10 ms·
New evidence of Japan's effort to build atom bomb at the end of WWII
- transfire 11y agoI am a bit skeptical of this. Not even the Germans were close to building an atom bomb and it was their scientists that figured out the physics. If Japan did have any real plans on the board it probably had more to do with stolen intelligence garnered from the States. Also, it is unlikely anyone would have realistically expected uranium to be delivered to Japan by U-boat in 1945.
- dekhn 11y agoThis is well documented in detail in "Making of the Atomic Bomb". They had the will, but not the means. They had much of the knowledge, but not all of it. It's unlikely in any outcome of the war that they would have been able to refine enough uranium to make a useful bomb and then deliver it.
- Someone 11y agoThe part of Germany sending uranium to Japan is well-documented, and I have never heard someone doubt that it is true. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_submarine_U-234 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_submarine_U-234.
- peterfirefly 11y agoI love the name :)
- hga 11y agoit was [ German ] scientists that figured out the physics. Not exactly, although they contributed a lot to the early work. If we start from "splitting the [heavy] atom", the first practical method, a German radiochemist was the first to recognize what happened, and the German physicist he first forwarded this information and her nephew figured out how it worked. But those two were Jews in exile, and most of the following more practical stuff was figured out, correctly at least, by scientists outside of Germany. Inside, they suffered a couple of disasters, a silly failure to get an higher priority for the project, and an incorrect evaluation of using graphite as a moderator, limiting them to heavy water. Which we made sure through sabotage that they couldn't get more/enough of. But if you put on your alternate history cap, note Heisenberg and Himmer's relationship from when they were school kids, direct all the V-2 resources into the bomb, who knows? Many on both sides were legitimately worried the Germans would get the bomb in time. As for the Japanese, no way. Besides what you read in the article, thermal diffusion was all but a failure in the US, among other things required fantastically too much steam, and was only revived to provide somewhat enriched feed stock into the caltrons (modified cyclotrons), and later into the gaseous diffusion plant before it fed the caltrons. ADDED (forgotten while drafting): centrifuges were of course obvious, and about the first thing we tried, but were beyond the state of the art then. 1,200 pounds of uranium at the normal 0.72% U-235 would not come close to yielding one critical mass, and for gun assembly apparently you need more like 3 times the normal pressure critical mass, although it doesn't all have to be of the highest grade.
- argumentum 11y agoImagine if Hitler's worldview focused cultural rather than racial superiority .. we might all be speaking German.
- sandworm101 11y agoI read somewhere that after being captured by the allies some german physicists were recorded speaking in disbelief about the bomb. They were under the impression that any bomb would have needed many many times as much enriched uranium (think tons) resulting in weapons too big for aircraft. That was an indication they hadn't done much criticality research with enriched material.
- hga 11y agoThose guys at least weren't up on the state of the art. Early rough calculations indicated a huge mass might be required, which is why the Einstein–Szilárd letter to FDR said "A single bomb of this type, carried by boat and exploded in a port, might very well destroy the whole port together with some of the surrounding territory. However, such bombs might very well prove to be too heavy for transportation by air." On the other hand, with as far as I know no more info than the Germans had, Otto Frisch and Rudolf Peierls estimated in early 1940 that a kilogram of U-235 might do it, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frisch%E2%80%93Peierls_memorandum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frisch%E2%80%93Peierls_memoran... They pretty much laid out the correct physics mechanism (fast neutrons) and were only off by a factor of 15 on the amount required; pity for Adolph that they were Austrian and German Jews self-exiled in England by then.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoGoogle "Farm Hall transcripts", that's what you're thinking of. But you're quite right. Heisenberg used an incredibly faulty method of calculating critical mass. And everyone around him simply deferred to his expertise. His method involved considering a branching tree of neutron chain reactions inside a sphere of fissile material, and if this tree can grow to include about 1 mole of material then that should be about enough to release enough energy for a "bomb". The reality is that it's completely unnecessary for an entire neutron chain-reaction tree to be encompassed within fissile material. All that matters is that on average from generation to generation there is a multiplication of neutrons, which will then grow geometrically incredibly rapidly. And that can happen even with many "branches" of the tree leaving the sphere and not contributing to future reactions.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoGermany was severely hampered both by Hitler's poor leadership as well as several key mistakes by top nuclear scientists, which resulted in the perception of a bomb not being feasible.
- asanagi 11y agoEven if Japan had made a bomb in time, by 1945, they had barely any navy or air force left to deploy it. By then, the fantastically inept IJN leadership had squandered all their best assets in strategic blunders. The only way they could have used the thing would be to drop it on themselves.
- sandworm101 11y agoI wouldn’t use the phase "attempt to build the bomb". I wouldn't even call this an effort. I would label this as discussion or thought experiments. Drawing up a few blueprints for a centrifuge is no more an attempt to build a bomb than Project Daeidalus was an "attempt" to travel to another star. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Daedalus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Daedalus. The amount of effort necessary to build bombs during the 40s was ridiculous. Japan didn't have the industrial power. And I mean literal power as the manhatten project's Oak Ridge facility used something like 1/8th of US electricity at the time. "Electric energy consumption, courtesy of the TVA, was 20 percent higher than that of New York City. Oak Ridge used one-seventh of all the electricity produced in the United States" http://www.u-s-history.com/pages/h1652.html http://www.u-s-history.com/pages/h1652.html (not the best source, but reasonable given the context.) I'm all for discussion of ALL history but to bring forward claims that Japan was trying to build a bomb so close to the anniversary of its use against Japan smacks of guilt-motivated justification. Japan's "bomb" program was of absolutely no threat to allied forces and therefore should not be part of any debate over the use of nuclear weapons against Japan. If anything, a Japanese bomb program would have sucked up resources from other war efforts.
- brighteyes 11y agoFirst, it was certainly an effort. They had centrifuges, attempts to gather enough uranium, and so forth. That is more than "discussion" and "thought experiments" as you call it. Also, I see no point to your ad hominem attack that the article "smacks of guilt-motivated justification". The article presents interesting historical facts, and I don't see it suggesting that dropping the bomb on Japan was justified. Finally, was the Japanese effort to produce a bomb likely to succeed? In retrospect, we know it was definitely not. But you seem, in addition, to be very confident that they knew that fact at the time. Do you have a source for that?
- sandworm101 11y ago(1) Research centrifuges for separating isotopes and a plant capable of creating enough for a bomb are different beasts. The former gives you the knowledge to understand the scope of the later. (2) I don't attack only the article itself, but also its timing in relation to the anniversary. Americans are questioning the actions of their fathers and grandfathers re Japan and WWII. Any opinionated or politicized articles appearing now must be judged in that context. (3) The article ends with the quote "If we'd built the bomb first, of course we would have used it. I'm glad, in some ways, that our facilities were destroyed." That quote is meant to leave the reader with the concept that Japan would have done the same as the US had the situation been reversed. Even more so, it suggests that at least one person in Japan welcomed the bombings. Those are justification arguments that, given the enormity of the context and timing, should be strictly scrutinized.
- akilism 11y agoAmerica is building new nukes. https://www.revealnews.org/article/new-mexico-thrives-on-nuclear-bomb-despite-us-pledge-to-reduce-arsenal/ https://www.revealnews.org/article/new-mexico-thrives-on-nuc...
- gshubert17 11y agoThis article is about the warhead B61-12; the whole program is estimated to cost about $11 billion. This is scary, as the higher-precision guidance and adjustable lower yields make it more likely to be used; and sad, that President Obama and the various contractors and New Mexico politicians are pushing this.
- chiph 11y agoNuclear weapons have a definite "shelf life" because of the exotic materials used. But if you think about things like the screws & bolts used on them - every time a technician applies a tool to them, there's a little bit of wear and tear. Over time, these and other parts need replacing because of ongoing handling & routine maintenance. The socio-political aspects are a much broader topic. Personally I don't like them, but I realize that once Pandora's Box Of Technology has been opened, there's no going back.
- bsder 11y ago> Nuclear weapons have a definite "shelf life" because of the exotic materials used. Not only that, but, because of the secrecy and security, many of the processes for building these exotic materials have been lost.
- e12e 11y ago"The uranium seized from the German submarine ended up in the American atom bombs" That's what I call cruel irony. I wonder how much of a role those 1200 pounds of ready-made u235 made for the timetable/viability of the bombs dropped on Hiroshima/Nagasaki? A few more days/weeks and Japan would most likely have capitalulated from the terrorcampaign of firebombings among other factors.
- tsotha 11y agoCountries don't capitulate in the face of strategic bombing. They certainly would have been willing to negotiate a peace (as most losing combatants are), but sans nuclear weapons there would be no unconditional surrender.
- e12e 11y agoLooks like we're both right: nuclear bombs are essentially strategic bombing -- and I misremembered the reason Japan was in the process of capitulating prior to the nuclear attacks -- but there have been a lot of discussion indicating that Japan was indeed in the process of surrendering prior to the attacks, see eg: http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/ideas/articles/2011/08/07/why_did_japan_surrender/ http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/ideas/articles/2011/08/07/...
- tsotha 11y agoThey knew they were losing and would have been happy to conclude a peace treaty. That's not the same thing as surrender, though.
- a8da6b0c91d 11y agoThe bombs probably had no affect. The Japanese leadership surrendered because of the USSR invasion. The Soviets were clearly going to sweep down the islands and there was no hope to hold out.
- tsotha 11y ago
- hapanin 11y agoA lot of people are talking about Germany's and Japan's nuke programs being failed wastes of resources. In retrospect this is certainly true, but the massive benefit of a working bomb outweighed the slight chance of success. By late 1944 it was fairly clear that both countries were going to lose the war. Had they devoted the same resources to conventional weapons as they did the bomb, they would have lost anyway. But they didn't know how hard it was to build a bomb, and if it had worked, either country probably could have negotiated a ceasefire immediately. Furthermore, Japan could have theoretically held out a lot longer than August 1945 due to its extremely defensible position. The only reason the Pacific War ended when it did and not after a protracted siege or invasion of Japanese home islands was, of course, that the US built a bomb first.
- caf 11y ago"of course" is a bit too pat. Tsuyoshi Hasegawa has used Japanese sources to argue that the Soviet invasion of Manchuria and the threat of Soviet occupation was at least as influential in the surrender decision.