5 ms·
In California, Uber Loses Another Round in Driver Debate
- pftom 11y agoGreat! Otherwise drivers will be Uber's slaves.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoSlightly off topic, but it's rather poor form to use the term slaves to refer to people who clearly aren't. Unless the driver had, say, taken out a loan from Uber in order to pay for their car, they don't even meet the mark for indentured servitude. There are millions of actual slaves living on this planet, children and adults forced into labor, sex, what have you. Calling someone with a shitty job a slave devalues the meaning of the term and softens the reality that there are right now more people than the number you have ever met in your life and likely ever will who can be bought and sold as property.
- codemac 11y ago> Unless the driver had, say, taken out a loan from Uber in order to pay for their car Uber explicitly does this for many of their drivers.
- hueving 11y agoIs it impossible to default on that loan? Can Uber beat their drivers into submission?
- matthewcford 11y agoNot condoning the term, but most user drivers I speak to have taken a loan out to pay for their car, or are paying high rents.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- trjordan 11y agoWould this open the door to preventing Uber drivers from operating multiple services at once? I've seen plenty of drivers with multiple phones up running both apps.
- Daishiman 11y agoI'm guessing the future of this is that there will be a certain standard to the amount and conditions of participation the driver will have before they're considered employees. Similar things happen for freelancer. You're a freelancer so long as you meet certain criteria for actually being independent and not living off a single client. As soon as your livelihood depends on a single client who's consuming an inordinate amount of time, no matter what the contract says you can successfully sue for benefits and the law will be on your side.
- worik 11y agoNot in New Zealand if you work in the movies or in game development. In New Zealand the law is for sale and Warner Brothers invested.... Now workers in the film industry and the computer game industry have no employment rights.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoHow would you prevent this if they use multiple phones? You couldn't.
- adventured 11y agoIf you make Uber drivers employees, you can prevent it. In the same way and for the same reason Google can prevent an employee from working for both Apple and Google at the same time (by firing them).
- toomuchtodo 11y agoYou can't govern what you can't detect.
- ab1212 11y agoGood. Now I want Uber to go after their Employee for stealing my laptop, ipad, and phone instead of brushing it off as requiring lawful intervention.
- Daishiman 11y agoYou could probably sue successfully for that.
- joshdance 11y agoI used Uber for the first time today and loved the service. Never had a horse in the race until now.
- ricree 11y agoWhat does this mean for Taxi drivers in California? My understanding was that they also frequently operated as contractors.
- interesting_att 11y agoDon't think this will change much. Taxi drivers get to choose how they do their job (i.e. who to pick up). Moreover taxi companies do not forbid customers from tipping nor do they get a percentage of a taxi driver's gratuity. Lastly, you can be a taxi driver at multiple companies, whereas Uber has sent messages to some drivers not to drive for both Lyft + Uber.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoWhich is why taxi drivers continue to meet the definition of a contractor, while Uber drivers do not. Uber's entire model is built over the control they exert to enable the experience they desire. Without that control, they don't have a brand, but by needing that control, it prohibits their operating model (using contractors).
- smokeyj 11y agoWhat about software contractors that are handed work equipment, required to work a minimum of 40 hrs (full time) and have to show up to an office. How are they not considered employees?
- jfb 11y agoThey are. If you are in this situation, consult with a California labor attorney.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAlso report them to the IRS. You'll receive a portion of the taxes and penalties recovered. http://www.irs.gov/Individuals/How-Do-You-Report-Suspected-Tax-Fraud-Activity%3F http://www.irs.gov/Individuals/How-Do-You-Report-Suspected-T...
- patrickaljord 11y agoAlways sad to see the state dictating consenting and willing adults how they should run their lives and work. I'm used to it though as a French.
- asdtgy 11y agoit's the free market ...
- patrickaljord 11y agoMore like the opposite of it.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoAre you being sarcastic? These are _interventions_ in the free market.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoYou're standing on the edge of a cliff. Be careful not to fall into the Sar Chasm...
- asdtgy 11y agoI don't like that word either
- asdtgy 11y agofree market controlled by the government sponsored by big business...
- dylanjermiah 11y agoThis sentence is contradictory. A free market doesn't work efficiently when it's 'controlled'. That's not a free market.
- 11y ago
- Spooky23 11y agoGetting disrupted sucks I suppose.
- troyastorino 11y agoUber doesn't actually have to win these legal battles. They just need to prolong the time until a definitive ruling on driver classification is made until they are ready to roll out a driverless fleet. And prolonging the outcomes of these legal cases 5 or 6 years (appeals, etc) seems pretty reasonable. There would be a political route to changing driving classification, but Uber has an incredible lobbying machine.
- philwelch 11y agoDo you really think driverless cars will be globally ubiquitous in 5 or 6 years? It's not even clear the technology will be ready by then, and if it is, the legal fight to get driverless cars permitted to operate without a licensed driver able to take control will make these legal battles look trivial.
- snogglethorpe 11y agoYes; given the technological and legal hurdles, they'll initially only be allowed in certain constrained areas and uses. They're not going to be anything like a widespread option for a long, long, time, and certainly not something a company like Uber should be betting their business model on.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoDid this person get "fired" by Uber for having too low of a rating? I would assume they can't get unemployment if they quit or simply stop driving.
- pbreit 11y agoCasual drivers should obviously be able to be contractors. Fuller-time drivers might deserve the choice. I suspect there's a good chance Uber would make much more money on W-2 drivers since they'd get minimum wage and Uber would keep the surge. But the current model makes much more sense.