14 ms·
Looking at this story (the wider Amazon story) it seems to me a lot of the value is getting extracted from employees in a sort of creeping way. So you might go
by lordnacho 11y ago
Looking at this story (the wider Amazon story) it seems to me a lot of the value is getting extracted from employees in a sort of creeping way.
So you might go to an interview where the manager says there's pager duty now and again, but it's not too intense. You get on the job, and it's a whole lot more intense than expected. You can't leave because you've just turned down a bunch of other offers and moved towns. You adjust to delivering maybe 25% more work hours than you thought. The company might do better hiring a colleague for you, but they don't, so you lose out on free time while all the benefits of your increased production goes to shareholders.
There's no recourse for this, and management knows it. They can hire people and make them work harder than they've been told, as long as it's within the range where a sensible number of people won't be looking for other jobs. At the same time, you have great reputation (well maybe that's changing) so there's a queue of fools applying to get in.
- bechampion 11y agoI completely agree , also , Us as employees we need to learn when to say stop , i know we all work hard and we want to be the an important asset. But remember going the extra mile and getting recognition for it will only last until the next downtime/problem which could be tomorrow.
- pjc50 11y agoUs as employees we need to learn when to say stop There's a word for this, beginning with "U", that a lot of people don't like.
- bechampion 11y agoi know , i hate Unicorns too!
- barking 11y agoAnd (in the UK at least) the demise of unions has seen the earnings ratio of company bosses to employees rise to levels not seen since the 19th or early 20th century
- mattmanser 11y agoThat's happening across the world at the moment isn't it? Doesn't seem to be linked to the demise of unions. Admittedly, there needs to be a new version of unions, the next evolution. We need the next Marx to bring the pendulum back.
- pjc50 11y agodemise of unions The demise of unions is also a general phenomenon across the western world. It's not helped by the migration of lots of factory industries to parts of the world without strong unions and with plenty of hungry workers. Ultimately unions have only one effective negotiating tool: the strike. And if it's easy to replace striking workers, it's not an effective tool. It's also very disruptive (in the bad sense) when it is effective. UK public opinion turned against unions when they rationed electricity to 3 days a week. We need a better check on unlimited greed than the blunt threat of going up against the wall in a Communist revolution. A lot of people have cited Piketty as the next Marx, but there don't seem to be Piketty-ist factions.
- barking 11y agoAs I'm sure you know, it wasn't just globalisation, Margaret Thatcher's intention was to spancel the unions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_labour_law_in_the_United_Kingdom#Conservative_government https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_labour_law_in_the_U...
- bechampion 11y agoUnions are noisy lately here in London , i'll have 2 hours commute next week thanks to them.
- barking 11y agoThe public sector is the only sector that is still strongly unionised while also being the sector with least necessity for it
- andrewmu 11y agoUnemployment?
- dimman 11y agoYep, it's as simple as that; almost. There's good ways to do it and there's bad ways to do it. 1) Figure out what's wrong at an early stage, why it's wrong and come up with a proposal of how it could be improved. Find solutions. 2) Always fix things despite the unreasonable amount of work or pressure. You wait until you'r almost broken and then say you can't take this anymore, it's too much. Problem needs to be fixed right away or you'll lose it. We very much create our own situations too unfortunately.
- serge2k 11y agoI really think a union at Amazon would probably fix a lot of issues, but would cost most of the things about the culture that are actually good. I do think the FC workers should be in a union. Absolutely.
- boxy310 11y agoI really think that if Amazon is only surviving with a razor-thin profit margin and they only do that because they treat their employees like beat-up warehouse equipment, then maybe it shouldn't exist as a company. My opinion of them has really downgraded from a "Sears" of the internet (back when Sears actually had a good reputation) towards more of a "Walmart" of the internet.
- toothbrush 11y ago...and that's not to mention their systematic tax evasion. I agree that the human cost is the bigger problem at the moment, but i really get worked up about the multinationals earning massive profit and paying single-digit percent taxes. That's another rant, though.
- rrss1122 11y agoI think it would be good if the FC workers unionize. It would greatly increase the speed of development for automation solutions and benefit robotics as a whole.
- serge2k 11y agoI really think a union at Amazon would probably fix a lot of issues, but would cost most of the things about the culture that are actually good. I do think the FC workers should be in a union. Absolutely.
- TheCondor 11y agoIt seems to me, as an outsider that has rebuffed them several times, that they've found this subculture of abuse takers that will just sort of deal with it. I know their pay isn't stratospheric, certainly not a shattering lifestyle change to leave. Many seem drawn to the allure of the name, it's a well known tech company.. Are these types capable of forming a union? by the time they are willing to stick their neck out to do something like form a union, it's just so easy to turn the page and leave. I worked for a satellite TV provider years and years back, it was similar, very abusive, very demanding. I did my project and left, it just wasn't a good fit. In retrospect, the people that stayed all seem to be somehow damaged. It was just unhealthy, emotionally, I don't remember anyone that was actually happy in life being there. Also very similar to Amazon, they sell to the lowest common denominator, Amazon is effectively going toe to toe with Walmart, more so than google or apple.
- deskamess 11y agoFor me its past 'like'... I think we need them. Abuses will continue without some sort of oversight (legal or behavioral); corporations are beholden to their share holders and not their employees. Medical/construction workers have established safety and paid overtime policies going for them and we need to emulate something like that. In addition, we (IT workers) should look at other avenues. Like the AMA (medical) and ALA (legal) professions we need an organization (or PAC/lobby) with political clout that influences law makers and fights for IT employee/labor rights. I would love for a David Boies or someone with that type of clout/knowledge to grow such an organization.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sshagent 11y agothis is pretty much what i took from this story. its not pleasant granted, but really you need to push back occasionally. Constant call outs is really an issue the management need to resolve so its not such a burden.
- 72deluxe 11y agoWithout sounding too cynical, loyalty to a company (working out of hours) is not always returned as loyalty from the company. They wouldn't be pleased you turning up a few hours late every day to compensate for your extra time outside work. Of course, time off in lieu may be arranged.
- eitally 11y agoTo be fair, it depends on the company and often the individual manager. I gave people comp time almost all the time they were forced into some extraordinary work.
- omouse 11y agoYep I got dinged for coming into work at 11am when I had stayed till 11pm the night before and had done weekend work. Fuck exploitation.
- honest_joe 11y agoThat's the problem with capitalism. On the other hand problem with socialism is that people do not work at all or just pretending to work because they are protected by XY laws,unions etc. And in order to maintain the social benefits they need to enslave other people (think germanic countries and the ost bloc). So what is the solution to this ?
- tajen 11y agoI always wonder whether the stock of Amazon should decrease after the HR-gate. I would expect the company to eventually start an HR policy and lose money on that. It seems the stock price didn't move, but I'm not a finance expert and there must be other events this month.https://www.google.fr/search?q=amzn&oq=amzn&aqs=chrome..69i57j0l2j5.2071j0j4 https://www.google.fr/search?q=amzn&oq=amzn&aqs=chrome..69i5...
- specialdragon 11y agoTL;DR: Amazon is trading at too high a price for massive movements, instead look at the volatility of the options market or for an instrument that allows buying part of a share of Amazon Full thing: It might not have moved because of the liquidity of the market. Due to their stock price, people won't generally own lots of the stock, so any sell orders would go through the SOES (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small-order_execution_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small-order_execution_system). I'm not sure whether a Level 1 book would include that information, I have a feeling it doesn't. [citation needed] However, SOES only works for lots of at most 1000 and only on stocks up to a value of $250. Amazon is currently trading at $535. Occasionally another instrument will be set up that works in parts of the stock, which will be a lot more volatile, so you could buy 1/10 of an Amazon share. Alternatively, people start trading in options on the stock. So you get the situation where the share price for Amazon looks fine, but the options market dries up or the volatility of derivative instruments is massive.
- acqq 11y agoAn event that possibly reduces the number of employees isn't something to typically make the stock price go down: http://money.stackexchange.com/questions/38856/why-is-it-that-stock-prices-for-a-company-seem-to-go-up-after-a-layoff http://money.stackexchange.com/questions/38856/why-is-it-tha... Stock markets don't respond only to the possible long term effect.
- intended 11y agoThe stock should not move at all. HR gate is a relatively localized phenomenon - almost entirely considered fluff by the markets. Data: "A company is making its workers work hard. They have bad press." Questions: "Has anyone been fired/resigned? is there a new policy change which increases wages and reduces money to shareholders?" Answers: "as of no, no one significant. No policy change, and no significant damage to brand. Questions: "Is hiring/firing within normal ranges? How long will people remember this?" Answers: "mostly normal. No impact to EBITDA. People will forget in a month, unless there is a significant miss step. Insufficient support for a policy or legal bill to be raised." Conclusions: Has happened before, will happen again, with near 0 impact to cash flow. If something happens theres many ways to mitigate damage to shareholders. In all honesty, this has near nil impact on the market.
- venomsnake 11y agoWell - you deliver 40 for the week and be gone. Not that hard. At 1800 you leave office. There is nothing your boss can tell you.
- lordnacho 11y agoWhen they decide to fire you, the real reason is never said. They'll just think of some BS and you'll be out the door.
- enraged_camel 11y agoExactly. In most states companies can fire you for any reason, or even no reason. And if there is a reason, they aren't obligated to disclose it.
- kabdib 11y agoAnd let's not forget that Washington does not forbid non-compete agreements.
- imgabe 11y agoExcept when you're fired without cause, you can collect unemployment, which costs the company money. So they usually either need cause - which means documenting poor performance for several months - or they have to gain more money than unemployment costs by letting you go i.e. layoffs. If you're creating value for the company, even if it's not the extreme 80 hours per week value they want, it still makes more financial sense to keep you. Yes, we have at-will employment, blah blah. It's no reason to be a pushover. If you're skilled enough to get a job at a place like Amazon, there's plenty of less insane places you could probably work.
- VikingCoder 11y agoWe're moving you from a level 6 engineer to a level 3 engineer, with reduced pay and benefits. We don't think you're contributing at the level we hired you at. Your job has also been relocated to ISIS-controlled territory in Syria. And you need to learn COBOL. And your job now requires 85% time travel on small, yellow, inflatable boats that leak somewhat.
- erikb 11y agoI think that's what happens in most companies all the time, all around the planet. But the reason is not evil management and it's not a result of planned activity. Management is also hard. They also have to deliver too much with too little budget at hand. The only difference is that they earn more money and they often don't have to pull the team out of the B.S. themselves on weekends and late night hours. They are naive people like you and me. There are things that are unmanageable so they ask you to help. Then they get used to your help and unconsciously consider it normal. Then their budget gets cut, or they have to cover for other departments who can't deliver as much as expected. And surprise, there is even more work for you. I don't say that for us to excuse bad management. But I think it's very important to understand the "other side". Understanding them can provide you with options. Just saying they are idiots or evil bastards leaves you powerless.
- lordnacho 11y agoI agree. But the experience for the producer is highly dependent on the manager's behaviour. - Does he keep asking for the impossible? - Does he hang around or go home at 5pm? - Does he at least do what he is able to do for the team, or does he just leave it all for the team? Difference between competent and incompetent management can often be little things that help handle emotional stress for the worker.
- erikb 11y agoYes, but the amount of emotional stress of the worker is mostly irrelevant to the manager. It only becomes a problem when the company gets bad press like from that article, or when the productivity of the team drops so much that he can't project success to his managers and peers. Our goal as workers can't be to tell our managers about our emotional stress (which he doesn't care about), but showing him alternatives that contain less stress for us but at least the same amount of projectable success to him, and/or just doing them, because in the end not being informed how the success was achieved is less important to the manager than having spare time to get a massage or visit the golf club.
- 11y ago
- hkmurakami 11y agoThis is part of the reason why employees work such long hours in Japan. Overtime is largely unpaid for white collared workers. Coercing an employee to work ever-longer hours is effectively "free" (in the short term, until some start to physically and emotionally break down). Because changing jobs is so difficult in Japan, there's often no recourse for the worker.
- x5n1 11y agoSolution, don't think about working for Amazon or any such company. Warn your family and friends and co-workers. Company will get the message and change its policies hopefully after losing a few billion. Alternatively unionize Amazon.
- eitally 11y agoI just turned down an offer because of something like this. I went through a bunch of interviews and things seemed pretty peachy, until I interviewed with a guy (who'd have been a peer) who was probably way more candid than management would've liked. He said things like "I haven't gotten a raise in five years so make sure you negotiate hard when you come in", "I got an apartment close to the office so I can be here quick when the shit hits the fan", "50hrs/wk is probably a good baseline, but you already knew that", and "yeah, your group has rotating weekly pager duty and even if they call it an 'engineering' team it's really support." I felt like I'd been completely mislead by everyone else, and even if this guy had a chip on his shoulder and was intentionally lying to me -- which I doubt -- that in itself would have been a red flag.
- sepeth 11y ago> I just turned down an offer because of something like this. One question, was this offer from amazon? I mean, are the things the guy said for amazon?
- mulletbum 11y agoWhy does that matter? He is drawing a personal story that is comparable to the Amazon story, trying to describe his ability to find the proper work culture for his life. I am not trying to argue, just wish your two questions had a reasoning behind them as in writing they sound harsh to me.
- rdudek 11y agoThe only reasoning I can think of is if it's widespread at Amazon or certain locations / departments are affected like that? It could be an interesting insight research to see how wide-spread such employer behavior is. I remember working for Van Blarcom Closures in NYC over 10 years ago. During interviews they said standard 40 hour weeks with occasional overtime. Except their occasional overtime meant every day was a 12 hour shift with some Saturday's and Sundays's as well. Let's just say, I didn't last more than 6 months there before moving out.
- 11y ago
- rmc 11y ago> So you might go to an interview where the manager says there's pager duty now and again, but it's not too intense. You get on the job, and it's a whole lot more intense than expected. And this is the biggest problem with tech hiring. The prospective employee can't know how bad it really is. So changing jobs is risky. Companies wanting to hire need to compensate for that risk with a definited benefit. Salary is the obvious and easy one.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- RogerL 11y agoThis is a big reason why people hang around. The stress of interviewing, not to mention the absurdities of how you are "measured", and you may just be leaping from the frying pan into the fire. It's easy, if not wise, to just stick where you are and grind through it. It'll get better, right? You'll always hear promises about how things are changing, how your concerns are being taken seriously, etc. Then you'll look up from your keyboard, 3 years have passed, and all that has happened is it got worse.
- amyjess 11y agoI went through that last year. For me, the inertia was a little stronger because of my gender transition. I had zero experience interviewing as a woman, and I wasn't sure if I passed, so I figured it was safer to continue working for the same company I transitioned at. The logic was "they know me, they knew me before transition, they know I've only been living as a woman less than a year, and I already know they don't care, so I might as well take the safe option and stick with them rather than risk freaking an interviewer out with my voice or accidentally wear something a woman shouldn't wear to an interview". Mind you, my employer at the time wasn't great. I was underpaid (75% market value in pure salary, plus I got no insurance whatsoever), my boss couldn't handle stress and took it out by screaming at his subordinates, software engineering leadership was absolutely terrible for multiple reasons (I and others tried to change it, and we were rebuffed, so the people I worked best with quit in frustration one by one), and I had a months-long nightmare involving the building management discriminating against me where my employer offered me almost no support (it only ended when I got the city involved). There were a number of other minor concerns as well, but these were the big ones. During the worst of the discrimination, the owner/CEO promised me a bonus if I stuck around until our next product entered production. Production was delayed by two months from what was originally planned, and even then getting him to actually keep his promise was like pulling teeth, though I eventually got it. Somehow, I ended up staying on even after that, though I should've probably at least started applying for jobs once the bonus cleared my bank account. It took way, way too long for me to accept that I needed to find a new job. Ultimately, after a particularly bad incident of my boss taking his stress out on me, I finally got up the courage to put myself out there, I got a wonderful new job, and I'm more than happy with my current employer. In the long run, the devil you know is the worse devil.
- teddyuk 11y agoFor me it is really simple, if you don't like the way you are treated then leave. If you don't have any employable skills, get some. If you have genuinely no chance of being employed somewhere start your own business and graft graft graft until you are employable. Life is too short to spend 6 years in a job that affects you and your whole family.
- s3nnyy 11y agoMany people are fooled by prestige. PG's elaboration on it changed my life: "Your opinions about what's admirable are always going to be slightly influenced by prestige, so if two options seem equal to you, you probably have more genuine admiration for the less prestigious one. [...] If you admire two kinds of work equally, but one is more prestigious, you should probably choose the other." (http://www.paulgraham.com/love.html http://www.paulgraham.com/love.html) I went to a no-name company, I love the freedom that I have in a small team, and I leave work around 4-5 p.m., if I want. Also, I have still enough energy to do side-projects. That is something people working at more prestigious places probably lack. (I am based in Zurich and I love it; here a blogpost about living & working here: https://medium.com/@iwaninzurich/eight-reasons-why-i-moved-to-switzerland-to-work-in-it-c7ac18af4f90 https://medium.com/@iwaninzurich/eight-reasons-why-i-moved-t...)
- fennecfoxen 11y ago> Easy immigration (for EU citizens) The lucky schmucks. As far as I could tell from research, immigrating as a US citizen is not an operation they support at all.
- s3nnyy 11y agoA company can get you a work permit into Switzerland by showing that they can not find anyone else: An employer has to show a couple of EU/Swiss-resumes to the authorities and point out how they are not suited for the job and how you are. I know a company that has done that with Ukrainians and Russians. Shoot me a mail, if you are interested in moving here; I can try to help out.
- nogridbag 11y agoI chose a similar route because of perks and pay. My only fear is this choice hurting my future employment when I'll likely be discriminated due to age. I would imagine having Google or Facebook on my resume would surely make getting a job at age 50+ much easier.
- s3nnyy 11y ago
- anentropic 11y agosounds like they need a union
- kabdib 11y agoOne of my cow-orkers is an ex Amazonian. Not damaged, though he rather disliked the culture. Amazon lost a good egg when we hired him. He says that the only thing you can expense without a manager's permission is a pager. Which, if true, tells you a lot about Amazon.
- a8da6b0c91d 11y agoIt's retail. Margins are thin. Walmart is notoriously cheap. Don't work in low margin, hyper-competitive businesses, is the long and short of it.
- therobot24 11y agoSimilar to the retail experience - find kids who are ok with selling warranties/pre-orders each week and if they fail to do so then bring in someone else from the stack of applications in the back.
- deskamess 11y agoThere is no recourse for this because IT workers do not have to be (legally) paid overtime. Remove that legality and enforce overtime to be paid at 1.5x regular wage, and you should see a better workplace and higher employment. I think productivity numbers will also be realistic (lower). The legality of uncompensated overtime drives me crazy. There is a lot that practitioners in our profession have yet to learn - valuing ourselves and what we do.
- muraiki 11y agoSomething that I was impressed by when I interviewed at my current job was not just that the company said that they value work-life balance, but that they demonstrated it: they pay time-and-a-half for overtime specifically in order to dissuade management from ever having us work overtime. And in the year I've been here we've had one period where we could optionally work overtime, but we've had no mandatory overtime. I didn't appreciate how great of a boon this was until I learned more about what it's like to work at other companies. Overtime isn't just about making more money, it's also about having realistic expectations of workers and not burning them out.
- no1youknowz 11y agoI've turned down plenty of offers whenever the subjects come up. There is a pager that rotates There are meetings after office hours There is a night-shift that rotates There is support that everyone is expected to do There is no training paid for by the company There is no advancement in career (small company) There is no payrise for the next N years All of these things are a huge RED flag for me and I move on to another interview. Seriously, no thanks!
- worklogin 11y agooncall and support are instant turnaways? How do you get employed in IT?
- grecy 11y agoMy former company (a telco) offered me an amazing "promotion". Way more responsibility, way more accountability, AND formally on-call off hours and weekends. The schedule was vague, but it looked like roughly one week in three I couldn't be more than 30 minutes from the office, had to respond all the time, etc. All of this for the amazing salary raise of zero dollars and zero cents over my existing salary! Needless to say I no longer work there - but they found someone else to do it.
- aianus 11y ago> There's no recourse for this If they grossly misrepresented the job you can just leave in the first month or two and not mention it on your resume. It's not like it's a tough job market out there.
- erroneousfunk 11y agoI think the big problem is that people often move (like the author did with his wife) to work for Amazon and feel pressured to stick with it for more than a month or two, especially if they have families.
- pm24601 11y agoDon't forget in the NYTimes article : you had to payback the signing bonus and relocation reimbursement if you left within a year.
- zo1 11y ago"There's no recourse for this, and management knows it" Of course there is, I'd argue. Maybe not a direct one, though. I'm sure you've noticed the large amount of articles about these sorts of practices at Amazon. It might not have a huge impact, but if it is indeed true, then people are wisening up to what's going on there.