camgunz

40 ms·

661.
by camgunz 2y ago
Training on all my work so you can generate my work and thus replace me is not fair use. If you think this argument is one salty software engineer yelling at CloudGPT, I'm sure Disney and every other media company feels the same way.
662.
by camgunz 2y ago
at-least-once/exactly-once/at-most-once delivery are all weirdly named from the wrong perspective. From the sender's perspective there are only two options: send once and send lots. Behold: - you send a message - you receive
663.
by camgunz 2y ago
I just run the cable under my shirt/sweater/hoodie/jacket; problem solved.
664.
by camgunz 2y ago
Yeah but if you're buying those headphones you know you need an amp. I do wonder how hard/expensive it would be to offer this as a configuration option though. Like if your favorite set is 300 ohms you could just configure your ph
665.
by camgunz 2y ago
> Producing copyrighted things isn’t illegal. There's no difference between producing and copying. Let's take a real world example: music samples. There's an entire clearinghouse process for music sampling, more or less fo
666.
by camgunz 2y ago
This kind of implies there's better or worse ordering. AFAIK that's pretty subjective. If the idea was to expose how the DB is ordering things, or even make things easier for autocomplete OK, but this just feels like a "I hav
667.
by camgunz 2y ago
I haven't had any, and yeah it's almost always the right thing IME.
668.
by camgunz 2y ago
I'm totally stunned by this, I think I'm in complete disbelief. It's truly incredible what humans can do; wow.
669.
by camgunz 2y ago
> The FSF has substituted the phrase “modified works” in place of “derivative works” in v3 of the license, yes, but not to narrow the definition - the intent was to broaden the definition to cover additional classes of modification. Eben
670.
by camgunz 2y ago
This was probably true of v2, but v3 doesn't refer to derived works. In OP's scenario they didn't modify the AGPL code, so there's nothing to release.
671.
by camgunz 2y ago
> What are you on about? The explicit purpose of a license is that it's users do not have to worry about anyone else's "explicit intent". A license needs to be unambigious about it's terms, else it's just no
672.
by camgunz 2y ago
Yep, it's a huge improvement for complicated pipelines. One thing to be aware of is "NOT MATERIALIZED". Here's what the docs say: A useful property of WITH queries is that they are normally evaluated only once per execut
673.
by camgunz 2y ago
Ha well, as a lover of spirited conversation I am not at all offended. I'm not telling you you have to use (A)GPL code, I'm just trying to dispel various rumor. I really, truly believe the GPLs have revolutionized our society. It&
674.
by camgunz 2y ago
Maybe, but that's more a comment about Minio than AGPLv3.
675.
by camgunz 2y ago
Neither the AGPLv3 nor your link reference "derivative works". It's a GPLv2 concept they jettisoned for (A)GPLv3. https://softwarefreedom.org/resources/2014/SFLC-Guide_to_GPL...
676.
by camgunz 2y ago
I know a lot of this stuff is legally pretty new (though AGPLv3 is almost 17 years old now) and there's not a huge body of case law around it. But--and I'm earnestly asking here--is there case law where courts reach in and modify
677.
by camgunz 2y ago
Super cool. I did some reading about Secure Enclaves with I was dreaming up ways to democratize compute; very cool to see a project like this making it a reality.
678.
by camgunz 2y ago
> That is certainly the case for LGPL, but by my understanding it isn't for GPL nor by extension AGPL. If you don't modify, you have no obligations. Easy.
679.
by camgunz 2y ago
I mean, they have a strong incentive to get you to buy a commercial license. I'm not surprised they're uninterested in giving you free legal advice in service of not paying them.
680.
by camgunz 2y ago
Interesting; this sounds to me like linking, but I'd email licensing@fsf.org to be sure.
681.
by camgunz 2y ago
If you diff them, you'll see the AGPLv3 is essentially the GPLv3 with this extra clause added: "13. Remote Network Interaction; Use with the GNU General Public License. Notwithstanding any other provision of this License, if you m
682.
by camgunz 2y ago
Here's how that section starts: "An “aggregate” consists of a number of separate programs, distributed together on the same CD-ROM or other media.". Are you distributing a lot of apps on CD-ROMs? Have you heard of Linux distr
683.
by camgunz 2y ago
> Aren't they? So, if I want to use a GPL library, all I need to do is write a little wrapper program that does RPC over a socket, and boom, I can use a GPL library in my closed source program? Yep. This is how MySQL/MariaDB wo
684.
by camgunz 2y ago
If you ctrl-f for AGPL you'll see it's for all of it.
685.
by camgunz 2y ago
> How do I know whether a particular API usage qualifies as well separated or not? The two paragraphs above what you quoted are: "However, in many cases you can distribute the GPL-covered software alongside your proprietary system.
686.
by camgunz 2y ago
"In AGPLv3, what counts as 'interacting with [the software] remotely through a computer network?'" "If the program is expressly designed to accept user requests and send responses over a network, then it meets these
687.
by camgunz 2y ago
At least in the EU there's some precedent where AGPLv3+ won out, though it was through settlement and not judgement (and it's not super clear how contentious the parties were anyway) [0] [0]: https://archive.fosdem.org&
688.
by camgunz 2y ago
Yeah I wouldn't rely on their editorializing. It's best to just refer to the FAQ [0], which covers these questions. [0]: https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.html
689.
by camgunz 2y ago
It can also be evidence that HN posters have a poor understanding of GPL licenses. Pretty much all these questions are answered in the FAQ [0]. Your guess is as good as mine as to why people continually post random, uninformed, needlessly c
690.
by camgunz 2y ago
Well that's not Op's question. They're asking "if I use Minio in my stack without modifications (as a file server that my other services interact with via an API), do I have to AGPL all the stuff the touches Minio or no

More ›