about being human.
- hkmurakami 11y agoJapanese technology companies are predominantly run by humanities graduates who come up the corporate FP&A side of the org and yet are notoriously "spec" driven in their product and technology development rather than being user driven.
- emp_zealoth 11y agoI'd hardly call IoT engineer driven It's VC money spawning this nonsense,followed by "design" (look fancy,do nothing)
- paulojreis 11y agoYou're probably right regarding the VC part. I should have said "technology-driven", actually.
- aianus 11y ago> Yeah, lovely - I can't wait to see this world where everybody's an engineer... I know you're being sarcastic but it sounds like paradise to me.
- sandworm101 11y agoNo teaching law? Scream about lawyers if you want, but they serve a purpose. Nobody wants to live in a society without laws. Equally, a society with laws but without people expert in that law cannot expect to follow it. Would anyone want their case heard by someone who hasn't studied? Shall we hand complex rules of evidence to laypersons? The result would be unpredictability, commercial chaos.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoWhat this will do is create a shortage of lawyers, making access to justice expensive. Which, if you think about it, is exactly what a conservative government would like. It's less people able to bring legal challenges against them, and less people who might defend 'criminals'.
- hkmurakami 11y agoWell, currently most law graduates are not employed in law in Japan due to the low number of people who can pass the exam in any given year.
- kristofferR 11y agoIt sort of makes sense for Japan, as defence lawyers aren't able to provide any chance of justice anyway... 99% of those arrested in Japan are convicted: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/05/29/abandon-hope-all-ye-tried-in-japan.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/05/29/abandon-hop...
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoMhm. The Ace Attorney series of games is a parody of this ridiculous justice system.
- ekianjo 11y agoI hope you never took any of these games seriously.
- Animats 11y agoI have some doubts about the validity of this report. Bloomberg got it from Time's education blog, which apparently got it from The Times of Higher Education (a blog), which claims it got it from Yomiuri Shimbun, one of Japan's major newspapers. But searching The Japan News[1], which is Yomiuri Shimbun's English-language site, there's nothing on this. The only recent reference to Education Minister Hakuban Shimomura is about a test-cheating scandal. [1] http://the-japan-news.com/news/search http://the-japan-news.com/news/search
- hkmurakami 11y agoHere's the source (Japanese): http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/kyoiku/news/20150824-OYT8T50033.html http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/kyoiku/news/20150824-OYT8T50033.htm... This has a scan of the paper clipping: http://matome.naver.jp/odai/2143619433341443601 http://matome.naver.jp/odai/2143619433341443601
- danmaz74 11y agoI could understand a move to somehow limit the number of students in some fields where (if) the number of people with degrees there is too high for the jobs market. But an order to "end education" in those fields is just retarded.
- hkmurakami 11y agoThis is only public (national) universities, of which there are only 26. And it is in fact true that there are too many grads in those areas.
- hkmurakami 11y agoIt has always been said that in Japan, "it is hard to get into college, and easy to graduate". By contrast, US universities are characterized by the Japanese as easy to get in, hard to graduate. The accuracy of above statements aside, it is true that generally speaking, Japanese students study much much harder in High School than in College, because the College you get into traditionally determines much of the rest of your life. So the stereotype is that students cram to get into great schools, then party for 4 years because their grades don't matter in landing employment. Within this general stereotype, there is a further stereotype that the students in science and engineering slave away in the labs while the humanities students have a jolly good time in the social culture group "circles". Given the hierarchy of stereotypes above, it isn't a big surprise to me if the humanities are seen by some as "glut" that can be cut, since government is subsidizing student partying. But it's surprising since the lawmakers should predominantly be from these exact programs being cut.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoIsn't the old system of guaranteed employment starting to break down, too?
- ekianjo 11y agoNo, not really. I mean, the % of folks with a guaranteed job BEFORE they graduate is going down a bit, but still higher than anywhere else in the world.
- hkmurakami 11y agoIn certain spots, yes. Vulnerable industries like semiconductors, IT vendors, and household electronics look like they are in trouble. However, that has meant that students flock to industries where said lifetime employment is still a rock. The #1 destination is Import-export trade companies (Mitsubishi Shouji being the top dog there), followed by ad agencies Dentsu and Hakuhodou, then super high quality industrial companies such as Toyota, Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, Utilities, etc.
- ekianjo 11y ago
- ekianjo 11y ago>In other words, it will need a bunch of social science and humanities students. Hah! Japan has those students for the past 25 years and nothing great came out of it. I don't think the government should eliminate such disciplines, but trying to make it seem like they are essential to run your Economy is a very shallow promise. Plus, I wonder what they teach in Economics in Japan apart from the government love for Stimulus, which is all what politicians in Japan seem to do no matter from which party they come from.
- hkmurakami 11y agoYeah honestly that part of the article reads like egregious hand-waving and idealization without considering the general quality of humanities grads coming out of Japanese colleges.
- jevgeni 11y agoBecause if the Silicon Valley has taught anyone anything, is that it doesn't matter how well you manage a company as long as it's full of engineers. /s
- ZenoArrow 11y agoSharing this video here is like pissing in the wind (I doubt there's many people from Japan here), but here's something for the rest of us to consider... http://youtu.be/4D0fLisyjBY http://youtu.be/4D0fLisyjBY When will we learn that science and technology cannot solve all our problems and apply this knowledge practically? Isn't the pace of technological change already too fast for our culture to keep up with? Culture should be in the driving seat, otherwise you get technology for technology's sake (making things because we can, regardless of the plausible consequences).
- michaelbuddy 11y agoJapan has culture and aesthetic handled. Why does everyone think that humanities college coursework somehow endows students with something exclusive and rose colored. Humanities courses are enjoyable but too subjective and liberal. Sociology in the U.S. is a joke. Good riddance. Learning a craft is better guidance towards understanding human experience. Problem solving in a workshop is what the soul needs.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago"Japan has culture and aesthetic handled." Really? I enjoy some culture from Japan, but I wouldn't say they've got everything sorted. Work culture, social isolation, fear of failure, suicide, rapidly declining population all appear to be issues.
- musername 11y agoguess they have enough burger flippers and taxi drivers? /s
- endzone 11y agowhat really is the value of studying these subjects at undergraduate level? i don't think i've ever seen a persuasive argument in favour