7 ms·
I do not think the pressure comes directly from the need for higher grades. I think it come from how those grades are created. I my academic history (highscho
by sandworm101 11y ago
I do not think the pressure comes directly from the need for higher grades. I think it come from how those grades are created.
I my academic history (highschool, undergrad, law school, now teaching) I only felt real stress where grades were incremental. Take my civpro class. We had an assignment after only three lectures, an assignment worth 5% of our grade. I had barely wrapped my head around law school and already my final grade, my scholarship, was on the line. I did poorly on that assignment, immediately chopping a few points off my final grade. On the other hand my crimlaw class had no assignments, just a big exam at the end. That class allowed me the time to figure things out and was much less stressful.
The highschool kids I talk to today are in a constant panic. ((That's how I see it. For them it's just normal.)) Grades are ridiculously high, with class averages well north of 90%. So every test, every graded assignment, requires the focus of a final exam. They cannot afford diversion or outside learning. Each week is prep for the next test and each of those tests directly impacts their grade. Have a bad week, or even a bad afternoon, and it might stick with you for years. They don't dare read anything that isn't assigned for fear of not aligning with the teacher's "learning plan". If it didn't come from teacher it isn't on next week's test and is therefore useless. Imho this constant "exam mode" is the real source of stress.
So drop the microtests. Give them the one big exam and let them relax and learn at their own pace the rest of the time.
- onionjake 11y agoI took a class from Matt Might and I like how we were graded: "Your grade is your tests grade or your projects grade, whichever is higher." http://matt.might.net/teaching/compilers/spring-2015/#grading http://matt.might.net/teaching/compilers/spring-2015/#gradin... This allowed both the really good test takers to succeed and also those who did better on projects, without all the pressure.
- toomim 11y ago...at the expense of people who are moderately good at both.
- onionjake 11y agoI believe the sentiment was more: I understand that you may have a bad day/week/month and do poorly on a project, but don't sweat it. If you really do know your stuff you can still prove it on the exams. I think it is fair and better than purely weighted grades because it allows for momentary failure while still requiring knowledge of the material.
- pmichaud 11y agoNot really. If you're moderately good at both then you'll get a similar score on both, and they will average out to about the same as both. So you'll still get the score you would've gotten before.
- pedrosorio 11y agoAs opposed to everyone else who will get a higher score than they would've gotten before. That means your grade will be worse than it would've been otherwise when compared to your peers (which is the only useful meaning of a grade).
- nitrogen 11y agoPeople who are really good at one thing but not another are very useful in society, and this grading system would seem to reflect that fact.
- Jach 11y agoThat would seem to justify the commonly done separation of project courses from non-project courses. It's not a great idea to lump the two together, nearly always one or the other suffers if the project is non-trivial. But even then one can suffer, it's just spread out across all classes instead of the individual class. Project courses are tricky to integrate into a curriculum well.
- chii 11y agoi wouldn't say specialization in taking exams is a useful skill for society.
- stfu 11y agoI am absolutely against that exam culture so I like that suggestion a lot. The exam perspective is just completely artificial which has nothing to do with the real world. That project based approach mirrors the real world much better where you can compensate for almost anything just by rising the effort one is putting into something.
- lbaskin 11y agoDisagree. While I did well in the same system in law school, most people I know hated the one-and-done testing system. That said, you do have a point in situations where testing is practically constant (and affects the final grade) - there's probably a happy medium to be found somewhere...
- sandworm101 11y agoI certainly remember many students with that view. After first year they started carefully arranging courses and boasted about how they would never have to write another exam ... until the bar. I think I had a final for every course but LRW and a bioethics class.
- lbaskin 11y agoYep, same here - paper classes were a real pain and always made the end of a semester rather unpleasant with deadlines looming. Just saying that system is a bit extreme, and I don't think it's universally applicable.
- adam419 11y agoYeah I actually advocate for the moderate form of what you're expressing. My issue with single, high-worth exams was that sometimes I would screw up, have some misconception in my head, and if it wasn't cleared up until the exam I was done. I think you should be examined on a semi-regularly basis where each exam is worth an equal amount of grade. That way the effects of various externalities, like I was sick, had something bad happen that week, or just didn't learn the material as well as I thought could be smoothed out of a period of time.
- sandworm101 11y agoThere are things that can be done within exams to counter those issues. For instance, the exams I set are heavily scaled. There may be 200 points available to be earned across 15 short essay questions. The raw scores generally fall between 45-90, which I then scale to set an acceptable average. So you can bomb or even skip questions and still be top of the class. Not much can be done if a student is sick on the day, but I would argue that multiple tests on multiple days only increases the likelihood of sickness during at least one test.
- kagamine 11y agoI have never understood scaling, exams are meant to provide employers and yourself with a rating of how well you know the subject, ideally in comparison to everyone else in the field. So if you fail, but everyone else fails too, you get an A. If yo do 'well' but a group of 5 out of 30 excel, you get a lower than representative grade (representative of your knowledge). How about making the questions worth points and the 100 points = 100%? 93+ = A, 80-93 = B etc. That's how all 3 of my undergrad degrees worked. I knew what I needed to do for a grade and damn everyone else.
- aninhumer 11y agoNormalisation makes more sense over larger populations. If most people across a large group do much worse on a particular exam, is it more likely that everyone screwed up, or that the exam was unusually hard?
- jeffdavis 11y ago"So drop the microtests." I disagree. Tests are part of the learning process. The problem is when expectation is 90%+. When that happens, there's no margin to differentiate between minor mistakes and actual misunderstandings -- the signal is lost in the noise. A good test will amplify the signal and attenuate the noise.
- wisty 11y agoFormative or summative tests? There's no rule that says every test has to count to your final grade.
- threatofrain 11y agoI think the calibration of quizzes and tests is already an area of research that is receiving academic attention, it's just that there's a gulf between research and practice. I also agree with emphasizing tests more, since measuring homework is so noisy (tutors and parents double-checking homework), but I definitely don't think having one big test is the right way. One of the reasons why people might face test stress is by dealing with the stress at the last minute.
- fezz 11y agoLearning, understanding & doing: real value for self Testing: external value for others The latter is useless in both the real world and for the student. Tests/grades aren't the only way to show progress. (disclaimer: dad homeschooling a kid)
- hkmurakami 11y agoWell I suppose that is the Oxbridge model. And you're right. It allowed me to pursue extracurriculars (rowing) throughout the year and then adjust to final exam studying at the end of the year.
- bitL 11y agoMicrotests should be bonuses; they should contribute to your final grade but you should be able to get A on the final exam even with 0 bonus points. So for a person that works during the year this alleviates the final exam pressure while allowing others that for any reason weren't scoring a lot to prove they mastered what was required.
- amag 11y agoThis is how it worked at my University some 15 years ago (for some classes at least). The teacher would give us optional assignments that if completed would score against the final exam. ASFAIR completing all assignments successfully meant you didn't need to take the exam unless you aimed for a higher grade than pass.
- aninhumer 11y agoThe UK system (at least when I was doing it) at GCSE (14-16) and A-level (16-18) consists of smaller module exams, but students are allowed to retake the exams each time they're administered. So if they do well, it takes the pressure off their future exams, but it's not the end of the world if they don't. (EDIT: They're also standardised, which is pretty much necessary for this to work.) I think it's a good balance between the massive short-term stress of big exams, and the consistent stress of smaller exams.
- jvvw 11y agoOxford has no exams in the second year for many subjects (and no tests other than maybe college 'collections' at the start of each term which don't count for anything, but my college didn't even do those for my subject). Personally I really liked it as it gave me a lot of time to spend trying to really understand my subject without exams and revision hanging over me. It also helped I think that our tutors didn't generally set or mark the exams when we did have them. It did put a lot of pressure on for finals though knowing everything was hanging on how you performed over the course of eight exams in a fortnight.
- datr 11y agoCambridge does this as well and I can't say I was a fan. In mathematics, three years of learning ends up being evaluated through five three-hour exams administered over the course of a week. All it takes is one to fall ill for that week and all of a sudden you don't get a grade. The best case scenario is you can convince the examination board your illness contributed to your performance and they might award you a DDH (Deemed to have Deserved Honours) which no one will really understand.
- lordnacho 11y agoI went to Oxford, and this actually happened to me. I got ill during exams, and there's no mercy. I sat in the exam halls sweating, unable to breathe properly, trying to hand-compute an analysis of variance calculation. And a bunch of other trivial stuff like singular value decomposition and other linear algebra riddles. I actually think having one big exam at the end isn't great. There's so much on the line you end up "learning" things too quickly, in a way that's focused on previous exam questions rather than actually learning stuff. And the stuff is actually interesting. Perhaps a pass/fail system would be better, spread out a bit. The problem with the system is that incremental gains in the exam result are favoured over learning that's hard to quantify.
- sjg007 11y agoYeah this is just the professors being lazy... The grief of having to write more tests and be accountable!
- zo1 11y agoImmediately, you've come up with a solution that wouldn't fit my type of learning, and my comfort level. I absolutely abhor "final" exams. It's like a grand-finale that is make or break, forcing you to study a ridiculous amount of content and make sure you know/understand all of it for a single event in the future. If you fail, you have to do it all over again. No course-corrections, no motivational reminders/nudges. Nothing. The example you cite in the beginning, your fear of the impending results of a small test. Now multiply that by 20 (as you said yours was just 5% of the final mark), and that is how anxious I would be for the entire course leading up to the final exam. So drop the ubertests. Test students understanding using application and insight, not giant knowledge dumps that can only be tested in one long-winded sitting. (I exaggerate a little, sorry about that).
- Folcon 11y agoI have to wonder, if the outcome we are interested in is whether students understand the material, can't we do both? Some optional mid point tests, where the student can chose to keep the grade or bet it all on that final assessment? I mean tests only exist to convince us that they know the material. Why does it matter how it works, beyond the test being an accurate reflection of their understanding?
- jsharpe 11y agoWhy not both? Some of my favourite classes have said, "Highest of midterms + assignment marks or final exam mark."
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoNow that is brilliant
- starfis 11y agoAlmost all of my computer science classes had two grading schemes - one "normal" one and another which was basically just taking your grade on the final exam and not counting anything else. That latter option actually saved me one time, but that's because I was astronomically lazy in that class and didn't do anything (didn't even show up to some quizzes, I think, when two quizzes added up to an exam). I definitely think that giving students the option is good, though, because if you asked me which I'd want I will always choose the small incremental tests over one huge test.
- orthoganol 11y ago> I do not think the pressure comes directly from the need for higher grades. I strongly disagree, it entirely comes from the narrative instilled in all of us that we're screwed if we don't get top grades, that I am a huge failure if I can't get into an elite program. If that pressure wasn't there, neither would this problem. Some kids literally think it's the end of their life if they don't get into x,y,z school. There's no one telling them that college doesn't actually matter a fraction as much as it's built up in their head. Just get a degree, but I mean, at this point, 5 years out of college, you're not limited in the slightest by where your degree came from, not in this industry, where what skills you have and your hustle dictates all (granted a degree from an elite program gives you a marginal boost, but still marginal). My fellow Ivy League grads would get blown out of the water by some of the people I work with.
- littletimmy 11y agoThat is completely untrue. It may be true for tech jobs which rely on hard skills, but for any sort of management jobs, graduate school admissions, banking jobs - virtually anything else - pedigree matters a lot.
- collyw 11y agoThe majority of tech jobs here in Europe will expect a degree in CS or something similar in the listings.
- nske 11y agoAt least in the UK, it is definitely not like that. Most IT-related jobs do not mention a degree as requirement, and of those that do, many have an "or equivalent experience" clause. This is how I remember it to be when I was looking for a job 2 years ago, but I also made a quick search for "devops", "senior developer" and similar positions in London through indeed.co.uk just now to confirm it.
- saiya-jin 11y agoyes, but that's it. be it the best UNI in europe or worst in most cases doesn't have any impact at all, in worst is a very minor disadvantage that can be easily overcomed by showing skillset.
- littletimmy 11y agoCompletely agree with that. As someone who came from the British education system (one big exam end of year) to the American college system (a test every week), I quickly realized that in the US I had no time to read around the syllabus. If you're being tested every week, you Have to stick to plan. Essentially, it is "teaching to the test". I much prefer the British way. You have a lot of time to explore your interests without the risk of jeopardizing your future, you are given optional exams to test your knowledge, and you can bring it all together at the end of the year with a final exam.
- rndn 11y agoIt think the pressure comes from globalization. The meme for success has shifted from a local scope to the global one: You are only really successful if you work around the globe in an international company. There are however, due to hierarchical centralization, there are very few positions in the global market, so you end up with a lot of people competing for a very low number of high-end jobs. That creates pressure, and in return, out of empathy teachers grade more benevolently. At the same time the education systems became more centralized too, leading to competition as well: Good teachers are those with successful students, leading also to grade inflation yet again. I’m unsure whether this problem is solvable (e.g. with basic income or laws that penalize globalization), or whether it will solve itself with time.
- pragone 11y agoGotta disagree wholeheartedly with you there. If I have one big exam at the end, I will procrastinate and likely end up doing poorly. Instead, in my medical school, we are quizzed at least once a week - this week alone I have 2 quizzes and 2 tests. I failed yesterday's quiz, as I knew I would since was at a wedding on the weekend. But I will know the material for the test on Friday, and now I know what kind of questions to expect. Weekly testing lets me figure out how I'm progressing, whether or not my study habits are working, and also provides a significant amount of opportunities to do well - that quiz I failed yesterday really does not in anyway hinder me from acing the course.
- Hermel 11y agoA much better fix would be: don't count the two worst tests towards the average. This would allow you to screw up every now and then.
- redcalx 11y agoThe logical extreme version is to take the median score.
- jsharpe 11y agoYou don't want a scheme where you know your course mark before the final, because then you have no incentive to try, and median allows this. If your marks are 75, 80, 80, 90, then regardless of what you get on the final, your mark will be 80.
- juliangregorian 11y agoPresuming that "trying" on the final is necessarily a good thing of itself.
- douche 11y agoGenerally, outside of some relatively garbage introductory classes, I found that my classes either required 2-3 papers or projects, a midterm exam and a final, or some combination of the above. The more bullshit courses, generally with the shittier professors, would impose a "class participation" component of between 5-10%, and do other garbage like clicker-based quizzes during lectures to try to get people to actually come to class, instead of just doing the reading, when exams were not scheduled.
- walshemj 11y agoIt would be better to set grades on a distribution rather than an absolute mark so you know that an A is the top 5% of the cohort that took the exam.
- jimmaswell 11y agoI just got out of public highschool a few years ago and it was fairly easy 99% of the time. Even the final exams didn't take serious studying. Any work that was "hard" was generally more tedious than challenging. It was an easy coast to get 90s. Maybe it's not high schools in general, just specific districts.