Y
HN Search
Hacker News Search
new
|
comments
|
top
|
jobs
jhasse
searching PlanetScale…
1.
▲
2.
▲
3.
▲
4.
▲
5.
▲
6.
▲
70 ms
·
841.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
> On the internet I still don't understand what that means exactly. > whereas Project Gutenberg has zero connection to Germany. I disagree. > what does the nationality of Gutenberg the historical person have to do with anythin
842.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
That's why the reasoning of the court went beyond "It's an international website".
843.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
> Other countries can try to block that content Opens the door for censorship. > they can try to punish their own residents for viewing it. Impossible without more surveillance > Why would residents of the permissive country comply
844.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
But then German ISPs will be ordered to block the content in Germany. I don't know what's better, at least now the gutenberg.org frontpage is still accessible and theres an explanation which wouldn't be the case with an DNS b
845.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
Sure, you know what I mean though.
846.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
It was just a small point which might make German think "this is a website that is legal in Germany" or even "this is a website from an entity in Germany". But it isn't, it's a US website, legal in the US and i
847.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
Those points can't be picked apart like you did. They add up and make it reasonable to argue that gutenberg.org is very well known in Germany and that lots of Germans have downloaded the books in question. The copyright owners are stil
848.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
No, but most do. So translating to German and offering German books (pretty well known ones btw) should get you thinking about German laws for a moment.
849.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
> Doitsche Welle What?
850.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
> But....why? In a certain way, it's just some random court from a country you've never been to ordering you to do something. Why would you comply. In the beginning (like it was in this case with gutenberg.org), it isn't a
851.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
I would think that if Saudi Arabia can't access my website, it's their loss, not mine ;)
852.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
How do you think so? From the court order: "Hierfür spricht, dass die Webseite teilweise in Deutsch gehalten ist, dass auf der Seite Werke in deutscher Sprache angeboten werden [...]" And there are even more arguments by the prose
853.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
gutenberg.org has a link to view it in German on the front page. I guess if you provide several translations and use a top level domain like .org, you are more likely an international web site than an English-only .us web site.
854.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
> I think this is an untenable position as it would mean that any website, published from any country, hosted on servers in any country, would have to abide by the laws of the world’s 193 countries. No. If you read the court order, they
855.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
> If your website breaks moral decency laws in Saudi Arabia, and a court there orders you to close your website, would you comply? Strawman, because we aren't talking about closing a website, but just blocking access from one cou
856.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
Another example: If you're in a country where child pornography is legal, should all other countries just accept it? If you're in a country where doxxing is legal, should the victims not be able to do anything against it?
857.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
Also Telekom DSL, not blocked. edit: Sorry: Only the frontpage isn't, search and books are ...
858.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
Loaded perfectly with Firefox and uBlock Origin for me.
859.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
GNOME isn't.
860.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
> What do you consider some reasons then? Too often users need to use the terminal.
861.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
> Typical app does not need to touch its window decoration, only some need. What's "typical" though?
862.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
I doubt that any of that has anything to do with the reasons that there's no "mass Linux desktop adoption". And I wouldn't count Linux running Windows in a VM most of the time as a "Linux desktop".
863.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
"But it can't proberly open .docx and play PUBG"
864.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
Fish https://fishshell.com/
865.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
Facebook tracks you even without an account.
866.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
> If your app have special needs and has to use CSD, [...] Who defines what's special and what's normal though? > I have showed you that while theoretically it might have some merit, especially on mobile, in practice it does
867.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
> WM is the place where I want to configure the appearance and behavior of window decorations. So that's expected and positive. Point to me. The appearance won't match with GtkHeaderBar apps then. > No, it's done by eve
868.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
> What's more, this relation in Wayland world is even tighter than it was in X11, since under X you could easily replace the window manager and still be able to configure stuff like screens and input with tools from your DE. What yo
869.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
The Autopackage project had a solution for this problem years ago called apbuild. It would search for the versions of glibc symbols and use the oldest possible ones, which resulted in portable binaries. With some quick googling I found the
870.
▲
by
jhasse
9y ago
What's the problem with that? Do you use any of glibc's private API?
More ›