11 ms·
A Woman Who Spent Six Years Fighting a Traffic Stop
- cafard 11y agoGood for Lavardain and the appellate court.
- ars 11y agoI've always felt that all fines - for any cause - should be turned over to the state. Even simple parking tickets. The state should fund the court for hearing those cases (but not enforcement). Then we'll see if cities really care about safety or about money.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoThen the state will get used to having a certain volume of such funds, and the departments that provide a substantial fraction of those funds will tend to get looked on favorably...that doesn't end well, either.
- mjevans 11y agoFines should go directly to a federally recognized not-for-profit. This is how repaying the community for a fine-able offence could be made. Also they should be /on top of/ damages. (In the case of most non-accident traffic matters, the 'damages' are non-existent.)
- briandear 11y agoNope. The Clinton Foundation is a "Federally Recognized not-for-profit." Could you imagine the stratospheric levels of corruption of non profits start to demand law enforcement revenues. The money should go to the general revenue fund but as an offset against tax income. More fines: lower taxes (which essentially means that the fines are distributed to the taxpayers, which is completely fair since the crime is against "the people." Law enforcement should never get fine money. That's a huge conflict of interest. It would be like a foreign government donating to the non profit of a sitting Secretary of State.
- realityking 11y agoThere actually is a system like this in place in Germany. Not for traffic fines, but if you get a fine in criminal court (technically your case is suspended conditionally on paying X€) it will go to a local charity. Caused quite a bit of drama a few months ago when the "Kinderschutzbund" refused the payment in a widely publicized child pornography case (the defendant was a member of the federal parliament at the time of the crime) despite accepting it before in similar cases.
- dibujante 11y agoProbably the money should simply be destroyed. There's too much conflict of interest when law enforcement can become a profit centre.
- ahallock 11y agoThere's a 25 MPH speed trap near me (no schools or anything nearby) that uses photo enforcement instead of actual police officers. It's basically an ATM for the tiny village of 179 residents. In 2013, they stopped 26 people for going too slow. Yes, too slow. Edit: more about Linndale: http://www.cleveland.com/metro/index.ssf/2014/12/linndale_with_its_reputation_a.html http://www.cleveland.com/metro/index.ssf/2014/12/linndale_wi...
- sliverstorm 11y agoYou could say the same thing about alcohol & vice taxes. It might make more sense than I realize, but destroying punitive damages seems like a terrible option. Damages are meant to penalize the offender; destroying wealth penalizes everyone.
- ahallock 11y agoSo how do you remove the conflict of interest? They have every incentive to abuse these revenue (more like theft) streams and become dependent on them.
- sliverstorm 11y ago"Send it far, far away" might be enough. It was only after local police departments started getting a cut of civil asset forfeitures (they used to be sent to the FBI, I believe) that counties started abusing it. There are surely other options too, such as spreading it out. You could fund a flat tax credit for all residents of the county with the fines. The wealth is not destroyed, and if the credit is on the order of a handful of dollars per resident, no one is going to have any strong incentives. You could vote to double all traffic fines- but if you personally stand to gain $3.72 from that doubling, the incentive exists but is very small.
- ptaipale 11y agoThen the state will start profiteering, as they do where I live. Here the government decided to just double the speeding fines, and they still pretend they do it for "traffic safety". It's a farce.
- crazyideaman 11y agoYou could remove all perverse incentives by putting all fines, fees, etc into a state fund that is paid back annually to citizens via a rebate of some sort. All funding of government would come only from taxes. This would eliminate any financial benefit to the government from fines, fees, and asset forfeiture.
- 542458 11y agoWow - that's a much more interesting article than the title would imply. I wonder if anything changed in Woodworth in response to the verdict (I doubt that it did, but still).
- repsilat 11y agoThe article seemed to try to indicate that Parker's (outragrous) treatment was indicative of a more systemic problem, but I didn't think the argument held up very well. So Woodworth collects a lot of revenue by enforcing the speed limits. Good for them. What is the connection to Parker's case? Is it just the implication that the town is too focussed on revenue-raising? That's pretty weak. As is the implication of racism, really. This one incident seemed arbitrary, not targeted. Again, without evidence of a wider pattern this just seems like one (egregiously) bad case of motivated reasoning in a town that (charitably put) seems generally to be interested in upholding the law to the letter.
- cperkins 11y agoThis is an issue that people are only recently getting a grip on. In isolation all these cases seem arbitrary and not targeted. And, absent any overt action, it can seem difficult to ascribe racism. Additionally the court system has made it very difficult to use "statistical" evidence in individual cases. But, when one steps back and look at the statistics, an overwhelming number of practices by law enforcement are disproportionately applied to people of color. This includes "fishing trip" stops, "consent" pretext searches, as well as unequal application in the court system (bail practices, pressuring to plead guilty by "overcharging", and more).
- icebraining 11y agoYou wouldn't say that if it was your dog being put on probation!
- bkmartin 11y agoYeah, that had to stop a bunch more people to recoup that $30,000+ in court rulings.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- conistonwater 11y ago> The original citations were reasonable... but the stop itself was not reasonable.
- mikeash 11y agoIndeed. The officer pulled them over for no reason. This isn't even disputed. The officer admitted as much, apparently thinking this is something he's allowed to do. The entire stop should have been voided instantaneously the moment it touched a court because of this.
- Cadsby 11y agoGiven that the original search was blatantly illegal, the original citations were not in fact reasonable. Law Enforcement generally gets away with this behavior, in part, because the public only pays attention to the end result (in this case "no insurance") and pays no mind to the fact that a search was never justified in the first place.
- youreadit 11y agoI recommend YOU read the appellate cases. It was established that NONE of the citations were correct. She had a valid license, registration, and insurance at the time of the illegal stop. The second appeal makes this crystal clear. (http://caselaw.findlaw.com/la-court-of-appeal/1693755.html http://caselaw.findlaw.com/la-court-of-appeal/1693755.html) Nothing about the situation was valid. Not the stop, not the citations. There's a reason why she was willing to fight a traffic stop for 6 years, and why an attorney would take on such a penny-ante case: because it was pure injustice, top to bottom. Perpetuating the notion that the victim had legitimate charges dismissed on the technicality of an illegal stop is wrong practically unto libelous. Don't do that.
- realityking 11y agoTo be fair, how should the officer have known that the license and registration are valid?
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoI used to live near a town like this. Thornton, Illinois is the site of a giant limestone quarry and there's one major road you can drive on to get around the quarry if you don't want to get on the expressway (which is a bit out of the way depending on where you're coming from). These streets have 25 or 30mph signs, yet are wide and underutilized enough to easily be 35-45mph streets. Drivers unfamiliar with the area would be taken off-guard by these slow speed zones as they enter from neighboring towns. The police there pull people over for 2 or 3 mph over regularly. According to IDOT, there were 2,334 traffic stops in Thornton in 2014. This town's population? About 2,300. That's one stop per man, woman, and child in this town! This is naked profiteering and pretty much all small towns in strategic areas turn into police-led profit centers. The real question is why isn't anyone stopping this?
- bryondowd 11y agoHammonton, NJ is one of these, I believe. Along with some other towns along the White Horse Pike in the middle of South Jersey. You cruise along the pike at 55, because the limit is 50, and then you hit Hammonton, where the speed limit drops to 35 with no visible cues, just one speed limit sign that is often obscured by foliage. And there are always police patrolling this tiny stretch of road, or parked alongside with speed guns. And of course, they are happy to allow you to use the NJ statute that lets you plea to a no points charge of 'unsafe driving' instead of speeding, with a much higher fine. I'd love to see a financial report on this town, and ones like it in NJ. Likewise, I expect Atlantic City and a couple of towns around it have a similar relationship with minor drug charges.
- tanderson92 11y agoHammonton native here (small world, Hi!); I've driven on those roads for a few years. Even to those who have driven on these roads all our lives it gets confusing, though I do understand that if a road passes by all the major ordinary shopping centers in a small town, it does warrant a lower speed limit. If you thought Rt. 30 is bad, try Central Ave (Rt. 542); that speed limit changes every 500 feet or so, and the police love pulling people over there.
- 11y ago
- rayiner 11y ago> Larvadain, who is now 74, worries that young lawyers are less concerned with right and wrong than with chasing dollars. Although Patricia Parker’s lawsuit against Woodworth offered small hope of a big payday, Larvadain agreed to represent her. “Because I saw wrong had taken place. And I knew someone had to take a stand.” I know a lot of young lawyers who'd love to take on a case like this one. But matching people who need help to lawyers who have the time and institutional resources to take on these projects pro bono isn't easy when you're talking about folks wronged in rural Louisiana. Also, I think there's something of a hesitancy to for business law firms to add suing municipalities to their pro bono docket. Which is a shame--a few New Orleans firms building up a pipeline of pro bono suits against places like Woodsworth could do a lot of good. EDIT: If you're interested in (potential) justice porn, it's worth following Fant v. City of Ferguson. The DOJ gave a lot of ammunition to plaintiffs' lawyers when it concluded that the city was systematically using fines and other police actions as revenue sources, particularly against poor black people. It's Woodsworth writ large. The complaint is here: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/02/08/us/ferguson-complaint.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/02/08/us/ferguson-co.... The docket is available here on Justia: https://dockets.justia.com/docket/missouri/moedce/4:2015cv00253/138015 https://dockets.justia.com/docket/missouri/moedce/4:2015cv00.... With her opinion last month on reconsideration, the judge has effectively denied the city's motion to dismiss. Dispositive motions are due May of next year, so we'll likely see by then whether this is granted class status. If so, things will get interesting.
- edw519 11y agoFirst: ...young lawyers are less concerned with right and wrong than with chasing dollars. then: But matching people who need help to lawyers who have the time and institutional resources to take on these projects pro bono isn't easy... Sounds like an excellent opportunity for a startup that is more concerned with right and wrong than with chasing dollars. Any takers?
- dswiese 11y agodoubtful. it can't be delivered in under an hour by a contractor.
- gknoy 11y agoIn case you miss the link inside the article, be sure to read the ruling[0]. It is both thorough and entertaining. http://www.la3circuit.org/Opinions/2015/03/030415/14-0943opi.pdf http://www.la3circuit.org/Opinions/2015/03/030415/14-0943opi...
- qiqing 11y agoWow. "A woman told the paper that she was pulled over by Woodworth police while in labor — and was kept for more than a half hour."
- bernardom 11y agoYeah, that got to me. I spent a good few minutes wondering whether I'd physically assault a police officer who was preventing my wife from getting to the hospital.
- mikeash 11y agoI wonder if it would be useful to call 911 in that situation. Even though the authorities are involved, getting some more people aware of what's going on might put a stop to the nonsense.
- icebraining 11y agoIt might help - but then again, it might not: http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/547/transcript http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/547/t...
- TheCapn 11y agoRealistically the correct course of action is to call the non-emergency dispatch or call 911 and immediately inform them that this is not an emergency and to inform them the situation. "An officer has turned on his lights and siren on Highway #101 but I am <continuing to the hospital>/<driving to a public/lit/safe location>." Dispatch should contact the officer, relay information and they can return the details to you. Whether or not the police take offense and make your life hell is another story.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoIt's generally not a good idea to assault a person with a gun.
- 11y ago
- barsonme 11y ago> in fiscal year 2006, each officer wrote an average of 1,539 tickets. Assuming a 2080 hour work year, that's 1.3 tickets per hour. To my (admittedly naive) idea of how many tickets police write per hour, that's nuts.
- NathanKP 11y agoYour ratio is reversed. It is 1.3 hours per ticket, or .73 tickets per hour.
- 11thEarlOfMar 11y agoRead the judges findings from the appeal. The article did not even mention the purported signed confession: "Ms. Parker admitted that she made the initials “PP” but stated that none of the other handwriting was hers. She also indicated that none of the other handwriting was on the document, including Ms. Gunter’s signature, when she filled in the initials “PP.”" Woodsworth went so far as to commit fraud in order to take money from Parker. http://www.la3circuit.org/Opinions/2015/03/030415/14-0943opi.pdf http://www.la3circuit.org/Opinions/2015/03/030415/14-0943opi... (thx gknoy)
- revelation 11y agoIf you want this to stop, presumably you need to step out of the middle age and allow actual automated speed cams as every other country does. Now, there are two sides here. A matter of fact debtors prison for poor people and a vicious cycle where they keep accumulating more fines through inability of paying is a travesty of law. But I can hardly sympathize with the discussion on speed traps, in a country where apparently 10mph over is considered a crass misuse of law (here, this nets you a month long driving ban) and tickets need to be written by officers, which naturally drastically limits enforcement, and driving on a suspended license is seen as a violation on the level of failure to use turn signals. Frankly, driving without a valid license should cause your car to be immediately and permanently impounded and any license only reissued on a retest after a ban. We can't get into a situation where having a valid license is more or less immaterial.
- klagermkii 11y agoAre you writing from a place that has an efficient and reliable public transport network that runs around the clock? If you are then I don't mind heavy enforcement of suspended licenses, but if you aren't when you clamp down on the "privilege" of driving a car you may also be destroying their ability to support themselves and their family. Having heavy punishments on a necessity like transport, without an adequate replacement, is hugely skewed against the poor. The rich can get someone else to drive or have their lawyer fight their license points, but the poor get disproportionately screwed.
- gorena 11y agoAmericans complaining about speed traps and red light cameras are a constant embarrassment to me. I live in New York. This city should look like a less architecturally tasteful version of Amsterdam. Instead, it's infested with cars. We should have red light cameras at every intersection, zero-tolerance enforcement of speeding laws, congestion charging, etc., instead the subway is crumbling. I've given up, I'm starting to learn Dutch... I want to live somewhere that actually cares about transportation.
- redblacktree 11y ago
- netfire 11y ago“Godwin’s testimony shows a complete lack of knowledge of the restraints imposed upon police conduct by the U.S. Constitution and the laws and Constitution of the State of Louisiana.” This. The 4th amendment protects against seizure (which a police stop constitutes) without reasonable suspicion of a crime. The problem is, unless you are fined, as the woman was in this case, and then appeal, what recourse do you have? Is there some way to seek damages for the violation of your constitutional rights? (even if the inconvenience is minor) It seems like this problem would go away if the police department and city had to pay for their violations of the constitution instead of just forfeiting potential money from fines.
- callesgg 11y agoIs there some way to seek damages for the violation of your constitutional rights? Sure "just" sue them.
- netfire 11y agoCan you sue someone simply for the violation of your constitutional rights? In this case, the defendant had to pay fines, was a victim of false arrest, spent 25 days in jail and changed jobs to avoid driving through the town. What I'm asking is, if you hadn't suffered such injustices, and had just been pulled over and let go without a fine or charges, would you still have grounds to sue the city simply over the violation of your constitutional rights? (that is, just for the unlawful seizure under the 4th amendment) How much damages would be appropriate in such a situation?
- callesgg 11y agoI would assume so. Your rights are your rights. In my mind a few 1000$ but i dont actually know. In practice the proceeding legal battle would probably not be worth it.
- tsotha 11y agoYou have to be able to show you've suffered an injury (in the legal sense) that gives you standing to sue. Just getting pulled over and let go might count as such an injury, but how much can you reasonably expect in compensatory damages? It's not worth the time and money.
- rasz_pl 11y agoLife imitates art? This is straight from 'Nothing But Trouble' (1991)
- xacaxulu 11y agoThis is quintessential americana.
- travelervdriver 11y agoit is completely unlawful to require non-commercial travellers on public roads to have licenses, insurance, inspections, and registrations, let alone subject them to stops, arrests and tickets or fines when no crime has been committed. unless actual or imminent destruction of property, or violation of anothers' rights has occurred, there is no valid cause of action. no right for a stop. traveling on public roads is not a privilege granted by the government [1]. it's already been adjudicated, by the supreme court, and state supreme courts, many times [2]. it seems, however, that the irrational fear of chaos and harm that might result from people travelling without government licensing and regulation is enough to keep these absurd and sometimes incredibly harmful and costly situations going for the foreseeable future. ask yourself; would you spend tens of thousands on a vehicle only to crash it into others' property, or use it to intentionally murder or otherwise harm others? no? have you ever met anyone who would? if yes, would having or not having a license in their wallet stop such a person? i don't think so. police should only be involved when actual crimes occur or are potentially about to occur. see a vehicle hit a mailbox, get in a wreck, with a leaky exhaust disturbing the peace, or someone driving recklessly endangering others, etc. then you can call 911. search "Driver Licensing vs. Right to Travel", for a fuller list of relevant case law. [1] "Personal liberty largely consists of the Right of locomotion -- to go where and when one pleases -- only so far restrained as the Rights of others may make it necessary for the welfare of all other citizens. The Right of the Citizen to travel upon the public highways and to transport his property thereon, by horse drawn carriage, wagon, or automobile, is not a mere privilege which may be permitted or prohibited at will, but the common Right which he has under his Right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Under this Constitutional guarantee one may, therefore, under normal conditions, travel at his inclination along the public highways or in public places, and while conducting himself in an orderly and decent manner, neither interfering with nor disturbing another's Rights, he will be protected, not only in his person, but in his safe conduct." II Am.Jur. (1st) Constitutional Law, Sect.329, p.1135 [2] "The right to travel is part of the Liberty of which a citizen cannot deprived without due process of law under the Fifth Amendment. This Right was emerging as early as the Magna Carta." Kent vs. Dulles, 357 US 116 (1958) "The essential elements of due process of law are ... Notice and The Opportunity to defend." Simon vs. Craft, 182 US 427 "Where rights secured by the Constitution are involved, there can be no rule making or legislation which would abrogate them." Miranda vs. Arizona, 384 US 436, 491 "Moreover, a distinction must be observed between the regulation of an activity which may be engaged in as a matter of right and one carried on by government sufferance of permission." Davis vs. Massachusetts, 167 US 43; Pachard vs. Banton, supra. "... the only limitations found restricting the right of the state to condition the use of the public highways as a means of vehicular transportation for compensation are (1) that the state must not exact of those it permits to use the highways for hauling for gain that they surrender any of their inherent U.S. Constitutional Rights as a condition precedent to obtaining permission for such use ..." Riley vs. Laeson, 142 So. 619; Stephenson vs. Binford, supra. "We find it intolerable that one Constitutional Right should have to be surrendered in order to assert another." Simons vs. United States, 390 US 389 "... For while a Citizen has the Right to travel upon the public highways and to transport his property thereon, that Right does not extend to the use of the highways, either in whole or in part, as a place for private gain. For the latter purpose, no person has a vested right to use the highways of the state, but is a privilege or a license which the legislature may grant or withhold at its discretion." State vs. Johnson, 243 P. 1073; Cummins vs. Homes, 155 P. 171; Packard vs. Banton, 44 S.Ct. 256; Hadfield vs. Lundin, 98 Wash 516
- bbcbasic 11y agoIs this hacker news? There are loads of general news stories or people being wronged that I would love to post here, but I resist because although interesting and relevant to people (as this article is) it isn't really tech news.
- 542458 11y agoI feel that (much like yesterday's story on selling lead settlements) it's a very specific, interesting, and well written case of systematic wrongdoing that can provoke some interesting discussion. Just like how there's lots of math in the world, but every once in a while somebody posts a particularly interesting tidbit that makes it to #1 on HN.
- TheCapn 11y agoI'd agree. Last time I argued against the droves of "health" stories being posted and the half-baked opinions people rabble about within them I was told it was "relevant" because health affects all hackers. I respect that all things lifestyle can improve the lives of those in the tech community but I come here specifically for blogs/news/events relating to my field, I can get feelgood/ignorant opinions on any news site.
- patcon 11y agoUpvotes solve this concern.
- stephengillie 11y agoThe guidelines say we're supposed to flag stories we don't like and then ignore them. Because a thread full of pointless comments, is valued more highly by those that run this place, than a flame war.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jugad 11y agoIt boils my blood to read about such incidences. US is turning into the India that I came here to avoid. Policemen in India will stop you at their whim and find a reason to fine you (exact a bribe really). A cop followed my car in Salt lake city for 10 miles before he stopped me for turning on my blinkers for only 2 seconds before changing lanes. Apparently the law in Utah says that it should be 3 seconds. I wish I had recorded that incident, simply because it is so unbelievable. The incident smelled racist, and made sure I will never live in Utah / Salt Lake City.
- nitrogen 11y agoDid you have an out of state plate? It frustrates me how often one hears stories about out-of-towners being singled out.
- joesmo 11y ago"The case also exemplifies a suspicion that, at times, law enforcement’s motive is profit." "At times"? Really? I think they mean all the time for a growing majority of districts.
- tempestn 11y ago> On Feb. 18, she provided the documentation. Her license had, indeed, been valid. But the mayor didn’t drop the two license-related charges. Instead, he “asked her how much money she had with her,” an appeals court wrote. “She responded she only had about $300. The Mayor informed her she could at least pay the unlawful use of a driver’s license charge that day.” > So she did, paying $215. > But despite what she paid, despite the documentation she showed, despite the registration count having earlier been dismissed, she was presented this same day with a bill of information, saying Woodworth was charging her with all four counts originally written up by the officer. She was given until March 18 to pay whatever money was still owed. Uh... what? I didn't expect the shakedown to be quite that blatant.
- breakingcups 11y ago“You can’t help it that you’re a racist. Your daddy’s a racist. Your children will be racist. It’s in your blood.” Now, is it me, or does that sound racist?
- kragen 11y agoNo, not unless the person who said it is attributing the racism to a race, rather than a family.