10 ms·
The Cheap Phones Quietly Winning the U.S
- quantisan 11y agoI had a ZTE Monte Carlo and used it for 3 years. It's surprisingly durable as a device. Everything works and there're minimal physical damage after my careless use for 3 years. Whereas my other Chinese brand phone (Umi) had more and more problems as it wears out just 1 year after.
- JonnieCache 11y agoI'm currently rocking the indestructible, inexhaustible nokia 105 (phone flashlight ftw), but next year when I go east to seek my fortune on the continent I've accepted that a smartphone and associated nightly charging ritual will become essential. What would HN recommend as a cheap, durable android device? These ZTE things look pretty good... Also, what happened to those ultra cheap windows mobile devices targeted at "emerging markets?"
- lmns 11y agoMoto E, G, etc.. Almost as cheap as chinese brands, but with much better update / software support.
- dharma1 11y agoI have Moto G. Software updates are fairly regular, but I still switched to Cyanogenmod. I'd say there isn't much difference between CM and stock android. You can tether with CM without worrying about telco tethering blocks, something that doesn't work on stock android
- rahimnathwani 11y ago"You can tether with CM without worrying about telco tethering blocks, something that doesn't work on stock android" Doesn't that depend on your carrier? IIRC some carriers detect tethering by looking for packets with different TTL values (which would represent different devices' defaults, or indicate an extra decrement as the packet went through the phone), or inspecting HTTP User-Agent.
- dharma1 11y agopotentially, but stock Android tells the carrier it's tethering, and there's no way around it. CM doesn't. http://danielpocock.com/android-betrays-tethering-data http://danielpocock.com/android-betrays-tethering-data You can hack around both TTL values and user-agent btw. Deep packet inspection, maybe less so
- dublinben 11y agoI was unable to replicate his results on my Nexus 5 running AOSP. This behavior has possibly changed in newer versions of Android. Also, DPI can be trivially bypassed by running all traffic from your phone through a VPN. All traffic, tethered or not, will be indistinguishable to your carrier.
- dharma1 11y agoOn my Android Moto G, running Android 4, I could not get around my carriers (Three UK) tethering block. CM solved that. VPN would work for DPI true, hassle though.
- dublinben 11y agoAre you running the 'stock' Google-provided ROM, did you try an actual fresh installation? I'm running a clean AOSP ROM, without any kind of CM customizations.
- nevinera 11y agoMoto E or G - wide base, good support, replacement parts easily available and installable. My kids keep breaking my screen, and I can replace the screen assembly for 30 bucks (takes about 20 minutes).
- smackfu 11y ago>Also, what happened to those ultra cheap windows mobile devices targeted at "emerging markets?" Nokia 635, $40: http://www.amazon.com/AT-Nokia-Lumia-635-Contract/dp/B00LBFFSNM http://www.amazon.com/AT-Nokia-Lumia-635-Contract/dp/B00LBFF... We bought one for my future mother-in-law, because the Windows Phone tile system was easier for her to deal with than the Android home screen. Plus, when she dropped it in a puddle after a few months, no big deal.
- mbucc 11y ago> Nokia 635, $40 I don't understand why these low cost Nokia's get so little love here in the U.S. My 520 was $50 a few years ago and is a rock solid piece of hardware. I guess it's the missing apps on Windows mobile?
- maxsilver 11y agoI bought a Nokia 640 for $99 It's great. I love it. It's not quite as nice as my old phone, but it's 90% of the value, for 15% of the price. And in some ways, it's better than my old phone (lighter, more damage resistant, better battery life, better cellular reception)
- JonnieCache 11y agoThis looks pretty sweet. And will run windows 10 apparently. Shame it doesn't go for less than £50 without a contract. Double the US price, as usual. EDIT: Except it comes in 512mb and elusive 1gb RAM versions, with identical product names and prices, so I have to search around to get the good one. This is how it starts! Perhaps I don't need a smartphone...
- samsolomon 11y agoIt depends how much of an upgrade you're looking for. If you want a flagship-esque phone without the price the new $220 Moto G is an excellent pick. I absolutely love mine—it's fast, has a good battery and is much more stylish than other phones in the category. The only thing keeping it back from being a flagship is the camera. Also possibly the 5.1 screen-size. But hey, I prefer the 5" screen over the 5.5" to 6" ones, so it works for me. EDIT: Also, Motorola has almost no bloatware on the phones. The few apps they pre-install are actually quite good.
- JonnieCache 11y agoWhat is a flagship? Just a really good phone?
- knd775 11y agoIt just means the company's primary high-end phones. For example, the iPhone 6 and Galaxy S6.
- mod 11y agoI got the Moto G 3rd generation a few weeks ago, and I really like it, so I second this recommendation. My two main complaints are that you can't touch to wake (and there's no physical button on the face) and that I don't get an SMS notification when the phone is sleeping if the messaging app is already open to the person who sent the new message (which is very, very common for conversations). If it's not the focused app, I get one like normal.
- shoover 11y agoHTC Desire 610, 170USD. I don't know about durable yet, but at a quarter the price of a new iphone and a decent feature upgrade all around from a 5-year-old iphone 4, I'm happy.
- olalonde 11y agoI bought a Xiaomi Note 2 months ago and really happy with it. It's comparable to an iPhone in terms of quality and at least twice cheaper (~315$). The only downside is that you have to figure out how to install Google Play Store by yourself (and most online tutorials on how to do it are outdated).
- vinceyuan 11y agoZTE is as big as Huawei. Both of ZTE and Huawei manufacture telecom equipments. Umi is a tiny company. That's why ZTE phone is much better than Umi phone.
- pingec 11y agoAre they running a non-Google version of Android? Because in these market share charts what I really see is just Google vs. Apple
- eitally 11y agoAs an app developer, that may make sense, but I don't think consumers see it that way at all. Perhaps that will change in the future, but the skins applied by HTC & Samsung, especially (Sony's & LG's aren't too overdone) make the UX completely different between brands, even if the underlying OS is the same. Add in the ability to use custom launchers and you very easily could end up with someone customizing their Android phone to the point where only they know how to use it.
- ourmandave 11y agoI've been an Android user since forever but HTC's interface kept nagging me to configure the HTC Experience after every little update, even though I'd dismissed it over and over. It's like that pop-up wondering if you'd like to take a survey while you're entering your shipping address during check out. It finally drove me to a cheap Windows phone.
- TsiCClawOfLight 11y agoJust get a Nexus or Sony. Vanilla Android is a much better experience. (or flash cyanogen)
- paulgb 11y agoSony's experience (at least the Xperia Z3) is far from vanilla and not in a good way. They replace pretty much every app and UI component with an inferior in-house version, and add a bunch of unremovable apps to try to sell you Sony stuff. I hear the Z5 is better though so hopefully they're getting the message.
- 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bobajeff 11y agoMoto G seems be my baseline for what I expect a good enough phone to be. That honor used to belong to the Galaxy S III US. Ver. I expect others like ZTE and Alcatel will catch up at some point. But probably will also face some fearce competition from the quality direct-to-customer type companies like Xiaomi, OnePlus, Wileyfox.
- mtgx 11y agoAlcatel has a few very nicely designed and study phones. Cameras are pretty bad though. ZTE also has a few beautifully designed and polished models, especially the Nubia line, but the new Axon that launched in the US is pretty good too - it's sort of a OnePlus 2 competitor.
- nothis 11y agoSo what's the catch with the ZTE? Processor speed is boring. Is it the touch screen being unresponsive? Some software thing? Bad screen? Does it break easily?
- caboteria 11y agoI got a $60 ZTE firefox phone then switched to Android. Compared to my kid's Moto G it's smaller, feels thicker, has a lower-res screen, no selfie-cam, crappy forward-cam, and that's about it. It's pretty great for texting but if I used it for email (which I don't) I think I'd want a phone with a bigger, higher-res screen and the extra $100 for the G would be worth it.
- UnoriginalGuy 11y agoThere is nothing specific. I owned a ZTE device (a sub-$50 one at that) and aside from being a touch slower (relative to flagships) and having a terrible camera it was darn good. To talk in particular about the Maven (per the article): 4.5" screen ("small"), 2100mAh battery (other similarly sized phones have 2500mAh), 1 GB of RAM (2 GM is typical in flagships), quad core 1.2GHz (flagships at that size have 2.5GHz quads), no wireless charging, no NFC, and the cameras are utterly terrible. So there are some trade offs with the Maven and many ZTE phones in general. But the real question is: are they "good enough?" And to be frank, yes, they are. If someone cannot afford a $600 flagship, get a $60 ZTE and get 80% of the value for 10% of the price. Between ZTE, Moto, and Nokia you can get a really nice phone for under $100 now.
- tsotha 11y agoAs phone subsidies go away there's going to be a lot more price pressure on mobile hardware vendors.
- smackfu 11y agoIt will probably create a gap in phone prices. The under $100 phones, for people who pay the full price up-front and don't need anything too fancy. And the $450+ phones, for people who pay $20 a month for a phone installment purchase plan on something like AT&T Next. IMO, a $300 phone doesn't really fit well in that world. Too pricey for an upfront purchase. And once you go monthly, most people aren't too price concious when comparing $15 per month vs $20 per month.
- soylentcola 11y agoAt the same time, when I'm buying a new phone (unlocked and up front) I don't go for the $100 phones but I do take price into account. Not that it does much for OEMs selling at those lower margins but it's a large part of why I buy $350-450 phones like the Nexus 5 or Moto X instead of the $650+ iPhone. I think you nailed it on the installment plans though. Splitting up the cost and spreading it out makes a few hundred dollars less obvious (psychologically at least).
- mkozlows 11y agoPeople are more price-conscious than you'd think. I mean, even Apple -- the brand that cater the most to the price-insensitive -- has always sold a decent number of its $550 and $450 phones. The more people see real prices, even if they finance them, the more they're going to reconsider the definition of "splurging."
- smackfu 11y agoThe $450 phone was $0 upfront, and the $550 phone was $100 upfront, but they all cost the same per month after that. Scrounging up $200 for a flagship $650 phone is tough for some people, even if they can pay the monthly cell phone bill. Now, with financing, all the phones are $0 upfront. The $450 one is $19 per month, the $550 one is $23, and the $650 one is $27. So I'd wager they sell more of those flagships to people.
- dharma1 11y agoI expect there won't be many other than the top Chinese brands left in a few years. Price/spec ratio is unbeatable
- adestefan 11y agoAt one point in time people said this about Japanese electronic vendors. Most of those companies are now dead. You can point at the Japanese automakers as a counter-point. However, I caution that comparison because they rallied around quality. In the early-70s the major American automobile makers were both terrible quality and expensive. The Japanese were able to create the holy union of both a more reliable and cheaper automobile. Could a Chinese market sprout up to make quality and cheap phone? Probably, but there's no real issue of all the phones are expensive, but terrible devices.
- dagw 11y agoPrice/spec ratio is unbeatable While true, I've found that the price/quality ratio leaves something to be desired.
- raverbashing 11y agoHard to justify the increased iPhone prices (and I'm a Mac user) Especially when you prefer to buy unlocked phones
- merpnderp 11y agoI read quite a bit on my iPhone (several books a month) and watch nearly all my TV/videos on it. If you really like iOS as apposed to Android or Win10, then it isn't that hard to justify spending a few hundred more on a device that gets hours of use every single day. And will resell in 2 years for quite a bit more than the competition.
- tdkl 11y agoPersonally, I don't see the price difference just in hardware or functionality, but in software and support. When I buy a premium iPhone device, I pay for future years of security updates and optimizations. I also pay for kind, instant support online or in a network of certified resellers or Apple stores (if I'm lucky to be near one at least in EU). Some people like to tinker with their devices or even have to from time to time when an app/service goes amok. I pay extra to not deal with that, because my time is worth more, then wasting it on things like that. Now compare that to a sub 100$/€ phone.
- jsf666 11y agoSelling phones with plans for a subsidized (when someone can't count the total cost) is one of the biggest multi-billion dolar "scams" I've seen for a while. Here (Europe) buying a pre-paid card and a phone separatly is the most cost effective option, isn't it the same in the States?
- jedanbik 11y agoIt is cheaper - I'm saving $1000 bucks on my iPhone over the course of two years, just by buying it unlocked and on a cheaper plan. I can use it in other countries as well, just a matter of swapping the SIM card. Only downside is that my network provider won't replace my phone if something were to happen to it, but I'd imagine there are third party insurance providers in this space. I think there are a few reasons why companies like Verizon are so big in the U.S.: they have a good network, they offer plenty of family plans, and they will replace your phone for what seems like subsidized rate under various conditions. Oh, and they advertise constantly. But not being able to use my phone out of the country? Very limiting. Why would I pay more for that handicap as an individual enrollee?
- meesles 11y agoIt would depend on your use I suppose? I always found that I could never live off a prepaid system because I would blow through the data too fast.
- lorenzhs 11y agoyou can get a 5GB prepaid plan as well, it's something like 15€ ($17) per month (in Germany, which is among the more expensive countries regarding mobile phone tariffs). And when you go over your cap, your speed gets reduced to 64kbit but you don't pay extra. Some prepaid providers then allow you to "reset" your data cap for another 3-5€.
- DanBC 11y agoGiffgaff offer unlimited phone data (no tethering) for £15 per month.
- coldcode 11y agoExcept of course for Apple with 44% of the market in the US, which is increasing, and somewhere around 90% of the profit. Winning in Android is a race to the bottom where only the cheap survive, exactly what happened to Dell and its competitors in the PC market. And someday Google will decide it needs to actually make money from Android and that world will fork into Google Android Phone and the seven dwarf versions.
- bobajeff 11y agoI don't think Google will ever try to make money directly off of licensing Android or selling phones. It's far more likely they'll continue to leverage it to bring users to their services. I think the point where Google and consumers are misaligned would be their preference of Chrome OS over Android. Still, I don't see them throwing away their market power in a play to move users to Chrome OS. They'll just keep mixing them both together until there is no difference.
- sremani 11y agoOnce the upgrade fatigue hits and people are no longer subsidized for their cell phones, putting down $600+ or putting down $60 for serviceable phone would become a no brainer. These phones have to become good enough and they are already getting there.
- graeme 11y agoHow true is this for that 44% currently using iphones? Iphones stay good enough for at least 2-3 years, if you're not picky. $600/3 = $200. $17 per month, 0.56 cents per day. It's not nothing. But it is nothing compared to what the iphone class spends on, say, coffee. There is the one-off hit from paying the $600 all at once, but credit cards reduce that pain somewhat. Meanwhile, you're using the phone every day. If you have the money, you probably want a phone you really like, not one that is just good enough. Don't get me wrong, I think these new "good enough" phones are going to capture a large part of the market. I just am not sure it will be the iphone part. Past a certain income level, $540 savings for years of daily annoyance isn't really a compelling saving.
- ck2 11y agoZTE makes the best $10-$20 phone I've seen anywhere. It is called the ZTE Zinger (T-Mobile) or ZTE Prelude 2 (AT&T) The formal model name is the Z667 or Z667T or Z667G Goes on sale that cheap a few times a year, otherwise $40 The screen is low resolution but you'd never know, works fine for all but the smallest text. It is dual core and runs KitKat 4.4 so it is very smooth. The problem is they are impossible to root and impossible to unlock bootloader. So they never took off. ZTE basically shot themselves in the foot and sold out to carrier desires. It should be a crime in the USA to not be able to root your phone if you paid for it.
- thoward 11y agoThis article reminds me of the "shitphone" story that got posted here a while back. Long but definitely worthwhile IMHO. https://medium.com/matter/shitphone-a-love-story-a44e66434807 https://medium.com/matter/shitphone-a-love-story-a44e6643480... Basically an exploration of value. An iPhone can cost 3x times as much as some of these other phones, and is certainly a more pleasant device to use, but does it really offer 3x as much functionality? The basic (world-changing) functions of the smartphone (location services with GPS, decent point and shoot camera with you at all times, web access on the go, etc.) are present in both devices.
- mfringel 11y agoDesign and execution count. If I have to wait 30 seconds for my phone to get out of its own way each time I desire to accomplish a task (camera, map application, web access), am I actually going to use it for those things, or do I now have a dumbphone with more things that can break?
- thoward 11y agoTrue, but consider this from the shitphone piece... "Things had gradually become slower. They rarely came to a full stop, but they got close. Complicated websites in particular were hard for shitphone. I found myself blaming the websites." Maybe you would just stop going to horribly designed mobile websites, and you wouldn't be much worse off.
- olalonde 11y agoHaven't read the article but the same argument could be made of cars (not saying it's wrong).
- vinceyuan 11y ago> The basic (world-changing) functions of the smartphone (location services with GPS, decent point and shoot camera with you at all times, web access on the go, etc.) are present in both devices. Generally, cheap ($30) phone's camera is awful. $200 Android phone's camera is good. iPhone 6's camera is excellent. (Though I am using iPhone 6 Plus, I still think iPhone 6 Plus is too expensive.)
- jhallenworld 11y agoMy wife tried the Moto G 2nd generation LTE $160, but didn't like the industrial design- too cheap. I think the first generation may have been nicer. We ended up with the Samsung Galaxy Alpha for $275: it looks nice, but not quite as expensive as their flagship phones: http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Galaxy-G850a-Unlocked-Cellphone/dp/B00UCJ0IBU/ref=sr_1_1?s=wireless&ie=UTF8&qid=1441376187&sr=1-1&keywords=samsung+galaxy+alpha&refinements=p_36%3A18000-28000 http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Galaxy-G850a-Unlocked-Cellphon... And yes, I think it's nuts to pay $100 for design, but happy wife happy life..
- wambotron 11y agoI own a Nokia Lumia Icon (Verizon) and a Microsoft Lumia 640 (T-Mobile). The Icon was bought on a plan and was $199 subsidized. The 640 was bought off-contract for $99. I believe the Icon was selling for around $700 off-contract. I've used both extensively now (the Icon was my old daily phone, the 640 is my new one). The 640 is lacking in the camera. That's it. Every other experience on the phone? Identical. I don't miss the Icon at all, and I think that really says something. Why would a phone 6-7x the price be roughly equivalent in experience? Why should it be? The 640 isn't subsidized by anything. $99 is the just the price of it. It's an amazing device, FAR better than an equivalent android. People complain about Windows Phone not having "flagship" devices, but realistically, it doesn't need them. The cheap phones are great. I've tried expensive android phones, iphone, as well. None of them stand up to the experience on WP for me. If Microsoft keeps making $100 phones like this, I'll never pay more than that for a phone.
- virmundi 11y agoHey, I'm glad you're liking the WP. Honestly, I think WP should be great. That said.... Android phones are starting to get into this territory too. OnePlus 2 is $400. That is 4x the cost of your $100. But it is less than half the cost of my $1000 Note 2. (I don't buy on contract because I have a grandfather plan on VZ for unlimited data). My wife's phone was $700. Next refresh in about 2 years we'll be in the OnePlus store. The reason I say all of this is that we should all, across every platform but Apple, be looking forward to getting less expensive, higher quality devices.
- randomhunt 11y agoI'm hoping that Android gets a lot better on the battery usage before that happens in earnest though. I've read they've focused on this recently but I haven't had time to drill into details. I love Windows Phone and have had 3 different models since Windows Phone 7. I'm currently on a Lumia 830 for my private phone and get about 3.5-4 days of battery life. Granted I don't call/text a lot relying on email, Lync and Skype. My previous Lumia 520 was about the same, and the previous LG E900 was 2.5-3 days. My partner has a Moto G (1st Generation) and loves it but only gets about 1-1.5 days of battery life. Good phone, similar price levels after offers on the Lumia 830, but dramatically lower battery life.
- cpursley 11y agoThe moto e is the best 'cheap phone' and service in the United States: https://republicwireless.com/phones/ https://republicwireless.com/phones/ The phone is absolutely sufficient and you can't beat the plan.
- qCOVET 11y agoThis is a great example of Clay Christensen's Disruption. The cheap phone manufacturers, will emerge as big winners in the long run and push the current high-end manufacturers to either compete at their price point, or have their market share shrink dramatically. Ref: http://www.claytonchristensen.com/key-concepts/ http://www.claytonchristensen.com/key-concepts/
- jldugger 11y agoI don't think you actually read that book. Disruptive innovation is moving a technology designed for one market, possibly a new one, into another existing market. Existing market participants focus on 'sustaining' innovations like reducing costs and inventing more expensive products. In today's environment, think using ARM processors, intentionally designed for low power draw in mobile phones, into laptops, desktops and eventually servers. ZTE's success is just price differentiation within an existing market. Their 'innovation' is selling phone technology from 2 years ago at a discount. I don't think that even counts as a sustaining innovation, and the article notes that sales doubled but profits growing only 4 percent-- this implies huge cuts to profit margins. The same article also notes that this 'reduced margins' strategy might be subsidized by Chinese security interests.
- qCOVET 11y agoFrom the author - Clay Christensen himself: "Consider the hegemony of Detroit’s Big Three—General Motors, Ford, and Chrysler. At one time, they dominated the auto industry, producing bigger, faster, safer, more comfortable cars with more and more features. But these improving products also “create a vacuum underneath them,” Christensen says, “and disruptive innovators suck customers in with fewer features and a cheaper price.” Toyota, Honda, and Nissan disrupted the Big Three’s marketplace by introducing smaller, lighter, less safe, and less comfortable but reliable cars that needed few repairs and got good gas mileage—at a significantly lower price. Within a few years, they had garnered a large share of the market. Says Christensen: “The leaders get killed from below.” A Toyota car, is a Toyota car that was designed to be a car..it was not designed for some other purpose and re-purposed for transportation. Reference: http://harvardmagazine.com/2014/07/disruptive-genius http://harvardmagazine.com/2014/07/disruptive-genius
- imissmyjuno 11y agoi really want a Firefox OS ZTE but it seems impossible to obtain in Canada through any of the carriers.
- aidenn0 11y agoThe last phone I had last for more than 2 years was made by Palm. After that: 1) lost the phone. We think it was left on the roof of my car 2) Dropped in toilet. Did not have removable battery, so it eventually shorted out 3) An OTA firmware update bricked it, the device was 2 months out of warranty so the manufacturer refused to fix it, despite their software being what bricked it. I'm now on a 1st gen Moto X I got used for $100. I don't plan on spending much more than that for a phone ever again.
- andyidsinga 11y agowhat do you use for a computer most of the time? reason I ask: I'm on my galaxy note 4 probably 40% of time and going up.pc/mac get rest of time and going down. got rid of all IOS devices.
- aidenn0 11y agoMost of my time on the computer is at work, so I have a Dell Optiplex with 2 24" screens. At home, I have both a workstation and a laptop, and probably use the laptop more. I use the phone for a quick lookup something, or for reading articles, watching videos &ct.
- andyidsinga 11y agogetting multi-screens connected to my "phone" is the key thing I'm missing. I can do it with one now -- but its not as good as attaching a mac/pc to an external monitor for coding or similar big screen tasks. I'd put cyanogenmod on my note4 - but then I'd loose the cool pen feature that I use a lot. I wonder if intel and microsoft will succeeed in shrinking the tablet/pc all the way down to phone size before the phone guys figure this out - I would love that (disclaimer I work for intel).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rsync 11y agoI have used a MOTO FONE (F3)[1] for 3+ years now. I drop it terribly all the time. It's very small and light and has advanced features like "redial" and "alarm clock". I think it's my favorite phone I've ever had. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_Fone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_Fone
- superuser2 11y agoFor $60 I'd much rather have a 2003-vintage Nokia. The battery would last for weeks. Only thing is I can't live without Google Maps anymore.
- simplexion 11y agoMoto G is the phone I recommend to everyone.