16 ms·
Scientists discover the world contains dramatically more trees than was thought
- elorant 11y agoHow on earth can you miscalculate something like that by almost an order of magnitude when we have satellite imaging around for decades?
- mninm 11y agoFrom the article: "satellite observations and ground-based ecological work. The former gives an overall view of where forests do and don’t exist on the Earth’s surface. But the latter goes underneath the canopy to determine how many trees exist in a given area in a given type of forest." It seems that satellites give a good measure of the acreage covered by forests but are not suitable for differentiating individual trees. To do that requires on the ground sampling and as more sampling is done it is being discovered that the actual number of trees differs substantially from previously established estimates.
- hessenwolf 11y agoDoesn't it seem that acreage is more relevant? (I didn't read the article)
- vidarh 11y agoAcreage doesn't tell you how much biomass there is. Imagine a 1m tall shrub with big leaves and not much underneath vs. a dense rainforest where the top canopy extends tens of metres up and there's massive undergrowth. So I guess the answer it depends what you're trying to measure.
- elorant 11y agoSo basically we have no way of counting trees from pictures? I mean it shouldn't be that hard, right? You have green pixels and brown ones. We have software that can discern car license plates in urban environments where you have a gazillion of different colors in the picture. I guess the need never arise for an automated tree counting algorithm.
- vidarh 11y agoYou'll have green pixels in areas covered by shrubs as well as in areas covered by 40m+ trees intertwined with massive undergrowth. I'm sure we can count trees from pictures reasonably well, but we can't count tree mass that's entirely obscured by other objects. To count trees accurately from pictures would require a vast quantity of footage taken from under the canopy.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoGeneral forest type can probably be determined quite well and I imagine that ecologists have been estimating tree mass of various types of forest for quite some time? Recent developments with laser scanning using drones is likely to improve accuracy too.
- kbutler 11y agoThe whole point of the article is that they've (hopefully) improved the accuracy by using recent developments and combining different types of counts, and that method dramatically increases the count.
- leppr 11y agoDid you even ever set foot in a natural, dense, wild forest? This isn't like in a timber plantation or the park near your home, trees are fighting for light and overlap vertically, and satellite images happen to be two dimensional. Shouldn't be that hard to understand, right?
- benihana 11y ago>So basically we have no way of counting trees from pictures? I mean it shouldn't be that hard, right? Are you a programmer? Have you never had to deal with someone who thinks they're smarter than they are and thinks they know everything get pushy about the simplicity of doing things that are not as simple as they assume? I have, and I can't say I'm a fan of those conversations or the people who initiate them. Your comment feels a lot like that.
- pawelk 11y agoIt's explained in the article. They have combined satellite imagery with observations from underneath the canopy, so they had both the area of forest and tree density in the particular forest. > The scientists were able to reach these estimates by merging together two separate mechanisms for sampling trees — satellite observations and ground-based ecological work. The former gives an overall view of where forests do and don’t exist on the Earth’s surface. But the latter goes underneath the canopy to determine how many trees exist in a given area in a given type of forest. Thus, the study amplified satellite views with no less than 429,775 separate measurements of the density of trees at different locations around the globe.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoMaybe it's me being grumpy this morning, or I'm too used to thinking in log-scales, but 7.6x doesn't strike me as "dramatically" more. It's not even an order of magnitude more! Sounds within the bounds of estimation error, which is what the scientist do, because surely they're not going out there and counting trees one at a time.
- andrea_s 11y agoThat would be like estimating the world population to be 1B instead of 7B, though...
- Ensorceled 11y ago... and, as a Canadian, it would be like you were living in China at the time you made the estimate :-P
- coldtea 11y agoWhat's "dramatically more" is all about context, it's not just about the relative change regarless of what's changed. Wouldn't you consider a 7.6x change in your salary "dramatically more"? >It's not even an order of magnitude more! That's irrelevant. Even in software profiling, making something run "merely" 2x as fast can result in HUGE profits and savings (e.g. the movie studio that gets its rendering done in 3 months instead of 6).
- jessriedel 11y agoThis isn't astrophysics. Personally, I had hoped the climate models would be sensitive enough to depend on 7x changes in key carbon sinks. Maybe they measure carbon absorption per acre rather than per tree and this result doesn't matter?
- danmaz74 11y agoI really wonder why, when talking about climate change, the reference to deforestation has been downplayed so much compared to a few years ago. Isn't that just as important as CO2 emissions?
- masklinn 11y agoDeforestation is a form of CO2 emission: a stable forest is roughly carbon-neutral (over long time scales obviously), a growing forest locks up carbon, a shrinking forest releases carbon.
- dredmorbius 11y agoI'm following the CO₂ emissions discussion less closely than I should, but agricluture generally (broadly scoped, including forestry) is a major contributor. Soil has considerable carbon content, and that can be and is released through human activity and disruption. Livestock account for 18% of CO₂ emissions, agricluture 8% (75% of that from production of ag chemicals -- pesticides and fertiliser). US EPA gives 9% of total CO₂ emissions as from agriculture: http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/sources/agriculture.html http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/sources/agricu... http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/images/ghgemissions/sources-agriculture.png http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/images/ghgemissions/sources... Nature puts the level at ⅓ worldwide: http://www.nature.com/news/one-third-of-our-greenhouse-gas-emissions-come-from-agriculture-1.11708 http://www.nature.com/news/one-third-of-our-greenhouse-gas-e... Deforestation: 6-17% of anthropogenic CO₂ emissions: http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/v2/n3/full/nclimate1354.html http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/v2/n3/full/nclimate13...
- jessriedel 11y ago> Soil has considerable carbon content, and that can be and is released through human activity and disruption. None of your numbers suggest that carbon from soil is significant. The vast majority of carbon involved with agriculture comes burning fuel or from plants (such as when cows eat them and emit gas), and the carbon in plants comes from the air.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- amelius 11y agoIf only we could plug these new numbers into the climate models and press "recompute".
- melling 11y agoMy understanding is that the earth's temperature is increasing within the model's prediction. Is it happening at the lower end?
- merpnderp 11y agoDepends on if you look at the satellite troposphere data or the ground and sea thermometer data. The UAH/RSS satellite data say the troposphere hasn't warmed in ~19 years. The ground/sea based thermometers say we're all going to die in a fire (depending on which data revision you look at).
- robotkilla 11y agoFrom what I'm understanding this discovery doesn't help the current state of global warming: > The study also finds that there are 46 percent fewer trees on Earth than there were before humans started the lengthy, but recently accelerating, process of deforestation. “We can now say that there’s less trees than at any point in human civilization,” > loss of 15.3 billion trees each year... 5 billion of those may grow back each year, so the net loss is more like 10 billion annually. > does not in any way change our understanding of the current rates of deforestation... “It does not say there’s more forest. It just says there’s more trees in the forest,” says Lovejoy. > deforestation is making global warming worse... if we were living on an Earth with close to 6 trillion trees, rather than 3 trillion, climate change would be less severe.
- twblalock 11y agoIt makes no difference. The amount of carbon in the atmosphere has not changed. If anything, this might mean that trees are less effective at reducing carbon than we thought, because there are more trees than we thought there were.
- 11y ago
- williesleg 11y agoNow that's an inconvenient truth!
- pvaldes 11y agoScientists discover the world can support dramatically more humans that was thought after zillions of spermatozoans were found in each male human. A 10 cm trunk diameter pine is not a tree, is a... (let's invent a new word for this) a 'treeddler', a baby. This is a classical case of apparent amount of population after dissapearing of the older trees. You can pack instead a lot of little trees in less space, but is not even remotely the same and only one or two will survive.
- bnegreve 11y ago> A 10 cm trunk diameter pine is not a tree, is a... (let's invent a new word for this) a 'treeddler', a baby. The claim is that the number of trees was dramatically underestimated in previous studies. Which definition of tree was used doesn't make a difference as long as the same definition was used in the previous studies. Unfortunatly this is not made explicit in the article, anyone knows?
- headstorm 11y ago> a 'treeddler' Only if it treeddles! If not, might sapling be a satisfactory existing word? Some dictionaries constrain sapling to 4 inches, which is ~10 cm.
- pvaldes 11y agoSapling is too generic to me. Two leaves in a 2 cm stick is a sapling but a juvenile 5 m high tree is also a sapling. Some trees grow really slow, some plants are not trees but have a 'similar' function in nature (bamboo for example) and a lot of trees begin as multitrunked shrubs. Is not trivial to count trees in a forest when several trunks share the same root system so we can expect a lot of troubles and variations. We should focus in measuring live biomass probably instead. To group different saplings of different species and try to cook a result from this is always a problem. Maybe to make people understanding the consequences of deforestation we need to create a new system and talk instead of ecological categories like seed, seedling, 'treedler', tree and perhaps 'treelder', but I'm just having fun with the words. Ash, for example, is equal to "a common tree" but people forget often that the morphospecies "a 500 years ash" is extinct in most forests (as all species that depend on it). This is like if we try to define and understand human societies just looking at "people from 20 years or less".
- paulajohnson 11y agoFrom what I've heard, it sounds like this is really "new method of counting trees produces much bigger results". The new estimate may be better, but it may not. Paul.
- louhike 11y agoWhy do you sign your comment with your first name?
- rokhayakebe 11y agoThe study also finds that there are 46 percent fewer trees on Earth than there were before humans came into the picture.
- oneJob 11y agoMaybe there is an issue with the idea of "discover"... This sort of hubris is insidious.
- sageikosa 11y agoPerhaps "awakened to their sheer lack of perspective?" That a global total estimate could be off by 8x, should probably bring a few other global estimations into question, but probably won't. Epistemology is a lost art.