11 ms·
I always find it interesting how many people automatically agree drunk driving should be a crime. Drunk driving per se is victimless- only when life or property
by hammock 11y ago
I always find it interesting how many people automatically agree drunk driving should be a crime. Drunk driving per se is victimless- only when life or property are injured is there a victim, and there are already crimes/legal remedies in place for those cases.
Consider the case where a drunk driver gets home safely while obeying all traffic laws. Or even the case where a drunk driver is swerving- she can already be pulled over under a reckless driving statute.
- donatj 11y agoI have argued this many times, but it usually gets heated on the internet where someone undoubtably knows someone who died from a drunk driver. That said I honestly believe the far and vast majority of drunk driving is victimless, and probably less dangerous than distracted driving.
- underwater 11y agoMaybe the reason people keep telling you that you are wrong is not because they're overly emotional or biased, but because you're actually wrong.
- kbenson 11y agoI think the difference between distracted driving and drunk driving is the foreknowledge of impairment, and intentional increase of danger to the public. As such, in many states driving while texting or on the phone without a hands-free system are also illegal. The reasoned decision that someone's convenience is above the safety of the public is what I see as the problem here (and of course if someone isn't sober enough to make a reasoned decision about that, then I definitely don't think they have any place operating a piece of heavy equipment).
- bobwaycott 11y ago> foreknowledge of impairment, and intentional increase of danger to the public. That sounds to me exactly like distracted driving.
- kbenson 11y agoYes, as in using a phone or being subject to a perception altering substance, as I stated. But you can also become distracted while driving without the ability to quickly stop driving. This could be the fault of the driver (paying attention to irrelevant things), or out of their control (conditions warrant splitting your attention between the road in front of you an another circumstance you have no control over). We don't punish these because we person is either not willfully causing the situation, or there is no way to determine if their behavior contributed. Another way to think of it is that you aren't punished for drunk driving, but for breaking the law, and the law has been decided by determining that drunken driving provides unacceptable risk overall. Whether individually a person would have caused harm is irrelevant, we create a enforce laws for the good of all, and without enforcement, or selective enforcement without due process, we have a slew of other problems.
- bobwaycott 11y agoYou were remarking on the difference between distracted driving and drunk driving. I was replying that your stated difference did not sound like a difference at all. Given the context of the surrounding discussion, I didn't think anyone was talking about situations of accidental distraction while driving.
- kbenson 11y agoI was trying to additionally distinguish between accidental and intentional distracted driving, because I find that when a distinction can be made like that but it isn't made clear, people end up talking past each other about slightly different things but with the same name. I was a bit unclear in what I was doing though.
- bobwaycott 11y agoWise enough. I suppose I was taking it for granted that we were discussing intentional actions that place others in danger, and automatically excluding accidents.
- brohoolio 11y agoGenerally when you know someone who has died because of the choices of someone else it impacts how you view those choices. I was in physical therapy next to someone who wasn't going to walk again because of a chronic drunk driver. Distracted driving / texting while driving should be punished on the same level as drunk driving IMHO. It's really dangerous and until it's actively enforced people are going to get hurt often. I ride my bike to work and it is so dangerous because of people texting. I've seen several accidents happen because one driver is texting and the one in front of them has to stop.
- serge2k 11y agoYeah, but all the other times where the drunk didn't hit someone it was victimless. So no need to try to stop him going out and driving drunk yet again.
- walshemj 11y agoIf your commute is anything like London its the HGV (large trucks) vehicles that are the killers not texting while driving. 90% or so of the fatalities in london are caused by cyclists undertaking HGV's who turn into them.
- logiclabs 11y agoThat's only the number of fatalities. A large number of serious injury occurs across a wider range of vehicles than just HGV's. I'd say the majority are probably down to poor driving judgement, and a modest number are due to distractions. A lot of these HGV injuries are to do with bad road design and poor cyclist judgement - pulling along side the left-hand side of a HGV while it's stationery into both the drivers blind spot and being unable to see the vehicles indicators. A few of the fatalities I know of were pretty unnecessary, since there are more than adequate cycle paths to skip around the dangerous sections of road. The Elephant and Castle roundabout is particularly notorious, but is surrounded by much safer cycle paths. Despite this, a large majority of cyclists stick to the highly dangerous road, and probably the same majority that decide to risk running red lights. (I am a cyclist, so I'm not starting a cyclist vs driver debate)
- tempestn 11y agoKudos for stating a taboo or at least unpopular opinion in a reasoned manner. I do think that drunk driving should be a crime, because on balance I expect making it so does more good than harm. There are certainly people who choose not to drive when intoxicated for no other reason than fear of being caught and punished. That said, I agree with aspects of your point: it should certainly be a greater crime to be swerving around the road while intoxicated than to simply blow slightly over the limit on a breathalyzer with no other symptoms, and while it could already be charged as multiple offenses, I'm not sure that that's often done in practice. Also, I tend to lean against "zero tolerance" laws, where any BAC whatsoever is a crime. Heck, you could even argue that a particularly good driver and/or someone with a high alcohol tolerance may be safer even when impaired than some drivers are unimpaired; perhaps then the oldschool impairment tests - walk in a line, touch your nose, etc., are fairer than the theoretically more impartial breathalyzer. I'm not sure how I feel about that, but it seems like a reasonable argument at least.
- titanomachy 11y agoYour comment made me think of cops pulling over a driver and sticking them in a VR driving sim for a few minutes to test their response time and motor control. Implausible, sure, and we'll probably have autonomous cars before it can become a reality... but it would be interesting to test for actual driving impairment rather than a proxy like a breathalyzer (or even walking in a straight line). It would also give police an opportunity to remove other dangerous drivers from the road, e.g. certain elderly or sleep-deprived drivers.
- nmrm2 11y agoThis wouldn't work. Motor control isn't the only (or most significant) problem with drunk driving. It's the combination with impaired judgement/attentiveness that can be so deadly. If you're in a VR driving sim with a cop standing next to you, you're going to pay attention and (virtually) drive, constantly paying attention to the speedometer and road signs. Rather than flipping through stations while turning around to tell a joke to the people in the back seat. Or just zoning out on a routine drive and not realizing you're 40 over. It's why people often say "I'm a better driver when I'm drunk" -- not true for sloppy drunk, but probably true for slightly drunk because the fear of DUI causes them to intently focus when otherwise they would be on auto-pilot not devoting their full attention to the operation of a deadly machine.
- sitharus 11y agoWhile I agree that all laws should be questioned your example here misses the point. When intoxicated with alcohol your reaction times and concentration level are slowed. You may obey all road rules perfectly on your normal drive home when drunk, but one night something may be a bit different - a train crossing that isn't normally used, an inattentive driver who pulls out slightly two late, or a pedestrian who crosses a bit slower than most people - and you're now in an accident that would have been avoided had you been sober and had your normal reaction and reasoning skills. It's not the stereotypical swerving red-light-running drunk driver that we target with drink-driving laws, as you've mentioned that's already covered by dangerous driving laws.
- aianus 11y agoWhen young/old/stupid/tired your reaction times and concentration level are slowed. But there are no laws against those things (unless you're actually driving badly).
- zeroonetwothree 11y agoDrunk driving causes 10,000 deaths/year according to the article. How many are caused by the factors you mention? Doubtless some, but it's clearly not our top priority, especially given that it's much easier to give someone a breathalyzer test than to check for "stupidity" or "tiredness".
- dllthomas 11y agoI expect quite a few are caused by tiredness specifically. I would not be surprised if it exceeded the drunk driving numbers (although I wouldn't be terribly surprised if it failed to either).
- bmelton 11y agoTo be fair, tiredness is likely attributable to a great deal of road related injuries, but it isn't tracked because being tired isn't a criminal act. I'm not saying you're wrong, per se, but suggesting that you're right due to the absence of evidence is premature. That said, while I don't know how official these numbers are, the NHTSA attributes 100,000 accidents to driver fatigue per year, and while the victim count is currently lower than your assertion for drunk driving, I think that driving while fatigued is underreported for the reasons I mentioned above.
- sliverstorm 11y agoShooting at people is victimless- only when the bullets actually hit people is there a victim, and there are already crimes/legal remedies in place for that. Consider the case where a shooter sprays bullets in a crowded building wildly, but no one is actually hit. Rightly or wrongly, drunk driving is considered endangerment of others. endangerment comprises several types of crimes involving conduct that is wrongful and reckless or wanton, and likely to produce death or grievous bodily harm to another person. Similar to crimes like attempted murder, we do not allow endangerment even though it may be the case that no one was hurt, because Person A took a high risk with Person B's life and we do not consider that acceptable.
- plonh 11y agoThat's not what "victimless" means. Victimless means no one is harmed, not even statistically, in consensually. Getting high at home, or having consensual sex, are victimless crimes.
- sliverstorm 11y agoThen drunk driving is not victimless, and my argument isn't needed anyway.
- sandworm101 11y agoBe careful about the victimless label. Just because an individual action does not cause harm does not mean that it should not be punished as if it had. The act is the same. Whether or not someone is physically injured is largely a matter of luck. It would be horrific if punishments were handed out on that basis alone. A long time ago I read a statement from a judge sentencing two defendants for felony murder. They both shot and a man was dead, but there was a debate as to which bullet actually killed. "The only difference between the two was aim, and I am not going to let one off for being the poorer shot." The more appropriate word for such laws are "regulatory crimes". They are meant to regulate behavior to prevent or reduce an evil that does not occur in all cases. This covers everything from practicing medicine without a license to drug possession, neither of which necessarily cause a physical harm in every case.
- gnaritas 11y agoAnd yet, punishing people who haven't hurt anyone seems far worse the crime. Victim-less isn't a label, it's a statement of fact that no one was hurt and thus cannot claim injury; there should be no such crimes. "Regulatory crime" is way of putting a soft label on a terrible practice, punishing the innocent just because something "might" have happened. What you call luck, others call knowing their limits.
- tempestn 11y agoI know you may not mean this literally, but taken at face value, you're saying even attempted murder (assuming you don't end up harming your intended victim) shouldn't be a crime. I would actually argue that an attempted murder should be considered almost as great, if not as great, a crime as one that succeeded. Similarly for most crimes, in my opinion the intent is at least as important as the act itself. Basically just because someone hasn't been hurt, it doesn't mean that a behaviour is acceptable in society.
- unfamiliar 11y agoNobody gets into a car drunk with the intention of harming someone else. With attempted murder there is clear intent to do harm. A better comparison would be to manslaughter - if you do something dangerous which leads to the accidental death of somebody you are punished. The question would be, if you do something dangerous and nobody happens to be hurt, should you still be punished? Should "attempted manslaughter" be a thing?
- underwater 11y agoBut isn't swerving is victimless too? And running a red light or speeding or driving against traffic on the freeway? If we only punish people for behavior that results in injury or damage then you're relying on each and every driver to correctly assess the risks of their behavior. People are notoriously bad at doing that, so any punishment will be ineffective as a deterrent.
- mangamadaiyan 11y agoYes indeed! For some kind of evidence towards this, try walking on the streets of a city where running red lights, speeding, and driving on the wrong side of the road are reasonably common. (I'm not joking - where I live, this /is/ common.) It's a victimless crime, all right - but only until the next victim.
- slavik81 11y agoI'd argue it's not. People breaking traffic rules erode my ability to travel. If they were to regularly speed through red lights, I'd have to stop at green lights to watch for them. I have a right to travel through on a green light, but they'd take that from me. We need to obey the rules of the road so other drivers can reason about our behaviour. We could have no rules, but it would be much less efficient. This is the prisoner's dilemma and the law enforces cooperation.
- titanomachy 11y agoTrue, you don't have to be killed or maimed to be a "victim".
- mangamadaiyan 11y agoThank you, slavik and titanomachy - this was pretty much the point I was /trying/ to make, it didn't come out right.
- gnaritas 11y agoYou're confusing crimes with civil violations of rules, so let me be more clear; when I say crimes I mean things for which you can be incarcerated. A ticket and a fine for a civil violation is outside the scope of my meaning. A DUI can get you put in jail, even if you're fine to drive, even if you haven't ingested a substance in days. DUI's don't just apply to alcohol you know.
- brohoolio 11y agoIf you've known someone who's gotten hurt or killed by drunk driving you stop seeing it as a victimless crime. There is no right to access public streets while intoxicated with two tons of steel.
- imakesnowflakes 11y agoI agree with you that it is not a crime by definition. But I think there should be a sufficient detriment to prevent people from doing this. And I think labeling it as a crime is the easiest thing to this end. What is the alternative? Being frowned upon? You say about how people automatically agree drunk driving should be a crime. But I always use to wonder how blindly we trust others on the road to behave responsibly. How often we leave our lives and our loved ones, to the fair judgement of a stranger. Driving on roads will be impossible, without that trust. When you are drunk, and choose to drive when you judgement is poor, you are betraying the trust implicitly placed on you by every other person on the road. So isn't that something like a crime? Just thinking loudly. I tell this as a moderate drinker myself.
- superuser2 11y agoSobriety is one of the conditions of the social contract you sign (literally, on your license application) in exchange for access to society's roads. Jail time is not really appropriate. Really, you should just lose access to public roads. But license revocation is adulthood revocation for all but the privileged few in SF, NYC, and maybe Chicago. In most of this country you can't get groceries or primary medical care without driving, and you certainly can't hold a job or provide a normal life for your children. A five-figure fine and even a month or two in jail is many times less severe than permanent loss of driving privileges; that's life-destroying (pretty much your only option is to drop everything and move to a high-cost-of-living area of a high-cost-of-living city to get adequate public transit coverage).
- serge2k 11y agoSo don't drive drunk. Oh look, problem solved.
- gnaritas 11y agoNo, not solved; DUI applies to more than alcohol, the issue isn't so simplistic.
- kwhitefoot 11y agoFines should be related to one's income. In Finland you can be unlucky enough to be fined a quarter of a million Euros for speeding if your income is high enough, same in Switzerland I think.
- titanomachy 11y ago> license revocation is adulthood revocation for all but the privileged few in SF, NYC, and maybe Chicago This is almost certainly true in America, but keep in mind that some other societies view driving somewhat differently. America represents less than one twentieth of the world's population. In major European cities, at least, car ownership seems to be the exception rather than the rule.
- 11y ago
- serge2k 11y agoand when they hit another car and kill someone that's okay too because punishing them at that point brings the other person back to life.
- edanm 11y agoSo, you raise an interesting point. I have two follow-up questions. Firstly, I'm not sure what "victimless" means exactly, and I think you may be taking it too literally. As people in the many comments below have pointed out, there are plenty of crimes which are "victimless", e.g. taking a machine gun and "spraying" a crowd of people with bullets, but failing to hit anyone. Is this a "victimless" crime? At what point do we decide to set the bar? Come to think of it, there are charges of "reckless endangerment", where someone it can be a crime to do something which endangers other people in a reckless manner. Drunk driving certainly falls under those, so I'd say that drunk driving laws are simply enhancements of "reckless endangerment" laws, providing more specific context. Secondly, we as a society will often choose to make our laws based on certain factors, like what an average citizen knows For example, driving under the influence causes a variety of physical changes that are not obvious and not known by every single driver, e.g. slower response times. These are things that a reasonable driver might not even realise are impacting them, and might not feel when they are partially drunk. But we, as a society that has done scientific tests, know that these effects always happen. In this case, it makes sense to block actions that we know are harmful.
- gnaritas 11y ago> Firstly, I'm not sure what "victimless" means exactly, and I think you may be taking it too literally. As people in the many comments below have pointed out, there are plenty of crimes which are "victimless", e.g. taking a machine gun and "spraying" a crowd of people with bullets, but failing to hit anyone. Is this a "victimless" crime? You've just terrorized a crowd of people, that's hardly victim-less; plenty of people there to complain about direct harm you've caused them, perhaps a few who will suffer years of PTSD. Plenty of lawsuits about to happen, victims by definition. > At what point do we decide to set the bar? If no one is aware enough to try and sue you, then you haven't hurt them, and thus your action is by definition victimless. You seem to think DUI means alcohol only, it's a bigger issue than that and it's an absurd law that can get you in trouble literally days after you've been sober because it applies to all substances, not just alcohol. We have several states now with legal recreational marijuana, think about that. Many things people do while driving are far more influential on their response times than being "intoxicated", being tired is far more dangerous, being old is far worse on response times. DUI laws are unjust.
- melling 11y agoIt's the people who kill someone who ruin it for everyone else. http://wtnh.com/2015/07/09/drunk-driver-will-serve-4-years-for-killing-north-haven-jogger/ http://wtnh.com/2015/07/09/drunk-driver-will-serve-4-years-f... You are a fucking idiot.
- dang 11y ago> You are a fucking idiot. Personal attacks aren't allowed on HN. Please don't do this again.
- melling 11y agoPerhaps others could take the time to better explain to people why, when 10,000 people in the U.S. alone are killed every year, it's probably far from a victimless crime? You might want to consider that you might save a life by being a little less polite. Thirty years ago I had a friend who's dad was drinking and driving, and he put someone in the hospital. He couldn't understand why the other family kept giving him evil looks. So, in those 30 years, the 300,000+ people killed and the millions injured, would have been much better off if we simply took a less tolerant view of drinking and driving. http://www.cbsnews.com/news/dwi-deaths-is-it-murder/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/dwi-deaths-is-it-murder/ Hey, I always look forward to the "do you code better when drunk" discussions by the same demographic.
- mikeash 11y agoIs it OK to shoot at you as long as I miss? Is it OK to poison your food if you turn out to be immune? Is it OK if I cut corners building your house to the extent that it's structurally unsound, as long as it doesn't actually collapse? Is it OK if your car's airbags spray shrapnel when they activate, if you never activate them?
- revelation 11y agoHere is the thing: through tens of years of auto dominance and "it's just an accident" precedent it has been rendered pretty much impossible to even charge anyone for killing someone with a car. Or injuring them, but then cops won't even investigate if all there is is an injury. The simple reason we need drunk driving laws is exactly because they are victimless. It rightfully establishes strict liability.
- rayiner 11y agoIts not victimless. The moment you got in the car, you created an increased risk for everyone else on the road. If someone came up to you, and asked you: how much would I have to pay you for an extra 0.1% chance that some drunk driver kills you on your way home from work tonight? The answer would not be $0. The risk it creates is in and of itself something that justifies criminalizing the activity.
- buzz27 11y agoI'd actually grasp the other horn: I think the penalty for impaired/reckless/distracted driving should be the same whether you happen to kill someone or not. We all know that you drastically increase the risk of killing someone, it is only blind luck that prevented it. The penalties should not be capricious.