4 ms·
It will be interesting to see if this pushes any traditional cab companies to become their own "mini Uber". i.e. sell all their medallions, get rid of all thei
by grecy 11y ago
It will be interesting to see if this pushes any traditional cab companies to become their own "mini Uber".
i.e. sell all their medallions, get rid of all their regulations and expense overhead, and just operate all their drivers like Uber operate theirs. At which point competing should be easy enough.
I think we're at a very interesting point in the Developed world - in the 80s, 90s and 00s everything about our society became more and more regulated and safety conscious (hotels, taxis, health care, education) meaning costs skyrocketed, and the cost of entry to compete in those markets became astronomical.
Now we're using technology to go back to way things used to be - less regulation, less rules, (arguably) less safety. Spend some time in the Developing world and you'll see their society still works like this - people will let you stay in their house for a few bucks a night (airbnb), people buy minivans then drive around picking people up for a fee (uber), etc. etc.
It's interesting we had to use technology to go back to the way things used to be in these areas.
I'm looking forward to seeing the uber/airbnb equivalent for education, healthcare, energy, etc.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> I'm looking forward to seeing the uber/airbnb equivalent for education, healthcare, energy, etc. The total disregard for laws and regulations? Exciting. Fingers crossed Uber burns up it VC money sooner than later. It's pretty terrible when people on HN pine for the days of less developed countries (no worker protections, no labor/safety regulations).
- grecy 11y ago> It's pretty terrible when people on HN pine for the days of less developed countries (no worker protections, no labor/safety regulations). The Developed World can not continue with it's standard of living, it's simply not sustainable. Something has to give. The way I see it, services like Uber and airbnb can slowly chip it down to something sustainable, or we can hold onto it until the bitter end when it all comes crashing down. Also, just because a job is offered with no worker protections, no labor/safety regulations etc, it doesn't mean a person has to take it. People vote through their actions.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- freehunter 11y agoAnd people are really bad at making decisions with long term repercussions. Take smoking, drinking, texting while driving, driving without a seatbelt, eating too much, sitting too much, spending all day staring at a computer screen, not sleeping enough, etc. Humans are short-term thinkers. So if you ask a poor person "would you rather protect your industry and reduce the risk to your health, or keep getting paid"... well look at all the people working in coal mines. They sacrifice their health, their neighbors health, their economy, and their planet just to have a paycheck. People vote with their actions. But people are short sighted, selfish, and greedy. That's why labor regulations and unions were invented. It's just been so long since the days before unions and regulations were created that everyone thinks they're useless. It's been so long since it rained that you start wondering why you have a roof over your house. You'll remember soon enough.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> The Developed World can not continue with it's standard of living, it's simply not sustainable. Something has to give. That's not true _at all_. How productive are self-driving cars going to be with no drivers? And electric powertrains? Very! Why would a government allow Uber to have a monopoly on that? They're government owned roads! You can entirely continue to provide a high quality of life to citizens of a developed country using automation and software. Shall we continue to socialize the losses and privatize the gains in society? Pardon me for being crass, but fuck that noise.
- minthd 11y agoBut still , that calls for something like UBER with democratic vote over it's decisions. And since most people will be consumers ,not employees of that service , the incentive towards how to manage it's drivers would be the same.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago
- minthd 11y ago>> no worker protections Worker protection should apply equally to everyone, not give preferential treatment to one group(taxi drivers) at the expense of most other groups who just have minimum wage laws and osha.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI'm referring to how Uber illegally classifies their workers as contractors. And I agree that worker protection should apply to everyone equally.
- matheweis 11y agoThey are losing that battle in a hurry... June: "In California, Uber driver is employee, not contractor: agency" http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/06/18/us-uber-california-idUSKBN0OX1TE20150618 http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/06/18/us-uber-california... Just yesterday: "Another Uber Driver in California Ruled an Employee, Not Contractor" http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2015/09/10/another-uber-driver-in-california-ruled-an-employee-not-contractor/ http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2015/09/10/another-uber-driver-i...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bradyd 11y agoThey are contractors, though. They own their vehicle and set their own hours. They can choose if they want to work that day or not. Uber is just a lead source to the driver. My neighbor drives a black car, legally licensed as a limo, and drives for Uber. Not all of his fairs come from Uber. He owns his own business, Uber is not his employer.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoGoverning bodies across the US continue to find Uber "contractors" to fit the parameters as employees.
- strickjb9 11y agoWork force disruption is an unfortunate side effect of technological disruption. If your solution is NOT to embrace change because you don't want to see disruption take place then that's not a long-term solution. Edit: I'd like to expand on this with a (not so) hypothetical. Autonomous cars are already here. How long until we have automated taxis? Let's just say 10 years. Would you make them illegal to keep the taxi workforce in place? There is disruption in virtually every workforce because of the Information Era. Our work force will have to adapt.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI don't think you understand my point. I'm not against technological disruption. When the shipping container revolutionized shipping 60 years ago, the shipping industry split the productivity gains with the longshoreman union to buy out those made redundant by said productivity gains. I'm inferring that the same will need to be done again. If technology obsoletes people, and they're unable to retrain, they'll be supported by social safety nets, funded by taxes on said technology.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- djrogers 11y ago(arguably) less safety. I don't even think this is arguable - there is literally nothing that owning a taxi medallion does to improve safety.
- Spooky23 11y agoThat's a ridiculous statement. The power to shut down a business gives a regulator a lot of power to do things like improve safety. In NYC, the Taxi and Limousine Commisson is a strong regulator the does a bunch of things to improve safety. Just because your city sucks and doesn't do it's job doesn't mean that the solution is to hope that Uber's army of independent contractors maintains their cars.
- SilasX 11y agoThe GP's point (under the most charitable interpretation) is that safety regulation is orthogonal to medallion limits. You can revoke someone's permission to drive for hire without also placing a limit on the total number of people who can drive for hire. Indeed, this is the typical model in Germany (IIRC): anyone who meets the standards and doesn't mess up can be a cab driver.
- djrogers 11y ago* The power to shut down a business gives a regulator a lot of power to do things like improve safety. * That can easily be done without the government provided monopoly of taxi medallions. Medallions (or any other form of monopoly granting) aren't required for regulation, enforcement, or any other aspect of keeping the public safe.
- Spooky23 11y agoSo, you don't think having 10x more cabs in midtown manhattan would cause potential safety problems? Taxis are a shitty business, no doubt, but replacing a government medallion with a corporate medallion isn't a solution. Uber has the valuation they have because after they kill off the competition, they'll limit the supply of rides and jack up the cost.
- SilasX 11y ago>It will be interesting to see if this pushes any traditional cab companies to become their own "mini Uber". >i.e. sell all their medallions, get rid of all their regulations and expense overhead, and just operate all their drivers like Uber operate theirs. At which point competing should be easy enough. There was a story on HN about a year ago, regarding an cab company owner doing exactly this, although the owner didn't have medallions to sell, he simply stopped renting them and paying associated fees. HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8134323 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8134323 My summary: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8134695 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8134695
- hackuser 11y ago> in the 80s, 90s and 00s everything about our society became more and more regulated and safety conscious (hotels, taxis, health care, education) meaning costs skyrocketed, and the cost of entry to compete in those markets became astronomical. Speaking generally, I think it's safe to say that this is the opposite of what happened. The hallmarks of Reagan's [1] and Thatcher's economic policies in the 1980s was massive deregulation (and privatisation). By the end of the decade it became the global norm for economic policy, a consensus generally accepted by even their left-wing successors, Clinton and Blair, by many others around the world, and became a key part of the "Washington Consensus",[2] which was a set of economic policies forced on poor countries who needed aid by Western governments and agencies (and accused often of coldly sacrificing the welfare of hundreds of millions of very poor people). As a more recent example, excessive deregulation of the financial industry, such as the repeal of Glass-Steagall act [3], is widely blamed as a signicant cause of the financial crisis of 2008. I'll add an interesting point: The period of perhaps greatest economic growth in the West, the 1950s and 60s, was the period of greatest government regulation and direct involvement in economies. Deregulation began in the 1980s and while economies have grown since then, wages for most Americans have been flat for 30 years. That proves nothing, but it suggests the evidence for the libertarian theory isn't so clear cut. (Personally I think regulation is not an ideology but a tool, good for some things and not for others.) [1] It actually began under Jimmy Carter, a little known fact. [2] http://www.cid.harvard.edu/cidtrade/issues/washington.html http://www.cid.harvard.edu/cidtrade/issues/washington.html [3] http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/wallstreet/weill/demise.html http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/wallstreet/wei...
- username3 11y agoPetrodollar starts in the 70s causing exponential inflation in the 80s.
- glenra 11y ago> The period of perhaps greatest economic growth in the West, the 1950s and 60s, was the period of greatest government regulation and direct involvement in economies. What calculation leads you to conclude there was more regulation in the 1950s and 1960s than today? My impression is that "deregulation" in practice largely amounted to at best a decline in the rate of increase in federal regulations, not an overall decrease in total regulation. Today there are vastly more federal rules and regulations and also substantially more government employees as a percentage of total employment than there was in the 1970s. Um, here's a plot of one proxy for new regulations - the size of the federal register in pages: http://politicalcalculations.blogspot.com/2012/07/the-regulation-of-american-people.html http://politicalcalculations.blogspot.com/2012/07/the-regula... There were several high-profile cases of actual deregulation (eg, regulations related to trucking and airline fares), but it amounted to pushing back the tide - the nature of government programs is to grow and most have continued to do so, occasional changes in fashionable rhetoric notwithstanding.