11 ms·
The Hardest chess problem in the world?
- kostyk 11y agonot really valid as white becomes black.
- ColinWright 11y agoDid you actually read right to the end? "But in fact, at the time this game was played there was no specific rule stating that a pawn had to be promoted to a piece of the same colour!
- ubernostrum 11y agoOf course there was also no rule saying that chess functioned on a restrictive rules system and a lot of evidence that it instead functioned on a permissive system. Which would invalidate the "no rule says I can't" argument. (when designing a game's rules, "restrictive" means the approach is "everything is permitted by default, unless explicitly restricted", while "permissive" means "everything is forbidden by default unless explicitly permitted" -- if we assume that chess is a restrictive-rules game, we can similarly mate in one from almost any position by simply inventing new pieces with unusual abilities and declaring that "the rules don't say you can't!")
- mikeash 11y agoIf the rule was simply, "A promoted pawn may be exchanged for any piece," then that would fit within a permissive system, and still qualify as "nothing says you have to promote to the same color."
- Maken 11y agoSo, promoting a pawn in chess is undefined behavior?
- dragonwriter 11y agoNo, its defined (both then and now), its just the spec has had breaking changes from earlier versions.
- lmm 11y agoNo. It was unclear whether you could promote to a piece of the other colour, but a conforming implementation of chess will not make demons fly out of your nose.
- Nano2rad 11y agoCan it be called promotion then, it is like country A promoting its soldier to general of country B. What will happen it is not endgame. Who will move the black knight promoted by white side?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- legohead 11y agoFor an actual legal and cool puzzle: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iSKtG-8TwI0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iSKtG-8TwI0
- Max_Horstmann 11y agoAlso cool: white to move and NOT mate http://www.chess.com/blog/AaronGo/white-to-move-and-not-mate http://www.chess.com/blog/AaronGo/white-to-move-and-not-mate
- jerf 11y agoWould someone like to post a ROT13 of the solution to that, if they have it?
- nikbackm 11y agozbir gur gbjre
- simcop2387 11y agoQbrfa'g gung serr gur ovfubc gb zngr gur xvat? Gur bayl zbirf V pna frr gung jbhyqa'g qb vg ner gb zbir gur juvgr xvat.
- shadefinale 11y agoJuvgr xvat pna'g zbir, oybpxrq ol oynpx ebbx naq ovfubc Vs lbh zbir juvgr ebbx gb p6, gur oynpx xvat vf gura va purpx. Ubjrire, oynpx pna pncgher gur ovfubc gb ab ybatre or va purpx.
- manveru 11y agoPna'g lbh zbir gur cnja ng o2 be u2 ol whzcvat bire gur cvrprf va sebag bs gurz fvapr vg'q or gurve svefg zbir? Gur ortvaare ehyrf ba gur fvgr lbh yvaxrq qba'g zragvba jurgure guvf vf n yrtny zbir be abg, fb V'z abg fher.
- philh 11y agoThe problem isn't showing up for me, but cached version: http://web.archive.org/web/20150918165831/http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-RwlnMx0bj50/TVTqt0g8EMI/AAAAAAAAASs/0GQKsEhy3yY/s1600/Mate+in+1+problem.jpg http://web.archive.org/web/20150918165831/http://3.bp.blogsp... White to play and mate in one.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- atmosx 11y ago> "I first encountered this position in June 1937 [...]" OT remark: Jesus. I work with the elderly, mostly. I would love to have her clarity of thought if and when I reach her age. I've heard before that playing chess retains hair loss and mental deterioration, especially in the elderly.
- hissworks 11y agoI, too, was curious about Lady Cynthia Blunderboro. It seems she's a fictional persona prone to hoaxes. https://www.google.com/search?q=lady+cynthia+blunderboro https://www.google.com/search?q=lady+cynthia+blunderboro
- Grue3 11y agoThe fact that she by chance happened to have the very same position during normal play gave it away. The probability would be astronomically low.
- philh 11y agoThe coincidence isn't quite what you think it is. In the story world, the puzzle probably took its precise form from that game. If the game hadn't happened, maybe Anderssen's unpublished notes would have included a similar puzzle, or maybe nothing along those lines. So the coincidence is "merely" that she's related to the person who played the game that begot the puzzle.
- swang 11y agoNot sure if you're referring to something else. But in the story she is just replaying the game that her grandfather played back in the 1800s. She didn't actually come up with that move from playing.
- atmosx 11y agoYou ruined everything :-P
- coffeevradar 11y ago
- z3ugma 11y agoCould it also have been a black rook as well?
- halosghost 11y agoNo. A Black rook would have allowed black to b8b7 and block the white rook from the final checkmate. A knight, on the other hand, would not be able to block the white rook and would therefore result in a checkmate.
- imaginenore 11y agoFrom FIDE rules: > When a player, having the move, plays a pawn to the rank furthest from its starting position, he must exchange that pawn as part of the same move for a new queen, rook, bishop or knight of the same colour on the intended square of arrival. > promotion: 3.7e. Where a pawn reaches the eighth rank and is replaced by a new queen, rook, bishop or knight of the same colour. https://www.fide.com/fide/handbook.html?id=171&view=article https://www.fide.com/fide/handbook.html?id=171&view=article
- ColinWright 11y agoThank you for the reference - appreciate that. I wonder when that explicit rule was introduced. It says in the article: "But in fact, at the time this game was played there was no specific rule stating that a pawn had to be promoted to a piece of the same colour!
- bradleyjg 11y agoSarratt in his Treatise on the Game of Chess (1808) says: "When a player has pushed a Pawn to Queen, he is at liberty to make a second Queen, a third Rook, or any other piece which he may deem more useful for his attack or defense". While this doesn't explicitly say that he must promote to a piece of the same color, it implies it. After all if the piece could be promoted to either color it would make sense to say a third queen or a fifth rook rather than a second or third.
- wowaname 11y agoThat doesn't really imply much. Having a fifth rook does not correlate at all to having a piece of the same or opposite colour. Regardless, based off that rule, a piece of the opposing colour would be defined by "any other peice [sic] which he may deem more useful for his attack" in that play, so it sounds perfectly legal to me.
- mikeash 11y agoIf you arrange your game just right, you can legally have up to ten rooks (or bishops or knights, or nine queens) of the same color on the board at once. (This will probably not be possible without the cooperation of the other player.)
- dsjoerg 11y ago"no longer strictly within the bounds of the rules of the game" I take exception to _strictly_... it's just flat out illegal now, no "strictly" about it. I would have been less ticked off if the article had simply written "no longer within the bounds of the rules of the game." It is fascinating that the move was formerly legal though.
- javert 11y agoYeah, but putting "strictly" there does not change the meaning of the sentence, it's just a superfluous word.
- jMyles 11y agoIt gives the sentence a nuance that suggests ambiguity, as if prohibition of this move requires some particularly "strict" reading of the rules. I agree that makes the sentence weaker, and given the gravity of the sentence, makes the article seem somewhat amateur.
- dsjoerg 11y ago"strictly" changes the meaning of the sentence. it suggests that there are "strict" and "not so strict" interpretations of the chess rules, and that if you're not so strict, the move is OK. but promoting to the other color is not allowed, even under "not so strict" interpretations of the rules of chess. an example of things that may be permitted in "not so strict" chess: taking back your move, not moving a piece even though you touched it, talking to the other player, agreeing to play on even though you've had a threefold repetition.
- javert 11y agoI mean really, the rules are the rules, and there is no ambiguity. So a "strict reading of the rules" is the same thing as a "reading of the rules." Because, as you say, there is no such thing as a reading of the rules that violates the rules and is thus merely "less strict." For example, under the rules, not moving a piece you touched and promoting to the other color are the same: illegal. The examples you are giving are simply cases where the other player is likely to let you break the rules if it's a very casual game. So again, having "strictly" in the sentence is, technically, purely redundant. It's a dumb thing to say, but then again, it probably made the piece more suspenseful and thus more fun to read.
- danso 11y agoI enjoyed the solution...I played chess when I was young but obviously not at an elite level, as I did not know of this rule. But what amused me was -- legal or not -- that I just had never even thought of doing that kind of move, ever. Technicalities aside, it's a nice thinking-outside-of-the-box example.
- ikeboy 11y agoPoking around that site's replacement, I bumped into http://www.hebdenbridgechessclub.co.uk/2011/02/11/castling-very-long/ http://www.hebdenbridgechessclub.co.uk/2011/02/11/castling-v.... Also interesting, and involving no-longer-valid rules.
- chengiz 11y agoThe Anon v Macieja is sweet.
- t0mbstone 11y agoA poorly phrased question that lacks context != cleverness The "puzzle" relies on an obscure situation which isn't even a rule. You might as well claim that the kings can checkmate each other, or that the rook can spontaneously transform into a queen. HEY GUYS CHECK OUT THIS FAKE PUZZLE THAT REQUIRES YOU TO IGNORE EVERYTHING YOU KNOW ABOUT CHESS RULES FOR IT TO WORK
- danso 11y agoHuh? The solution doesn't require you to "IGNORE EVERYTHING YOU KNOW ABOUT CHESS RULES". I can't speak for all casual players but this is a rule that seems technically possible but just never executed because it's hard to conceive a situation in which it would ever be used in practice. For those of us who don't know this specific rule, there's no excuse for us not thinking-outside-of-the-box...and learning of the "solution" is enjoyable. Life is full of rules in which the exception was never addressed or outlawed because the exception was never even considered. [Insert Kobayashi Maru trope here]
- nnoitra 11y agoNot really, it's an illegal move which makes it a puzzle from a different game of chess. Clickbaity title.
- mikeash 11y agoIt's not a rule now. This move was legal at the time. You can reasonably object that you shouldn't be expected to know that history, but that makes it quite different from "rook can spontaneously transform into a queen" and similar.
- twcooper 11y agoI think you're just disappointed because you wanted to solve a chess problem. I liked the article because I read it as a story to be enjoyed rather than a problem to be solved.
- fizixer 11y ago
- jkot 11y agoHarder problem is to find a sequence of turns, where white always wins, from starting position. Anyway this turn is not legal in chess I learned.
- parennoob 11y agoThis is interesting, but as the author acknowledges, not legal in modern games. Another famous position which relies on (legal) underpromotion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saavedra_position https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saavedra_position
- aaronrenoir 11y agoIf chess is a analogy of war and a pawn infiltrates the other side. I believe he has the right to choose a side. I mean he may scale the castle wall only to die releasing a captured prisoner, or he may disrobe a night and get back on the battle field. I love this idea.
- pnut 11y agoI thought defectors were also executed by opposing armies? Who would want a known traitor in their ranks?
- eternalban 11y agoHe was a POW.
- dorgo 11y agoI would want. Just find a way to use him for your purposes..
- electrotype 11y agoWhy is it illegal now? I think it would be more fun if is was legal for the very, very, few cases where it can actually help a player.
- nichochar 11y agoThe article is interesting, but the title is frustrating because clickbaiting. I personally love chess and love challenges, and this was downright disappointing. I don't encourage clickbaiting. This is a shame because the article is interesting
- praptak 11y agoI remember reading about a chess puzzle where a similar "out of the box" thinking was required which would probably put it outside of reach of computer solvers. As a plus it was within currently legal rules. The winning move was en passant and the solution required observing that the only way the situation could have arisen was the opposite pawn moving 2 ranks forward, making this move possible.
- stouset 11y agoThis doesn't seems like the kind of move that would be the crux of a puzzle, tripping up both computer and human. En passant captures are a normal, straightforward move in chess that few above amateur level would overlook. En passant captures are the first move you tend to look at if an opponent has moved their pawn two spaces adjacent to one of your own.
- fenomas 11y ago> En passant captures are the first move you tend to look at if an opponent has moved their pawn two spaces.. GP is clearly saying that you're not given the information that a pawn has moved two spaces, the trick of the puzzle is to infer from the board's layout that such must be the case. Seems damned clever to me. From a quick google it appears that such things are known as "retrograde puzzles".
- sandworm101 11y agoIf we are playing fast with the rules re sides, was there any rule at the time saying the black King couldn't take the black Knight? That would break the check, force white to move the rook to block, allow the black king to take the rook, and place black in a winning position.
- arasmussen 11y ago> "force white to move the rook to block" A better move would be to just move your king out of check and to go protect your rook.
- joseraul 11y agoAlso very challenging for chess players is retrograde analysis, where you have to find the only possible legal moves to reach the given position. See the cover of this book by Smullyan http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/81y-bMMYCoL.jpg http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/81y-bMMYCoL.jpg
- sanderjd 11y agoThanks for that link, it was fun and took me quite awhile to figure out!
- lcfcjs1 11y agoThis is awesome :) thanks
- grondilu 11y agoThat's the best example of out-of-the-box thinking I've ever seen in chess.
- binarymax 11y agoFor a really good problem, with legal moves, feast on this: http://gameknot.com/analyze-board.pl?bd=0&fen=8/3P3k/n2K3p/2p3n1/1b4N1/2p1p1P1/8/3B4%20w%20--&rnd=0.5244399076637669 http://gameknot.com/analyze-board.pl?bd=0&fen=8/3P3k/n2K3p/2...
- toolslive 11y agoreminds me of "0-0-0-0". Before the rule was added that castling was a 'row move', you could promote an e-pawn to a rook and than castle superlong by moving the king from e1 to e3 (and the rook to e2). This oversight in the rules was later corrected.
- DavidWanjiru 11y agoI'm not much of chess person, but I don't get it. Even if the black knight plays for white, it's still not checkmate. What prevents the black king from "eating" that black knight?
- zornthewise 11y agoThe black knight plays for black.
- DavidWanjiru 11y agoIn the solution presented at the end of the article, whose turn to move is it? Who can't make any further moves coz they've been check-mated? That's what I don't get. If it's white, white can still move their king back towards their home row and there's more than one move left in the game. If it's black, black can move the black knight in between the two kings and we'd still have more than one move left.
- teahat 11y agoBlack is in check from the white rook. Moving the black night doesn't escape the check, so isn't a legal move.
- DavidWanjiru 11y agoNow I get it. The "beef" is that white replaced their white pawn with their opponents black knight, which of course the black king can't eat...
- thedufer 11y agoWhite advanced the pawn and promoted it. It is black's turn. Moving the knight between the kings is illegal because the black king is in check by the white rook.
- Pizzalover 11y agoYou can't eat your own pieces
- dnautics 11y agoI moved the pawn down one space, assuming the board was backwards and the white pawn was on the second rank.
- philh 11y agoThat's not mate, the black king can move diagonally to G1. Same thing black would do if white promoted to a white piece.
- raam86 11y agoCan't the knight capture the white king resulting in checkmate for black?
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoNo, it'd have to be in the position of the white pawn in the initial position to reach the king. It moves two pieces (not three) horizontally and 1 piece vertically, or vice versa.
- cyphar 11y agoDefinitely an interesting hack, it's interesting that the rules were updated to make it illegal.
- delinka 11y agoSPOILER ALERT I don't know about "hardest" but I do tend to wonder: who'd have thought to promote to anything other than one's own color? Kinda feels similar to doing some odd operation "in a single processor instruction" but the trick is that the ISA in question went the way of the dodo about four decades ago.