20 ms·
Why Is Europe Failing to Create More $1B Startups?
- veb 11y agoAwesome read, but you write that Europe has no SV or NYC. I'd say that it does have a NYC: London. London is the centre of finance in Europe. It utterly dominates.
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoPlus I don't think location really matters that much; startups don't need an environment with thousands of hip enterpreneurs, all it takes is a small team with a good idea.
- gaius 11y agoLondon actually has no "startup scene", the dirty little secret is there is no silicon in Silicon Roundabout. Lots of ad brokers, social media strategists, hairdressers and bakers with Twitter accounts, but no actual tech is developed there.
- justincormack 11y agoThat is a lie that the Register likes. There is actually lots if real tech. Perhaps less actual silicon than Cambridge but lots of tech. Some decent exits in real techn prove it.
- s73v3r 11y agoThey don't need it, but it's much easier to build that team somewhere with that environment.
- atmosx 11y agoLack of investors. Simple as that. Companies that run on deficit for 5-10 years can not survive in Europe. Facebook, twitter, etc. Wouldn't be able to survive in Europe, simple as that. ps. I hate the word 'unicorn'.
- ThomPete 11y agoI hate the word unicorn too, but it's shorter than private market companies with a valuation of more than $1 billion :) With regards to lack of investors I don't think it's as simple as that. If it was only a matter of investments then surely US investors or Asian investors could just come in with the money. There is something that makes European VCs risk averse and keep american investors out of Europe IMO.
- atmosx 11y agoFirst, thanks for ghostnote. It's an awesome app, worth every penny. > I hate the word unicorn too, but it's shorter than private market companies with a valuation of more than $1 billion :) Ah, is 1 billion the limit for the 'unicorn' definition? In what amount of time? :-) We have 7-year old companies, with 50+ employees posing around as startups everywhere these days. It's not related, but you know... Everyone is playing with words here :-P > With regards to lack of investors I don't think it's as simple as that. Of course you don't, otherwise you wouldn't have written a blog post... You could tweet! But, unfortunately, as most social phenomena is not that complex :-) The reason we can't have a "unicorn" in Europe is that no one is going to support a company that it's expenses outsize it's turn-over even if this is because of extremely high growth rate. If you're lucky enough, you might land some millions from some startup event. But even they, ask to see growth (in terms of users) and (hehe) immediate ROI. In startup Istanbul 2014 the no1 startup which received investment was the only company who didn't actually need it... It was already generating way more than it could burn. So it was a very easy bet.
- copsarebastards 11y ago> I hate the word unicorn too, but it's shorter than private market companies with a valuation of more than $1 billion :) Small-cap companies is shorter than that too and it actually means something. Don't give excuses for using stupid terminology.
- Vexs 11y agoUnicorn just pokes my brain the wrong way, like bad kerning. On the other hand, it does describe how rare these things are, which I feel does make it an accurate term- it also explains how companies like this are essentially legends. It's an annoying term, but it works (unfortunately)
- afsina 11y agoState intervention on innovation is considered harmful.
- atmosx 11y agoWhat about gun control? Does that stop innovation too?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- atemerev 11y agoSure. More gun control -> more police expenses -> more taxes -> less innovation. Try opening a company in, say, France. (This was a cruel joke. Please don't, for the sake of your sanity).
- notNow 11y agoActually More permissive & lax gun laws -> More police militarization to preserve the competitive advantage -> More govt spending local or federal -> Less spending on other sectors such as health and education BTW I'm centrist on the issue of gun ownership & carrying but I just wanted to point out the flaw in your deduction.
- throwaway1967 11y ago> Actually More permissive & lax gun laws -> More police militarization to preserve the competitive advantage Are you sure your arrow there means causation? Explain like I'm five, why do you think the police feels it needs to compete with law-abiding gun-carrying citizens? I've never heard of this silly idea before, but maybe I'm silly and you have a great argument for that. If you had said "the more guns in criminals' hands, the more police militarization to preserve advantage" then I'd agree with you but I'd ask to see how you know the number of guns in criminals' hands. 0.001% of law-abiding gun holders are a problem for the police. 100% of criminals are a problem for the police, whether they're carrying guns, knives, or a closed fist.
- scrollaway 11y agoSite is struggling. Mirror: https://archive.is/qBEfh https://archive.is/qBEfh
- rubidium 11y agofirst thought: not enough horns to go around and add to the horses. second thought: europe=continent. US = country. third thought: what good does this question do us?
- fennecfoxen 11y agoSince you bring it up: the US is a $18-trillion economy. Europe is a $19-trillion economy, of which about $18 trillion is from states in the EU. In that respect, it's the only comparison that makes sense. (Well, maybe that and something like the UK and Germany vs California and Texas, roughly $3T vs $2T each).
- jleyank 11y agoI would think that the (mandatory) benefits required for companies in Europe (or even outside the US) raise the bar for startups. More $$ is required, more paperwork to ensure compliance, ... On the good side, this might/should act as a filter. On the bad side, money flows along the path of least resistance. I guess this is an argument for accepting remote work. There are lots of talented people in places where they like living. How (new) companies deal with this will determine how the talent pool is used. As everybody argues there's insufficient talent, by definition there's insufficient talent wherever you are.
- wpietri 11y agoIn Paris a few years back I met an entrepreneur whose business was in California. He liked living in Paris, and really wanted more of his team there, but the regulations around hiring employees were a big issue for him. If I recall rightly, it wasn't so much the paperwork or the benefits, but the extra burdens around firing. So he was hiring all his new people in CA. Here in California, most employment is at will, meaning that either party can end the relationship immediately. I can quit without notice; I can be fired without notice. (In practice, notice is generally given, but that's custom, not a legal right. One can also write an employment contract with other terms.) But from what he said, it was very difficult to get rid of underperforming employees, and also hard to reduce staffing levels if the business needed fewer people.
- vorador 11y agoTo contrast with what you said, it’s very common in french contracts to be able to fire an employee in the first 8 month of her employment. This isn’t really « at-will » employment but it’s pretty close, especially for Europe.
- adaml_623 11y agoA more interesting question is: 'Are unicorns good for the economy and good for society'?
- hodwik 11y agoWhy is that the more interesting question? Is there anything you can add to the discussion of substance? Or, perhaps, is this drive-by FUD all you have in the content holster?
- adaml_623 11y agoOk you have a valid point but since the article is full of kind of wishy washy questions I didn't feel guilty about adding some more into the mix. The title 'Why is Europe Failing to Create More Unicorns?' has an implicit bias in it. The question is saying that Europeans should create more of these massive new companies. 10 smaller companies might be better than 1 big company. 100 companies worth $10 million dollars each might provide the same number of jobs and the same services to the economy. Maybe? Admittedly if you listen to European entrepreneurs you can't come away and believe that everything is rosy for new businesses.
- ThomPete 11y agoThats not what I am saying at all though. In fact I am very open in the essay to the question as to whether it's even something you would want. But the fact is that they have an effect on the world outside the US. Perhaps you are fine with that, I would love to see some more Europeans get into the game if nothing else to boost morality and have more people try and create companies.
- rjsw 11y agoYour essay does suggest to me that you think that companies like Uber and AirBnb are a good thing though. If a proportion of those europeans who could run startups hold back from following certain business models then you will get fewer startups overall.
- atemerev 11y agoWhy everybody is so obsessed about unicorns? You can get your own in a few minutes: http://unicornify.me/ http://unicornify.me/
- neuronic 11y agoGerman law makes the "out of the garage + Angel investor" start-up culture impossible. The only possible way is to make money AND start out with a huge amount of cash. I can't speak for other Euro countries.
- jdimov9 11y agoHow so?
- SyneRyder 11y agoBerlin seems to be bursting with startup culture, between all the co-working locations & Soundcloud & 6Wunderkinder acquisition. Are the German startups focusing more on profit & bootstrapping approaches rather than Angel funding then?
- smcl 11y agoWhat part? Is the incorporation of a company complicated\bureacratic? I know here in Czech Rep you pretty much need to have a local Czech speaker setup\registered\licensed with a certain status before you can create a new company. Or is there some capital requirements ("you must have €x,000 in the company accts to operate"), or lawyers fees that make it either tough\impossible for the early "ramen" stage?
- kuschku 11y agoIn Germany, only very few legal types of incorporation allow the owners to be free of risk. Usually they require a high amount of money to start such a limited (so, in case of bankruptcy, all debt can be paid). There is now a mini-GmbH, essentially a type of Ltd. that can only handle a limited (pun not intended) amount of assets, but does not require you to have enough assets to pay back the debts. Then there are GbR, etc, a lot of nice incorporation types, but these, while effective for a normal company, are not useful for a silicon-valley type of company, as the silicon valley relies on an investment bubble - and a GbR and similar place the liability completely with the owners of the company. Then there are consumer cooperatives and so on, but while these, again, are useful for the normal economy, you can’t use them to make profit by scamming people (as they are effectively profit-less).
- Asbostos 11y agoHe mentions the multiple languages. I don't understand why Europeans stick to their local languages when they all know English anyway. Are they trying to keep foreigners out? Surely they realize there's a huge social cost of having your own minority language. This problem exists in China too but most people recognize the need to learn the standard Mandarin so they're largely bilingual. Dialect at home and Mandarin talking to everyone else even if it comes with a funny accent.
- atemerev 11y agoNo, not everybody in Europe speaks English. Not in France, not in Germany, not in Spain, not in Italy.
- cosarara97 11y agoAnd even if we did, we wouldn't just let an essential part of our culture die like that.
- vixen99 11y agoAnecdotal of course but for what's it's worth on the basis of around twenty cross-Europe trips by car I would say very few speak English. We live in bubbles and tend to believe they're shared by all.
- donkeyd 11y ago> they all know English anyway Not all of us speak English.
- pluma 11y agoI haven't seen any serious tech companies in Germany that don't require at least basic English skills.
- pvaldes 11y agoAnd thus, the percentage of talent that european companies are able to see and reach is only a part of the whole talent available. Bad for both parts. Yes, is another big problem also.
- Shivetya 11y agoOver regulation. He talks all around that word but its key to why. The barrier to entry becomes much more difficult to surmount.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoEurope historically had a problem where powerful nobility owned massive portions of the economy outright. Competition? Maybe with an army. Today, it's a lot better than it was, but in many places the powerful noblility have been replaced by other powerful interests and some industries still operate like they have the God-given right to supply automobile tires to the French people and all good men must express solidarity to expel these upstart invaders... :(
- kuschku 11y agoOver regulation is not really a thing – the US has under regulation, especially in regards to data safety. Over regulation is what the US does with taxis. Which is why in Germany companies that do essentially the same as Uber (but legal[1]) already existed before Uber was even founded. What I see the "issue" is that as soon as some size is reached, we don't really care about expanding further. Why take a risk when you already have a pretty nice market? [1] In Germany, where UberPop is currently banned, you can start a taxi company if your drivers are insured with commercial insurance. To make profit, your drivers need to have a 55€ license as taxi driver. Simple as that. UberPop is only banned because they did not want to insure the drivers (the license is less of an issue).
- aianus 11y ago> UberPop is only banned because they did not want to insure the drivers. Do you have a source for this? Uber insures its UberX drivers in both Canada and the U.S. so I don't see why they would be opposed in Germany. There must be something else.
- mschuster91 11y agoYes there is, the fare is regulated - no matter the demand, the area of the source or destination, or how drunk the passenger is. Uber does heavy demand-based price adjusting, and well, fuck that. Better have the assurance of always paying 20€ for my trip home, than the variability of an Uber with 10-50€.
- ksherlock 11y agoThose that don't remember history are doomed to repeat it. Maybe you guys learned something from that tulip episode?
- donkeyd 11y agoI've posted this before, but since I think it's relevant here: People seem to forget that Europe is not a country. Europe does not have a single uniting language. What happens, is that every country starts their own smaller versions and they stay mostly within that country. If they want to move to another country, there's often already a major player there, and they might not have the means to kick them out. I think the reason that silicon valley is so powerful, is that the initial market is 325 million people who all speak the same language. Once you get the US market, you have the size, name and means to easily start conquering European countries. It's always about scale...
- ThomPete 11y agoI really hope that I am actually addressing that in my essay.
- donkeyd 11y agoI commented before reading the article, as I was having trouble loading it. I've managed to read it and I see you did mention it. You other points do add some interesting ideas that I haven't considered before. Especially #3 is interesting.
- pinaceae 11y agoyou're absolutely right. successful examples that started in europe soon moved to the us to take off. qliktech/qlikview as a swedish example. intercom being spread across ireland and SF. etc. the one market that could rival the US will be china. it is harmful to non-chinese investors though, but once they open it up a huge, homogenic market will pop up. wechat, baidu, alibaba already show what is possible there. apple and uber coming in with mature(rer) businesses. wonder when we'll see a mixed-background startup emerge in china. as someone from austria that moved to the bay area - you must be bonkers to try ramping up a startup in most of europe. if your desire/plan is unicorn-scale of course.
- mattmanser 11y agoMore like 450 million when you include the UK, Canada and Australia.
- cronjobber 11y agoEurope had a crippling diversity deficit and so the US easily took the lead in tech, but under the guise of the so-called "refugee crisis" Europe is now executing a cunning Blitzkrieg assault on America's former advantage. D is for diversity, E is for EUgle!
- cronjobber 11y agoAddendum: Note that I honestly think that it is basically true: Europe's capitalists will not only profit from the refugee crisis, but they will do so for precisely the same reasons US capitalists profited from diversity. I'm deeply sorry I can't discuss mechanism on this forum; it takes too much hard boiled cynicism to fully grok. Yet I'm serious: The refugee immigration will ultimately boost Europe's tech competitiveness.
- mamon 11y ago"The refugee immigration will ultimately boost Europe's tech competitiveness" I don't think so. Most of the immigrants are uneducated people, with no willingnes of finding a job. They want to go to Germany because that's the country with highest benefits for unemployed. How would we benefit from THAT ?
- pluma 11y agoHere's a thought: these people went through hell in order to get out of the misery they lived in. That's not exactly what I have in mind when I think of underachievers with no work ethos.
- mamon 11y agoHere's the thought: if they really went through hell they would appreciate stay in any decent EU country. But most of them really wasn't in danger when they decided to travel to Europe. In fact, such a travel, as organized by people smuggling gangs costs about $10k so it's obvious that they were pretty wealthy before they decided to come here. Also, most of them openly admit that they are here for economic reasons, not running from war. Please, get some info before posting such stupid comments. Also, if this was really about finding safe haven from war, there are rich, muslim countries like Saudi Arabia or Turkey, which are much closer and would be much better place for them anyway, due to similar cultural background, but for some reason they prefer EU with it's social benefits.
- bsaul 11y ago"The third reason I hear is that the US market is bigger and therefore it’s easier to get traction. Yet there are 503 million Europeans living inside the EU vs. 319 million US living in the US" Stopped reading after this line. So to this guy, a market is a geographic definition. Well, we're not in the 19th century anymore. We're not defined by hills and roads and river access. IT startups identify markets from culture and language first and foremost. And you obviously won't market a product the same way in germany, france, or greece. It's the biggest issue with euro so far: same currency, 25 different cultures.
- realusername 11y agoIt's indeed difficult to explain how diverse the countries are in Europe, you have the same kind of cultural differences that you have in the whole United States in just a single European country from one side to the other, it's pretty dense.
- bsaul 11y agoYes, yet i would hope that someone that tries to address the fundamental flaws in parts of Europe economy has at least a minimal knowledge of that fact. To make such a fundamental mistake in an analysis, one has to have never had even one single business relation with two different european countries.
- ThomPete 11y agoRead on from there, I am well aware of this but my point is a little different.
- ThomPete 11y agoYou should have continued reading cause I am actually addressing this :)
- andreamazz 11y agoUnicorns? Ha! It's hard to survive, let alone be successful. No investors, convoluted laws, high taxes and complete lack of startup mentality. I'm a cofounder of an italian startup, and the road is on an unbearably steep slope. The bureaucracy is insane, the cost of running a small business is daunting. Other companies refuse to work with you because in their eyes you're a scrub (I heard so many times bullshit like "I don't know if you'll be alive in a year or two, so I can't adopt your technology"). You can't hire someone else because you simply can't afford it, and the best people go to the USA anyway. It's immensely frustrating, the only thing that keeps us going is passion, but passion won't pay the bills. Before talking about unicorns we should talk about creating an healthier business environment.
- IndianAstronaut 11y ago>I'm a cofounder of an italian startup, and the road is on an unbearably steep Pardon the question, but I have read that organized crime is making a strong resurgence in Italy. Does this factor into your startup or affect it in any way?
- hobo_mark 11y agoAnd where did you hear that?
- IndianAstronaut 11y agohttp://www.economist.com/news/europe/21636046-italian-mobsters-have-spread-south-northward-mafia-middle http://www.economist.com/news/europe/21636046-italian-mobste...
- andreamazz 11y agoLuckily no, organized crime is spread mostly on other regions, and as far as I know it doesn't seem involved in the ICT field. At least I hope :)
- npizzolato 11y ago> I heard so many times bullshit like "I don't know if you'll be alive in a year or two, so I can't adopt your technology" I'm not sure why you think this is bullshit. Most startups fail. It seems like good sense to be wary of taking a dependency on another business that might not be around in the near future instead of an alternative that has already proven itself in the market.
- pinaceae 11y agoon the legal argument - remember that is easier for a wealthy US citizen to break the law internationally and even at home than say a German trying to break the law in Germany. get a local conviction on your personal record and you're toast.
- dovereconomics 11y agoOkay, everybody will hate me. But, why are more unicorns a good thing? Yes, there are less VCs willing to throw money at 'SOCIAL APP n', but most startups will tend to have something more concrete. Plus, assuming unicorns are 'natural forces of free market' is ignorance and hurts the economy in the long-term. These 'natural monopolies' use/abuse a financial system created by government. In a free market(no government intervention), they'd never be able to raise as much money and takeover as much market cap as they currently do. Less monopolies is not a signal of a interventionist economy. Quite the opposite.
- lumberjack 11y ago>These are of course mostly older companies and not part of the Unicorn category, but at the end of the day that’s just semantics. No, it's not just semantics. Look at the history of Siemens or any other of these old European companies. There's one aspect that is present all their history and that's government involvement. One could even say that their first venture capitalist that gave them a chance was the government. They all pretty much started out by getting contracts for building infrastructure or military hardware.
- ThomPete 11y agoYou bring on a good point, but thats not what I meant with that so sorry if that was imprecise. My point is that in the historical context most large companies made it big with or without government help both in the EU and in the US. So whats changed and thats what I am trying to explore and one of my conclusions is that it might have to do with how Europe is implementing laws. Keep in mind that the EU still have many government supported companies so if thats all it takes then there might be more. But it's a complex issue which is why I wrote it because I was hoping for discussion like these and points like yours to surface. So thanks.
- kavabean 11y agoI wonder if the following could be relevant. 1. In my experience, Europeans are less dominated by the "newer is better" desire to constantly get the latest gadget/technology. I wonder if others agree. 2. European money appears to be more dominated by old money / aristocracy and that these people like to invest within that network. Engineers are less likely to be part of the aristocracy and are treated more like commodities than the enabling superstar athletes they are (at least the kind that make unicorns). I know quite a few engineers that make over $200k in SV but only one who makes over 100k GBP.
- andreamazz 11y agoAs far as gadget goes, "newer is better" is a dominant factor in Europe too. The problem lays in the enterprise world. One time a client told me "you call this Visual Basic application old, but it's not. It's consolidated". Can't argue with that logic. As for the second point, you're right on the money. I can't count the amount of engineers that make less than 25/30k€ here.
- pluma 11y agoIt's 2015 and I'm happy I finally have clients that let me set the baseline of Internet Explorer support to IE 8. Not long ago I still had to support IE 6. I have no idea how American start ups can get away with demanding users live on the bleeding edge but apparently cultures can be very different.
- mschuster91 11y ago> I have no idea how American start ups can get away with demanding users live on the bleeding edge but apparently cultures can be very different. Most of the startups have private customers, not corporate!
- timonv 11y agoIt's not a single country. There's different ideas, ideologies and beliefs all around. Conservative Dutch versus conservative Italian is quite different. > 2. European money appears to be more dominated by old money / aristocracy and that these people like to invest within that network. Engineers are less likely to be part of the aristocracy and are treated more like commodities than the enabling superstar athletes they are (at least the kind that make unicorns). I know quite a few engineers that make over $200k in SV but only one who makes over 100k GBP. At least here in the Netherlands that seems to be pretty common. Generally, investors are more conservative, and rarely take major risk. Salaries are also just slightly above working for a consultancy, but not always.
- dang 11y agoSince there's much evidence we're not the only ones here who cringe at this use of "unicorns", we replaced it with "successful startups" in the title. If anyone thinks of a better substitution, we can change it again. (Edit: we changed it again.)
- harperlee 11y agoBut OP makes an interesting case for it in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10220546 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10220546 : this is more specific than "successful startups". Perhaps we should coin a new term in HN. Something with cosmic rays in it might be appropriate.
- dang 11y agoOk, we replaced "successful" with "$1B". I forgot that we'd used that in the past.
- waterlesscloud 11y agoRegardless of how it makes anyone "cringe", unicorn is a jargon term with a common understanding and that is in growing usage. It also carries a subtextual reminder of just how rare $1B startups are. No substitution does this. It's just jargon with a useful subtext. There's absolutely no need whatsoever to cringe, and even less to censor the word from titles.
- oldmanjay 11y agoIf you develop a culture of risk-averse comfort that you feel needs legal barriers to protect, you can't be surprised that you have a population addicted to risk-averse comfort.
- Scarblac 11y agoYou say that as it risk-averse comfort is a bad thing. I'd much rather have comfort than a unicorn that happened to start in my country.
- vonnik 11y agoNot sure that the premise of this article is even correct. I can think of a lot of successful European startups -- Minecraft, Spotify, Skype, DeepMind, the list goes on... -- and just as many startups led by Europeans that have succeeded in America (Lending Club, etc.). But if Europe has trouble supporting "unicorns", there are probably a couple reasons: 1) Gaps in the funding ladder. 2) Talent flight. 3) A preference for regulation. 4) Countries, like France, that combine technological conservativism with social rigidity.
- stretchwithme 11y agoIts number two, the ability to move to somewhere where you can keep more of what you create.
- briandear 11y agoWhy is this downvoted? It is exceptionally valid. Starting a company in France subjects you to almost punitive labor laws, horrible taxes and regulation about almost very aspect of your business. Even doing something as simple as buying a rental property and leasing it out in France is loaded with difficulty. For example, an eviction can take years. Leases are standard for three years with the tenant being able to exit the lease with one month notice with no penalty. Capital gains taxes discourage the free movement of capital. If I want to sell a building and invest the proceeds, I am hit with an insane tax which provides a huge disincentive to moving capital from fixed assets to potentially more risky but higher return startup investments. France shuts down during August. I was in mid deal with some equity investors in July and pretty much the entire process was suspended until now. The French are also in love with paper. To get business class internet in a residence requires me actually registering and forming a French company. In the U.S., I can call any provider and with days have whatever services I want without having to "prove" I have a business 'need.' I certainly can't speak for all of the EU, but France is high on the list as a difficult place to get anything done quickly. In the UK, even opening a business bank account for a non-UK resident with a UK registered company is literally impossible. They are so paranoid over money laundering that essentially the banking industry is not accessible to anyone who wants to do business in the UK but isn't a resident. The regulatory environment in the EU is harsh. Investors are not necessarily risk adverse but they do have to be much more deliberate because every transaction is regulated and thus incurs a cost or a tax. For example, to buy any property in France, you have to pay a Notaire 8% of the purchase price just to legalize the sale. This is exclusive of normal agent commissions and closing costs. Imagine adding 8% to every asset sale on top of VAT of 20%. You're looking at a transaction cost of 28% to just pay the government! There is no such thing as a 1031 exchange either. Taxes and regulation is the surest way to crush innovation. Combining that with the violence-filled reaction to Uber, the hysterical response to AirBnB and the obsession with physical paper and it's no wonder that France is a horrible startup environment. Also, let's not forget the billion+ dollar exit for Daily Motion that was blocked by the French government. If if you were to build a unicorn you wouldn't be able to do anything with it except maybe cut it up and cook it in a sous vide: provided it wasn't imported from Spain or Poland in which case the farmers would drive tractors into Paris and set piles of shit on fire in protest. I am not making a judgement on is European Socialism a good thing or not; I am merely stating reasons that it is difficult to expect high returns in such an environment.
- robk 11y agoThose lists are often incomplete sadly because the actual underlying data on startups is much worse here in Europe. For whatever reason people don't submit data to places like Crunchbase and the media channels here are far less consistent covering things, particularly outside the English-speaking domain. My partner has been compiling his own list here. Feel free to edit. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/u/1/d/1cWhizlf_KU7KOsw8RamL4jaQ7uCHLDbyvsjBmEsTDzA/edit?usp=drive_web https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/u/1/d/1cWhizlf_KU7KOsw8...
- ThomPete 11y agoThanks for the list!
- bitL 11y agoThere is no Delaware. Taxes are paid regardless of whether the company hits $1M revenue or not, salary taxes are high, health/social insurance is mandatory and paid for the most part by the employer, there is a minimal salary, extensive bureaucracy and you can't sign away most of your rights if necessary for company survival. Moreover, some countries impose rules which make starting up with little to no money impossible (Germany).
- robk 11y agoPlenty of companies can incorporate offshore though. That's probably easier than in the US.
- briandear 11y agoYou could incorporate offshore but good luck getting a local bank account or even an offshore one. To do anything in France you have to be incorporated in France and pay French taxes.
- s73v3r 11y ago"and you can't sign away most of your rights if necessary for company survival. " I don't believe for a second that someone signing away their rights is necessary for company survival. Maybe you as a company leader need to do a better job so you don't come to that point, and if you have, then maybe you aren't fit to run a company.
- paulsutter 11y agoExits are the key to a successful startup ecosystem. Scarce exits at low valuations means scarce venture capital, and less enthusiasm among potential employees and even founders. Silicon Valley is dense with natural acquirers. China has a market for exits. Other aspiring startups hubs around the world just do not. I realized this from spending time in Tokyo and Singapore. People commonly think "everything would be different if we just had a few more VCs", or some such. But really, it's not complicated. Investors want exits, and when they dream, they dream of big exits. They're not in the business to lend a helping hand, or reward the deserving.
- OJFord 11y ago> The third reason I hear is that the US market is bigger and therefore it’s easier to get traction. > Yet there are 503 million Europeans living inside the EU vs. 319 million US living in the US. That's a really dodgy reason to discount the "third reason". Britons are not to Belgians what New Yorkers are to Californians!
- mizchief2 11y agoToo much regulation and not enough testicular fortitude.
- OJFord 11y agoI certainly agree that "Europe has no Silicon Valley", but I'm not so sure about "or New York". What part of "the full stack entrepreneurial ecosystem and access to funding" does London lack that New York has? (Genuine question - I don't know NY well)
- raverbashing 11y agoOr you know: Paris, Amsterdam, Berlin.
- ThomPete 11y agoI was trying to explain that. New York and SV have been accumulating talent, knowledge about the US in general, lobbyism, transfer of knowledge and so on. London have a lot of that but it's doesn't have enough to counter the power of the political system of the EU.
- laurencerowe 11y agoIn terms of tech activity, London is much closer to New York than New York is to Silicon Valley. Their dominant industry is finance not tech. By number of 'unicorns': 69 Silicon Valley 16 New York City 10 London 9 Beijing 8 Boston http://tech.co/top-global-startup-scenes-vc-firm-2015-08 http://tech.co/top-global-startup-scenes-vc-firm-2015-08
- jamisteven 11y agoBecause they understand the definition of the word "Bubble"
- csomar 11y agoThe third reason I hear is that the US market is bigger and therefore it’s easier to get traction. Yet there are 503 million Europeans living inside the EU vs. 319 million US living in the US. If the size of the market was any indication of how many unicorns a market could create, Europe would be in the lead. So size of the market alone isn’t an explanation either at least not by comparing the numbers. I really don't find the EU market to be bigger than the USA market. The US already has tech giants that no other country has (China is starting to have some). So if we are starting from here, the US market is much bigger since it's usually these big/giant companies that drive the VC/Startup market. The tech industry in the US took the lead. Why? It's complicated to tell. Countries emerge from poverty to richness but there is little correlation how that happens. And if we know how it works, shouldn't we be all rich now?
- jon-wood 11y agoThose 503 million Europeans are spread across 50+ different countries with widely varying laws and customs, and speak dozens of languages. To consider them a single coherent market doesn't make any sense.
- fsloth 11y agoLots of the modern giants like Google are based on software and computers. Computing, electronics and semiconductors benefitted from being heavily invested in by the US government long before commodization of the technologies took place in the form of military applications and the like. Cultural and technological headstart in computing is one good explanation. Most of Europe was in ruins after 1940:s, whereas the USA emerged from the war mostly unscathed and with a freshly mobilized manufacturing industry.
- fleshshelf 11y ago6 unicorns out of Sweden since 2000 alone. The problem to me seems we don't seem to have the ability to sustain Google/Facebook sized companies.
- raverbashing 11y agoOn that subject, how many Unicorns Canada has?
- briandear 11y agoCanada only has about 15 people though.
- yxhuvud 11y agoIt is not as if Sweden has more.
- throwaway859876 11y agoPrehistoric times: Nortel, Mitel, Corel, RIM Recent times: possibly Shopify, one other moved to USA Most money in Canada is controlled by civil pension funds, who don't like smallish investments for big risks. Thus a large percentage of software engineers move to USA, and are active in Silicon Valley.
- aianus 11y agoBlackberry, until recently. Canada suffers from dutch disease; it's simply too easy and profitable to dig stuff up (oil, diamonds, gold, potash, etc.) instead of producing value through software or technology.
- e5india 11y agoThere are a couple things missing from this article that really need to be fleshed out: 1. You're comparing the unicorns which is like comparing the top of the pyramid without measuring the base. In other words, where are the figures for seed-round startups? What is the amount of capital available to startups at the different stages in the business life cycle? Without those numbers we can't really tell if this is a matter of investors in the EU being less efficient in their investments or if its simply a matter of scale. 2. The other mistake that people I think when making this comparison is in comparing the success of the US market compared to Europe as a whole. First of all, you have to keep in mind that much of the success in the tech sector is highly localized. Now obviously the definition of 'tech sector' can vary wildly but generally when we talk about The Tech Sector we mean Silicon Valley. Almost every other state not named California has tried to replicate Silicon Valley and met with the same lack of success you're speaking about here. The major two exceptions are New York and Texas in that order. The rest of the American States see the same kind of out migration of tech chasing money that the essay sees among foreign tech entrepreneurs. 3. Expanding on the above: on a national level we don't care if the tech sector concentrates in California or Texas or wherever as long as it is in the US. The EU might refer to itself as a union, but are the French willing to invest in a tech sector centralized in Romania for the benefit of a Europe as a whole? Not likely. Silicon Valley, as much as we celebrate the free market aspect of it's success, also benefited from massive federal government spending in that region that played a huge rule in establishing its tech ecosystem back in the 50s and 60s. edit: I've been editing for grammar.
- humanrebar 11y ago> we don't care if the tech sector concentrates in California or Texas or wherever as long as it is in the US Hmmm... I'm not sure that's true. For some definition of "we", it would be tautologically true, I guess. Many states complain about paying more in taxes than they get back in spending. California, Texas, and New York all pay more in taxes than they get back in spending, though Delaware takes the biggest hit, per capita: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_taxation_and_spending_by_state#Tables_of_federal_taxation_and_spending_by_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_taxation_and_spending_...
- SneakerXZ 11y agoIt is quite easy question actually. In short, US is unified market with one language, laws for business are same across all states, one currency, one culture, low taxes, no social system and a lot of money. In EU you have 28 countries, 24 languages which equals to same amount of cultures. 11 currencies. Every country got own laws so once you make business across many countries, you have taxation and law hell. EU tries to improve it so it is getting better but it is still very bad. You basically need a lawyer and a translator for every country where you operate. We have quite big taxes, social system and health system. All these needs to be payed for every employee and it increases the operation cost. The country that I am from, we had better search engine than Google before Google, we had Uber before Uber and many other. Unfortunately they didn't expand because of problems I mentioned and nobody gave investment that would overcome all these problems. At the end when big name comes to our market they just buy established local competitor and rename it. Also Silicon Valley is a bubble. In Europe we never heard about most of startups from there and we have local competitors that are established here and do basically same things.
- ThomPete 11y agoEurope has more Fortune 500 companies on than the US according to what I am linking. If it was just a matter of language then how come they USED to be able to create global players but aren't able to as much any more. Whats changed thats holding Europe back?
- egwor 11y agoAccording to the fortune web site, the fortunate 500 only covers companies that "are incorporated and operate in the US." I think it was probably cheaper and easier to do this in the past, but now regulatory and tax reasons make it more difficult and more expensive. > Companies are ranked by total revenues for their respective fiscal years. Included in the survey are companies that are incorporated in the U.S. and operate in the U.S. and file financial statements with a government agency. This includes private companies and cooperatives that file a 10-K or a comparable financial statement with a government agency, and mutual insurance companies that file with state regulators. It also includes companies that file with a government agency but are owned by private companies, domestic or foreign, that do not file such financial statements. Excluded are private companies not filing with a government agency; companies incorporated outside the U.S.; and U.S. companies consolidated by other companies, domestic or foreign, that file with a government agency. Also excluded are companies that failed to report full financial statements for at least three quarters of the current fiscal year. Percent change calculations for revenue, net income, and earnings per share are based on data as originally reported. They are not restated for mergers, acquisitions, or accounting changes. The only changes to the prior years' data are for significant restatement due to reporting errors that require a company to file an amended 10-K.
- allendoerfer 11y agoAside from the obvious fact, that you cannot compare 500 million Europeans that speak plenty of different languages to 300 million US Americans (have you been to Eastern Europe?), it is because the PC, the internet etc. were invented in the US, thus SV was formed and the start-ups there still reap the benefits (exit opportunities, investors, etc).
- KaiserPro 11y agoBecause investors in Europe are less optimistic. Why would I invest a lot of money in a company that for it to succeed will have to burn through anywhere between $10-$250 million, before they even think about breaking even? even as a seed fund, the rate of attrition is genuinely terrible. The only way unicorn can survive is to bend reality long enough so that people are willing to gamble on the pyramid scheme that is behind all non profit making pre-IPO startups. Think about it. Uber is only in the position it is because it keeps on taking funding. That funding is used to A) expand at a massive loss B) Inflate the current valuation C) pay off previous investors. If uber were for what ever reason not able to raise any more capital, they would literally collapse over night. They are unable to make a profit without making massive structural changes, changes not scheduled for years. Yes they have cash reserves, but they'll be convertible if some investors need them. More importantly, if an investor decides to sell for a lowerprice, the only thing that makes Uber Uber, its valuation will disappear. Let me be very clear, There is nothing special about uber. Unlike netflix, amazon, or facebook which either have unique content, or many thousands of hours of personal content, Uber is just a service which can be swapped out at will. It is just a taxi service, one that is cheap because its being subsidised by not paying health care, and the many investors. It is the very embodyment of the south sea bubble.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- aianus 11y agoI highly disagree. Uber is like Amazon; it could stop expanding and investing tomorrow and immediately start turning a huge profit. They charge 10% of all taxi rides with a marginal cost of maintaining some server software and a mobile app. No cars, no human dispatchers, no medallions, no nothing. It's a great business.
- ThomPete 11y agoJust not for the uber drivers exactly because there is no medalions :)
- verybitter92 11y agoWhy is there no Silicon Valley of Europe? Because programmers and other IT professionals are paid laughably low wages and shown even less respect than they are in the US. It's a similar situation in Japan and Australia. Yet whenever politicians talk about the need for startups to compete with Silicon Valley, you never hear them say a word about the insultingly low wages that are the norm in Germany, France, UK, Belgium, and others. Want to create a Silicon Valley of Europe? Then pay Silicon Valley wages, you cheap bastards! The Irrlicht guy wrote about this: http://www.irrlicht3d.org/pivot/entry.php?id=1295 http://www.irrlicht3d.org/pivot/entry.php?id=1295
- gaius 11y agoAnd some laws against offshoring and "business visas".
- verybitter92 11y agoWhy was I downvoted? Everything I said is the truth. Why would someone want to be a programmer in Europe when the pay and respect is so bad, and with what money can a programmer be expected to start a startup when they're only being paid a €3000 a month salary?
- mschuster91 11y agoUpvoted you, I agree. Also, for the non-Germans, take-home cash (after taxes and mandatory medical insurance), depending on your tax class, may be as low as 1.800€ from said 3.000€.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- PythonicAlpha 11y agoIn my opinion, the EU has failed (still) to be an open big market, where companies can grow without restrictions. One current big example are the new VAT rules in the EU for non-physical products. They just do the opposite, what a free market should be. There are already companies that say on their website, that they will sell to their own countries people and happily even to people outside of the EU, but not to people living in other EU countries. The total opposite what the EU once should be. The new VAT rules also should limit the possibilities of big companies like Amazon to circumvent VAT. In reality it become a big stumble block for smaller companies. The EU is a big market, with many, many rules. To many rules and to few thoughts on the effects particularly for smaller companies. (instead, the big corporations are effectively writing the rules) When smaller companies do not get the chance to come up (what is happening) than the chances for Unicorns are also greatly limited. Instead the same big players are winning again and again and are doing the same dinosaur stuff again and again.
- pvaldes 11y agoVAT has become a big problem for commerce, yes.
- PythonicAlpha 11y agoIt's not about VAT, but about the new VAT rules in the EU particularly for non-physical goods. The problem is not the VAT amount, but that small companies potentially have to deal with all the finance offices (and special rulings) of all EU countries. That is ridiculous!
- pvaldes 11y agoVAT is a problem for a small company because you have two works and one of them (tax recolector) is unpaid and eat lots of hours that you'll need to blow some life in your startup. If your client is a big company they can blackmail you to have a "VAT discount". If you want to do business with them, you'll need either to eat their VAT with a percentage of your expected benefits, or you are obliged to cheat to survive. You end figthing with your clients for paying the damned VAT. Always. With each one. If you take in mind all the lost work hours, angry clients and nuissances that causes to everybody it is clear that is worthless and hurts the economy, but the problem is that VAT is like cocaine for the government. Is wonderful and they always want more. With VAT you can bill taxes to children and to elders for the privilege of buying something in your city but you are not obliged to provide them with a future pension, or any other service instead. And like any other drug, you raise and raise the doses until finally all collapses. You want to raise VAT and bill 21% for a book or a film? Not problem, people can survive without going to cinema or buying a book. Now you have a 21% of 5 tickets, instead a 4% of 500 tickets and so.
- highCs 11y agoMany EU countries got startups during the mass consumption revolution. US however is the only country to have not missed the micro revolution. US got micro startups in 1975, 1983, 1995 and so on. Hard to beat 40 years later as no one has experience nor tech money. Its not that we dont have hackers in EU, its that we dont have Paul Graham. I dont think this - tech experience and tech money - is easily relocatable as it is stated in the article.
- cm2187 11y agoIn a couple of years, when this tech bubble have burst we will laugh at this kind of headlines
- wellboy 11y agoSpeaking for Germany, which is probably the "best" country after the UK, here are a few reasons 1. Almost no investors who have built a tech-company before 2. Investors are very risk averse and want business models that monetize from day 1, because that's what a business is and those are good German values. This way, there is a strong incentivization by investors of e-commerce businesses and strong disincentivization of startups that want to build a great product first and focusing on scale. 3. In the same vein, investors simply don't know the idea of growing first and delaying monetization, which is what made the majority of "unicorns" possible. This is because there are no German examples for that, so they could not experience it themselves and German investors don't know or don't care about what happens in the U.S. 4. Fundraising takes double the amount of time here at half the valuation. I have seen 3 companies of close friends shut down after having raised Series A, because of exactly this. 5. Because of all that, there is little courage or idealism of the generation of first-time German entrepreneurs left. We have enough talent, there is just not the mindset baked into our ecosystem what makes the U.S. so successful. That's why most founders have to revert to building copycat e-commerce shop, but very few of the founders (maybe 3% of those that I have met) have the goal and the idealism to build something new that can really improve our world. However, that's why there is a big opportunity to take the market of early stage seed investments that is focused on high risk bets only. If you want to do it really well, you announce that e-commerce ideas are not allowed.
- digi_owl 11y agoThe impression i have is that European (if there is such a singular entity) tech development is more oriented towards system wide efficiencies and disability assistance than producing the next stock market rocket.
- tschellenbach 11y ago1.) Lack of seed stage investors 2.) Lack of exit scenarios and later stage investors. This makes seed stage investing less attractive. 3.) Few experienced engineers, designers etc. There is plenty of talent, but it's hard to build up experience without successful startups. 4.) Part of the talent leaves Europe 5.) A vicious circle of those factors
- petercooper 11y agoCombine lots of languages with lots of regulatory areas and you end up with numerous smaller communities. Add this to Metcalfe's Law and you have disproportionately smaller opportunities for company size when social effects are important (as they are to most Internet-based unicorns, though not to companies Europe does do well at - like car companies and manufacturing, say). Mathematically, say one network with size 100 has opportunity of 10,000. Ten networks of 10 have opportunity of 100 each - totaling a far lower 1,000. Note how several of the top "unicorns" are from China (Xiaomi, Lufax, Didi Kuaidi, DJI, Zhong An, Dianping) or India (Flipkart, Snapdeal) - other countries with (mostly) unified languages (formally, if not in practice) and vast middle class populations (due to their overall gigantic populations). Other unicorns outside of big territories are Atlassian and Spotify - but they're valued so highly because they work in the US market almost as if they were US companies.
- ThomPete 11y agoYes but historically Europe have had much more success with creating large companies so the question is what changed? Historically the EU used to be much more divided which is exactly why the harmonization process seems to have such a paradoxial result.
- petercooper 11y agoI might be wrong but I think it's because the sorts of companies that become "unicorns" nowadays are more dependent on cultural, language or social network aspects (Snapchat, Facebook, Airbnb, Pinterest) than manufacturing, drug, or oil companies ever were (all areas Europe has excelled in). If biotech or robotics ever take off in a huge bubbly way, I imagine we'll see a much larger of Europe unicorns coming to the table as those areas play to European strengths again.
- ThomPete 11y agoI think that is a great point. So is it that because of the market in the US it's easier to establish enough momentum what when you move into Europe you have the power to establish yourself there despite the different languages?
- mapgrep 11y agoI have trouble accepting any of the conclusions in this piece when it has significant factual errors or at least false implications. Here are some of the EU rules listed in an apparent attempt to show Europe has more onerous regulations than the U.S.: >There are rules for the curve of the cucumber to the bendiness of bananas. This hasn't been the case since 2008. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/12/world/europe/12iht-food.4.17771299.html http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/12/world/europe/12iht-food.4.... Also, according to the U.S. Congressional Research Service, "U.S. imports of some fresh fruits and vegetables also are subject to federal marketing orders that... create mandatory grade, size, quality and maturity requirements that apply to domestic and imported products." https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/RL34468.pdf https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/RL34468.pdf Just to take one example, here is one document where the USDA regulates potatoes for their air cracks, bruises, dirt, enlarged lenticels, external discoloration, flea beetle injury, sunburn, and growth cracks, among many other things. http://www.mipotato.com/CMDocs/MPIC/usda%20grade%20standards.pdf http://www.mipotato.com/CMDocs/MPIC/usda%20grade%20standards... >Recently large vacuum cleaners and incandescent light bulbs were banned. The EU has not banned incandescent light bulbs but is phasing out many types of incandescents. As it happens, so is the U.S. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phase-out_of_incandescent_light_bulbs#European_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phase-out_of_incandescent_ligh... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Lighting_Energy_Policy#Incandescent_phase-out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Lighting_Energy_Policy#In... Here is a recent map of all the nations in the world phasing out such bulbs. Notice the U.S. and EU are listed at the same level of prohibition: http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/plugged-in/the-overly-dramatic-demise-of-the-light-bulb/ http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/plugged-in/the-overly-dr... >Recently the EU was looking into banning cinnamon used in cinnamon rolls because of a too high amount of coumarin, known to be causing liver damage if consumed too extensively. Wildly incorrect, although there have been some misleading headlines so perhaps forgivable. What happened is that the Danish authorities ruled that a type of cinnamon swirl ("kanelsnegle") was not a specially exempt traditional or seasonal food. This meant it was subject to EU recommended daily limits on the ratio of coumarin per kg of dough. The Danish Food Administration had done a survey and found half of the nation's fine baked goods were probably over the line. Cue hysteria about the beloved rolls being banned (never mind that bakers could just cut back on coumarin, for example by changing quantity or type of cinnamon). Anyway what ended up happening is that the rolls were reclassified as a traditional national treat and thus exempt from the recommended limits. http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2013/12/25/256602581/when-is-cinnamon-spice-not-so-nice-the-great-danish-debate http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2013/12/25/256602581/whe... http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/dec/20/cinnamon-intake-food-argument-denmark http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/dec/20/cinnamon-intake... http://www.eubusiness.com/news-eu/denmark-food.wo7 http://www.eubusiness.com/news-eu/denmark-food.wo7 FWIW the FDA regulates how much yeast, citric acid, Sarsaparilla, Sassafras, tallow, green walnuts, unmodified starch, and vanilla can go into foods, among many other ingredients. (see http://www.fda.gov/Food/IngredientsPackagingLabeling/FoodAdditivesIngredients/ucm091048.htm http://www.fda.gov/Food/IngredientsPackagingLabeling/FoodAdd...)
- xacaxulu 11y agoI think comparing cities against cities might be a more apt comparison, especially normalized for available investment amounts, population, etc. Remember that a number of US states rival single European nations in GDP, population, physical size, etc. I'd rather talk about Berlin vs Austin, London vs Manhattan, Paris vs Boston. Second, is '# of $1B startups' even an important metric? Just like some employees prefer Europe for worker protections, smaller work weeks, paid maternity leave, healthcare unattached to employment status, etc, so some startups might find that their success has more to do with the markets they find themselves operating in and serving, rather than total income.
- tsotha 11y agoThere's a huge network effect in startups. Once the financing structure, the management skills, and technical know-how are in a place, companies start (or move) there, which in turn brings in even more skilled work force and VCs. How many articles have we seen about governments trying to create The Next Silicon Valley and failing after dropping loads of cash? And over the short run the talent picture is a zero sum game - Europeans who moved to SF to start their company are potential founders Europe doesn't have any more. Also, don't underestimate the draw of US universities. We get people from all over the world coming to the US for their graduate degrees and many of them stay.
- icc97 11y agoThe University system certainly has something to do with it. Compare the startups from those who've graduated at Stanford/Harvard [1] with Cambridge [2] [1]: http://minimaxir.com/2013/07/alma-mater-data/ http://minimaxir.com/2013/07/alma-mater-data/ [2]: http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/dec/01/cambridge-university-internet-tech-startup http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/dec/01/cambridge-...
- brooklyndavs 11y agoI think asking this question without addressing the overall cost/benefit to society is not very productive. The overall goal, I think, is to allow startups to grow and thrive while at the same time being a net plus for society. I would argue that "ask for permission later" mentality of some US based startups is a net minus to society overall. While I don't have any love for the taxi industry the regulations around cars for hire were put in place for consumer protection. These are some of the same regulations Uber is currently trying to get around (surge pricing in particular). Similarly, while I don't have any love for the hotel industry the regulations around short term housing exist to allow ample housing supply for long term residents of that city. While inconvenient for the entrepreneur/investor/1%class most regulations exist for the common good of society. If a startup can prove that the regulation is outdated and doesn't make sense in the context of a new technology they should be able to convince the regulators that the regulation needs to be adjusted.
- ThomPete 11y agoI don't disagree with a word you are saying but I don't think I was implying that you shouldn't do cost benefit. It just wasn't what the article was trying to explore. I am saying both in the beginning and the end that I am not even sure it make sense to focus on unicorns for Europe. But given it's importance on many things after all I wanted to understand why Europe didn't have more than they do.
- unabst 11y agoIf these valuations are based on funding rounds, then aren't they the direct consequence of VC funding and VC math? If this is the case, then More VCs should equal More Unicorns, because they are the one's creating them. If EU vs US VC funding is about 1:8, then the ratio correlates with the output of unicorns. If is even less, then that would imply EU actually may be outperforming the US in unicorn output per VC head. As it turns out, the EU numbers are booming this year, so it's tough to compare, but the numbers do seem to back this somewhat [0] [1]. -- [0] http://blogs.wsj.com/briefly/2015/04/27/european-vc-investment-in-q1-2015-the-numbers/ http://blogs.wsj.com/briefly/2015/04/27/european-vc-investme... [1] https://www.cbinsights.com/research-venture-capital-q1-2015 https://www.cbinsights.com/research-venture-capital-q1-2015
- thetruthseeker1 11y agoIndia has 7, 1 less than Europe, that is very interesting from many accounts. GDP of Europe ~20 Trillion $. GDP of India is 2 Trillion $ - I wish there were more studies like this, but not just at the billion $ evaluation, but say 100 million $ evaluation, I think reaching the mark of 1 B$ also requires significant amount of luck(in addition to great execution), a smaller number like 100 M$ may be a more consistent measure
- loourr 11y agoBecause they're further downstream from where all the money is being printed.
- erdevs 11y agoWe need a new term for "unicorn" ... "Paper unicorn", perhaps. A better comparison would remove the confounding variable of valuation. Instead, it'd be interesting to look at start-ups in each region with >$200M in annual recognized revenue. Valuations fluctuate based on investor sentiment and market conditions. Revenue is more fundamental.
- dschiptsov 11y agoThe same reason as why almost all the activity is on the Everest and there are orders of magnitude less expeditions on K2 and almost 0 on Kanchendzunga. Because it requires Silicon Valley (the Everest region) and US-style financial institutions (free money) and bankruptcy protection laws.
- trgn 11y agoI'll speak for Flanders, where I've lived. I presume it's not unlike some other large metropolitan mega-regions in Europe. Something that may contribute is that life is fairly predictable in Europe, and by many accounts prosperous. This may sedate the entrepreneurial spirit. Selling your labor to make a living is an entirely respectable choice. A comfortable life all the way to the end is more or less guaranteed. Labor protections are much more generous as well. In the US, starting a company is partly an attempt to escape wage slavery and toxic work environments. Somewhat exaggerated perhaps, but in the USA, the entrepreneur is celebrated while the salaried employee is pitied. (Unless when it's election season and all suitors crow about jerbs, jerbs, jerbs). There is also an enormously amount of stored wealth in the existing infrastructure and built environment, much of it owned by families or collectively, and people enjoy continued long term robust family relations and social support structures nearby, cradle to grave. Generations of prosperity and fairly modest lifestyles see to that. This is lost to many Americans, when comparing snapshot measures like average yearly income or per capita GDP. But wealth - the measurable money kind and immeasurable chicken-soup-for-the-soul-kind is accumulated over time and regions like Flanders are positively rich with both. America - somewhat a cliche - MUST be sustained by growth, because the recurring costs of the necessities are so high. The built environment in America is basically a gigantic liability, only supported by a promise of future revenue. And the constant geographical movement of labor breaks apart families and existing support structures, constantly in need to be reconstructed. In this context, the promise of a fat payout after an IPO is a soothing balm.
- dayone 11y agoi have been to europe. trust me, the so-called stars of european tech community are definitely overhyped. Not only do they solve much smaller problems, their beliefs and thoughts are really small too. The engineers they attract are very average not rockstars at all.
- tim333 11y agoRecent take from Reid Hoffman: >Many parts of the world now have the necessary ingredients to create start-ups. There are brilliant technical graduates everywhere. Venture capital has gone global. >Why does Silicon Valley continue to produce a disproportionate share of industry-transforming companies like Google, Facebook and LinkedIn? Or the next generation of companies like Airbnb, Dropbox, and Uber? The answer, which has been hiding in plain sight, is Silicon Valley’s ability to support scale-ups. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/39001312-4836-11e5-af2f-4d6e0e5eda22.html#axzz3lZpkJz9X http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/39001312-4836-11e5-af2f-4d6e0e5eda...
- tim333 11y agoInterestingly Stockholm does almost as well as Silicon Valley >on a per-capita basis, Stockholm is the second most prolific tech hub globally, with 6.3 billion-dollar companies per million people compared to Silicon Valley with 6.9 http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/e3c15066-cd77-11e4-9144-00144feab7de.html http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/e3c15066-cd77-11e4-9144-00144feab7...
- known 11y agoYou need Cash/Caste to succeed as an Entrepreneur in India; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varna_in_Hinduism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varna_in_Hinduism