16 ms·
The toxic side of free – how I lost the love for my side project (part 4)
- chamalilem 11y agoIf you want to learn russian via skype free, visit http://preply.com/en/russian-by-skype http://preply.com/en/russian-by-skype for more information!
- Mahn 11y agoGood read, but I wonder why didn't he hire a tax advisor to deal with VATMOSS? It's usually not that expensive even if you are not doing revenue, and unless you are in the business of taxes there's little to gain in doing it yourself.
- jpallen 11y agoThe VATMOSS rules mean that you need to collect, verify and store a bunch more info than previously: You need to be able to show evidence for the country the buyer is in, and check that ip address, address, credit card, etc match. It sounds like the cost came from the software development required to put the infrastructure in place to adhere to this and so wasn't something an advisor could help with. With it being a new rule, there was very little info about the penalties for not complying. The penalties for normal UK VAT are only proportional to revenue, so not much risk for small companies getting it wrong. It wasn't clear that this was true for VATMOSS and so there was fear amongst even tiny company of big penalties for getting it wrong. We went through the same worries last Nov/Dev, but were lucky that our billing provider dealt with adding in all the required logic. (Shout out to Recurly!)
- pnathan 11y agoStupid question: is there a service which you can hand off the evidence-gathering to? Seems like a very good opportunity.
- stevoski 11y agoYes. I've been researching this in recent weeks, and have found several operators that build on top of Stripe and PayPal, in various ways, to handle the VATMOSS burden. Without offering any recommendation for them, here are two I've investigated: * https://www.taxamo.com/ https://www.taxamo.com/ * https://quaderno.io/ https://quaderno.io/
- wlesieutre 11y agoAnother comment mentions http://www.fastspring.com/vat http://www.fastspring.com/vat
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoThere are various attempts, but currently no one - especially not HMRC - has any idea how to handle VATMOSS correctly. I've heard a few stories about small businesses suddenly getting demands for thousands of pounds (etc) after only a handful of transactions. But what I suspect will happen is that HMRC will realise that chasing and fining microbusinesses for non-compliance is a complete waste of everyone's time. They won't bother unless businesses are being obviously, blatantly fraudulent - and considering how short-staffed they are, perhaps not even then. It'll be similar to the EU's legislation about cookie notices, which created a big initial compliance explosion, but now seems to be being quietly forgotten. The UK is lobbying hard to set a minimum threshold for VATMOSS. It will take a few years for the idiot lawyers in Brussels to catch up, but even though some member states seem to think VATMOSS is a good thing, common sense and experience will prove that it's utterly unworkable and destructive in its current form.
- tzs 11y agoThe stories you heard may have been due to the Irish fuck up a month ago. The Irish tax authorities mistakenly sent out a couple thousand notices claiming completely bogus deficiencies. More info here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10083238 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10083238 Germany and one or two others have also sent deficiency notices to UK sellers. The UK tax authorities have complained about that, saying one of the main points of the VATMOSS system was that sellers would only have to deal directly with the tax authorities in their country. If Germany, for example, thinks a UK seller underpaid for VAT on German customers, the UK's understanding was that Germany was supposed to bring that up with the UK tax authorities, and they would be the ones to get it straightened out.
- sergiotapia 11y agoThis is incredibly interesting and something most pet-project hopefuls don't even consider. Building the project is the easy part, what comes next is where things sink or swim. Thanks for sharing!
- Osiris 11y agoRegarding his fraud issue, I found that my website was being used in the same way when I added a credit card payment form. I implemented a system that first does an "Auth". If that passes, then I pass details to MaxMind and get back a response with a "riskScore". If the score is too high, I void the auth and decline the transaction. This has saved me a lot of chargeback fees, though it's still not perfect. I prefer PayPal because a "not authorized" just reverses the transaction; there is no chargeback fee.
- thesis 11y agoDefinitely definitely definitely use something like Minfraud from Maxmind. The cost is negligible. We set the score we block transactions at rather low, and manually approve anything over that. It's super cheap and has saved us tons of money and headaches!
- finnn 11y agoSeems like this should be on the credit card processor to deal with?
- pjlegato 11y agoUnfortunately for merchants, no, the legal responsibility for fraudulent transactions rests entirely with the merchant. Not only that, but processors routinely penalize merchants who fail to screen fraudulent transactions sufficiently with fines and eventually banishment from the processor. A few processors might provide something like this as a paid value-added service, but it's unusual. The next-gen all-in-one card processors would make a lot of money if they offered this.
- ricardobeat 11y agoBy "all-in-one card processors" do you mean payment gateways? The majority of them do offer built-in fraud protection, though the efficacy varies a lot. In fact, Stripe also offers it: https://stripe.com/docs/fraud https://stripe.com/docs/fraud But if you think about the case he describes in the article, there is very little distinguishing a fraudulent purchase to test the validity of a credit card vs a legitimate one, unless they are completely careless and initiate multiple transactions from a russian IP, in the middle of the night. The biggest problem is the very expensive chargeback fee from Stripe. It looks like he could avoid some of them by, for example, reporting accounts that had no activity as fraudulent and refunding the purchase before being hit with a chargeback claim, but I don't see how putting such a burden on businesses makes sense to begin with. A fee that grows in proportion to the % of chargebacks the company generates would be more fair.
- Mahn 11y ago> it's cost me, £21.54 to allow some shithead to use JS Bin as a stolen card testing facility. Not sure if it's standard practice, but in our case we let the users use the "free tier" service first, and we offer the paid plans only once we can validate they have a genuine interest in the product . It works well for us to avoid these cases.
- dasil003 11y agoIf that works for you I'm glad, but I've had to deal with credit card fraud hitting my service, and it tends to be an arms race. There's simply too much money it for them to be deterred. If you are an attractive target it's difficult to find something which prevents credit card fraud without also hurting your business.
- markbnj 11y agoThat's an interesting approach, but if the "pro" features are something the user really needs, then don't you risk losing a sub if the feature is withheld until you "get to know each other?"
- dbpatterson 11y agoYou could give them 15 days free use, and only charge it after that... there is a risk that the charge doesn't go through (in which case you've given a couple weeks free service - big deal), but otherwise, you've just made it much less useful for card testing (to the point that they certainly won't use your site).
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI discovered a similar problem with writing, which is that writing an email or a comment takes no time at all, but when someone is paying for what I write it takes a lot more effort. I wrote a column for a couple of years and it wasn't until the second year that I actually took my editors advice to just send her the first version and work on it collaboratively rather than try to get it perfect. I see side projects also get bushwacked by this mental shift.
- teddyh 11y agoStudies Find Reward Often No Motivator http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/motivation.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/motivation.html
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThat was a good read, but there was a different mechanism at work for me. When I do something for free, and someone complains about it or finds it wanting, it does not bother me. Sort of like "Double your money back on Free Advice you don't like." But when I am being paid to provide the thing I am providing, a big sense of my wanting to make sure they are getting their value kicks in, and since I undervalue my time tremendously I try to over deliver on value. And that slows me down. Letting my editor have an early draft let her decide if there was sufficient value and on at least one occasion she took my column as written and said, "This is great, we'll have proofs ready tomorrow." Had I not sent the draft I would have spent at least another week writing and re-writing.
- eschutte2 11y agoBoy, can I identify with this. It can be very hard to turn off that impulse to over-deliver. It can also be hard to objectively look at your own limitations and not overcommit yourself, and hard to adjust when you find out too late you've overcommitted.
- kelnos 11y agoI guess I've just become a bit more jaded. Or maybe I always have been. I used to maintain a good amount of open source stuff, and the entitled complaints really got to me. But if I'm being paid for something, I feel the obligation to deliver what I've promised, and I feel bad if I fall short. I do struggle sometimes with valuing my time "correctly", but overall I think I've experienced less stress building software for a paycheck vs. dealing with the (minority of) ungrateful leeches in the open source community.
- emilburzo 11y ago> With JS Bin, everything users need is given away and open source. That's honourable, but doesn't pay the mortgage. Well that hit home pretty hard, I think I've made the same mistake with my project. Although the great reviews and personal "thank you"'s are great, as the author said, they don't pay the bills.
- ffn 11y agoOkay, say you're a US citizen building some digi service like JS Bin, and VATMOSS starts fling threats at you, for how long can you go about ignoring them? I mean 3.5k GBP and however many weekdays it took isn't exactly affordable for every small business, and if you don't even have many Euro pro-users, I don't see the cost-benefit justification of giving VATMOSS priority unless they can reach across the Atlantic.
- nkozyra 11y agoI think the obligation to pay customers' VAT goes back way before VATMOSS. That said, I think you've answered your own question. Unless you're at a size that would be drawing attention, it would be logical to ignore this if you're not in the EU.
- masklinn 11y ago> I think the obligation to pay customers' VAT goes back way before VATMOSS. Yep, VOES was put in place in 2003 and that was a simplification, before that businesses were supposed to register themselves with each country's tax office and fill VAT everywhere. For non-EU businesses VATMOSS mostly updates the scheme: register yourself in any member state and use their MOSS portal as a non-EU business, the tax office is supposed to redistribute VAT based on your fillings. The business also has the option to forego MOSS/VOES and register itself in each country of course.
- bluecalm 11y agoYou only needed to register in different countries once your sells to them are above a quite hefty limit though so when you started you just paid VAT in your country and that was it. (I am talking from EU citizen perspective)
- masklinn 11y agoMy comment is about businesses from outside the EU, sorry if that wasn't clear.
- aldanor 11y agoThe credit card problem is quite easy to solve: allow a few months of free "pro" functionality upon signup, and then allow users to upgrade. During that period of time, you can also track whether they actually used the service at all.
- degenerate 11y agoBut then you'll have people creating new accounts every time the trial ends, instead of paying! The sweet spot is probably 24 hours. Too long for a fraudster to wait around, and too short for people to bother making an account every day for pro fuctionality.
- munificent 11y ago> But then you'll have people creating new accounts every time the trial ends, instead of paying! These would be malicious users. Both words are significant here. People using the service just to check credit cards are malicious, but not users. Free users are users but not malicious. I think for most services, the set of actual malicious users—people who do want to use the service for its intended purpose, but don't want to support it—is fairly small.
- Namrog84 11y agoYeah and if heavy users want to constantly deal with changing email addresses and moving accounts just to get out of it. Like you said is few. Let them be? It's likely they generate word of mouth and other value being invested enough to go thru the hassle.
- Paul-ish 11y ago>Like you said is few. Let them be? It's likely they generate word of mouth and other value being invested enough to go thru the hassle. This sounds a lot like the arguments piracy apologists use. A lot like the arguments people looking for free web design use. I am very skeptical whenever anyone asks for anything to them for free now because it will somehow (nebulously) come back to me later in a good way.
- nnat425 11y agocan i edit this?
- dspillett 11y agoThis is why if any of my personal projects go anywhere they'll remain free while they are in my hands. They can act as a portfolio ("look what I've done, aren't I clever") for when job hunting but I'll not even try make money directly from them even to cover costs. If they become worth charging for then someone can buy the rights from me and run it. Yeah they'll take the lion's share, but also all that hassle and I can still have credit for having created the thing in the first place. This is assuming that whatever project I'm talking about isn't released F/OSS of course, at which point if there is any sort of demand someone will already be hosting an instance or few. If the costs of running one of the projects gets higher than pocket money and no one else wants to run it? It either stops taking new users or is otherwise rate limited, or gets turned off completely, or in the case of a F/OSS project my instances become "friends and family only" and others can host their own. My side projects are just that: personal time projects, either just playthings or intended to grow my experience in something. They are not second jobs and I wouldn't want them to become so. Similarly I'll be careful not to include any features that can send mail or SMS, or call other sites, in a publicly addressable service that isn't locked to F&F-only. I don't want the faf of accidentally becoming a spam source due to a silly bug in my code or some support library I happen to be using.
- srtjstjsj 11y agoThis is why Amazon DevPay(?) exists. You ship software, and Amazon directly bills your customers for the AWS usage. you don't have to get into the AWS-reselling business just because you wrote cloud software.
- mooreds 11y agoThanks for mentioning this. "Amazon DevPay removes the pain of having to create or manage your own order pipeline or billing system, which is traditionally a challenge for online subscription services or applications running on demand." https://aws.amazon.com/devpay/ https://aws.amazon.com/devpay/
- gkop 11y agoExcept Sellers of Amazon DevPay applications must be able to do business in the United States. Funds earned through the sale of Amazon DevPay applications can only be withdrawn to U.S. bank accounts. https://aws.amazon.com/devpay/faqs/#general_10 https://aws.amazon.com/devpay/faqs/#general_10 Q: How are taxes handled? Amazon DevPay does not provide tax collection services for you. You are responsible for paying the appropriate taxes (local, state, federal, etc.) as applicable. https://aws.amazon.com/devpay/faqs/#pricing_7 https://aws.amazon.com/devpay/faqs/#pricing_7
- stevoski 11y agoPlease, please, anyone, if you are getting started in online payment processing, don't do it yourself. Use a service that already handles the VAT and fraud detection issues. Then, when you've proven your product, and got substantial sales, you can write your own. Maybe. The author of the article spent weeks and thousands of euros to implement a payment system. And yet he had only a handful of customers.
- jlongster 11y agoWell, he used Stripe, so he didn't write his own. Personally I wasn't aware that there was such a high fee for a chargeback. Is that because Stripe doesn't handle fraud well? Seems like most of his time was spent dealing with tax issues, which you'd have to do regardless of how money is actually transferred.
- stevoski 11y agoGood point. I consider using Stripe a "do-it-yourself" solution, which requires manual coding. As far as handling EU VAT, Stripe offers nothing, and you need to manually implement this. I meant that you should use a service last FastSpring or Avangate initially, which require no coding, and completely take care of VAT.
- vfdfv 11y agoDo you know if Braintree handles EU VAT in an automatic way? I've read the article below but I'm not totally sure what to make of it: https://www.taxamo.com/braintree-announce-partnership-taxamo/ https://www.taxamo.com/braintree-announce-partnership-taxamo... I am definitely not interested in hand-coding a solution.
- thibaut_barrere 11y agoI don't know about Braintree, but I can report that for my SaaS app (https://www.wisecashhq.com https://www.wisecashhq.com, currently priced in $ but France-based), I used Recurly (https://www.recurly.com https://www.recurly.com) which handles EU VAT very nicely (including VAT changes happening in 2015). I use them together with Stripe as my gateway, it generates proper invoices and applies the rate of the buyer's country unless a valid VAT number has been provided. They also provide a stripe-like js library so that the credit-card number doesn't go through my server. With regard to VAT MOSS report, they do most of the checks, I only wrote a little ETL script using http://www.kiba-etl.org/ http://www.kiba-etl.org/ to create a break-down of the related amounts for each quarter and each country, which I then submit manually to the VAT MOSS French website. So in my case, this is fully automated, and I'm pretty happy with this :-) Feel free to email me if you have questions.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoThere is a need for services that can let indie developers do what they do best, and handle all the admin, business, marketing for them for a significant % of revenue and % of ownership earned over time.
- paulus_magnus 11y agoWhy don't you "motivate" frequent users to start paying? ex. by making the free version (gradually) worse until you see revenue. ex. - non pro user pastebins last 5mins, 5 views etc - non pro users can post 1 pastebin per day (cookies, IP) - non pro user pastebins are max x characters long. - you get the idea - there are clever people on this forum who will come up with good ideas to help you out. - do everything BUT show ads, PLEASE. Internet's sole purpose is almost all that already.
- tobr 11y agoYou're confusing pastebin.com with jsbin.com. None of those restrictions wouldn't really make much sense for JS Bin I think.
- paulus_magnus 11y agoNone of those ... Hope you got my point. The above are only meant as an example. Main idea is to cripple* the free tier enough to push a chunk of current users from free into pro. Some will leave but you don't want them anyway (they will never pay). * how exactly cripple? This is the product design / product-market-fit stage work that was skipped when building jsbin.com
- umziehennachbar 11y agoIf $6 is too cheap and encourages fraudsters to test credit cards on your service because banks don't get concerned about transactions at that cost, how much should he have charged at a minimum? $10 $20?
- cvandebroek 11y agoFraudster doing credit card tests is something that happens everywhere. This is not specifically related the the type of service or to the amount charged. Everything < 50€ / $50 / £40 will hardly trigger any security measures.
- StillBored 11y agoI wondered that myself, especially since it doesn't have to be more expensive to the end user. Instead of selling them 1 month for $6, sell them 12 for $72 or some such, or make them buy a minimum of 10 accounts to get a monthly rate. Yah, I know the trend is to do a bunch of little micro payments, but its not like you can't do the math for them an say "$6 a month" then when they go to order it, limit the minimum number of months in order to increase the total.
- umziehennachbar 11y agodoes Fivvr.com experience this problem?
- Nexxxeh 11y agoIt was £6, which is closer to $10 USD. But good question. Could you require the first payment to be for say three months upfront, and rolling monthly after that? Or discount quarterly billing and hike the rolling monthly above the threshold?
- crazypyro 11y agoA good way to counter testers is to add a delay to charging the card.
- 11y ago
- aianus 11y agoHow would the EU enforce VAT requirements on an online business based in the U.S.? If I have an online business in the US and no presence in the EU and no intention to ever go to the EU, I don't have to charge VAT, right?
- JoshTriplett 11y agoCorrect. In theory if the project grew large enough (as in "billion-dollar industry"), the EU might start attempting to control it or block it, or attempt to regulate transactions involving it under the auspices of import/export/tariffs, but in general the EU (or any non-US company) has no jurisdiction to impose taxes on a US company. (Nor does the US have jurisdiction to impose taxes or regulations on an EU company, for that matter.)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bluecalm 11y agoEU thinks you have to pay VAT if you sell to European countries of course (otherwise it would be unfair competition vs European businesses) by means of VATMOSS but I am not sure if they have any way to enforce or if they could have any kind of jurisdiction over you.
- archagon 11y agoReading this stuff makes me glad my side projects are all native apps sold through app stores. No servers, no payment processing, little upkeep; once you're done, you're done.
- saidajigumi 11y ago> I can't win the complaint. The card was stolen, the £6 belongs to the original card owner, no question. This is so wrong. Business owners, on average, have little to no information or power to deal with this. The only agencies that have ultimate ability to deal with fraud are the card issuers and banks. IIRC, it was Bruce Schneier who first clearly articulated this for me. By placing all fraud risk on the issuers, they're fully incentivized to fix the problem as well as possible. But instead when small (or even large) business customers are subjected to ridiculous fraud charges as described in Remy's article, fraud is transformed into a kind of externalized cost imposed by these same issuers.
- amelius 11y agoCard issuers should make sure that cards are password-protected in the first place.
- hughw 11y agoDoes Paypal ameliorate the problem? Is there less fraud if you accept Paypal only?
- cpncrunch 11y agoYes, paypal seems to have very good fraud detection. I've been using them for the last 9 years for mostly $10 transactions (about $30k a year or so) and I don't think I've had a single fraudulent transaction in that time. Before paypal I used worldpay, and although their support is infinitely superior (paypal's support sucks balls), I did have a few fraudulent transactions a year. Also, paypal's refund fee is just $0.30. (Not sure if it costs any more for a chargeback).
- fixermark 11y agoBut it's not in the interest of Stripe et. al. to subsidize fraud. The fact that they have the penalty set so high is because they don't want services like JSBin acting as basically defrauded card authentication gateways (as a side effect of their legitimate business). Unfortunately for Remy Sharp, he built a fraud enabling system that doubled as a pastebin, and the financial system responded as appropriate for an open fraud portal. It's a bit like calling foul when email gateways start mistrusting your server because it's a proven open-relay node for spam. Not fair, but the system has to protect itself and its users.
- chejazi 11y agoJS Bin is a service that appeals to techies. As such, it should see moderate success accepting Bitcoin! Bitcoin transactions are non-reversible, which would solve the fraud complications.
- Nexxxeh 11y agoBut would it fuck him on the VATMOSS? Would he lose the ability to verify the address via the cardholder billing address? A question I don't know the answer to.
- joshvm 11y agoAt the moment it's a bit of a grey area. In the future, the Government is already planning: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/revenue-and-customs-brief-9-2014-bitcoin-and-other-cryptocurrencies/revenue-and-customs-brief-9-2014-bitcoin-and-other-cryptocurrencies#vat-treatment-of-bitcoin-and-similar-cryptocurrencies https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/revenue-and-custo... You'll have to charge VAT as normal, before the price is converted into bitcoin.
- chejazi 11y agoThis is a really good question. It's funny, a little digging led me back to the same blog. https://remysharp.com/2014/12/30/vatmoss-proof https://remysharp.com/2014/12/30/vatmoss-proof I could see the location information being supplied using a Bitcoin service provider (Coinbase?), but whether it is accepted as "proof," is questionable.
- ufo 11y agoHow many people do you think would pay for jsbin via Bitcoin but not via regular money?
- kentt 11y agoA couple percent at most. I think companies who've implemented Bitcoin payment have seen a 1% or less. A good number of those would have been customers anyway. I love Bitcoin and use it a lot, but the truth is, this likely wouldn't do much for jsbin.
- Mz 11y agoThe second, major issue was that I had hoped, naively, that the web community will swoop in and pony up some cash. With JS Bin, everything users need is given away and open source. That's honourable, but doesn't pay the mortgage. He has come up with a very jaded either/or point of view. You can visit Patreon and find sites being supported by user "donations". There are sites making money on ads. There are sites making money on product sales. There are sites supporting staff from a combination of the above. It is naïve to think "If you build it, they will throw money at it," but that doesn't mean you can either cut your own throat by giving it away for free until you feel like a chump or you can hold everything hostage until people pony up. It's fine if you have a service that works well with a pay per use or subscription model of some sort, but lots of services are not monetizable that way. Television, print magazines, newspapers and on and on have to find ways to pay the bills using a combination of charging the end user and selling advertising and possibly other things I am not thinking of. As far as I can tell, it would not work to only charge the end user for quite a lot of things we use regularly. The world would be a poorer place if the only services that lived were ones that charged the end user. There are some services that are just not conducive to that model. I hope he revisits the question of how to monetize JS Bin. Do some brainstorming. Do some research. Try to figure out a monetization scheme that is a good fit for the specific service in question. I think the best salve for this wound would be a monetization scheme that works. There are enough embittered, jaded people in the world already. We need to find more ways for people to follow their bliss and also pay their bills.
- scrollaway 11y agoThis was a great read. The VATMOSS stuff was especially scary. I don't understand why there isn't a lower bound on how much money you have to make before you have to worry about bureaucracy like that =/ Monetizing foss projects is hard. It's funny... at this very moment, in another corner of Github, there are people fighting against ads being introduced in Flyspray, a self-hostable gpl issue tracker. There's good discussion in the commit and it's a perfect lesson in how not to monetize FOSS projects. I thought it was relevant so I submitted the details here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10235858 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10235858
- petercooper 11y agoI pay for Gmail, because I need real business email accounts. Did I get lucky with being one of the early Apps for Your Domain users? We don't pay a bean for our company's Gmail accounts but seem to get most of the features (no ads, custom domain, etc).
- SupremumLimit 11y agoYes, it used to be free until maybe 3 years ago. I've got a free setup as well.
- pluma 11y agoYou've been grandfathered (i.e. you got lucky and Google decided to uphold the original terms you signed up on). Frankly, as a European I don't find the paid version worth the price tag (which can be hefty if you have a lot of freelancers working for you). Yes, it's Google Apps, so if you use the entire stack you can avoid the cost of a lot of additional services, but at the same time that means you need to be okay with storing all your confidential data with Google. But for me the deal-breaker was the way e-mail accounts work when using the same Google Apps for Business account with multiple domains. At least when I evaluated it, there was no way to define aliases per-domain. So if you add both domain-a.example and domain-b.example and want contact@domain-a.example to go to a different person than contact@domain-b.example -- no dice. Also if you want to be able to receive e-mails on firstname.lastname@domain-a.example but not firstname.lastname@domain-b.example, again: not a chance. I'm not sure whether this has changed since then, but this is why I took my business to Fastmail and other isolated services.
- javajosh 11y agoRemy, I'm sorry. JSBin is my favorite live JS environment, and I use it several times a week, and I haven't paid a thing. That's not fair to you. I'm also sorry that I haven't sent the emails that probably still sit in my drafts folder, because I think that the JSBin genre of software development tools has a very bright future - and I encourage you to not give up. For now, is it at all possible to just send you $100 via paypal?
- boyter 11y agoI can totally understand. I just read through each post and I can relate to pretty much every point. For searchcode I have not implemented paid accounts though I have considered it for a while. This post pretty much confirms for me that it would be a bad idea. searchcode also gets a lot of abuse, particularly to the API's (millions of requests) and though hot-links. I think the worst part for me though is the constant takedown notices. Most are nicely worded emails, but quite a few have been very nasty threatening legal demands. I haven't lost my love for my side project yet and the ad's that are running at least cover hosting costs. Really looking forward to the next part in the tale.
- imchillyb 11y agoFollowing the bliss isn't supposed to pay the bills. Following the bliss increases skill-sets, creates necessary connections between persons, and gives the bliss-seeker an out. Out is good. The bliss is not the means to an end. The bliss is self serving and self improving, while also finding an escape from the daily grind and its deleterious effects. Follow your bliss, by all means. But, at the same time, realize that it's not the end goal. You're not learning programming to make money. You're learning programming because you enjoy it, and or it increases your skill-sets. Also, programming isn't bliss. Programming is an addiction. It's a sometime beneficial addiction, but an addiction nonetheless. Something to consider.
- inDigiNeous 11y agoIf you're dedicated enough to follow the bliss, it will pay your bills, and also do the other things. If you have failed personally, please don't discourage others. Programming can be bliss, at least seeing the results. I mean, why else would anybody program? Just for the money?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jakevn 11y ago> I mean, why else would anybody program? Just for the money? Considering the pay, absolutely!
- inDigiNeous 11y agoThen, I would recommend, through experiences of doing what I dont love long enough, to reconsider what is more important, money or doing what you love. Of course, sometimes it can be just the money, or the learning, or working with a great team, but to recognize when it turns into a struggle and just drains our energy is something that is important. Working with software, it is such a toll on the mind and the body, that doing it just for the money seems really pointless at least for me. But I understand that this realization may come through only going through enough work that is not really fulfilling us inside on a deep level. On a superficial level programming can be good just to gather resources, but is this really the best we can do? I mean, what if Elon Musk, Nikolai Tesla, Newton or other brightest minds would just worked for money ? Would we have the inventions we have today ? This is my point I want to remind people everyday. I have worked for 5 years (3 of those fulltime, and so that I have always managed) on a project (http://GeoKone.NET http://GeoKone.NET and now http://Geometrify.net http://Geometrify.net) that is the product of my pure love, and at times it has been difficult, yes, eaten a lot of porridge during those days, but the Universe has a way of supporting those who really want to help others, and to provide something to support others in their quest too! But you have to give back something too in order for it to work. I think this is also a big problem in our society right now, not giving back, but just gathering resources for selfish uses, like many big companies do. This is why I am reminding to really think about what we are putting our energy into.
- curiousjorge 11y agothis is my worst nightmare. free users are some of the most abusive and aggressive people that will without question overrun and destroy your product.
- TheHolyLancer 11y agoHonestly, his target users are those who needs a free place to try out web coding, which means many of his users are likely not well off enough to be able to want to throw money at something that they get the full use out of. I won't say the thing is bad, but the business behind it is bad. Got to have a viable targeted userbase as the core, and handle any new userbase as they come in.
- pcr0 11y agoThere was a post here recently trying to figure out why Europe's startup scene was falling behind the US. Kudos to companies that can survive past monstrosities like VAT and VATMOSS. Out of curiosity, how is VAT enforced for a non-EU seller and an EU buyer? Let's say my business was registered in the Cayman islands for example.
- toddkazakov 11y agoI can tell you about EU seller and US buyer - there's no VAT
- wyager 11y agoAre US businesses obligated to pay VATMOSS? Does the EU have any recourse if you don't?
- germanier 11y agoYes and no. If you have a physical presence in an EU state, that one will probably get you for tax fraud. If you have sufficiently high transaction volume they might find another way. I have never heard of it happening, but theoretically any member state in which you sold can start a criminal trial against the responsible persons, making travel to Europe a bit more complicated.
- jondubois 11y agoFree products need to have a way to lock users in. It's not evil or unethical - In fact, it's the opposite; if you don't lock your users into your free product, your competitor will lock them into an expensive alternative which will give them less flexibility.
- voltagex_ 11y agohttps://github.com/jsbin/jsbin/issues/2320 https://github.com/jsbin/jsbin/issues/2320 is a good read, too.
- Asbostos 11y agoI know PayPal isn't popular but it's by far the easiest way to accept payments online that I've found. You don't have to live in the US,Canada or EU, which is a weakness of all the new services like Stripe and every other startup promising to "fix payments". I set it up for my small business years ago with no coding or worrying about weird tax rules and it just works. I process each payment manually so there's a bit of a delay for the customers but I've never had a chargeback although my prices are a bit higher. The main drawback is customers think they need a PayPal account and nobody wants to open one - for good reason. The payment page has a dark pattern that makes it look like you have to sign up to pay by credit card.