6 ms·
A lot of the reliability problems with desktop 3D printers comes from the fact that they're forced by patents encumbering better methods to use Fused-Deposited
by moron4hire 11y ago
A lot of the reliability problems with desktop 3D printers comes from the fact that they're forced by patents encumbering better methods to use Fused-Deposited Material (FDM) style printing. Extruding plastic thread and building up a model from that requires a lot of moving parts, some with extreme thermal changes being applied to them.
I've seen a lot of DIY folk waste a lot of time on 3D printers. As it currently stands, I think you should expect at least a year, maybe even 2, of your hobby being "building a 3D printer" rather than "building things with a 3D printer" if you get into it.
If you don't want to spend a few thousand dollars (and even the cheap ones you end up spending on, because of the replacements and upgrades you'll need and want to do), don't want to put up with the hassle, then I have three suggestions:
- For simple things, stick to wood-working, it's significantly easier and faster than 3D printing. e.g. if all you need is a box to hold a Raspberry Pi, A) you can probably get a pre-fab box at an arts-and-crafts shop near you, or B) making boxes is not terribly difficult (there will be methods you will have to learn, it's not something you just jump into, but the actual techniques are not that hard).
- For things requiring precise dimensions and non-standard cuts, go with laser cutting. There are a wide variety of materials you can use, and a huge number of very cheap, very fast services you can employ. You basically draw your thing in InkScape or Adobe Illustrator, email it away, wait a day or two, and then glue your thing together. It is very easy and it makes for extremely clean and professional-looking "prototype grade" results.
- If you need the complexity of 3D printing: order from ShapeWays. Don't buy a 3D printer. If not ShapeWays, you might have a local shop that has 3D printing available. They will only charge you for the finished product, they don't charge you for the failures.
At this point in time, with the speed of all 3D printers being so bad, and the reliability of any 3D printer you could own on a single person's budget, there is no point to owning your own 3D printer. If that is going to change anytime in the near future, it will require a few seachanges in how we go about 3D printing. Otherwise, it's waiting for certain patents to expire.
- steve19 11y agoI disagree. it took a weekend to build my reprap from a parts kit imported from China. it took another weekend to tune it. easy.
- moron4hire 11y agoI would say you are very lucky. I used to work out of a hackerspace and got to see a lot of traffic come through with 3D printers. We also had several of our own. The only ones that worked reliably were the ones built and operated by a guy who was doing a PhD, studying the use of 3D printers in medicine. That was RepRaps, MakerBots, PrintrBots, UltiMakers, etc.
- marcosdumay 11y agoIt took me a week to build my reprap from parts (not kit) imported from China. It took me about a week to get it to print reliably, and it took about a year to get it to print reliably with different filaments, in varying weather, for long periods and without supervision. It's not the "you won't get anything done on the first year", but it's also not the "just a week of tinkering" either.
- dozzie 11y ago> - For simple things, stick to wood-working, it's significantly easier and faster than 3D printing. Or cardboard prototyping. Much less technology required, tools are much cheaper (glue gun, segmented knife, ruler, and a mat for cutting the cardboard), material can often be obtained at zero cost, and it's even faster to work with than wood. It can supplement woodworking (or 3D printing) really well.
- moron4hire 11y agoSure, depends on what you're doing. For 3 years, I had a coffee table I had built out of cardboard. Nobody could tell it was cardboard until they touched it.
- Gracana 11y agoEven metalworking isn't so hard to get into. You can get the tools anywhere, used or new, and there's an enormous number of books on the subject. The only power tool you really need at the start is an electric drill. Hacksaw, files, punches, chisels, etc.. all powered by you. No software needed either, cover your part with a fat sharpie (or better yet, blue dye) and use a scribe and punches to mark out what you want to cut and drill. If anyone is interested in this sort of stuff, check out Adam Savage's "One Day Builds" videos on youtube, they are great examples of the sorts of things you can do with basic tools and ingenuity.
- moron4hire 11y agoOh yeah. I think his "One Day Build" videos go a long way towards demystifying build process. I've seen a lot of people never start on their projects because they think the methods are inaccessible to them, for no reason other than they just don't know what the methods are. You can see it in their eyes. They walk in the hackerspace and they have this "we're not worthy!" look on their faces. "Stop it!" I'd tell them. The place is nothing without the people in it. The space is not sacred, it is not too good for you to insert yourself.
- Asbostos 11y agoI'm surprised that hobbyists building their own printer aren't going for the patented laser methods that actually make high quality parts. Surely you can make your own copy of a patented item, just not sell it. Even if you're not allowed to, nobody's going to know.
- moron4hire 11y agoHobbyists mostly build from kits, so the kits would be restricted by the patents.
- serge2k 11y agoIt's complicated and much more dangerous. 3d printer you need to be careful (it's hot) and probably want to get a solution for exhaust (smells and particulate). Laser sintering you have lasers melting metal particulate to form the piece. That goes wrong you end up with nasty consequences.
- moron4hire 11y agoI will say this: unless you have a lot of experience and really know what you're doing, start with laser-based systems (laser cutters, laser sinterers, etc) over a CNC router/mill. The failure mode is much more catastrophic with high-speed rotating parts. Worse thing that can happen with a laser is you start a small fire--startling for sure, but pretty easy to handle. Worst thing that can happen with a CNC mill: the milling head shatters and peppers you with high-velocity shrapnel.
- ridgeguy 11y agoNo, we can't use a patented method even if we don't sell stuff we make with it. From the USPTO site: "Patent infringement is the act of making, using, selling, or offering to sell a patented invention... http://www.uspto.gov/patents-maintaining-patent/patent-litigation/about-patent-infringement http://www.uspto.gov/patents-maintaining-patent/patent-litig...
- 0xffff2 11y ago
- dekhn 11y agowe purchased a Wan Hao Duplicator i3. it's a solid $400 printer. There is no hassle; it's better than a $2K MakerBot or anything else in the $2K price range. It just prints beautiful pieces repeatedly with no maintainence.
- willholloway 11y agoI just built a 3D printer (Reprap Prusa i3v) so I could design and build custom parts for a hardware project I'm doing and I think that this is overly pessimistic. I needed to print, try and tweak parts, if I ordered everything from shapeways my iterations would have been stretched out. Here is a page I wrote about my experiences: http://winterstartupchallenge.com/3dprinter.html http://winterstartupchallenge.com/3dprinter.html The only difficult thing was the calibration, making sure the surfaces were level etc... this could all be drastically improved with better reprap design. Learning how to design models that could be 3D printed took some time, but now its second nature and basically comes down to not having any overhangs greater than 45 degrees. I'm really glad I built my 3D printer and have the skillset. My ambition in life is to become what I call Master of the Intelligent Networked Machine, which is a grandiose way of saying I want to have the full skill set to design and build Internet of Things devices, from the hardware to the code. I think its the most valuable skillset around today and 3D printing is a valuable part of the toolset. It took me time to build the printer, but in the process I learned about the technology and I immediately saw the possibilities for using it in new and interesting ways. By seeing how a RepRap is built (commodity parts + custom home fabricated parts) it changed the way I designed and built my hardware product. Becoming a 3D printer master builder only took a couple months and was well worth it.