16 ms·
The Most Misread Poem in America
- RodericDay 11y agoI tend to love articles that tease a bit before revealing what they're about, but I found this one a bit overwrought. tl;dr: it's about Frost's "The Road Not Taken" (Two roads diverged in a wood, and I— / I took the one less traveled by, / And that has made all the difference). This article, at its clearest, says: > Certainly it’s wrong to say that “The Road Not Taken” is a straightforward and sentimental celebration of individualism: This interpretation is contradicted by the poem’s own lines. However, the thrust of the whole article is better captured by its soggy, everybody-wins non-conclusion: > The poem both is and isn’t about individualism, and it both is and isn’t about rationalization. It isn’t a wolf in sheep’s clothing so much as a wolf that is somehow also a sheep, or a sheep that is also a wolf
- jessriedel 11y ago> I tend to love articles that tease a bit before revealing what they're about Could you give me some insight about why you like this? It's one of my least favorite aspects of journalism. Most articles are bad, so don't you find that you waste more time sorting through chaff?
- lobo_tuerto 11y agoBecause of the thrill of it? I think is the same as to why people like suspense movies.
- RodericDay 11y agohmmm I can try. Sometimes a bunch of drifting around, talking at length in detail about seemingly unrelated minutiae, and blatantly teasing the reader along can set a mood or an atmosphere. If it is done properly, it can convey more than what the words on the paper are explicitly saying, it just makes an impression. An example that would maybe work for the HN crowd is this old essay about Earthbound [0], where the writer (Tim Rogers, translator) "reviews" the game by just going on long detours about fishing, being sick in bed, things that happen in other games, etc. As a huge fan of Earthbound, it just captures a lot of it for me. An absolute master of this kinda thing was the well-known rock record critic Lester Bangs (who, again, may be vaguely known to some; Philip S. Hoffman played him in "Almost Famous"). His rock album reviews are barely recognizable as such by the "8/10 graphics, 6/10 sound" crowd. He just goes on and on about completely esoteric topics, from politics and his life philosophy and little vignettes about his personal life, and occasionally relates it back to the record. I don't know why, but I dig it. I've read "Psychotic Reactions and Carburetor Dung", an essay compendium, a couple of times. I don't know if I'd want something like that if I was writing an essay for university, or trying to decide which laptop to buy, but it can occasionally be a very nice piece of journalism. [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20100102165201/http://www.largeprimenumbers.com/article.php?sid=mother2 https://web.archive.org/web/20100102165201/http://www.largep... (ps: it opens up with a really weird line about games being like prostitutes, which I think feels stupid and dated, but it gets better after that)
- tunesmith 11y agoThanks for that description, it helps me appreciate the practice more. The success of that technique entirely depends on the talent of the writer, apparently, because I've come across a few too many "long form" articles after "longform" became an internet buzzword, and where the writing just seems to alternate between the topic and an unrelated topic in almost an algorithmic fashion, before they are weakly tied together.
- a3n 11y agoI also like it, when it's well done, but it's very difficult to pull off. I think most instances are just poor decisions by the author that they're going to do just that, and they don't quite pull it off. I see it well done in The New Yorker quite often, and sometimes the NYT.
- gglitch 11y agoI have two related points of reference. The first is a chess game, the shifting long-term tensions of which become more perceptible and enjoyable in the opening phase as one increases in skill; and the second is another article posted not so long ago on HN about linguistic studies measuring the distance in sentences between the main subject data and the main predicate data (or similar, I may be abridging it). At the time the focus was on how much more comprehensible sentences are when that distance is short, but I kept thinking about how many of our celebrated authors and poets display virtuosity by extending that distance from time to time, building and exercising suspense.
- arrakeen 11y agosoggy, everybody-wins non-conclusion is it really that surprising that a poem that quite literally presents a duality could also have one in its interpretation?
- kendallpark 11y agoYES. I love the fact that someone has written about this. I remember reading the full poem in high school and we were like, "That's... not the poem I thought it was."
- tgb 11y agoAnd it's a much better poem because of that!
- skaevola 11y agoIs it? I much prefer the interpretation about rugged individualism. It's not surprising to me that that's the interpretation that caught on in America. This other interpretation seems so cynical. "Yeah, choices in life don't really matter because you always end up at the same place, but I tell people I picked the less obvious choice anyways!" Sometimes it's actually good to believe in something, you know?
- normloman 11y agoEven believing in a lie? Not saying our choices don't matter, but we often attribute too much of our own success to our choices, and not our circumstance. Gives off a distorted view of reality. Coming to terms with the truth would be easier.
- skaevola 11y agoI'm not convinced that believing in something false is always bad. For example, there's a concept in psychology called an "internal locus of control", which basically means believing that you have control over aspects of your life. It turns out that having an internal locus of control is very negatively correlated with depression, so it might be that holding these beliefs actually help people's mental states. Another example would be people turning to religious beliefs to cope with tragedy. Anyways, I'd like to believe that the belief isn't false. I do believe we do exert some substantial control over our own destinies.
- 11y ago
- matt_morgan 11y agoFantastic. It's not about tredding your own path. It's about how we embellish our own pasts. I didn't know.
- ctdonath 11y agoA good insight. The key is the middle line "Though as for that the passing [travelers] there / Had worn them really about the same". Yes, he chose the path less travelled, and the poem itself is remembered for extolling the choice of the less travelled path - but that path was not barely used as we all tend to recall the poem's point (and the author's future listeners interpret), but instead was quite nearly the same and chosen only because it hadn't been trampled quite as badly as the marginally more popular alternative.
- chippy 11y agothis is exactly the misreading!! The paths were the same. He is saying that far in the future he will look back and say that whatever path he took was less travelled, whereas in reality it wasn't.
- ctdonath 11y ago"Then took the other, as just as fair, / And having perhaps the better claim, / Because it was grassy and wanted wear"
- andreaferretti 11y agoI may be ignorant, but I find weird that this is reported as the most famous poem of the 20th century in America, and possibly the world. In fact, I had never heard about it at all. Honest question: is it that well-known? I don't think in Italy it is all that common. Or again, it may be just me...
- tgb 11y agoIt's incredibly well known in my experience. You see it in posters in elementary schools, for example. At least the phrase is all over the place, I'm sure there are plenty who don't know or remember what it's from.
- naiyt 11y agoYeah, it's very popular in the US. Or at least the "road less traveled by" part. People rarely recite the entire poem, but I've heard phrases from it hundreds of times. I've heard it so many times that it really just lost all meaning to me, and just felt kind of pithy when I heard it. I'd never heard of this interpretation, which is quite interesting.
- theresistor 11y agoIt is very commonly taught as an intro to poetry is US schools. I had to memorize it at age 10, for example.
- morley 11y agoNot only is it incredibly well known, but the first half of the article is about why it's well-known and how well-known it is.
- unmole 11y agoIt is very common in India.
- melling 11y agoIt often gets referenced. You probably just never noticed. Ever watch Dead Poets Society? The common message is used in one of the scenes: http://youtu.be/68SLg5ofQMI http://youtu.be/68SLg5ofQMI About 1:30 in case you miss it.
- Grue3 11y agoHas anyone considered that the roads are equally travelled precisely because every traveller chooses the less travelled path? Could the poem actually be a commentary on load balancing?
- x5n1 11y agoBrilliant. A+ certification.
- sharkweek 11y agoI have literally never even remotely thought of this poem in such a way. Grue3, you have shined new light upon these words.
- Apocryphon 11y agoGame theory, perhaps?
- noonespecial 11y agoThat is exactly the sort of thing some pseudo-highbrow twit would have given me a 'D' for in high school after assuring me that "there are no wrong answers". I love it.
- davidw 11y agoI once got a D for an essay on "how does the symbolism help us understand the author's message" when I said that, frankly, it didn't, and that if the author wanted to send a message, he should have come straight out and said it. Sorry, but that's the way my brain is wired, and I was exasperated by the teacher going on about a bunch of stuff that to me seemed like you could just make it up as you go along. "Well, the boat symbolized her relationship with her father, and when the anchor broke, it meant that her affair with her uncle was doomed from the outset because the barnacles on the boat were symbolic of the calluses on his hands, because he was a factory worker, rather than one of the landed gentry..." or some horse shit like that. You can downvote me, but I won't apologize for loathing that kind of thing.
- DarkTree 11y agoSimilarly lost in meaning is Frost's "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening" which is a beautiful poem, but many people don't see the suicidal undertone. I've had it memorized for years and only just learned about this.
- mkaziz 11y agoI just reread it and don't detect that undertone. Could you explain it?
- DarkTree 11y agoLike all literature, it is easy to draw different meanings from the same words, but most of the suicidal undertone is simply in the last stanza: The woods are lovely, dark, and deep, But I have promises to keep, And miles to go before I sleep, And miles to go before I sleep. The narrator has been traveling far to fulfill the promises he made to others. He's looking at the lovely, dark, deep woods and thinking how peaceful they are. The woods are a metaphor for death, which is dark and lovely because you don't have to worry about life's hardships. The miles are not distance, but a metaphor for time. The narrator decides he has to continue on, because he cannot sleep/die before fulfilling his promises to those he made them to. Frost was an amazing writer whose poems beautifully described rural settings. But I think because of his brilliance, it is likely that his poems had deeper meaning than their face-value imagery. But it's also possible that they were one-dimensional, I just doubt it.
- mkaziz 11y agoThat's a very interesting explanation. It's much clearer now, thank you!
- DarkTree 11y agoThe woods = death Lovely - All your worries and obligations no longer exist Dark - When we imagine the absence of life it's like the absence of light, darkness Deep - Death is deep because it's irreversible and never-ending
- 11y ago
- molotv 11y agoClicked thru expecting it to be about "The Mending Wall" http://writing.upenn.edu/~afilreis/88/frost-mending.html http://writing.upenn.edu/~afilreis/88/frost-mending.html "Good fences make good neighbors." is often misused to mean the opposite of what it does in that poem. ...at least I guessed the poet correctly.
- qq66 11y agoGuilty of using this phrase, even aware of the poem's meaning. I use it because it's an instantly recognized American phrase, and I do believe that good fences make good neighbors in many situations (e.g. File permissioning).
- e12e 11y agoBut isn't the use of the phrase in the poem a comment on the proverb/quote, not a source of the quote itself? http://quotes.yourdictionary.com/articles/who-said-good-fences-make-good-neighbors.html http://quotes.yourdictionary.com/articles/who-said-good-fenc...
- whoopdedo 11y agoBut Frost didn't invent that phrase. I hadn't read the poem since school, so I didn't consider it before. But looking at it again now I notice that the phrase is presented in an ironic way. So I turned to the power of the internet and found that, indeed, "good fences make good neighbors" predates "The Mending Wall" by about 30 years. https://books.google.com/books?id=zAgTAAAAYAAJ&dq=%22good%20fences%20make%20good%20neighbors%22&pg=PA29#v=onepage&q=%22good%20fences%20make%20good%20neighbors%22&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=zAgTAAAAYAAJ&dq=%22good%20...
- aresant 11y agoWhat is truly meta is that this entire "misunderstanding" is CENTRAL to the Poem's popularity. Variations of this story and headline have been popping up for years - like in the wonderfully informative "Top 10 Most Misunderstood Lines in Literary History" (1) Or heck, as a monologue in Orange is the New Black (2) Didn't see it there because you're too high-brow and busy, so saw it in business insider last year like me (3)? The poem's dual-meaning is central to its popularization - similar to the "big reveal" that drove the Six Sense to become one of the top 100 grossing movies of all time. (1) http://www.toptenz.net/top-10-most-misunderstood-lines-in-literary-history.php http://www.toptenz.net/top-10-most-misunderstood-lines-in-li... (2) http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat/2013/08/15/orange_is_the_new_black_on_road_less_traveled_show_gets_robert_frost_poem.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat/2013/08/15/orange_is_the... (3) http://www.businessinsider.com/frosts-road-not-taken-poem-interpretation-2014-3 http://www.businessinsider.com/frosts-road-not-taken-poem-in... (3) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Road_Not_Taken https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Road_Not_Taken
- ghaff 11y ago>The poem's dual-meaning is central to its popularization I'm not sure about that. Ask 100 people at least peripherally familiar with the poem what its central point is and 99 would answer something along the lines of "taking the less popular path." I agree with the author's point though. I remember a Dartmouth English professor talking about this years ago and once he pointed out what the words actually said, the actual meaning seemed obvious in retrospect.
- jack9 11y ago> he pointed out what the words actually said, the actual meaning seemed obvious in retrospect. > Yet knowing how way leads on to way, I doubted if I should ever come back. This section negates the "actual meaning" being derived by the author. The reference to the future aspect of having traveled the choice he did not make is imaginary. Once we make a choice, rarely do we change it. The poem is not about choosing the less traveled path, for sure. It is lamenting the possibilities offered, unknown, and therefore attractive in hindsight for a choice made and likely never faced again...allowing for exploration of the reality.
- creeble 11y agoDavid Orr did a talk on NPR that was far less overwrought (http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/weve-gotten-wrong-robert-frost-classic/ http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/weve-gotten-wrong-robert-fros...) It got to the point quickly: "DAVID ORR: He claims that he wrote it because he used to go on walks with the English poet Edward Thomas, because Frost spent a brief time in England. It was actually the beginning of his career as a poet. And what he would like to say at readings afterward is that he and Thomas would go on these walks, and then Thomas, who has a somewhat more romantic sensibility than Frost, Thomas would always regret whatever path they had taken. And then afterward, he would say, well, we really should have gone to the right. I could have shown you something over there. We should have gone to the left. I could show you something over there. And Frost was very amused by this. And so he wrote the poem as a kind of joke at his friend’s expense." In other words, it's more about regret than making the right choice, or that you deceive yourself sometimes by dwelling on a choice that is actually perfectly random. Or a million other interpretations...
- ttkeil 11y agoCue the loss aversion chart: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prospect_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prospect_theory
- septerr 11y agoThe backstory clears things up greatly. Thank you for posting this!
- LoSboccacc 11y agohowever, if I were to ignore the backstory just for fun and apply the law of logic to the poem wording, given the information the road not taken are both, since the poem state he's taken the less used road and the two road ahead are equally worn, he got back to the road he came from. (and by necessity more people went to the crossroad from the other two roads and left on the other road without going to the road the writer is coming from)
- 11y ago
- jameshart 11y ago"It may be the best example in all of American culture of a wolf in sheep’s clothing." Not sure about that. I suspect Springsteen's Born in the USA takes that crown, or perhaps any number of satires that have been taken at face value (looking at you Paul Verhoeven).
- jandrese 11y agoThere is an interpretation of Born in the USA other than how the system beats down the common man with its useless wars and arbitrary bosses? The lyrics are pretty unambiguous. Unless I guess you only listen to the chorus and ignore literally everything that isn't "Born in the USA"?
- mhurron 11y ago> The lyrics are pretty unambiguous. Unless I guess you only listen to the chorus and ignore literally everything that isn't "Born in the USA"? Which is exactly what happens.
- seanalltogether 11y agoAnd here's dave grohl illustrating how true that is. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFHD7kuAqu4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFHD7kuAqu4
- pluma 11y agoGerman chancellor Angela Merkel's party unironically tried to get the rights to use the Rolling Stones song "Angie" for her campaign tours. IIRC The Rolling Stones vehemently objected, but I thought it was a rather defeatist choice in the first place: "But Angie, ain't it time we say goodbye / With no lovin' in our souls and no money in our coats".
- jameshart 11y agoRonald Reagan asked if he could use it as a campaign song.
- Randgalt 11y agoWhy should I believe David Orr? His argument is slim and I disagree with his conclusion. I read the poem again after reading Orr's article and it has the same meaning as it always has for me: go your own way and it will make all the difference. We will never know Frost's true intentions and, frankly, it doesn't matter. The words are the words regardless of what he intended.
- vinceguidry 11y agoYou can know Frost's intentions by reading the letters he wrote to his colleagues about the poem. He makes his deception clear there. This was alluded to in the article and you can go read the source material yourself if you're not satisfied. You are really making a statement about yourself and not about the poem. You want to read it a certain way, and intend to keep reading it that way, because that's the way you've always read it. The "words are the words" sentiment says nothing about the words, but rather how you read them. The sort of traditionalism you're expressing fascinates me, as the psychological phenomenon appears to me to underpin things like climate denial-ism, anti-vaxxing and religious fundamentalism. At the very core, I suspect, is a tendency to be defensive about our limitations. To apply enough critical analysis to the poem to divine Frost's true intent, to become informed enough about science to accept the basics of climate change, it takes a lot of time and effort, yet we treat people who can't / refuse / just don't have the time to do these things as if they're stupid. So they retreat into defensive positions, that the evidence is suspect, why believe Orr, I / we had a way to interpret the poem / organize society so why should we change? Changing is cognitively expensive, just understanding that we need to change is the expensive part.
- Randgalt 11y agoI haven't read Orr's book so maybe there's more evidence for Frost's intent there. But, in the article, there's just one quote from Frost on the subject: "I’ll bet not half a dozen people can tell who was hit and where he was hit by my Road Not Taken". This quote is as enigmatic as the poem and is inconclusive.
- Randgalt 11y ago
- nsxwolf 11y agoIf you have only the poem, the common interpretation is perfectly reasonable. Frost said the poem was "tricky", which is a clue from the poet that the common interpretation could be wrong. But what gives the poem meaning? Are you allowed to interpret it yourself? Or does the poet's obscured intent trump that? In Blade Runner, Is Deckard really a Replicant just because Ridley Scott said so later? There's a few clues in various cuts of the film, but nothing is a slam dunk.
- plonh 11y agoIf you are careful, and parse the whole poem instead skilling the parts with especially nonstandard grammar, you see the inconsistency between the path-walkers thinking and the narrator's thinking and the "ages hence" perspective. You have to reconcile those inconsistencies when reading.
- CurtMonash 11y agoMy wife -- who has taught poetry at the college level as well as writing a whole lot of popular novels -- reminds me from time to time of the "intentional fallacy". What she means by that -- I think :) -- is that the author isn't the sole determinant of a work's meaning. So (while she's unavailable to be asked at the moment) I'm pretty sure she'd agree that the poem is about both the things it's often claimed to be about. Indeed, some of the works she and I both admire the most are ones that work on several levels at once.
- uxp 11y agoThat's precisely what the author of the article determines by quoting from private correspondence from the poem's author: > “I’ll bet not half a dozen people can tell who was hit and where he was hit by my Road Not Taken,” he wrote to his friend Louis Untermeyer.
- a3n 11y agoIt is in fact my favorite poem. I've never thought of it as a triumph of choice, "See, it's because I chose thus!" And I've never thought of it as self-deception, which I think is what the article says. A poem is in some sense our own, but to the extent that you can be wrong about a poem, I think this article is wrong. I think it's merely a wonderful acknowledgement that choosing different paths do make a difference, even when it doesn't appear to matter at the time. Frost's character wasn't making an obviously important choice between the paths. But way did in fact lead to way, and life was probably different, partially determined, because of this metaphorical inconsequential choice of direction. My other favorite Frost poem is "The Hired Man," from which we get the line "Home is the place where, when you have to go there, they have to let you in."
- eyeinthepyramid 11y agoI don't think that your interpretation is wrong, but I think you also have to acknowledge that poem is about how when we look back at these choices, we romanticize and assign meaning to these choices that were essentially random. The man in the poem while reminiscing says 'I took the road less traveled by' but the narrator explicitly says that travel had 'worn them really about the same'. So the self-deception part is fairly explicit.
- allenwlee 11y agoconfirmation bias
- chippy 11y ago>The man in the poem while reminiscing This is not true. This may be the reason for the misreading! He is not reminiscing. he is commenting about reminiscence itself. The author says that in the future he will look back with a sign and state that.
- a3n 11y agoTo your first paragraph, I had that in mind, but struggled to say it. To the second, yeah, OK, but I think deception is a little strong, in part because he acknowledges that they're about the same. He knows that. He had to go somewhere, so he went. Geeks and poetry!
- werber 11y agoAmerican nihilism is so often mistaken for something else
- mbubb 11y agoInteresting - but too cryptic - point. The article mentions a scholar, Richard Poirier, who was at Rutgers when I was a lit student there. I vaguely remember lectures on "Emerson as the American Nietzsche", etc but that was a lifetime ago. American nihilism is terrifying. Philip Dick has created indelible images of it. Minority Report and also a book which was recently made into a series for Netflix a "what if the Nazis won WWII" story. I remember growing up and having a hugely idealistic idea of the 60s. I saw MLK, Bob Dylan, etc as these incorruptible, anti-commercial fonts of wisdom. And in my lifetime they are used to sell khakis and Chryslers. This poem fits into that narrative. Everything is ultimately for sale - that is American nihilism? Leonard Cohen gets at something in the poem/song "Democracy" describing America as the cradle of the best and of the worst. The same engine that powers innovation and imaginative leaps also fuels the intolerance and wackiness so visible in our political process. The poem in question says in short - you can choose any path; just come up with the good story and an advert slogan to explain it later. American nihilism?
- werber 11y agoSorry that was kind of cryptic and vague. I meant that the poem talks about two things that are more or less the same, and then championing the more-or-less equal path you chose to take as some great defining decision. To me American nihilism is the championing of non decisions. Taking pride in your political party, car brand, part of the country you live in, etc. Americans tend to see meaning in the meaningless, morality in being content, identity in pre-selected choices, and they do it with a smile.
- electricblue 11y agoIt seems to me that the poem is more about regret than the stories we tell ourselves about our lives to make us feel better about the randomness of the universe. The poet desperately wants to know what would've happened (if anything) on the other side of the 'difference' but can never know.
- colomon 11y agoSince becoming reacquainted with the poem a couple of decades on from 8th grade English, I've read it as regret at the way age reduces your choices. That comes from interpreting the fall woods as being the autumn of the narrator's life, and focusing on "Yet knowing how way leads on to way, I doubted if I should ever come back." That is, when you're young, you can choose one path and presume you can come back and take the other path sometime; you've got lots of time. When you're getting old, a lot of choices are more or less the only shot you will get; you cannot count on having the time to come back and try the other path.
- kej 11y agoDistantly related, The Road Not Taken is also an excellent short story by Harry Turtledove that the HN crowd would probably appreciate: http://www.eyeofmidas.com/scifi/Turtledove_RoadNotTaken.pdf http://www.eyeofmidas.com/scifi/Turtledove_RoadNotTaken.pdf
- shaftoe 11y agoThat's my favorite Turtledove story. He also wrote a sequel.
- undershirt 11y agolooks like the annotations on genius have this interpretation as well: http://genius.com/46404 http://genius.com/46404
- tamedimp123 11y agoJohn Green made a video about this last week. I'm almost 100% sure that's where the author got his idea for this article: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snQvRZ2vDHE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snQvRZ2vDHE
- kazinator 11y agoIn a different category, the "most too-literally-applied" poem in American administration, however, is Emily Dickinson's Tell all the Truth but tell it slant--.
- mbubb 11y agoI love that poem. And Dickinson. This case reminds me of Plato's Allegory of the cave. Beyond that - the quick transition from Truth to 'success'. And the telling of fairy tales to kids to make the lightning less scary. Wonderful monad of a poem. And there are great images of angles in her works. ``` There's a certain Slant of light, Winter Afternoons – That oppresses, like the Heft Of Cathedral Tunes – ```
- unoti 11y agoI never felt like the Road Not Taken was about individualism, even when I first read it in high school. To me it's about the fact that sometimes you have to make momentous decisions in life, in which neither choice is clearly right or wrong. Either way you choose, the choice is defensible, but once you make the choice, you can't go back. I decided to go into computers, instead of joining the Air Force and becoming a pilot, for example. Sometimes in life you will meet someone who clearly could have been your soulmate, but you decide to let the acquaintance lapse. I wanted to spend a couple of years in the Peace Corps, learn another language, and help people build power plants in remote locations, but I chose to get married and start making babies instead. And I look back on these kinds of choices and say I made the right choice. But no matter what choice you make, it makes all the difference. Isn't this what the poem is about? Regardless of what the poet says, I think the important thing is to be out there on that road, travelling, and doing your best. It's all too easy to stay in your comfort zone forever rather than travelling. Edit: corrected title. Apologies!
- Falcon9 11y agoHow do you get the title of the poem incorrect when commenting on this story?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hugh4 11y ago>I never felt like the Road Not Taken was about individualism, even when I first read it in high school. To me it's about the fact that sometimes you have to make momentous decisions in life, in which neither choice is clearly right or wrong. Either way you choose, the choice is defensible, but once you make the choice, you can't go back Yeah, the "common misinterpretation" doesn't seem to be that common. However: I suppose you could say that when the poem is quoted it's more likely to be by someone making a point about individualism than someone making a point about irrevocable low-information choices, because people are more likely to drum up inspiring-sounding quotes on the former than neutral-sounding quotes on the latter. So that could explain why people think that other people think that the poem is about the former when they all privately think itabout the latter.
- jsalit 11y agoAlso presented here by John Green - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snQvRZ2vDHE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snQvRZ2vDHE
- eggoa 11y agoI'd like to think that those who appropriate the poem for car commercials and such and fully aware of the poem's meaning, but are exercising a subversive irony.
- joaorico 11y agoRobert Frost himself wrote about this intentional light mocking [0]: "I suppose I was gently teasing them." [1] "but about a friend who had gone off to war, a person who, whichever road he went, would be sorry he didn't go the other." [2] -- [1] "On one occasion he [RF] told of receiving a letter from a grammar-school girl who asked a good question of him: 'Why the sigh?' That letter and that question, he said, had prompted an answer. Amherst Mass April 1925 "Dear Miss Yates: No wonder you were a little puzzled over the end of my Road Not Taken. It was my rather private jest at the expense of those who might think I would yet live to be sorry for the way I had taken in life. I suppose I was gently teasing them. I'm not really a very regretful person, but for your solicitousness on my behalf I'm your friend always Robert Frost" [Finger, L. L.: "Frost's 'The Road Not Taken': a 1925 Letter come to Light", American Literature v.50] -- [2] "(a) One stanza of 'The Road Not Taken' was written while I was sitting on a sofa in the middle of England: Was found three or four years later, and I couldn't bear not to finish it. I wasn't thinking about myself there, but about a friend who had gone off to war, a person who, whichever road he went, would be sorry he didn't go the other. He was hard on himself that way. (RF, Bread Loaf Writers' Conference, 23 Aug. 1953; tape recording)." "(c) Frost said that he wrote the poem, 'The Road Not Taken' for his friend [Edward Thomas] and sent it to him in France, getting the reply, 'What are you trying to do with me?' (L. Mertins: Robert Frost)" [Thompson, Lawrance: Robert Frost: The Years of Triumph, Notes.] -- [0] http://www.retiredtractors.com/Frost/Roadfrost.html http://www.retiredtractors.com/Frost/Roadfrost.html
- marquis 11y agoThe NZ ad mentioned: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1wwXfAFQoh8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1wwXfAFQoh8 (NZ isn't a large country: those roads probably ran to the same town anyway).
- code_sterling 11y agoWe spent a week discussing the possible meanings in college. And each was as valid as any other interpretation, this one was mentioned, but it was clear that none were more valid than any other. You can't get a poem wrong, just like you can't interpret a painting wrong. And artist will be inspired to create, but what that means to the observer, is personal between them, and the work.
- linkydinkandyou 11y agoI certainly don't disagree with this critic's (correct) interpretation: it's that these decisions don't matter, unless you retroactively assign meaning to them. I, too, wince when I see self-help gurus using the phrase "the road not taken" as if it's a directive to choose unconventionality over normality. But I do take issue with this essay's assertion that most Americans are too stupid to understand this poem. That's just elitist nonsense. I'd like to think my fellow American is smarter than that, and not just elite readers of The Paris Review can figure these things out.
- ap22213 11y agoI'm particular struck by the part "...long I stood And looked down one as far as I could To where it bent in the undergrowth;" It reminds me of my over-analysis in developing software. Sometimes, I over think things, try to predict the outcomes of things, spend lots and lots of time considering what's behind the 'bend': what's the perfect solution. Analysis paralysis. But, at a certain point, the analysis gives way to intuition. I choose the path that 'feels' best, knowing that many different paths could have been just as right.
- chippy 11y ago...and five years later we justify to our peers "yes NodeJS was the right choice after all!"
- adregan 11y agoI like to think that Roland Barthes would have loved to use "The Road Not Taken" in his piece "Death of the Author"[0]. Truly, at a scale that's frankly staggering, agency has been given to the reader—though one could also argue that the clipped version of the poem often remembered is a case of remixing and rewriting and that the agency isn't merely passive interpretation but a very active creative endeavor. 0: http://www.ubu.com/aspen/aspen5and6/threeEssays.html#barthes http://www.ubu.com/aspen/aspen5and6/threeEssays.html#barthes
- kazinator 11y agoThe Fork Not Taken Two spaces forged in the obscure core And sorry I could not both address And be one stream of loads and stores Blocked while tables copy, bored Yielded to the next process(0) I got the new one, once unblocked And having perhaps the better claim, Because it was COW(1), not yet untwained(2) Though as per that POSIX doc, The two should look about the same. --- 0. Not accurate. 1. Hay, cows like it grassy! 2. Naive misconception that there is a difference.
- aaroninsf 11y agoITT: many well-spoken comments reflecting how different personality types (or if you prefer, ways of thinking, or, viewing or understanding the world...) have very different relationships to poetry. No such codification is perfect, but I find the Meyers-Briggs binning a useful shorthand for understanding how different colleagues relate to the world (and respond in different ways to different kinds of problem, management strategy, social environment, etc...)... ...and in this thread there are comments which would make me bin people immediately. :) (There are no good or bad bins; just differences.)
- midnightmonster 11y agoFrost's duplicity (sometimes triplicity, maybe more) is part of his charm. Yet if there were not also insight and beauty, I think the charm--the mere pleasure in being as clever as the speaker (if not as clever as the poet)--would wear thin. I truly love Frost, but I love even more Gerard M Hopkins. One gets the feeling Hopkins resorts to dense layers of images not to share a joke with the sufficiently-clever reader, but in desperate earnestness to show what can't be said in prose. "Look--look! See this beautiful/terrible/mysterious thing!"
- musesum 11y agoThis or that? I would bet: either way, one regret. Until now, this thought will vet — a better look. The past is done; the future not set. Just keep on going, and watch your step.
- giltleaf 11y agoThe whole argument of the article establishes a false dichotomy. While I'm sure there are some people who can play the role both of the sheep and the literary insiders (as in the author's description), I'm sure most people, like the author, fall somewhere in the middle with their interpretation.
- chippy 11y agoWell, (as seen in a few comments in this thread) the idea of the individualist ploughing their own way is strong - and the misreading fits in really well with it. I certainly used to follow this also. So I would get the idea from the poem via pop culture or an idle hearing in an advert, and that would stay with me. I wouldn't read it with the same attention as a literary person of course. Perhaps thats the false dichotomy? I now have more delight knowing that it is a commentary about how, when dealing with a change, we can look into the future and see ourselves justifying our actions regardless of which action we take.
- jmount 11y agoIt is like they started the essay before they knew they could actually come to a coherent point.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bastijn 11y agoAnd here I am. At the end of a comment feed with many opinions about a poem everybody knows. Wondering if I should have known this poem before I read it today for the first time. Or if I could wave it away as just a USA thing. Written by USA who falsely claims everybody outside US also knows the poem. Pondering, which road did I take?
- chippy 11y agoThe more faithful comment would read: And here I am at the beginning of a 278 comments thread where they are all alike. And although they do seem to be saying the same thing, it appears they get the same amount of upvotes. Anyhow, when I'm finished, I will give a sigh and say I, I read and spent my attention better because the other unread comment was not read by me and that made all the difference.
- jmadsen 11y agoI'll allow myself a semi-related tangent, just for the heck of it. Another similar example of misunderstanding well-known lines from literature is Shakespeare's "Now is the winter of our discontent..", which everyone quotes meaning we are in dark times... Except it is the opposite - "Now is the winter of our discontent made glorious summer by this Son of York.." is the full line.
- markbnj 11y agoIf art has a downside, it may be in the fact that there is always some very smart person at hand to analyze it for you and explain why you don't understand it.
- vijucat 11y agoTwo roads diverged in a wood, and I took the one that was less popular on Google That was not a smart move (With apologies to Frost fans).
- x0054 11y agoOk, a honest question here. And English is my second language, so maybe this is why, but this middle part sounds like compleat nonsense to me. Is it just me and I don't know how to read poems? Is it how people used to talk back in the day? > And both that morning equally lay > In leaves no step had trodden black. > Oh, I kept the first for another day! > Yet knowing how way leads on to way, > I doubted if I should ever come back. I think I can understand the rest of the poem pretty well, but that 3rd stanza just sounds like random words just tossed together. No? Maybe I just don't get poems.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoPoems tend to be a bit more fluid with word order than ordinary prose.
- plonh 11y agoEnglish poetry alters word choice and order in order fit the pronunciation into patterns of rhythm and rhyme, and to convey emotion by putting certain words together or apart. It is nearly ungrammatical, or you could say that each poem has its own nonstandard grammar. Here is what it means: On that morning there were two essentially similar paths, not walked on so much-- none of the fallen leaves were crushed into dirt. I decided to leave the first path, and walk on it another day. Yet knowing how one path leads on to another, I doubted that I would ever return to this place and have a chance (to walk on that first path)
- injulkarnilesh 11y agoIt's already been well explained in Orange is new black. Here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EAkYlhhFvbk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EAkYlhhFvbk
- mbubb 11y agoTangentially saw this in Quanta magazine. https://www.quantamagazine.org/20150903-the-road-less-traveled/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/20150903-the-road-less-travel...