11 ms·
Twitter Falls Below IPO Price as Concerns Mount Over CEO, Growth
- theseatoms 11y agoBoth Jack Dorsey and Anthony Noto recently bought shares, fwiw.
- tenoman 11y agoJack Dorsey has sold more than 10x the amount of shares he just bought over the last few years, so the gesture rings a little hollow.
- Greenisus 11y ago"At stake is whether Twitter [...] can become a mainstream platform instead of a niche forum favored by journalists and celebrities." I found that line interesting, because I often think of Twitter as a niche forum favored by technology workers and celebrities.
- freehunter 11y agoWhen I think of twitter I think nothing but mainstream. There are two platforms that anyone who is anyone (celebrity or business or politician) needs to have: either Facebook or Twitter. Niche is Instragram. Niche is Snapchat. But when Kardashian is on CNN once an hour because of a tweet, it's not niche. App.Net is niche. Twitter is the epitome of mainstream.
- icpmacdo 11y agoI think thats the main problem with Twitter, saturation. Its mainstream enough the regular people are not likely to jump on Twitter now if they already haven't.
- bluepostitnote 11y agoAnd yet Facebook is still signing up users
- incongruity 11y agoI'd argue they're better about extracting value from network effects – Facebook allows you to broadcast, but it really encourages interactions... the value grows a lot more with your network... whereas, following more people on twitter just makes it harder to follow.
- dredmorbius 11y agoMy understanding was that FB growth stalled in the US./EU in 2012, slipping since. No?
- somebodyother 11y agoThis. Nobody who could conceivably make an account is just waiting to hear about this hot new thing called microblogging.
- mmahemoff 11y agoPart of Twitter's challenge is that it's mainstream, but in a "write-only" way. Every celebrity, politician, religious leader, and journalist may be tweeting 24-7, but their followers aren't engaging in the same way they do on Facebook. A lot of users don't login, tweet, or spend much time on the site/app according to various reports. Chris Sacca said a lot about this recently. http://lowercasecapital.com/2015/06/03/what-twitter-can-be-2/ http://lowercasecapital.com/2015/06/03/what-twitter-can-be-2...
- Zigurd 11y agoGoogle will buy it because Google+ is Twitter minus the people.
- dredmorbius 11y agoG+ is a staggering number of peoole. 2.6 billion last I checked. Its simply that mist of them don't want to be there and say nothing. Engagement is by a fraction of a percent of the whole.
- eterm 11y agoCNN is precisely the journalism niche they are talking about. It isn't about niche celebrities, but celebrities as a whole is their niche. And journalists, of course. Newspaper websites publish vast quantities of tweets because it costs them nothing, it means you indirectly consume a lot of tweets. But the celebrity content consumed by journalists is as a whole still a niche, even if all celebrities are on there. FWIW I think it would be a mistake to abandon that, but it does raise questions about how they grow.
- nuclear_eclipse 11y ago> "Niche is Instagram" Except Instagram has more active users than Twitter...
- freehunter 11y agoWhen was the last time you saw a business with nothing but an Instagram profile, or saw Instagram referenced on the news, or cited in a paper, or used for a press release? It's not about active users, it's about how it's used.
- mkr-hn 11y agoEveryone had an AOL keyword. AOL isn't dead, but it fell hard. Ubiquity isn't enough.
- freehunter 11y agoAre you saying AOL wasn't mainstream? The Internet might have been niche as a whole, but out of that, AOL was as mainstream as it got. AOL was synonymous with Internet, like Facebook and Twitter are synonymous with social media.
- mkr-hn 11y agoI said: > Everyone had an AOL keyword. AOL isn't dead, but it fell hard. Ubiquity isn't enough. Every business having a Twitter account won't save Twitter any better than everyone having an AOL keyword saved AOL.
- Altay- 11y agoI don't think that's a fair comparison. AOL didn't initially position itself as a portal. It positioned itself as an ISP with a portal. Had AOL built itself as a web portal like Yahoo from the start it may very well have stayed relevant. I still have business partners (in non tech fields) that use their AOL email and news/portal services.
- moron4hire 11y agoIt's the same thing they do when they talk about Google+ being a "ghost town". Certainly doesn't look like a ghost town from my perspective. It's because Social Media gives out exactly what you yourself put in.
- dasil003 11y agoYeah, or protesters and celebrities. It could actually be anyone and celebrities, because you only see the groups that you participate in, and the only one with global visibility are, duh, celebrities! I think Twitter's biggest problem is lack of vision and a commitment to that vision. Going public was a big mistake for them, because Wall Street has no concept of what makes technology good or interesting over the long haul, they can only reduce things to the most simplistic metrics. Facebook is pretty much a known quantity at this point, and is the biggest social network that has ever existed. So now everyone wants to measure Twitter by the Facebook yardstick. But Facebook only has 5 times as many active users as Twitter, and I would bet money that the average Twitter user is more than 5 times as influential as the average Facebook user. If you can't build a viable company with 300M of the most influential users, then something is very very wrong in the world. The biggest tell-tale for me is that everyone knows exactly what Facebook is, and many people (especially younger ones) see it as a crufty accumulation of old friends and family that they have no interest engaging with. But for Twitter there's still a majority of people who "don't get it", and yet it has been a revolution for celebrities and the aforementioned groups in terms of what it's done for the public conversation. To me this is all an indication that Twitter has way more upside than Facebook. In fact, I'd be willing to invest in Twitter if I thought their leadership was strong, but my big concern is that they don't have a clear vision, and therefore they will get picked apart by the clueless hand-wringing of Wall Street until they become so cheap that Google or Facebook snaps them up.
- jerf 11y ago"If you can't build a viable company with 300M of the most influential users, then something is very very wrong in the world." One of the intriguing thing I'm keeping my eye on is that if TWTR keeps sinking, will there be any other follow-up effects? Because if TWTR can't convert eyeballs to money at the Wall Street-expected rate, that suggests in that invester-sphinctor-tightening way that maybe the other companies depedent on that model may have trouble too. The market's faith in eyeballs ---advertising---> money has always struck me as excessively strong. Not that it's a stupid idea, just that Wall Street seems to believe it's about 5-10 times more effective a plan than I do.
- teaneedz 11y agoTwitter has appeal and reach, but it seriously needs to get it UX in order and focus on being great at simplicity. The official app is a jumbled mess. Instead of trying to be Facebook it needs to be Twitter. I think the advertisers and many of the investors are placing too much pressure on Twitter to become more like Facebook. I'd wager that Twitter's userbase and power-user is more influential and savvier than the typical FB user. We don't want another Facebook experience.
- sreyaNotfilc 11y agoThe big issue is this - The goal of many start ups and software companies (especially modern ones circa 2000) is to get really big and then figure out how to make money. The problem with Twitter is that its doing just that. Exactly that even after its IPO. Its humongous yet doesn't have a decent business model (thus the falling stock prices). You can't get much bigger (well known) as a brand/company than Twitter. From networks such as CNN, FOX NEWS, ESPN, ABC, etc... Twitter is everywhere! Everyone knows them. So, there's a check. The issue happens with the second part : what do do with our fame? Can Twitter use their power to make services that are profitable? Yes! Do they? No, not really :( I often wonder why it takes so long for companies like these to blatantly monetize their services. They are backed by billions yet you rarely see an ad here or a "shop" there. Its as if they feel that its a bad thing to do. Its as if they feel that they are betraying the people using their services. I feel that these services can survive with a little more push towards that. Then again I'm not the CEO or founder of that BIG company so I'm sure most would feel that my idea is not valid. It just frustrates me that you see so much potential (money-wise and service-wise) in a product/service yet it takes a long time to see those changes.
- teaneedz 11y agoThe problem is that Twitter is trying to monetize like most with ad-tech at a time that many are becoming ad adverse. The rise of ad blockers should be a wake up call for such monetization efforts. Twitter is placing ads everywhere now. Auto play videos, promoted ads, a jumbled UX, and product decisions springing from a want-to-be-like-Facebook mindset are just damaging the brand especially with the lack of strong product leadership that exists (which shows in the official app). It's all about monetization and listening to advertisers who don't have UX chops.
- mkr-hn 11y agoI use it to talk to people into the things I'm into. Mostly writers, furries (which has a billion subgroup interests), and artists. You wouldn't know these communities exist on Twitter from the logged-out home page, and the discovery tools don't help until you've already figured out the major players in a community. Twitter should make the many different and largely unconnected communities a first-class part of the Twitter experience, rather than this informal thing they are now.
- grok2 11y agoActually it is a fantastic platform for businesses to reach out to people interested in their business. It is the easiest way to do the equivalent of cold-calling and introduce your business to someone you are interested in selling to. I have always thought they don't do enough on this front to mine the possibilities here.
- codingdave 11y agoEveryone says it is all about growth. Twitter is not growing. Pretty simple story, really.
- theseatoms 11y agoTheir revenue is indeed growing, but, as you indicate, the company's valuation is not.
- codingdave 11y agoBecause they are not profitable - everyone who defends startups who lose money have the same rationale - increase users now, at a loss, and turn it around later. Twitter is neither growing users nor turning it around. Maybe they will come up with a new CEO and a new strategy... maybe not. But there is almost zero reason to hold their stock. There are better investments out there.
- Animats 11y agoTwitter is still growing in terms of revenue, but they're losing money. They've already scaled up. They've had ads ("promoted tweets") since 2010. It's not clear where they go from here. Increasing the ad density to boost revenue begins the Myspace death spiral.
- theseatoms 11y agoIIRC they announced a Buy button, but I haven't encountered any instances of it in my feed.
- hyperbovine 11y agoTwitter was the first in a long list of current (i.e. post-2000) startups where I thought to myself, Really? That's a $X0 billion business? I wonder if this is just the tip of the iceberg.
- hatred 11y agoTwitter had a Q1 revenue of $436 million. Doesn't it make it a $X0 billion business or am I missing something ? The main concern to investors is primarily the growth and their ability to warrant a premium price on the stock.
- scandinavian 11y agoTwitter is huge, it costs a lot of money to run. They had a net profit of negative $162.4 million Q1. I don't know what defines an $X0 billion business, but I would imagine that it would be profit.
- biot 11y agoPut simply, future value. Otherwise a sidewalk lemonade stand profiting 1 cent per glass would be far more valuable than a lemonade manufacturing business which sells millions of bottles a day and pumps all the profits plus additional investment money into manufacturing facilities. At some point, the money-losing lemonade manufacturer no longer needs to ramp up their facilities, they pay down the equipment cost, and generate boatloads of profit. That or they get bought out by a larger player who wants to enter the lemonade market but doesn't want to reinvent the wheel.
- swingbridge 11y agoOf course, but at some point the whole "future value" logic runs flat. The market is losing faith in TWTTR's ability to generate value.
- criddell 11y agoWhat are they spending almost $200 million on each month?
- mandeepj 11y agoAt one point Facebook's stock also fell below IPO price. It happens. I hope they will come back like FB.
- brainflake 11y agoIt's not really the same... Facebook had a botched IPO where the price tanked immediately, but then recovered after a few quarters and their earnings started rolling in. Twitter has had consistently bad quarters, whether through poor earnings or over promising on their projections. But in one way or another they are not meeting expectations.
- rezashirazian 11y agoTwitter hasn't focused on anything else besides twitter. Facebook is taking on the mission of "connecting the world". Google has gone well beyond being only a search engine. Amazon has expanded into mobile, AWS and ... Twitter, on the other hand, is still pushing the same product.
- Aleman360 11y agoTaking a step back, what's the advantage to society of every company growing into a conglomerate? Why not just let a company live and die on its core business? Do we really want to allow all that power to be consolidated into company boards and executives?
- smithkl42 11y agoThat's a great point for the larger societal stakeholders in our collective capitalist enterprise. But given the limited horizon that the market places on Twitter's management and shareholders, I don't know that it answers the question of why Twitter doesn't expand beyond its current narrow focus.
- Dwolb 11y agoIt's not really a societal advantage, it's an investor one. If you're an equity holder you expect some return on capital you've contributed. If you're Twitter, this means returns on current products/services or on new ones. Hopefully, from a strategic perspective new products are either higher return on capital than current products/services or exhibit (excuse the wording) synergies with current products/services. Additionally OP alludes to a greater vision which a company may use to impact its decision making on new projects to pursue.
- zalzane 11y agoimagine if snapchat announced that they would start living and dying on their core business rather than try to expand now you have a bunch of investors who are upset that they invested in a company at a 16 billion dollar valuation that has jack diddly squat for income and has no promise of some magical "over the horizon" way to monetize
- joaq 11y agoAm I the only one who never really liked the whole concept of Twitter?
- ohitsdom 11y agoIt's really hard to sell/explain to the uninitiated because it's a diverse platform. Even my twitter feed is very diverse- breaking news and headlines from the beat writers for my favorite teams, activists and protesters covering police brutality, and developer blogs. With this mix, my twitter feed varies greatly. Unrest in Ferguson? Breaking news from the ground. Microsoft Build conference? Latest in tech from Redmond. Eagles training camp? Live highlights from reporters I trust. It's really a wonderful thing.
- joaq 11y agoNo, I've tried it. I've really tried to like it, but it just didn't click with me. I know it's perfect for others, but it can never reach the growth of a platform like Facebook that is more universally liked. That's pretty much my point.
- mkr-hn 11y agoYou sound like someone who dislikes Reddit because they think the defaults are all there is. Twitter could do a better job helping people discover their interest communities, but Twitter is more than the gossip-focused logged out home page. You need to look deeper if you think it has nothing for you.
- simonswords82 11y ago> You need to look deeper if you think it has nothing for you. Surely the onus is on Twitter to make the information easy to locate? This is one of their key failings, if you have to wade through too much noise to find something of interest, then the app isn't good enough.
- nemothekid 11y ago
- fauigerzigerk 11y agoTwitter should do group messaging and structured tags. I want to do things like: @friends Don't forget my birthday party on #(Aug 20, 8pm) at #SomePub or @friends Don't forget my birthday party! #invitation(Aug 20, 8pm, SomePub) And I want to be able to create a list where all invitations from people in the @friends group go And finance people could do things like Twitter has bottomed #buy(TWTR) And I want to be able to specify a rule that makes these messages go to my stock trading list
- bosdev 11y agoThis would be fantastically niche and tech-person-oriented, probably not the right move for the company as a whole. That said, nothing stops you from writing a bot on top of Twitter to power any of these interactions.
- fauigerzigerk 11y agoIt would be a big niche if you consider how many people use Excel functions. It could make Twitter part of enterprise and group communications infrastructures.
- fizx 11y agoThis was going to be a thing. It didn't happen for reasons. http://techcrunch.com/2010/05/08/twitter-annotations/ http://techcrunch.com/2010/05/08/twitter-annotations/
- saurik 11y agoI think Twitter now (recently) has group messaging.
- busterarm 11y agoI've been short on Twitter from the get-go, I just didn't think it would take this long. This doesn't mean I'm anti-Twitter - I would actually prefer that it stay the niche platform for journalists/celebrities/activists. I don't know the business strategy to make sure that is viable, but I don't want it to be a mass-market product (except in terms of consumption)...the signal to noise ratio is so much better than other social platforms. Twitter, quite bizarrely, is filling a void no longer filled by newspapers (wow, what that says about our attention spans). It's only peripherally mainstream but incredibly useful as a _tool_ to a small group of people. It's not any one thing: it's different depending on who you are.
- getdavidhiggins 11y agoThat's why I wrote ‘Twitter Should Be A Public Utility’ http://blog.higg.im/2015/06/12/on-twitter/ http://blog.higg.im/2015/06/12/on-twitter/ For me the disconnect was that Twitter failed and partially succeeded in making Twitter what I call 'plumbing', or a sort of duct tape for the web. If microblogging had a stack similar to TCP/IP that could be fundamental to how the web operates, then they missed that boat repeatedly.
- mikegioia 11y agoTo me the problem with Twitter lies solely with what Twitter's logged-out homepage looks like. I don't know what it's trying to be but asking me to sign up, browse categories (?), and read top celebrity posts is not it. Why is logged-out Twitter not a search engine? They have up-to-the-second thoughts from their users about everything and it's the first place I go when a site is down, or some news story is breaking. They're sitting on a search goldmine yet they're trying to convert signups and popular celebrity post clickthroughs.
- ohitsdom 11y agoThis. I get that they want sign-ups, but it's hard to sell the service with that page.
- therobot24 11y agobut would a search engine approach be any more effective at conversions? I use google and wikipedia, but it doesn't mean i have a blog or edit.
- mikegioia 11y agoThat to me is the problem, that for some reason conversions is the sole metric with which success is measured. Why is that though? I don't have to be a GMail/Google user to get value out of Google search, yet Google generates most of its revenue from search. If Twitter knows what everyone likes, or is talking about (especially the influencers), then that would be a good source of search results if I'm looking for something to buy or do. Its an entirely different search engine than Google or even Facebook.
- adventured 11y agoThat prompts a question as to whether Twitter can best grow its future value more through user signups / conversions, or through maximizing one-way consumption as a broadcast medium. I read the nytimes.com all the time. They have no idea who I am and never will. I'll never signup for an account. They still get to feed me ads. I consume ESPN one-way. They have no idea who I am and never will. It's worth $50 +/- billion to Disney (per Forbes and others). Why can't Twitter maximize that potential? Most of Google's global users don't have or don't use a G account, and are not signed in when they search (even if Google builds a profile on them anyway). That doesn't detract from Google's ability to monetize based on interest and intent. Twitter's intent will never be as valuable, but it wouldn't take much given we're talking about Google's intent being worth $100 billion in advertising sales in the near future. My point being, perhaps Twitter's biggest mistake is in trying to be Facebook and worrying about users. Instead they should focus on maximizing output of high quality sources, and boosting total consumption.
- mkorfmann 11y agoGood times to buy into $TWTR ;).
- jchrisa 11y agoTwitter should print out these comments and throw darts to pick their new executive team.
- meatysnapper 11y agoThe interesting question will be the on-going struggle between engineering (Roetter/Weil) and business (Noto/Bain), who actually want to run a profitable company. My bet is Roetter and Weil will be out before the year is done.
- mrdrozdov 11y agoStop stressing out. Twitter will be fine.
- OldSchoolPro 11y agoIMHO with the current management Twitter will stagnate and die.
- meatysnapper 11y agoAs opposed to the previous management? 3 heads of product since 2013: Sippey, Graf, Weil. How's that supposed to work?
- natecavanaugh 11y agoIs there anyone else who hates Twitter because of its 140 character limit and overall focus on broadcasting rather than sharing? For the 140 character limit, I get the historical SMS reasons and that it helps you "focus" your content, but taking 10 minutes to squeeze a thought in that turns from something half interesting to "bc u r 4 the GPL" or whatever. Sure MAYBE I could reword things a little denser, but a tweet should be somewhat in the moment and nothing takes me out of it like editing to some arbitrary limit. As for the aspect of people liking smaller messages, they can do what FB does and hide behind a "Read more" link. Overall, Twitter feels like being in a crowded bar. Lots of noise, not many conversations. This could all just be me, though...
- teaneedz 11y agoIt's what makes Twitter, well Twitter. I love the 140 char limit because it enforces brevity and aids quick consumption. That's me.
- nkozyra 11y agoBut often it encourages abusing the limitation by splitting long(er)-form content into multiple tweets. I agree that it's so fundamental to the brand and Twitter's identity that it might cause a lot of problems if it were reverted, but frankly it's completely arbitrary. If you want to produce 140 (or less) content, you can do that without a hard limit. People hack around it because it's such a ubiquitous platform, but people would also like to address that audience in long(er)-form. It culminates in inconvenience for both producer and consumer.
- mahyarm 11y agoIt creates a barrier to doing long form content although, encouraging brevity. The amount of multi-part tweets are low compared to the average tweet.
- smtddr 11y ago>>Is there anyone else who hates Twitter because of its 140 character limit and overall focus on broadcasting rather than sharing? I actually love twitter for those reasons.
- udev 11y agoMany here comment just on sub-IPO price of shares. The problem is bigger. As per Financial Times, there is a larger shift in investor mood towards Twitter. It seems that there are many who intend to short Twitter indicated by the amount of "borrowed" shares.
- jtouri 11y agoI never thought the problem was the product, rather it is the management and the community. What's valuable about hacker news is the people who are involved, and what's great about Quora are the people who give a response. It's not helpful that most people spam useless tweets constantly. It took a while, but I finally set my twitter to follow news updates perfectly.
- stephengoodwin 11y ago> I finally set my twitter to follow news updates perfectly Just curious: What's your setup or setup philosophy?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nosuchthing 11y agoIt's a delicate mix of both. Ello caused a mass migration away from Facebook but new users had difficulty understanding the Ello UI, and eventually after the hype simmered, people generally stuck with Facebook as their main network interface. There was also much talk around the time Whatsapp was acquired by Facebook.. people were eager to find alternatives and could easily migrate. I can't imagine Twitter being around in 5 years. IMO the best aspect Twitter has right now above all other services is it's realtime tag/search/trend system. The 140 char limit is antiquated, the userbase is mostly twitter joke addicts and an unceasing torrent of self promotional noise. I'm still sorta hoping Ello get's their shit together. I'd gladly pay for their service instead of being immersed in AOL 2015.
- smegel 11y agoTime to flush the toilet.
- rdl 11y agoTwitter seems like both current-shareholders and the userbase would be best served by either acquisition by Google/Alphabet, or a takeover by either activist shareholder or private equity, with new, product-focused management. If you focused on mobile in the right ways, you could turn Twitter into a legitimate $30-50b company. It's amazing that FB Newsfeed has basically taken the low hanging fruit from Twitter -- "normal" people sharing life events, leaving only weird communities of people interacting in public. There has to be a way to preserve that, grow that, and get interpersonal interaction among more closely-knit communities happening. They had such a huge opening when Facebook fucked themselves with the shitty-HTML5-only-mobile-clients. Sad.
- ThomPete 11y agoTwitters main problem is that it's a protocol more than an actual content platform. What they need is to get more content onto their platform and the only way to really do that is to allow for richers posts which means loose the 140 character limit. I know a lot of people will say "but thats what so great about twitter" and I would claim that it isn't, they just think it is. The short tweets and the asyncronous character of twitter creates quite a lot of noise and so you are actually reading way way more than interesting 140 character tweets you also read a lot of noise and redundancy. No whats really great about twitter is that it's more centerede around interests than friendship and that this provide the actual value of using the service.
- benwoodward 11y agoTotally agree. I stopped using Twitter because I got so tired of rewording everything to fit into 140 characters. The most interesting people on Twitter tend to use multiple tweets to broadcast one message, and join them up with "...", but when I see that I'd rather they had just written a short blog post and linked it. In my opinion, what Twitter is most useful for is sharing links and short updates to prompt action from your followers, like reading your new blog post. And because of this, it's not the kind of place where you want to spend a lot of time, because the content isn't that engaging, it's just the news ticker that you scroll through for 5 minutes and leave.
- capkutay 11y agoSnapchat's "Stories" page is the UI Twitter should have built...It has search, a list of your friends updates, and targeted content from a few big name media vendors. Logging into twitter just takes you to a big list of crappy, uninteresting content IMO.
- meerita 11y agoI have never installed Snapchat. I don't know if it is good or bad. All my friends doesn't have Snapchat, but everyone has Twitter. I found Twitter a better place, and it's ageless to me compared to all those new-UI paradigms that come each year. The problem of Twitter is they cut off all the innovation of 3rd party software developers to keep their shitty in house software.
- mbesto 11y ago> Noto struck a critical tone, saying user growth won’t improve until the service boosts its appeal to a bigger market and that product improvements and marketing so far have met with minimal success. This is going to sound anecdotal, but still feel is telling: until my parents and my co-workers (enterprise IT professionals) see the benefit in adopting Twitter, then Twitter will forever be in limbo. I fear the same for reddit. Neither service has a product that supports a wide enough appeal to be considered for that demographic, and they are effectively the last mile in this equation.
- panabee 11y agoTwitter owns unique and compelling content. Lots. Yes, there is lots of junk, but there is also lots of junk on the web. The challenge is surfacing and distributing great content, and this is where Twitter should focus: maximizing reach and curating content. Instead of forcing users to come to Twitter, Twitter should go wherever users are. Bring Twitter’s amazing content to them, wherever users are, through partners and syndication. Get people hooked as consumers before worrying about conversions. The upside is much cheaper user acquisition by piggybacking on media habits rather than breaking them. The downside is less revenue and possibly less loyalty, at least in the near term. Media distributors like HuffPo and Yahoo boast massive audiences but need interesting content. Twitter can supply the content while Yahoo and others provide the users and sell ads. Both sides share revenue. Outsourcing user acquisition to Yahoo and distributors doesn’t endanger Twitter. Twitter and only Twitter can produce this content, and since the content is unique, there is no risk of Yahoo swapping out Twitter for another company. Put another way, syndication only strengthens Twitter as a product. Syndication expands the audience for tweets and deepens the incentive to publish via Twitter, which in turn generates more content and attracts more users, which in turn attracts more publishers. Syndication feeds a virtuous cycle. The second piece, curating content, requires doing more to help individuals find and consume interesting tweets, and helping partners find and present interesting tweets. There is lots more Twitter could do, both with man and machine, in this area. Maybe Twitter's greatest sin is not being Facebook, but it shouldn't be. There is enormous potential in helping people connect with others and enjoy content based on interests (Hi Reddit), not friendships. Many people, especially those on Wall Street and in the media, need a foil for Facebook, but hopefully the next CEO is not among them. Twitter is a special company with special potential.
- firebones 11y agoFacebook fell out of favor after its IPO, so some of this seems like the periodicity for Twitter is similar, just stretched out much longer and more attenuated due to the lower market cap and lower rung on the ladder. Your comment that Twitter owns unique and compelling content: I view unique and compelling content as a scarce resource. Growth rate in the boring tail perhaps means less if they're cornering the market on the compelling blurb real estate. Twitter as a REIT, where the real estate is focused attention on compelling content? Are The Donald's FB posts featured on the networks nightly? The nightmare scenario for Twitter is that they've stumbled into a Craigslist-style niche of providing incredible, essential value that can't be monetized in proportion to the value it actually provides.
- vasilipupkin 11y agoI like twitter, but there is just no compelling use case for it. Basically, I use it as a news aggregator + pmarca monitor. But it's not super exciting.
- WalterBright 11y agoI get constant emails from twitter.com, I finally just marked them all as spam. I have a twitter account to get tweets, why do I need them to email me other tweets?
- brainflake 11y agoFrom a product standpoint, I feel like Twitter has barely changed in 5 years. There's been some polish and redesign, sure, but the main dynamics are almost exactly the same. Facebook has features like intelligently improving the quality of your feed, being able to hide posts from certain people, prioritizing posts (not just stacking them based on their age), calendar/birthday stuff, events, chats, etc. Twitter is just a never ending stream of information, not prioritized and always overflowing with too much content (at least IMO). I think Facebook nailed it with realizing their engagement levels are directly related to the quality of the newsfeed, and because of this they put a great deal of effort into making it as relevant as possible to each user. They realize that if you friend (or follow) somebody, you're not necessarily interested in ALL of their content, but maybe only their most interesting or popular. They also realize that if you only log in 2 times per week, they should prioritize with the best recent content, not just the stuff that was posted 1 hour ago.
- djloche 11y agoTwitter is useful to me specifically because they do not filter the feeds. If they start removing or preventing me from receiving content I specifically request to receive, that will be the knell for twitter. I can put up with ads. Even being flooded with ads would be better than twitter deciding to hide content from me.
- runevault 11y agoI find it interesting you mention the improved feed, people I've talked to (obviously this is anecdotal but it is all I have to go on) HATE it, and especially the fact it always defaults to it instead of staying with most recent as they prefer.
- brainflake 11y agoWell, I think it probably depends on the demographic and/or how many friends you have. I would imagine the younger ones hate it but older professional types who don't log on as much appreciate it. And likewise the larger the size of your network the more you might appreciate it, but who knows...
- sloanesturz 11y agoI feel like every three weeks I see an article like this on Hacker News and a gazillion good ideas about how to improve Twitter's service. At the same time, there have been no core changes to Twitter in the last several years. Is Twitter the only company in the Valley where every engineer isn't checking Hacker News every few hours!?
- harlanlewis 11y agoThis exactly captures why Twitter is so disappointing. From my normal user perspective (not advertising, not a celebrity...) they've never been an internally innovative company - @mentions and retweets are community inventions, the best clients for niche, power, and general use have always been 3rd party, and after stumbling onto a private messaging hit they shot DMs behind the woodshed just before the world went wild for whatsapp and snapchat. The community continues to come up with interesting ideas, never to be implemented. There's no doubt Twitter has stellar engineers. It's strategy that needs to be externalized. A shame they've spoiled so many developer relationships.
- niccaluim 11y agoFor the past five years Twitter engineering has been focused on two things: rebuilding the infrastructure and building an ad platform. They nailed both of these. But unfortunately that left little time for product engineering. Add in the revolving door of heads of product and it's no surprise there hasn't been much substantive change to the product.
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoIs Twitter the only company in the Valley where every engineer isn't checking Hacker News every few hours!? They're all too busy passing joints and/or bongs around to really care about HN or about their product. :-) Peter Thiel: Twitter Executives 'Probably' Smoke Too Much Pot, And That's Why It's A 'Horribly Mismanaged Company' http://www.businessinsider.com/twitter-executives-smoke-too-much-pot-2014-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/twitter-executives-smoke-too-...
- pinaceae 11y agowhy does twitter not have a default feed of the most favorited/RTd individual tweets? they only show trending topics/hashtag, but not a default feed. or have create a couple of curated best/of feeds. tech, sports, humor, etc. sort of like apple music, pandora, but for tweeters.
- dredmorbius 11y agoSingle "most popular" feeds tend to the most mind numbingly banal. See G+ and its "What's Hot" problem. That stream is insultingly vapid. A set of highly filtered feeds might be better. Still tough to pull off.
- apapli 11y agoI gave Twitter two solid tries (ie spent time finding people to follow, downloaded the mobile apps,installed desktop apps too), once in 2010 for 3 months, and again over 2011-2013. I'm a technical business person and really believe that outside of the tech and media scene it is pretty much useless for every day use. They have a cool brand, but pretty uncompelling and un-engaging user experience. And I never missed Twitter compared with the way I "miss" Facebook or LinkedIn when I haven't logged in for a while. Their instability with their management team doesn't help them much either. IMHO they'll be out of business in a decade at most.
- criddell 11y agoTime to open up their (very nice) API to third party clients again. I think there's still a lot of room for innovation on the Twitter platform and it isn't going to come from Twitter themselves.
- xentronium 11y agoOnce bitten, twice shy. I'd never built my business around twitter api however nice it is. It's just not worth it to close shop after twitter blocks your token for superficial reasons.
- lnanek2 11y agoAs a developer, I'm really hoping they fail and some developer friendly alternative comes up. Google Plus is really bad because not many people use it and they only approve certain verbs. Twitter is really bad because they banned a bunch of my games for letting people tweet their scores easily claiming they were too much like clients and have starved a lot of apps with user token limits. Unfortunately there's really nothing out there that has Twitter's numbers and is developer friendly. Facebook has some screwed up approval process nowadays where their rejection reasons don't make any sense. They seem to have gone the app store route and are having call centers in third party countries try to apply rules to apps and ending up with a bad experience.
- sirbetsalot 11y agoTwitter is the Ganges River of Social Media. Filled to the brim with garbage, everyone who floats in it drinks the water, dies and joins the floating corpse pile at the end of the data funnel. you can't have a fresh mountain spring of great data when you let people pollute constantly with their verbal offal.
- simonswords82 11y agoI'll be using "Twitter is the Ganges River of Social Media." in casual conversation from now on. Great analogy.
- puranjay 11y agoTwitter is one of those you either "get" or you don't (same with Snapchat). I could never get Twitter. I couldn't understand why I would want a rapid fire stream of messages that were a third witty banter, a third retweets of marketing messages, and a third "breaking" news. I know you can filter your feed out, but for me, it's too much work.
- vit05 11y agoI read all the comments, and have a totally different point of views. Yes, twitter needs to innovate more. You need to make a number of changes to the user interface and give more options. But I think that for now, the best and easiest thing they can do to bring back most users is to give more power to his Big Players. Help than make more money, be more promoted, have more publicity in twitter than any other social network. Stop thinking that promoted hashtags and other options that are only used for spam have a great return for the sponsor. Celebrities, players, journalists, politicians. People want to talk to them and twitter is the best media tool for this.
- marcusgarvey 11y agoTwitter has been a go-to for celebs and the powerful. The entertainment / fashion celebs are adopting Instagram in a huge way. Right now it's easy to have Insta. auto-post to Twitter, but it doesn't speak well of Tw growth. If other types of influential people follow suit, that will be another headache for Twitter.