5 ms·
one could argue that what AM is doing is an explicit attempt to damage the basic building block of society Sure, but one could also argue the same about per-ma
by dagw 11y ago
one could argue that what AM is doing is an explicit attempt to damage the basic building block of society
Sure, but one could also argue the same about per-marital sex, divorce and homosexuals.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoMarriages are not just moral issues, they're also contracts between people themselves and between the couples and the government. They come with privileges and tax breaks and social status, and all of it is built upon assumption that marriages are mostly permanent. AM is explicitly attempting to attack that.
- lentil_soup 11y agoI think this is not such a big issue, if it was divorce would be illegal. If anything I would argue the problem lies then on how the estate sees marriage, not the other way around. The agreement I have with my wife is between us, no one needs to judge what we do with our private lives.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI think this is a thing that is actually changing in the recent decades. It used to be that marriages were more about connecting families, securing deals and even state issues (and so it still is in some parts of the world). Nowadays in Western society, marriages tend to be more about two people and their decision. But we're not 100% in the latter model yet, there's lot of social and legal baggage around the older ways. Divorces are not illegal, but they're still socially stigmatized. The point is, we have to deal with how things are actually now, and not only with how they may/should be.
- kalms 11y agoWho are you to judge how people live and should their lifes? How dull. There are so many different family structures — incl. open relationships. A family's structure and agreements is not public, nor should they be. Unless said family choose to disclose that fact by their own volition.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI'm not judging. People may live however they want. Institution of marriage is one of the choices, that is established in the society and carries with it some particular set of features. In particular, joining in marriage is somewhat public, even if it's much less public than it used to be. Also marriage comes with explicit (even if not legally binding) expectation you don't cheat. If you don't like those aspects, don't marry; no one is telling you have to, open relationships are fine too.
- kalms 11y agoMaybe you have that expectation about marriage, but that doesn't mean your expectations are shared by every married couple. You're forcing your point-of-view upon others.
- humanrebar 11y ago> Who are you to judge how people live and should their lifes? Churches have no ability to enforce promises with violence or confiscation. And they shouldn't. So it's important for governments to establish some sort of lowest common denominator and hold people legally accountable. I understand the impulse to be non-judgmental, but when both laws and the rest of society get out of the business of enforcing marriage contracts, you actually take choices away from people that want a stronger marriage contract. They can no longer enter an enforceable contract that requires monogamy. We're not adding more choice for everyone that way. We're just choosing (as a society) a different lifestyle.
- TsiCClawOfLight 11y agoWhich conservative Christians do.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agomm so the FBI just have to look at the ex employees backgrounds up bringing - should be easy to do some profiling "not just for brown skinned people any more"