7 ms·
Porsche is showing off an electric sports car
- onion2k 11y agoPorsche expect it to be a production car within 5 years. So this shouldn't be compared with Tesla's current offering. This is going to have to compete with the products Tesla are making in ~5 years time. Statements like "It charges in 15 minutes, faster than Tesla's superchargers" are effectively meaningless unless Tesla make absolutely no improvements to their charging technology over the next half decade. I think Tesla have the edge here.
- worldsayshi 11y agoYeah, comparing a concept car with what their competitor is currently selling to consumers is ludicrous.
- huhtenberg 11y agoIt would've been ludicrous if it were what they were actually doing. They are not comparing cars. They are comparing technologies.
- calinet6 11y agoTechnologies are not as relevant to the market until they're implemented in a product. The challenges in that task make technology demonstrations something of a sideshow alone.
- braythwayt 11y agoIf they are showing us vaporware that's five years away, their comparison is roughly equivalent to doing a grand reveal in 2020 and saying "Look how much better this is than the state of the art for 2015." Imagine Apple had revealed the iPhone in 2007... And compared it to a 2002 Nokia.
- dabeeeenster 11y agoThey can say anything they want right now - it's just a concept and not real. The proof of the pudding is what the feature set is when they ship. The same goes for the price. Tesla are at least 5 years ahead. What a total embarrassment from Porsche.
- penetrarthur 11y agoIt is not an embarrassment. The more companies start producing electric cars the better.
- lispm 11y agoProbably Porsche wants to stay the world's most profitable car company for a while. Tesla has a lot done for the market of electric vehicles, but they also need to make money.
- mtgx 11y agoNot to mention it shouldn't be compared to the Tesla Model S, which is a sedan not a sports car. Tesla has already announced it will release a new Roadster in four years [1]. So now that Porsche has already shown its cards, you can bet that the new Roadster will be better in every single way AND arrive earlier. We already know it will be significantly better in at least one way - the Maximum Plaid acceleration will probably give it a ~2.5s acceleration from 0-62 miles. And Porsche's increase in mileage 5 years from now compared to current top of the line Model S seems tiny as well, and my guess is the new top of the line Roadster will have at least 20-30% better mileage as well. [1] http://www.theverge.com/2015/7/17/8994649/new-tesla-roadster-four-years http://www.theverge.com/2015/7/17/8994649/new-tesla-roadster...
- threeseed 11y agoWell hopefully Tesla will improve on the interior quality and ergonomics of their car during the next 5 years. Because right now it is sad compared to a Hyundai. It is a downright joke compared to a Porsche. The Porsche is a premium luxury vehicle in which most of the drivers are rarely going to give a crap about 2.5s acceleration spec.
- brusch64 11y agoWell - that depends on the model. The cayenne is no sports car - thats for sure. But in Germany / Europe Porsches are used for racing. Here is an overview of the "official possibilities" http://www.porsche.com/porschesportscup-germany/en/series/ http://www.porsche.com/porschesportscup-germany/en/series/
- draugadrotten 11y ago> The Porsche is a premium luxury vehicle Totally agree. The Porsche outside my office window belongs to the CEO of the neighbour company. The Tesla belongs to the chairman of the board. They are both up in luxury territory because they are both really expensive cars. Tesla wants to fight BMW and possibly but less importantly Porsche - their interiors and build quality needs to match the price tag. No exceptions.
- SmellyGeekBoy 11y agoAh cool, we should have fusion power by then to charge it as well. ;)
- threeseed 11y ago> I think Tesla have the edge here. Perhaps not: http://appleinsider.com/articles/15/09/14/apples-project-titan-car-initiative-negatively-impacting-teslas-product-development-source-says http://appleinsider.com/articles/15/09/14/apples-project-tit... And also Tesla isn't exactly making a lot of money right now. And this is just selling in a handful of countries as opposed to Porsche which is selling in most of them.
- eps 11y agoOh, take off that "I love you, Elon" t-shirt, will you? It's ridiculous to assume that Porsche is talking about taking 5 years to productize today's tech. Their tech will evolve just as anyone's and a car that ships will be way different from what they showed today. What you are missing is that Porsche has batteries that charge in 15 min and power driving for 400 km. They can do it now and Tesla can't (or Musk would've demo'ed it already). That's direct and accurate apples to apples comparison, so, no, Tesla doesn't have an edge. Not here.
- 2muchcoffeeman 11y agoCan they do it? This doesn't look like even a prototype. Just a bunch of ideas and computer mock ups.
- huhtenberg 11y agoIt's certainly not a "bunch of ideas and computer mock ups". http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/motor-shows-frankfurt-motor-show/porsche-mission-e-electric-saloon-revealed-frankfurt http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/motor-shows-frankfurt-moto...
- scotty79 11y agoThen what is it? Actual working prototype with advertised parameters? What are concept cars? Do they need to actually drive at all? Or can you get away with design, idea an chassis physical mockup?
- forgetsusername 11y agoAnd yet people talk about a $30,000 Model 3 as if it exists. Or the battery swap system. Or autopilot. These are just ideas and concepts at this point. Why does Tesla get credit, but Porsche is ridiculed for them?
- jgalt212 11y agoWhat you say is very true, but we are talking about Porsche here, the maker of the 911. For that very reason, Tesla should keep their eyes on them and the buying public should take note whenever Porche's electric offering hits the market. The upshot is that Tesla will not have this market to themselves forever. So that's probably bad for TSLA shareholders and good for the low emission* car buying public. The gigafactory is probably a direct response to the their knowledge that they won't have the high performance electric car market to themselves forever. * assuming your electricity is not generate by a coal fired plant.
- baq 11y agoi wouldn't be surprised if this new porsche, when it goes into production, used batteries made in the gigafab.
- something123 11y agoUnless it uses some capacitor technology and the gigafactory is obsolete haha
- rogeryu 11y agoWe are not talking Porsche here, but VAG, so Audi, Skoda, Seat and VW as well. That means that this technology will soon find its way into their cheaper brands. Porsche means high marketing value. VW means high market value.
- ebbv 11y agoThe 15 minute charge time is based on an 800V charger. There's nothing magical here. Tesla (and the Nissan Leaf, and some other eVs) use a 400V charger which charges to 80% in 30 minutes. If you double the voltage, then cutting the charge time in half is what you'd expect. The thing that isn't mentioned here is that setting up a 400V charging station is already expensive. Tesla has taken up this expense themselves creating its SuperCharger (400V) network that all Tesla owners can use for free. I don't see anything in this article indicating Porsche is planning to do the same with 800V chargers. If they are that would be amazing, but I doubt it. Setting up 800V charging stations would be even more expensive than the 400V ones Tesla has invested heavily in. Honestly, the best thing VAG (VW Audi Group, who own Porsche) and all other EV manufacturers could do is put a Tesla SuperCharger port in their vehicles to allow for using the SuperCharger network.
- jfoster 11y agoWhat actually stops other auto manufacturers from putting a Tesla SuperCharger port on their vehicles? Does Tesla's port do any authentication?
- ebbv 11y agoConsidering Tesla has opened up their patent portfolio, I think they'd be able to put the physical port no problem. But licensing use of the SuperCharger network probably involves some kind of agreement with Tesla.
- jfoster 11y agoHence my question. If a manufacturer built the port, does Tesla have any mechanism (eg. vehicle authentication) for blocking gray-charging?
- adventured 11y agoPorsche can probably more easily afford to setup the 800V network than Tesla can its 400V network. They have a large, wholly self-sustaining business. Their operating profit of $3.x billion last year is comparable to Ford's operating profit.
- toddmorey 11y agoYeah, to me the big surprise was that this car isn't coming within the next two years. I don't think it should surprise anyone that Tesla would have a Model S challenger within 5 years. I thought for sure Tesla would have strong all-electric competition by next year at the latest.
- vjvj 11y agoThe Mission E can even "reflect the mood by displaying an emoticon in the dashboard". Porsche's PR/engineering team are losing the plot if they consider that a feature worth speaking about.
- HiYaBarbie 11y agoYeah, that was seriously weird. No one needs an emoticon to tell himself his own mood. It could be useful for surveillance purposes though..
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- coldpie 11y agoIt's a concept vehicle. They're always full of crazy, stupid crap that would make actually driving the vehicle awful.
- alexhawdon 11y agoI also thought that was a totally bizarre feature. The only use I can think of is collecting the data and using it to determine and suggest enjoyable routes. So the Sat Nav can suggest an alternative route that might be slower but is a lot more fun to drive.
- CamperBob2 11y agoCharging any EV in 15 minutes is going to be challenging in a residential area, I suspect. Imagine going out with a full charge and driving like a maniac with the goal of draining the charge completely in 15 minutes. How much energy did you turn into tire smoke during that 15-minute drive? That determines how much available power you'll need to charge that puppy back up in the same amount of time. 250 HP * 750 W/HP = about 50 kW for 15 minutes....? On a residential 220V circuit that'd require 225-amp service. The thermal losses will be massive. Once again, the only way this even remotely makes sense is to standardize the battery form factor and swap them.
- venomsnake 11y ago> Once again, the only way this even remotely makes sense is to standardize the battery form factor and swap them. But then how will the apple car be distinct and unrepairable. /joke. The battery standardization train is long gone. We missed the opportunity with consumer device Li-ion. And manufacturers now know that non replaceable battery is better for them, than for the consumers. Because you can bundle higher capacity batteries with only premium devices. If some big regulatory power like EU steps in as with the universal USB charge it will be possible. But I doubt it.
- VLM 11y agoAs long as they remain expensive and unpopular, electrical service simply won't be an issue. If you're buying a $150K sports car, dropping around $3K to upgrade to 400 amp service is pocket change. People who live in extreme rural areas or service needs to trench thru solid rock ($30/ft!) or live in extreme tax areas could pay a small multiple of that, but its such a small percentage it'll round down to nothing. Two problem areas are what if entire subdivisions go electric, distribution lines are going to need upgrading, and that will not be cheap. For that matter it trickles up all the way to the plant, shutting down gas refineries is going to mean installing lots of coal burning electrical plants... The other problem area is if electric cars drop to reasonable prices, the used market will suffer horribly in the early years if a couple years old electric sells used for $7K but it'll cost $3K to charge it. This will create a class distinction where rich people charge their cars in 15 minutes and poor people leave their cars plugged into standard extension cords overnight. Something to think about with swapping is its so dangerous WRT connector damage and immense weight that even trained industrial users generally don't do it on pallet jacks up to medium size forklifts. It seems to "work" as a technology up to push lawnmower size, no bigger. Also the cost of swapping is staggering, now the cars engineering is compromised by having removable batteries ($$$$) and obviously people need to own multiple batteries ($$$$$). It rapidly becomes a financial win to simply not drive more than 200 miles per day or to become a multi-car household.
- leyfa 11y agoThe original press release contains more information. It seems like they are already using the drive system in race cars right now. The “Porsche Turbo Charging” seems to require special charging stations though. http://newsroom.porsche.com/en/products/iaa-2015-porsche-mission-e-mobility-all-electrically-concept-car-11391.html http://newsroom.porsche.com/en/products/iaa-2015-porsche-mis...
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoDoes this actually exist, even as a one-off? It's a bit ambigous whether they're "unveiling" and "showing off" an actual car that you can sit in and drive, or just some pictures. If it's the latter, then this seems to be a very weak offering, vaporware FUD so lame that it actually makes the company putting it out seem worse than if they'd just kept quiet.
- josefresco 11y agoIt's a concept car - so it's a "one-off" and seeing as how it was at the IAA in Frankfurt, I'd say it actually exists. If you RTFA you'd have found this link: http://newsroom.porsche.com/en/products/iaa-2015-porsche-mission-e-mobility-all-electrically-concept-car-11391.html http://newsroom.porsche.com/en/products/iaa-2015-porsche-mis... Found an event pic on Twitter: https://twitter.com/PorscheNewsroom/status/643718735669391360 https://twitter.com/PorscheNewsroom/status/64371873566939136...
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoI did RTFA, and that link, before I asked as all the images look like obvious renders to me (with the possible exception of the interior shot). Apparently something physical does exist, given the Twitter pic, but it's still not clear if that's a dummy that needs to be rolled into position, or if it's a car you can actually drive. And whether it fulfils the various claims (15 minute charging combined with the claimed range seems something worth shouting about, even apart from the rest of the car)
- josefresco 11y agoPorsche doesn't f*ck around. It think the questions would be valid for a start-up, but not one of the largest auto manufacturers in the world. Porsche is also not a stranger to "electric" vehicles (see 918).
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoIt's enough of a stranger to fully electric cars to be announcing a concept car for 5 years out that hasn't been confirmed for production, that doesn't really seem to add anything new beyond emoticons and holographic eye-tracking dashboard controls. Given the apparent disruptive nature of this change to existing car companies that cling to their ICE engine technology as their reason for existing, I'd probably be more inclined to give the benefit of the doubt to some random new entrant created by a Chinese battery manufacturer or Netflix competitor who don't have such a big stake in the status quo.
- bane 11y agoThis is excellent news, it means that VW is testing the electric car waters. While Tesla has to trickle down all of its technology into wholly new cars, VW can trickle down consumer level stuff into electric VWs (and yes, I know about the e-golf but it only goes 83 miles on a charge and isn't even the blip the Nissan Leaf is).
- mzs 11y agoSorry air heads, it's water cooled: http://www.porscheengineering.com/filestore.aspx/Porsche-Engineering-Magazine-02-2014-Le-Mans-%E2%80%93-Battery-Development-for-the-919-Hybrid.pdf?pool=peg&type=download&id=pemagazin-02-2014-artikel-lemans-batterieentwicklungfuerden919hybrid&lang=en&filetype=default&version=3e549e9a-c26c-11e4-a19d-001a64c55f5c http://www.porscheengineering.com/filestore.aspx/Porsche-Eng... (seriously now though - nice document about the 919 hybrid)
- braythwayt 11y agoAn excellent essay about "concept" products, including (of course) cars: Why Apple doesn't do "Concept Products" http://counternotions.com/2008/08/12/concept-products/ http://counternotions.com/2008/08/12/concept-products/
- 6stringmerc 11y agoKidding here, but after a few hypercar Porsche 918s caught fire being refueled because somebody thought it'd be just fine to put the gas filler next to an exhaust port, I'd be interested to see how they deal with electricity.