12 ms·
Understanding ETF “Flash Crashes”
- stygiansonic 11y agoFor a related article concerning this sort of market microstructure and the behavior of its participants, see this post by Matt Levine: http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2014-12-01/apple-had-a-rough-morning http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2014-12-01/apple-had-a... I especially liked this quote: "The equity market is set up to dampen small movements (market makers tend to buy when others are selling), to exacerbate mid-size movements (as market makers capitulate and stops get triggered), and to dampen large movements (as circuit breakers cut off trading and let algorithms catch their breath)." From my layman's point of view, it seems like this sort of "system behavior" is a peculiar emergent property that derives from the rules of the system and the individual actions of the actors working under those rules.
- mrchicity 11y agoDefinitely. That's the world of market microstructure. You could certainly change the rules but there might be other unintended consequences. For example, removing circuit breakers could make people less confident in the market since a fat finger order or error could mean Game Over instead of a manageable but significant loss.
- drcode 11y agoSo, the take-home for me seems to be that there are weird regulations on these types of ETFs that block liquidity (like the "current single stock circuit breaker rule") and when you take that and combine that with preset orders (mainly stop loss orders) you have all you need to create a textbook chaotic system.
- kasey_junk 11y agoThe regulations aren't "weird" and they aren't based on etfs. There are well documented trading halt conditions regulated at the country level that restrict all the equities exchanges that want to be public venues.
- drcode 11y agoThe weird part is that they presumably exist to reduce volatility, but if everyone has to put their order in for 2 seconds every five minutes it just makes the volatility much much worse. If they really feel that a circuit breaker serves does something useful here (and I'm skeptical this is the case) they should stop trading for longer periods of time and allow a larger window between haltings in order to allow all trade participants put in an order and not just a few of the fastest HFT engines.
- lmm 11y agoEveryone has an HFT engine. Five minutes is intended to be long enough for a human to have a think and then put their orders into their engine - then there's an opening auction and theoretically the price stabilises as the humans will have reached some kind of consensus. The circuit breakers only tripped again because they hadn't - which suggests that either there really was disagreement between market actors (and the volatility was in some sense correct), or that some participants were trading poorly - whether that's automated systems, human traders, or brokers executing retail orders. I don't see what you think extending the circuit breaker time would accomplish? "Allowing a larger window between haltings" would defeat the whole point - if the price moves by more than 10% immediately after the re-opening auction, the circuit breaker goes off, as it's supposed to, for all the reasons it goes off whenever there's a sudden >10% price move.
- drcode 11y agoSo your thesis is that this circuit breaker was effective at reducing volatility for the ETF described in the top article? (I don't know how to counter your arguments, since your claims seem to contradict the empirical evidence from the original post)
- lmm 11y agoNo, I'm objecting to your second paragraph. I don't think the circuit breaker was particularly effective; I think the problems are fundamental and having a longer time on the circuit breaker wouldn't make any difference.
- dnadig 11y agoThe single stock circuit breakers were put into effect after the 2010 "flash crash" and they're designed to "let cooler heads prevail" when stocks or ETFs go wonky. The problem is that in a real panicky freefall, it just makes the window where the stock is trading very very small (it halts for 5 minutes, opens, hits the next breaker, halts for another 5 minutes, etc.) It happens both up AND down. This last monday was really the first time they'd been tested en mass.
- aianus 11y agoWho cares if stocks flash crash? If you're buying stock for short term profit you deserve to be screwed by volatility and I have no sympathy for you.
- josu 11y ago>If you're buying stock for short term profit you deserve to be screwed by volatility and I have no sympathy for you These people increase market liquidity, they too serve a purpose. If only long term investors were in the market, the exchanges would end up looking like ebay.
- netrus 11y agoWhy would that be a bad thing? (honest question)
- mrchicity 11y agoBecause most people have things they'd rather do than playing trader when their expertise is in something else. Being able to trade in and out of assets at a fair price at any time is valuable. Would you rather have your net worth tied up in a liquid index ETF or illiquid startup equity?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoIf I need the cash more than a few years out, whichever provides the highest return, like all long term investments.
- VLM 11y agoThe linked article interpretation is really good as a long format, but as a very short format in EE-ish math-ish terms HN readers will likely understand, market prices are not fractal and are occasionally very noisy on small scale. They aren't fractal in that they are strongly scale sensitive, and at a small scale over a short enough time period on an unusual day you're basically looking at noise. As per innumerable statistical analysis given enough noise samples all possible values (of price) are eventually, however temporarily, touched. "Lastly, if we’re concerned about protecting individual investors, we need better education and controls around the most dangerous tool in the ETF investor’s toolbox: the market order." Seriously, those things should just be banned from retail investment and retail investment education.
- usertaken 11y ago"Seriously, those things should just be banned from retail investment and retail investment education." The problem is we aren't just talking about ETFs...there were similar effects happening in individual stocks where they were down much, much greater than this ETF. We should just ban stocks for retail investors? What's wrong with people learning about things before they throw money into something they don't understand? Banning this and banning that blindly just makes people more dependent on someone else doing their homework for them. People need to take responsibility for their own actions and read up on stuff before dumping money into something.
- testerralph 11y ago> Sleeping-stops kill...If you had a stop to sell if RSP crossed under $70, say, right after the open, your order became a market order, and you could have been executed anywhere in the line of terrible trades. Is there another mechanism that serves the same purpose as a market order, but that isn't quite so vulnerable to these flash panics? Maybe something like "sell if it stays below $X for more than an hour"? Though I guess that wouldn't save you if the crash really was because of bad news.
- seanhunter 11y agoI used to work on the algo-trading desk of a big brokerage firm (so writing trading algorithms that execute other people's orders for them), and I have to say almost always if someone sends a market order, it would be safer for them if they sent the same thing as an aggressive IOC ("Immediate or Cancel") limit order. The IOC flag gives similar semantics to a market order (in that no portion of your order is going to stay on the book if it's unfilled), but you are guaranteed to execute no worse than the limit you have set. This is clearly way better in situations where the market has big dislocations.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoThe problem with the IOC order is that you have execution risk. I.e. quite possibly your order isn't filled. Then if your favorite stock were to go down and stay down, you would still be holding it. In short there is no perfect "stop loss" order. There is either price risk or execution risk - pick your poison. That said, unlimited price risk and zero execution risk is probably NOT the optimal point to be at.
- secabeen 11y agoI'm not sure about that. If the market is moving in an orderly fashion, and you're trading in a very liquid asset, market orders remove a psychological impediment to trading. For someone who trades 3-5 times a year, doing a limit order requires additional consideration (making sure you're doing the right limit, setting a limit price, etc.) If you just want to buy or sell some stock for reasons totally unrelated to trading, It's rational to accept a tiny risk that the market is going to have a shit fit between when you hit submit and when your order is filled 2 seconds later when the news is quiet. Certainly, I would never put in a market order when the market is operating under circuit-breakers and things are unstable. When things are stable, it can be a reasonable choice for someone transacting in stock who just wants it done so they can get on with other things they have to do.
- hiou 11y agoAre we sure causing those halts was unintentional?
- kasey_junk 11y agoAre you suggesting a market actor was manipulating the market so that no one could trade? Can you come up with a scenario where someone could make money doing that?
- hiou 11y agoI'm not sure. The halt is broadly applied across over the counter and exchange markets and introduces additional opacity into the system over a 5 minute window which seems like it could be useful to someone.
- TheLoneWolfling 11y agoExtending arbitrage with other markets, perhaps?
- btbuildem 11y agoOne scenario would be to gum up the market during a volatile time - eg to retain "value" while investors are panicking. But I would lean towards the halts being an unintentional (as in: not well thought through) consequences of all the layers of regulation and counter-regulation.
- lmm 11y agoCertain? No. But never attribute to malice &c.
- inglor 11y agoPfft. https://www.tipranks.com/etf/rsp https://www.tipranks.com/etf/rsp
- vasilipupkin 11y ago"When irrational actors are at work (and let’s be clear, anyone selling RSP for half off isn’t being rational), the smartest thing to do, if you’re the actual human being watching RSP trade, is to simply step out for a cup of coffee". If you honestly believe that selling for 50% off is irrational, then you should not step out for coffee but put in bids and buy that ETF. That's the rational thing to do, conditional on your beliefs about valuation.
- maguirre 11y agoI would guess that this specific advice would be for those who already own the securities currently being sold at 50% "discount".
- vasilipupkin 11y agoI thought the discussion was about market makers, not long term investors? but yes, if you already own your full allocation, then the advice is sound.
- dnadig 11y agoWell, plenty of traders are out there selling without actually owning -- that's something market makers and only market makers are allowed to do, and it's certainly possible that market makers algos were selling too low along with high frequency traders. But regardless, when you have a derivatively priced security like RSP (which holds actual stocks -- it has some inherent worth at all times that's knowable) any selling at a discount is supposed to be arbitraged away. In these cases, it wasn't,because the trading windows were too short. (Hi, I'm the author of that blog post).
- vasilipupkin 11y agoright. So if you think selling is irrational and you don't already own it, you should buy, not walk away. If you are not buying, it means you don't believe that the discount is irrational.
- wusatiuk 11y ago
- wusatiuk 11y agoWhat i don´t understand is - there are arbitrage players, who calculate "real value" of the single stocks in each ETF. Aren´t they liquid enough? Because if they were, the price would not drop that much, would it?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lmm 11y agoA lot of stocks were hitting circuit breakers IIRC, so some of the underlying single stocks simply weren't trading for part of the time.
- wusatiuk 11y agoahh, so arbitrage players simply paused trading, as their automated calculations where incomplete?
- lmm 11y agoYeah. A human can probably spot the difference between a flash crash and a true crash, at least after making a few phone calls - but by that point the opportunity has probably gone.
- minimax 11y agoI know it's anecdotal, but I have heard from some of my human prop trader friends about guys who made a killing buying on Monday morning.
- phkahler 11y agoThis whole thing was triggered at opening. Why does the market even close these days? There is "after hours" trading going on for some people. Why shouldn't the computers be running 24/7? Is there some batch stuff that goes on after close? I've seen cases where transactions were unwound, but aren't we nearing real-time across the board?
- jperras 11y agoWouldn't you like to sleep, at some point?
- aianus 11y agoBanks can (and already do) have multiple shifts. I used to work for a forex broker (forex is 24h a day) and we had offices in different timezones (Toronto, New York, London, Singapore) so we would always have trader coverage without requiring night shifts.
- branchless 11y agoAnd you had full 3rd level knowledge of all issues in all regions? Or key people in key regions who got woke up a lot? They should run these things for an hour a day 4 days a week. It's just a game, we don't need this.
- aianus 11y agoYou don't have to participate. But I don't see how it's your business if people want to trade equities 24h a day any more than if people want to open a 24h McDonald's.
- branchless 11y agoIt's not "my business" but it's my opinion that tech has enabled far more finance business to occur and that this is not "a good thing". Finance needs to be a means to an end not the end in and of itself.
- roymurdock 11y agoEquity markets have become so complex and convoluted. It seems like a silly game of people trying to fool each other through layers of abstraction: How can we take the fundamentally abstract idea of a company, its products, its business model, and its future potential, abstract that one level to a claim for some "portion of the company" (one share of equity, or a stock), abstract that into an index that tracks a portfolio of companies based on some abstracted notion of how to weigh different companies to model some desired strategy that tracks a market, sector, or industry. Then we're going to build software in order to abstract the task of trading whatever residual is leftover from this process amongst ourselves using formulas and algorithms that we think will outperform or trick other formulas and algorithms. It's fascinatingly complex, which is why I suspect so many people on HN are trying to figure out how things like an ETF flash crash could happen. But for the average retail investor, it's damn-near impossible to comprehend.
- harryh 11y agoThe average retail investor doesn't need to comprehend it.
- roymurdock 11y agoAgreed. But if retail investors are allowed to plow money into the stock market, then regulators need to understand it. Which I'm not sure is the case/is entirely possible with the complexity of modern finance. The average consumer doesn't need to know anything about the drugs she takes. She just needs to know that the drugs are FDA approved and that she can trust the FDA. I guess it comes down to how much you trust the SEC, FINRA, NYSE, etc. to stabilize and support markets. I have no idea if they're doing a good job or not. Any thoughts?
- __d 11y agoThere are opinions on both sides. Some are quite insistent that the SEC etc are not doing enough: eg. Themis, Nanex, most of the ZeroHedge crowd. I think the "SEC is doing fine" crowd is less noisy, but probably the majority. Of course, opinions can be influenced by whether the management of the markets is to your financial benefit, and perhaps that's why there seem to be a more people saying nothing: they're heads down, quietly making a fortune ... It's worth noting (again) that the LULD circuit breakers were introduced after the 2010 flash crash, as an attempt by the regulators to "stabilize and support" markets. In some previous events, I think they've worked better than they did on Monday.