8 ms·
Matchstick to refund everyone's money
- ChuckMcM 11y agoOk, on the one hand as a backer of the project I'm thinking "So DRM is hard, why not ship without it? Why not give people the choice?" Another possibility is this : http://www.faqs.org/patents/app/20120243158 http://www.faqs.org/patents/app/20120243158 although I don't see that it has been allowed yet so perhaps not a "real" patent? I'm one of the people who would have settled for working hardware and just a basic Linux port with graphics support.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoI agree; this would be useful even if it only played local content. I wouldn't expect a "Firefox OS" device to play Netflix or similar.
- pbreit 11y agoI would expect Netflix over time but agreeing with both of you that an open source TV stick without such a thing still has quite a bit of value. And, really, they couldn't find someone to continue working on it with all those proceeds?
- mcphage 11y agoIt might be useful, but it isn't what they promised their backers. That would lead to a lot of angry people.
- zz1 11y agoThey never promised DRM content during the Kickstarter campaign. Stretching for a feature that I don't want, running late, runnning later and then not building the product BECAUSE OF THE FEATURE I DON'T WANT. Now that is gonna make me (and some others backers too) very angry!
- nadams 11y agoTo me this seems like the realization that they completely underfunded the project - not that DRM is a road block. If I was in their position I would consider releasing without DRM. Then after it ships and assuming people like it - if they want netflix support tell them to phone netflix everyday. I doubt netflix wants their support lines tied up.
- zz1 11y agoIt seems so strange to realize that you're underfunded when you can refund 470k.
- nadams 11y agoIt's not really so strange. A common theme I've seen on kickstarter projects is that they come up with product Z. They find a supplier in China who gives them quote X. But they will also need some money for themselves (not being greedy but just a living wage so they can quit their jobs and work on this full time) so we will call that Y. However, after they collect the money the supplier says - actually it will cost X+N dollars. (X+N) + Y > the kickstarter amount. Perhaps they also found other issues which will cost extra money (perhaps needing to hire another developer).
- eclipxe 11y agoThey promised Netflix.
- zz1 11y agoCould you point me to a source, dating from the campaign, stating that they will deliver Netflix?
- zz1 11y agoAlso: DRM-reading capabilities is a software feature, right? Couldn't they deliver it through a software update and just send me a frigging Matchstick not reading DRMs like I wanted it!?
- Avshalom 11y agoWhere are they getting the money for the refunds?
- _delirium 11y agoOne of the executives' pages on LinkedIn says he manages 30 employees at the company. If true, it must have gotten some kind of venture funding, since the $500k they raised on Kickstarter is nowhere near enough to run a company that size for over a year.
- javert 11y agoIf I were a VC and my money were being used to repay kickstarter backers instead of me, I would be pretty pissed. I wonder if there is more to the story. Maybe the company is pivoting.
- Sanddancer 11y agoI imagine a pivot is likely, given the tone of their message. Everything they wrote talked about how hard their goals, like the DRM portion, were under Firefox OS, and there was no talk about winding down the company. Leads me to believe that there will be /a/ product from them, just not one based on Firefox OS.
- coderjames 11y agoAs a backer now apparently getting a refund, I'm extremely disappointed with the way this project was managed. The DRM that apparently blew up the project wasn't in scope when I backed it. This was supposed to be an open source, No-DRM stick. After they had everyone's money, they decided to build a Chromecast clone instead. Classic bait-n-switch.
- hermanmerman 11y agoI am completely out of the loop and hove no idea what the project is about, but apparently every one on the KS page is basically saying that they couldn't care less about this feature. I'm curious now at what really happened and why they shut it down, if their biggest hurdle is something so few people want.
- justonepost 11y agoNo, classic bait n switch doesn't involve refunding money...
- zach 11y agoSigh, yes. "Bait and switch" is the "begging the question" of product forums. It has an actual meaning that nobody cares about and by now just means "I feel disappointed". This is one of the least unfair outcomes for what is a barely a purchase and it is still a "Classic bait-n-switch".
- javert 11y agoHis point is that it was an attempted bait and switch. The fact that they failed and refunded the money doesn't change that. They purportedly promised one product and worked on a different one.
- Sanddancer 11y agoIt's not even an attempted bait and switch. They thought that a certain feature was needed/wanted, so they tried implementing it. Extra features have killed projects before and will kill in the future.
- qopp 11y agoDoesn't this go against what Kickstarter is about? Will other projects feel pressure to refund if they don't pan out?
- itafroma 11y ago> Will other projects feel pressure to refund if they don't pan out? They should as it's one of the remedies Kickstarter requires projects to pursue should they be unable to complete the project and fulfill the rewards:[1] > If a creator is unable to complete their project and fulfill rewards, they’ve failed to live up to the basic obligations of this agreement. To right this, they must make every reasonable effort to find another way of bringing the project to the best possible conclusion for backers. A creator in this position has only remedied the situation and met their obligations to backers if: > [other required remedies] > * they offer to return any remaining funds to backers who have not received their reward (in proportion to the amounts pledged), or else explain how those funds will be used to complete the project in some alternate form. [1]: https://www.kickstarter.com/terms-of-use#backer-creator https://www.kickstarter.com/terms-of-use#backer-creator
- derefr 11y agoWell, obviously, if you still have the money, it's nice to refund the money. I think the parent meant more "will this create an expectation in Kickstarter backers that they'll always get either the product or their money back, thus creating some sort of reputational debt-slavery for the project creators who genuinely just use up the money and fail? And doesn't that defeat the purpose of Kickstarter?"
- itafroma 11y ago> will this create an expectation in Kickstarter backers that they'll always get either the product or their money back, thus creating some sort of reputational debt-slavery for the project creators who genuinely just use up the money and fail? Hyperbolic imagery aside, the expectation is already there. They can't just walk away from the project with a shrug should it fail: they have a contractual obligation to demonstrate that they did not squander their funds and to provide the best possible outcome to their backers. If they fail to do that, the terms of the agreement allow backers to seek legal action: > The creator is solely responsible for fulfilling the promises made in their project. If they’re unable to satisfy the terms of this agreement, they may be subject to legal action by backers. In this case, Matchstick's project creators have assessed that they have enough money to pay everyone back, so they're doing exactly what the terms of the Kickstarter agreement between backers and project owners have obligated them to do: provide the best possible resolution to backers by, in part, returning the money. Another project may determine that they can't pay everyone back: in that case, they're subject to the requirement that they "demonstrate that they’ve used funds appropriately and made every reasonable effort to complete the project as promised". If they can't do that to the satisfaction of every backer, they're still on the hook. That's why a lot of times, project failures will have a note about providing a refund to anyone who requests one instead of Matchstick's strategy of proactively refunding everyone.
- blhack 11y agoHuh... I've always thought that "this thing might totally fail" was something that people understood when backing a kickstarter project. The idea that if they fail, they have to refund everybody's contribution kindof stinks, since I've always thought kickstarter was for people trying new things (which is obviously going to have a lot of stories about failure) Maybe there is more to the story here.
- TillE 11y agoThere's been a lot of persistent misinformation floating around about Kickstarter, and I don't really understand why. It's not complicated. Yes, Kickstarter projects are legally obligated to fulfill their promised rewards, or else provide refunds. It has always been this way. Really, the only difference between Kickstarter and a preorder is that the schedule is a lot looser.
- ghaff 11y agoThat is no longer the case in the current ToS. Among the current verbiage: "they offer to return any remaining [emphasis mine] funds to backers who have not received their reward (in proportion to the amounts pledged), or else explain how those funds will be used to complete the project in some alternate form." As you say, the older ToS looked a lot like a pre-order which wasn't really the intention and didn't frankly make a lot of sense for a project that had some material probability of failing. After all, if the money is gone, it's not there any longer to issue refunds.
- makomk 11y agoIt made sense because it was the only thing holding Kickstarters accountable to the people funding them. With an investment, you're taking a risk but have some control over how the company's run. With a pre-order, you have no control but they have to deliver the product or refund you. Kickstarter now is the worst of both worlds: projects don't have to deliver anything and you can't even make sure they give it a decent try. Someone could promise the Earth, use the money to pay all their friends living costs for years while they tool around and fail to make a working product, then say "sorry, the money's all gone" and that's fine now according to Kickstarter.
- idlewords 11y agoI pity the people who have to run 17K refunds by hand.
- downandout 11y agoI don't know why they are actually shutting down, but this explanation doesn't ring true. They're blaming DRM complications - a part of the project that no one cares about - as the lynchpin that has taken down the whole thing. To be honest, I would be quite surprised if anyone receives any money back. The "everyone should have their money back by the end of September" thing seems quite long. Having seen some other, very similar scenarios play out, to me it sounds like they did something else with the money and are trying to stave off the consequences of it or are trying to buy time hoping for a miracle that will allow them to replace it.
- eclipxe 11y agoThey need DRM to support most Chromecast apps (that people care about)
- joshstrange 11y agoI'm a plex user (Local media server) and I've found after trying Chromecast, AppleTV+PlexConnect, and FireTV Box I've found that using a Raspberry Pi 2 running RasPlex (total of around $85 w/ media center remote, I don't use it but it got the USB->IR so I could use my universal) provides the best experience of all (by which I mean sub $100 sticks/boxes). Similar results can probably be experienced with XBMC.
- icelancer 11y agoYeah, I repurposed a Lenovo T420 that has a broken keyboard into a media center. Grabbed a DisplayPort to HDMI adapter, installed Ubuntu + KBMC (Kodi, now) on it, and it works pretty good. You can use various plugins to get a lot of features minus Netflix, of course, which will never work properly with third-party software under Linux because.... well, whatever.
- natrius 11y agoI'm a heavy Chromecast + Plex user. What do you prefer about the Raspberry Pi setup?
- joshstrange 11y agoDirect play for everything. Way less stressful on the server and you can skip around in the video without hardly any delay (this is something I've never experienced with any other clients). I also quite enjoy being able to browse my collection on the TV instead of just on my phone.
- luma 11y agoI've been through just about every Plex client possible and in my experience the Roku offers the best combination of easy setup and reliable operation at a low price. It doesn't rock the flashiest interface, but it's the one I can run in my living room or park at my parent's place with zero further maintenance required.
- olympus 11y agoReally bummed that the team came to this conclusion. I am a backer and found them at CES 2015 since they said they would be there with a demo. They had screencasting working and controlled it with an app on their phone. It was a little buggy and froze once, but totally worth the amount I backed them for. Around this time they decided to redesign the sticks with more processing power. I figured respinning the boards would take a while, but the software looked so good in January that I never thought it would be what brought the project to a halt. Personally I'd be fine with transcoding videos on the fly from another machine to remove the DRM, but I suppose that defeats the purpose of a small hdmi stick if you have a full powered desktop running in the next room over. But really most of the stuff on my local netowrk doesn't have DRM and I don't do a whole lot of online streaming beyond Amazon Prime and I have an app on my TV for that. I suppose all I really wanted was screencasting without having to pay $100 for a WiDi adapter. Oh well. But at least I'm getting a refund, so I don't suppose I have any ill will for the team. I have backed projects before that did a magic trick with my money - one shoe KS took $130 for a pair of boots and kept up a sham for almost a year, even claiming that production had started and we would see our boots in a few weeks (it was always just a few weeks away), and then abruptly vanished. So I hope whatever project the Matchstick team works on next pans out better for them.
- TD-Linux 11y ago>Personally I'd be fine with transcoding videos on the fly from another machine to remove the DRM That would probably be either illegal or against the ToS of the streaming service they were trying to add.
- braythwayt 11y agoThe old reality, with companies like Google, was that if you aren’t paying money, you aren’t the customer, you’re the product. Then Kickstarter came along, and the premise was, “Gives us $X0,000 and we’ll do our best to give you product Y as a so-called-reward. But this is not a store.” So now you’re giving them money, but you still aren’t a customer! Because people are now using this as astro-turf marketing campaigns for products that are already funded by other investors, or as market research, or as a line item on their pitch deck to raise money from investors. In this egregious case, the company seems to have had no intention of really entering into a “deal” with the backers of its kickstarter campaign, it was entering into a deal with its other investors, in accordance with a business plan its backers have never seen. Thus, they struggled to build DRM into the product, although DRM had nothing to do with the product they promised their backers, and everything to do with their other business dealings and plans. And now their backers are discarded like a one-night stand, but hey, here’s your own money back. Frankly, this stinks. If you go on Kickstarter and say you’re going to build product Y, that’s what you should do. If your business plan requires raising Kickstarter backing and then going after investors, you should say so up front and not pretend you are off to start work as soon as the project is funded. And as for the investors, shame on you. If you invest in a company that has entered into an agreement with backers to build product Y, you should actually make them do that, or not invest in the first place. Whatever pivot the go on to do, everyone has been forewarned that simply giving them money and receiving promises in return means very little to them, their attitude seems to be, “well, if we change our minds, we just give you your money back and do whatever we like.” That is not a principled way to run a business. If they couldn’t build this thing with the funds raised on Kickstarter, then they shouldn’t have been on Kickstarter.
- Eliezer 11y agoThey gave the money back. Regardless of surrounding events or further stories, you do not get to call them unprincipled.
- hluska 11y agoFirst, he did not call the founders unprincipled, he said that this is not a principled way to run a business. I know that's splitting hairs, but I think the distinction is important. Granted, I just told a doctor about a grammatical error in her Emergency Department's mission statement, so this may just be a symptom... :) Second, the surrounding events do matter. They claimed to be raising money to build a product. Then, their efforts bogged down because they tried to build an entirely different product than they originally promised. Where I'm from, we call that lying. But, for fun, let's check out their own words: Q: Why did Matchstick select Microsoft PlayReady ? A: Matchstick intends to offer DRM on its platform and bring premium content to its users in the quickest timeframe possible. Microsoft PlayReady offers a mature technology, has relationship with premium content providers and is quick to deploy on the Firefox OS platform. Funny how a solution that is so 'quick to deploy' could sink the whole ship, hey?
- pjc50 11y agoLook, if you want this it could undoubtedly be done much more cheaply by not building new hardware and taking one of the Chinese Android sticks and getting it to run Firefox OS. A hassle, and not an inconsiderable project, but much less so than building the thing from scratch.
- AndrewDucker 11y agoThe thing about Matchstick was this line from the original campaign: "The product is fully functional today, with the hardware design final, tooling complete, and manufacturing ready to ramp up in the next 30-60 days" followed six-months later by: "We want to update the hardware" and "is being updated to support DRM" amd the ship date being moved back to now. A lot of people backed Matchstick because it was going to be open - the plans were all available for download, it was all ready to go, and we were going to have kit in our hands really quickly. Instead we were going to get something that was slowed down by six months so that it could have closed DRM-support added. And then it's cancelled because they added support for something that wasn't even part of the original campaign! It's not surprising that the backers are upset.
- CmonDev 11y agoTheir fault for dealing with Firefox OS.
- dlitz 11y agoMore useful tech destroyed by DRM. How long are we as an industry going to keep this up? The only DRM that's even remotely defensible is like what KDE's PDF viewer has: a checkbox that says "Enforce DRM restrictions". For that, we don't need anything more than a couple of flags and some copyright metadata.
- mseebach 11y ago> we as an industry Step 0: There is no "we". There are millions of individuals in thousands of companies across dozens of industries with wildly divergent goals, priorities and philosophies.
- corobo 11y ago> How long are we as an industry going to keep this up? Depends who you ask. I imagine the RIAAs and the MPAAs would respond "We'll keep doing it until people stop pirating". Otherwise the response would be along the line of "Until they realise it doesn't stop us pirating anyway" People will always pirate digital goods, so there'll always be DRM.
- tinco 11y agoNetflix is half of all Internet traffic (crazy), and all the content owners are hopping on board. We want to create an ecosystem built on open hardware and software so its easy for anybody to get to this great content, anytime, anywhere, without one of the "big guys" imposing their rules on who gets what, when, or where. This is plain crazy. Netflix can't offer their service without DRM, Intel can't even release a chip without supporting DRM. How on earth did anyone expect this to be succesful without DRM? In the kickstarter movie they even show clips of Game of Thrones and John Oliver, how did people envision the Matchstick to play that content without DRM support? And then the craziest part, after working for 11 months with I imagine a team of at least 3 but probably more, they fail which is understandable but then they refund the kickstarter campaign. That means they actually have 470k lying around. Probably from VC funding. So they used the kickstarter money as leverage in VC negotiations, got funded. Then worked for 11 months on something the kickstarter backers didn't ask for which creates a backlash, then they decide to drop the kickstarter. I wonder what their investors think of it "Oh yeah, the initial 17000 people that believed on our project whom we woo-ed you with? Yeah they're not happy with the direction we're going in so we're dropping them". So now it's just going to be an HDMI TV stick which to my knowledge already exist right? (BTW the proper way this should've gone is: After 11 months Matchstick admit they got nowhere because of supplier issues (i.e. they couldnt get DRM) have run out of money and give up. The backers sue for reimbursement. Matchstick LLC files for bankruptcy, court finds no wrongdoing, no one gets money. The end and everyone lives happily ever after. Faith in Kickstarter restored)
- georgemcbay 11y agoYup, assuming they were on the up-and-up to begin with, they could have saved a bunch of time and effort by just asking anyone who had worked on video playing devices in the past 10 years if their idea was remotely feasible to bring to market while keeping both open source developers and content providers on-board. The Sony Dash was the only locked-down "tivoized" (in the rms sense of the word) "chumby powered" device and also the only "chumby powered" device that had netflix support. These two facts are not unrelated.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoI wonder if this could, in any way, be covered under bait and switch laws. Yes, I know people are getting their money back. I'm just thinking to help prevent other people on kickstarter from trying to switch up their product midway.
- michaelbuddy 11y agoGood lesson in keeping product simple. They could have delivered their original product. And the backers would have figured out what they'd do with it. Why wouldn't Netflix help them succeed I wonder instead of just scrapping it.
- zz1 11y ago"Rumor is that they're being bought out by the Chinese company they've been developing the unit with. So the refund is so that no can have claim the designs (like a bunch of people who bought a product because its all open source.)" https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/matchstick/matchstick-the-streaming-stick-built-on-firefox-os/posts/1266549?cursor=10773496#comment-10773495 https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/matchstick/matchstick-t...