8 ms·
Judge Rules 160,000 Uber Drivers Can Sue in a Class Action
- closetnerd 11y agoIs this only Uber drivers or does it effect all ride sharing services?
- aikah 11y agowell it sets a precedent, obviously.
- closetnerd 11y agoThat's unfortunate for Uber because thats sets them up for a competitive disadvantage. Most lawyers would be interested in class actions suits with the potential to yield the most amount of money. Laws might implemented under the guise of fairness but they're rarely upheld with the same vigor and intent.
- funkyy 11y agoSo, Uber might become taxi company soon, just bit more modern?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ps4fanboy 11y agoConsidering how much pressure Uber gets from governments around the world this doesnt surprise me.
- ddoscampaign 11y agoObvious reading between the lines: Uber arrests in France were more to protect Uber employees from being assassinated. [0] French Taxi drivers can fuck some shit up. [1] 0: http://techcrunch.com/2015/06/29/uber-france-leaders-arrested-for-running-illegal-taxi-company/ http://techcrunch.com/2015/06/29/uber-france-leaders-arreste... 1: http://www.cbsnews.com/news/violence-erupts-in-france-during-taxi-driver-strike-against-uber/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/violence-erupts-in-france-during...
- hippo8 11y agoSadly just another reason why employers in the future would prefer a robot worker over a human one. I honestly can't understand this. Why would you make it harder for your own employer to do business. Call Uber whatever you like, but these guys have changed many things, they have helped make a lot of people's lives better.
- pfisch 11y agoidk, maybe Uber shouldn't be allowed to operate illegally by declaring all its employees as contractors. I'm not allowed to do this so I don't really understand why Uber can. If you have a job how would you like being reclassified as a contractor right now. It would only double your tax burden.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mgraczyk 11y agoIf my current job were as a taxi driver and my choices were retain my current job or become a contractor at Uber, I would switch to Uber. Uber would not have been able to succeed early on if it didn't classify its drivers as contractors. The drivers are better off for it. That doesn't mean the drivers shouldn't sue Uber to be employees now that Uber is successful. It's in their self-interest to do so. However, everybody including current Uber drivers would likely be better off long term if they could not sue.
- pfisch 11y ago"If my current job were as a taxi driver and my choices were retain my current job or become a contractor at Uber, I would switch to Uber." Why? I don't think it is very clear that being a Uber driver is better than a taxi driver.
- ddoscampaign 11y agoI had a long chat to a taxi driver medallioned in Chico, Sacramento and SF the other day.# It seems Uber is doing good to bring the fight to the pay-to-play bureaucracy, but it doesn't seem to be showing enough demonstrative acts that their drivers are making more/have better conditions than non-Uber drivers. # This summer, it seemed there were only 1-2 Uber X drivers in Chico which didn't work weekends. If they did, I had a credit to use which would've meant a free ride. Also, the rules in Chico is that a Paradise (a nearby town) company can't pickup in Chico and vice-versa.
- yazaddaruvala 11y ago2024 Headline Class action lawsuit in California: Uber not allowed to replace 360,000 drivers with self driving cars
- yazaddaruvala 11y agoIs it bad that all I care about is getting a self driving Uber-like?
- bpodgursky 11y agoidk why people are instinctively downvoting. If Uber drivers are really classified as employees, and the NLRB decides that whatever category this is has a right to force collective bargaining, they could very easily prevent self-driving cars from being rolled out by Uber. Many unions, famously automotive ones at GM, have blocked the closures of plants which were running at 10% capacity.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoActually, false. The NLRB could not decide not to allow self driving cars. What could happen is local or state governments could acquire self driving cars and then provide rides to citizens (as they do with other mass transit systems), and legislate private self driving car companies out of existence (as the roads are government-owned).
- bpodgursky 11y ago? I never claimed the NLRB could prevent it. I said that Uber's drivers could unionize, and through collective bargaining, that union could prevent the rollout (from their point of view, prevent Uber from laying off any drivers). Which is absolutely true.
- zzalpha 11y agoUmm no. They couldn't. Uber, today, is (probably) breaking the law by hiring contractors but treating them as employees. It's actually a very easy line to cross and any contractor or business working with contractors should know those laws well, as crossing that line without reporting it is, among other things, a violation of tax law (and I guarantee you if Ubers contractors are classified as employees, they'll be hearing from the IRS). Roboticizing the workforce does not involve breaking labour and tax laws. It's simply replacing labour with automation, something that's been going on since the cotton gin was invented.
- pm24601 11y ago> Human nature is incredibly easy to understand and predict: on average people want to work the least hours necessary, for the most income possible. I don't mind the downvotes on this. ROTFL, LMAO Really? Yet another true believer in the "Rational Market Theory". Yet another techie type that thinks humans are rational. ... yet you can't explain: * Love, * why marketing works, * why shiny pretty packaging effects how people perceive the quality of the product in the packaging, * or why people use price as an indicator of status. ( are those $300 pair of jeans really 10x better than a $30 pair ? ) If you can't explain and predict those non-"logical" behaviors, stop thinking you understand how people will budget their time. Give me the downvotes, I don't care :-)
- ZoeZoeBee 11y agoThe answer to most of those questions is people are generally uneducated sheep attracted to shiny objects and the American consumer cares far more about quantity than they do quality, an accurate reflection of its society
- pm24601 11y agoReally? So why did Steve Jobs pay so much attention to the unboxing experience. And only uneducated people fall in love?
- ZoeZoeBee 11y agoYes really, logically what does the unboxing have to do with the use or value of the object, its not a coincidence Apple fanboys are often referred to as iSheep, Jobs knew that better than anyone.... Statistically the more intelligent and educated a person is the less time they are to devote towards Love.
- pm24601 11y agoIts a shame Steve Jobs got married and had 4 kids. Think about how much more time he would have had to create new gadgets. So now tell me about your love life?
- philip1209 11y agoThis could have turned out so differently if it were forced into mandatory arbitration.
- hackuser 11y agoCopied from an HN user who said much better than I could: [1] [EDIT: I'm now questioning, is it appropriate to repost their words without their knowledge or consent?] Human labor is not a commodity. This was the common sense amongst all working people for most of the 20th century. Samuel Gompers, maybe the most conservative labor leader of his time, said "You cannot weigh the human soul on the same scales as piece of pork." And working people, along with the management class for the most part, understood this to be an undeniable truth. In fact, this piece of common sense was enshrined into US law with the Clayton Act of 1914, which stated "The labor of a human being is not a commodity or article of commerce." But in the last 20 years, as capital has gained the firm upper hand, the common sense understanding has shifted towards the idea that labor is in fact a commodity. The ideas behind the so-called "on-demand workforce" further solidify the notion that labor is a commodity. After all, you can order an uber ride just as easily as you can order vitamins online. It's so pervasive that even I, someone born into a union family and a firm believer in the idea of worker solidarity, have to force myself to believe that labor is not a commodity. Why? The business class treated labor as expendable in 1915, just as they do in 2015. Why did working people understand this truth in 1915 but not today? I don't know. I read a recently released sociology book earlier this year (going crazy looking for the title/author, can't find it), that posits millennials are far more likely than any recent generation to blame themselves for the problems they face. It's part of the reason that the self-help industry is bigger business than it's ever been. It's not always your fault. Our modern economy is built on rotten ideas like labor = commodity. If we want to do something about inequality, it's time that we subject fundamentally unjust ideas like these to a serious critique. [1] Thank you maceo: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9502757 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9502757
- skwirl 11y ago>The ideas behind the so-called "on-demand workforce" further solidify the notion that labor is a commodity. After all, you can order an uber ride just as easily as you can order vitamins online. How does this make Uber drivers any more or less of a commodity than the taxi drivers they replace?
- jstalin 11y agoThe case docket is available online as well: https://www.unitedstatescourts.org/federal/cand/269290/ https://www.unitedstatescourts.org/federal/cand/269290/
- ZoeZoeBee 11y agoUber is preparing for this by building one of the best robotics divisions in the world, be careful what you wish for Uber drivers, you may just quicken your obsolescence
- s73v3r 11y agoYup. Fuck people who want to be treated fairly. Profits are more important, amirite?
- dragonwriter 11y agoThat seems to encourage, rather than discourage, efforts to assure that current drivers get the most while they can.
- closetnerd 11y agoUntil it becomes an effort that inevitably leads current drivers to becoming luddites so they can keep their jobs.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAnd then we just tax Uber and their robotics-generated revenue (note I said revenue, not profit; profit can be gamed). That's what Hacker News doesn't get. You're not entitled to a profit. You're not entitled to "disrupt". And if we change laws so you squeeze technology-heavy companies in order to support people displaced who no longer can find jobs, that's how it goes (does "eminent domain" ring a bell? if intellectual property is "property", what stops taking that?). You can serve bits from anywhere. Physical infrastructure? Good luck profiting off of that from another jurisdiction. EDIT: HN, you make me chuckle. A US court is about to slam the hell out of Uber for violating labor law, and everyone here is up in arms about how their match-driver-to-passenger unicorn couldn't possibly be required to bow to "mere mortal" law.
- onewaystreet 11y ago> A US court is about to slam the hell out of Uber for violating labor law The class action suit will be tied up in the courts for another decade. FedEx has been fighting this same fight for years and the vast majority of its drivers remain independent contractors.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoI really do not understand. If you want to be classified as an employee, it's simple, don't drive for Uber. They're offering a particular type of job for particular people, it's clear up front. You have a choice.
- s73v3r 11y agoNo. I don't care if they don't have to drive for Uber or not. That does not mean Uber gets to ignore employment law.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> They're offering a particular type of job for particular people, it's clear up front. The reason this is in court is that some people think that the particular job they are offering and the working conditions actually experienced in that job meet the legal requirements for employee (vs. contractor) status in US labor law, triggering the legal protection according to that status.
- kazinator 11y agoI hear what you're saying, but labor laws have had their place historically, on the other hand! Let's warp back in time to Industrial Revolution England. "If those children kids don't want to be exploited, working fourteen hour shift in the factory, they can find something else to do." People sometimes have choices only in theory: like when we consider one particular choice, versus some unspecified others.
- mmanfrin 11y ago"I really do not understand. If you don't want to work 14 hours a day, it's simple, don't work for these factories. They're offering a particular type of job for particular people, it's clear up front. You have a choice." - Opponents of the 8 hour work day during the industrial era. Regulations on employment are there for a reason -- you cannot say that an employer is free to ignore them because people 'don't have to work there'.
- dylanjermiah 11y ago