Y
HN Search
Hacker News Search
new
|
comments
|
top
|
jobs
Falling3
searching PlanetScale…
1.
▲
2.
▲
3.
▲
4.
▲
5.
▲
6.
▲
10 ms
·
91.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
I became a vegan 15 years ago because I couldn't morally justify the unnecessary raising and killing other individuals. You may not agree, but writing that decision off as "trendy" is more than a bit condescending. Every stud
92.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
Sorry, I'm not following what you were trying to do there. Are you trying to bring this back around to human population growth?
93.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
Referring to a "lifetime committ[m]ent to what is seen as a positive relationship" as a fairy tale is pretty ridiculous.
94.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
That would certainly be a potential solution for the environmental issues. I still don't find it to be ethical for the individuals being farmed.
95.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
Ah yes. The well-known environmental impact of rectangular shaped foodstuffs. Seriously, this amounts to nothing more than a Naturalistic Fallacy.
96.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
There is no way to satisfy the growing demand for meat in a way that is not damaging to the environment. And that's leaving aside any questions of ethics for the animals themselves.
97.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
Are you implying that children that are weaned shouldn't have non-dairy milk substitutes?
98.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
Paying for the externalities and eliminating subsidies would go a long way.
99.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
Very disappointing. I'm not at all clear on the concern over semantics except in the case of lobbying groups and large companies on the animal ag side.
100.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
>In many cases, you can't have one with the other. Privacy or Personal security - pick one. You have a lot of work ahead of you to demonstrate that empirical fact. I haven't seen any compelling evidence that infringing on our r
101.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
You criticize his post for only include some of the background information, yet yours includes none of it. If you're willing to call out the former for being misleading, what of the latter?
102.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
Thanks for providing all of that background information! I was skeptical of the parent comment's claims - particularly how overly simplistic they were. But as someone on the other side of the world, I can't easily know how unreali
103.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
> you waltz in and tell them what they prescribe is wrong and your automated treatment plan is better. That doesn't really capture the conversation though. Susan specifically said (as you quoted) that it was possible she would use t
104.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
> However I recall the night my son was born - the facilities, staff and resources of the hospital were unmatched - the mother and baby would not have the same experience anywhere else in the world. We had a wonderful experience with the
105.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
> There is no “legalize it” solution with these drugs That's why keeping in mind the difference between legalization and decriminalization is important.
106.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
I don't. And "just raise your own" is obviously not a viable option for the overwhelming majority of people.
107.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
I would strongly disagree that any commercial operation - regardless of its labeling - could be called cruelty free. That leaves neighbors with backyard hens, which will never be enough cover any significant portion of egg consumption.
108.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
> It's an analogy. None are perfect It's more than just an analogy when the parent comment claimed that if you support one, you should support the other. I'm not disagreeing that the scenarios aren't analogous. I'
109.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
> If you agree with tenant eviction protections, then you should probably support similar eviction protections for cloud computing I can't say I agree or that I find this analogy valid. Tenant eviction protection is, in part, to pro
110.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
Pointing out bias and lying are ad hominmem attacks now? Almost every one of the videos posted to Ngo's twitter are accompanied by his own commentary so I'm not sure how you could claim otherwise. And even if they weren't, I
111.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
> Or put another way, because they theorise that white police are involved in an enormous, coast-to-coast conspiracy against black people That is a blatant straw-man. The U.S. has a violent, racist history - particularly it's police
112.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
Andy Ngo is completely and utterly full of shit. He spent much of 2019 working with Far Right groups like Patriot Prayer and the Proud Boys crafting narratives to demonize left-wing groups. He is on video discussing an upcoming brawl with P
113.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
> I mean 3rd trimester babies that could survive outside the womb are fair game. Got a citation on that?
114.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
> The whole point is that this is a biased assumption It's absolutely not. Whether the president's claims are true is another matter entirely. When he makes a claim with no specifics, no explanation of how it occurred, and no e
115.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
Oh I see you were the original commenter as well. Are you disputing the idea that you tried to use the actions of a specific wild animal to justify our treatment of animals? I mean, I get it. It's a really common tactic. I'm just
116.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
It pertains pretty specifically to the comment I replied to. I'm not sure how that's not clear?
117.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
That's exactly where most veal comes from - the male offspring of dairy cows.
118.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
The highest good or the only good? Do you actually try an quantify the suffering of an animal on a farm and make an honest comparison to the pleasure a human gets from eating them? Do you also support torturing animals and bestiality with t
119.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
What moral questions are you comfortable using the actions of hyenas to justify?
120.
▲
by
Falling3
6y ago
> Purely lab-synthesized food that does not involve cultivation of any other organization is still a long way off from reaching any kind of scale for mass consumption. I don't disagree, but I don't see how that's relevant
More ›