11 ms·
Yale to Be Paid Interest on Dutch Water Authority Bond from 1648
- kchoudhu 11y agoCUSIP?
- haarts 11y agoThe image accompanying the story doesn't seem to be the bond in question. The date on the bond states the year 1944, and the payments also start around that date. The last payment was done in 2003. Odd.
- gpvos 11y agoLook at the second image on the page, which is definitely old; I think I can make out year numbers in the 1700s. The first image looks like an extra sheet appended in 1944.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoYes, it looks like the original sheet was filled up. There may be other auxiliary sheets that aren't shown (or are simply missing -- perhaps they went missing in WWII?).
- gpvos 11y agoThe technical term appears to be "allonge", which is also the first word on the added sheet: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allonge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allonge
- hydrogen18 11y agoInteresting point. The second image has dates much farther back, I see many from the 1700s. Perhaps the bond was originally issued and in 1944 a companion document was issued with it? So now the single bond consists of two documents. It would make sense to issue a newer document that goes along with the original. I imagine some numbering scheme was introduced between the original issue and 1944. The 1944 document would provide a number in the modern scheme for the original bond.
- mcv 11y agoI can imagine a document from 1648 wouldn't be big enough to keep writing interest payments on for more than 3 centuries.
- rbinv 11y agoSerious question: Why is (bond) interest not adjusted for inflation (or deflation for that matter)? Very long timespans such as these really devalue any interest payments, do they not?
- icebraining 11y agoSome are: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation-indexed_bond https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation-indexed_bond Back then, inflation was probably less of a problem for investors.
- gahahaha 11y agoIt didn't use to matter much. Consistent inflation is a rather new phenomenon that basically only appeared after WWII. There was for example almost no inflation in Britain between 1814 and 1914. For the record, in case there still are Ron Paul fans/goldbugs out there: moderate inflation is generally considered a good thing by economists today and inflation is probably too low at the moment.
- msandford 11y agoPersonally, as a reductionist, I like the idea that money is somehow permanent. Maybe economists like inflation, and perhaps it is "good" for the economy overall. But the idea that a dollar saved today can buy roughly the same amount of stuff in a decade or a century seems like a powerful idea to me. To me that seems like a goal that's worthy of pursuing because then money becomes a true abstraction that's not leaky. And because of the way my brain works, I see that as incredibly useful. Not having to always inflation adjust things, not having to do this or that, not having to worry about how much retirement you actually have versus how much you think you have, etc. I understand that for various reasons few other people want this, but that doesn't convince me personally otherwise. One person described money as "sweat, distilled" and I find that definition incredibly attractive. I recognize that plenty of people making money not by sweating but thinking or whatever, but I still find it an excellent description. And I can't see how devaluing a person's effort over time is a viable strategy for building a lasting civilization. I think it leads inevitably towards the kind of throwaway society we have here in the US and virtually guarantees that we won't build infrastructure of long lasting value like exists elsewhere in the world. Well built stuff can last for hundreds or thousands of years. I wish money was the same.
- Someone1234 11y agoPerpetual bonds are a terrible idea. Just like "unlimited" anything, if you offer unlimited then someone will try to use unlimited. Even if they had done 200 years, it likely wouldn't have diminished the bond's value too heavily (at purchase), and would have put a stop to this. I guess they figured that they would eventually buy back all of the bonds, but missed a few or never had the money.
- cletus 11y agoAny kind of unlimited tends to be a terrible idea. Just look at the wrangling over the AAirpass: http://articles.latimes.com/2012/may/05/business/la-fi-0506-golden-ticket-20120506 http://articles.latimes.com/2012/may/05/business/la-fi-0506-... At least, from AA's perspective, that ends when the holder dies so there's light at the end of the tunnel.
- newjersey 11y agoWhen I first started learning about Individual Retirement Accounts, one thought I had on Roth was how long can income from a Roth IRA stay tax free? I was hoping the answer would be in perpetuity. Sadly, it seems that the longest you can draw it out is until the death of one's surviving spouse. Imagine how glorious it would be if you could stow away about $5k of post tax income every year and invest it in some stock index fund if you could give it to someone upon death. Of course, it wouldn't be a retirement account anymore though.
- csense 11y agoTrusts are sort of like this. I think the key is you have to have signed away the money irrevocably to the legal entity of the trust, so it's totally out of your control when you die and thus not taxed with your estate.
- selimthegrim 11y agoSomeone named Jacques Vroom buying one of these has to be right up there with "Headless body in Topless Bar" as godsends to lede writers.
- gpvos 11y agoAs an aside, note the typical Dutch way to write the digit 8: starting at the left of the middle with the bottom part, instead of at the very top left. It is used universally in the Netherlands, but I have been told it's used nowhere else, not even in Flanders.
- louhike 11y agoI do it this way and I'm french. It seems strange to me that it is specific to the netherlands.
- gpvos 11y agoWell, I wouldn't know for sure, but I haven't seen it differently yet (yes, I know, anecdotal). I don't think it is generally taught that way elsewhere. But the main intention of my post is to find out, so your data point is welcome. :) There are some corpora of handwritten digits (for OCR training) lying around the net, I guess I should check those to be sure.
- strictnein 11y agoWait, people start at the top left for 8? I start at the top right. I also write "e" by first writing the "c" and then filling it in, so it's very conceivable that I'm the outlier. I blame wanting to finish those dang writing practice sheets in 2nd or 3rd grade as quickly as possible.
- gpvos 11y ago
- vasilipupkin 11y agoFinance has eaten the world
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoI can't tell if this is finance or numismatics.
- rocky1138 11y agoDoes the pier still exist? It would be amazing to see it on Google Street View as a follow-up to this amazing story. I love stuff like this.
- hydrogen18 11y agoDepending on where it is, it is possible the shoreline doesn't even exist anymore. Land reclamation is great at stuff at like that.
- Luc 11y agoI'm not quite sure but I think the bond is for repairs to a 32km long dike. E.g. (in Dutch) http://shhv.info/projectgroep-harmelen/geschiedenis/gedenksteen-watersnood-1624/ http://shhv.info/projectgroep-harmelen/geschiedenis/gedenkst... "Aan de noordzijde van de Lek was een dijk aangebracht van ruim 32 km lang en hij liep vanaf Amerongen (aan de rand van de Utrechtse heuvelrug) naar het Klaphek bij Vreeswijk, de Lekdijk Bovendams genaamd."
- gpvos 11y agoSome details from Dutch news sources: It was an bond ("obligatie") of 1000 guilders, given out by Hoogheemraadschap Lekdijk Bovendams (more recently merged into Hoogheemraadschap De Stichtse Rijnlanden). It returns 25 guilders (now 11,35 euros) interest per year. Yale bought it in 2003 for 24.000 euros. It was given out in 1648 to build a groyne ("krib") near the hamlet of Honswijk. Looking at Google Maps, you can see a system of multiple groynes there; I am not sure whether this bond paid for only one of them or for more: https://www.google.com/maps/place/3998+Honswijk,+Netherlands/@51.9709538,5.1798967,3041m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m2!3m1!1s0x47c660e762d7a323:0x5606466a56d976e4 https://www.google.com/maps/place/3998+Honswijk,+Netherlands... Original buyer of the bond was Niclaes de Meijer: http://www.zeit.de/2015/15/ewige-anleihen-kredit-geldanlage http://www.zeit.de/2015/15/ewige-anleihen-kredit-geldanlage (German!). In the first 50 years of the 17th century, Lekdijk Bovendams gave out 300.000 guilders of bonds to repair the dikes along the 8 km stretch it was responsible for. Stichtse Rijnlanden is nowadays responsible for the Lek dikes between Amerongen and Schoonhoven, as well as water management in most of the province of Utrecht.
- murbard2 11y agoPerpetuities are a great idea. One of their advantage is that new debt issues are fungible with old debt issues (provided the coupon payment dates debt align). The downside of that is that the duration of such a bond is fixed and depends on the prevailing interest rates. However, one can issue a perpetuity where the coupon is set to decrease (or increase!) geometrically over time. Different issue of such bonds are still fungible (provided they use the same rate of exponential decay), but their duration can now be tuned at will, by changing the characteristic time of the exponential. Why does this matter? There is a large market in government bonds (particularly in the US) and this market places a large premium on the latest issued bonds, or "on-the-run". This is because these bonds enjoy the most liquidity and can be used as alternatives to cash. The premium disappears as the bond is replaced with a new issue. Real economic value is being destroyed because the bonds aren't fungible. Perpetuities with exponentially decreasing coupons would immediately solve that problem in one fell swoop.
- rjdevereux 11y agoYou've obviously never had to build a system that tracks bonds when their original currency no longer exists. ;)
- brador 11y agoHow would you do that?
- boxy310 11y agoWhen a currency disappears on a planned basis (like the Deutschmark) the government issues a recall of the currency in banks at a set exchange rate: e.g. for the Deutschmark it was set by law at 1.95583 DM = 1 euro (source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deutsche_Mark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deutsche_Mark) When a currency disappears entirely (like with Zimbabwe), there's a much more chaotic basis as it switches to separate sovereign currencies, which often have different inflation rates baked in. As this can be much more unexpected than a planned currency transition, the market often doesn't incorporate the expected changes in real interest rates, and often the exchange rate needs to keep floating for a while to account for ongoing inflation. More info on Zimbabwe's abandonment of their currency: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zimbabwean_dollar#Abandonment_and_demonetization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zimbabwean_dollar#Abandonment_...
- z2 11y agoPart of the reason Yale holds this artifact is due to Prof. Geert Rouwenhorst, who researched Dutch financial instruments. If I recall correctly, he actually collected a few decades of interest on behalf of Yale during the purchase of the bond back in 2003, and even had an ancient ledger updated to reflect the payout. I still consider the more 'recent' 19th century bonds he passed around in class to be the coolest show-and-tell item ever from a professor.
- gpvos 11y agoYou can see when the interest has been collected: more or less yearly until 1963, then in 1971, 1976, 2003.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>Yale, which has an endowment of $23.9 billion As a side note, that's about half the entire GDP of Ethiopia last year. That's a country of 100m people.
- adventured 11y agoA better reference, given the endowment is capital rather than annual output, would be national wealth. Per capita wealth in Ethiopia is close to $500, with 94 million people. They have around $45-$50 billion in wealth.
- samstave 11y agoI'm actually surprised that Ethiopia can generate ~46B at all...
- adventured 11y agoTheir economy is finally growing nicely, after 30 plus years of disaster. From their small base, GDP has tripled in ten years. They've seen 11 straight growth years. The prior two years both saw around 10% growth, while inflation has been relatively low. Life expectancy at birth has climbed from 50 to 64 in 20 years. The poverty rate has fallen from 45% to about 25% in 20 years. The infant mortality rate has fallen from 140/100k in 1980, to around 40 today, falling by 50% since 2000. It's expected to continue to fall. They're actually generating wealth faster than any other comparable nation in Africa: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/dec/04/ethiopia-faster-rate-millionaires-michael-buerk http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/dec/04/ethiopia-faster...
- samstave 11y agoWell, jesus -- good for them! However that article only left me suspicious as to how these new millionaires are making their money... Even in the article it states that some dont know where the money came from... I err on the side of corruption...
- IkmoIkmo 11y ago
- Jerry2 11y ago>Yale, which has an endowment of $23.9 billion Fascinating. Yet they still require their students to pay tens of thousand of dollars each year in tuition. They should do what Stanford did and make education free for students whose families earn less than $125k.
- rhc2104 11y agoYale does have a comparable program. http://admissions.yale.edu/financial-aid http://admissions.yale.edu/financial-aid Families don't have to pay if they make less than 65k. Stanford's program is similar. Their 125k threshold is for not paying tuition, but a family making 125k is expected to pay for room and board.
- emmett 11y agoQuoth Yale's website: "Yale does not require students to take out loans for their education. Instead, Yale meets 100% of demonstrated need for all admitted students with a financial aid package consisting of need-based scholarships, term-time employment, and a student income contribution." http://admissions.yale.edu/financial-aid-prospective-students#101 http://admissions.yale.edu/financial-aid-prospective-student... So...Yale does what Stanford does already...
- dragonwriter 11y agoYale -- like a lot of elite private schools -- has very comprehensive need-based financial aid that often covers full costs. Despite the higher nominal tuition, its usually practically cheaper for a low- to moderate-income student who can get into such a school to pay less out of their own/parent funds (including both out-of-pocket and loans) than they would if they went to a nominally cheaper public university. This has been true of elite universities in general for decades.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoYale already does that. Tuition at top universities is essentially a steeply progressive tax. If you're a Rockefeller you pay the sticker price. Everybody else gets a discount.
- msie 11y agoMaybe now more money will go to the students who need it. ;-)
- msie 11y agoMaybe now more money will go to the students who need it. ;-)
- Someone 11y agoA slighlty older one (1634) on the same dam sold at Christie's in 2000, for $47,000 (http://www.christies.com/LotFinder/lot_details.aspx?intObjectID=1965498 http://www.christies.com/LotFinder/lot_details.aspx?intObjec...) Christie's also gives background info on the bond, such as "While it was originally a requirement that the bond-holder send the original parchment to the Lekdijk Bovendams on 12 January to receive the annual interest, the successful bidder on this lot need only send the allonge, on which the payment will be neatly recorded by a responsible clerk of the Waterschap Kromme Rijn (successor to the monk and Secretary who sealed the document in 1634), as it has been for 302 years since 1698."