Y
HN Search
Hacker News Search
new
|
comments
|
top
|
jobs
e7620
searching PlanetScale…
1.
▲
2.
▲
3.
▲
4.
▲
5.
▲
6.
▲
7 ms
·
61.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
And you don't have to update the kernel in sync with systemd Quote from http://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/systemd-devel/2014-May... : > > You update systemd but you don't update the kernel? H
62.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
GNU/Linux requires vi, perl, python... also as dependencies, but they're separate programs, the thing with systemd is that nothing can be separated, you use ALL components at the same time or change OS. Bear in mind that systemd i
63.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
systemd is less stable than upstart (and sysvinit, obviusly), "it lacks maturity" says the author. You've had several problems with upstart, but count yourself lucky, certain problems with systemd will take down the whole sys
64.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
What feature of systemd did you always wanted on a server?
65.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
> lets drop Gnome. Slackware is an example of this. They removed Gnome almost a decade ago.
66.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
Slackware, CRUX, Funtoo and Gentoo are some distros that follow traditional Unix paradigms and unlikely to adopt systemd.
67.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
> But Linux itself doesn't need udev. Would it really work? I think you'd have to rewrite some parts of the kernel, but I may be wrong now, in the past or the future. Anyways, we're arguing semantics here, it'd be be
68.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
I feel your pain. I expect the badly-documented bug-and-vulnerability-ridden unmantainable mess aka systemd to collapse as abandonware in the future. That's what happened with similar projects before. I used systemd last year to see if
69.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
> You can run a Linux system without the udev daemon, or with one written by you. A GNU/Linux system consists of several components. http://www.gnu.org/gnu/linux-and-gnu.html shows some examples. If you remove
70.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
udev is a necessary component of Linux. You could say just use a fork like eudev. Fine (for the time being). But the thing is, you can't remove udev from the Linux kernel if you want to keep it calling Linux, as it'd be a f
71.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
You're correct, but that's not the point. Some device drivers run in userspace, even the Linux kernel itself can run in userspace!
72.
▲
by
e7620
12y ago
In general, this is not about the merits of systemd as a program. GNU/Linux represents choice and freedom. The abundance of distros is proof of that. You can choose your preferred init system, system logger, cron daemon, desktop envir