5 ms·
Really interesting and spot-on article, I really liked this insight, though: > But the Stream, mobile applications, and moving images: They all show a departur
by paganel 11y ago
Really interesting and spot-on article, I really liked this insight, though:
> But the Stream, mobile applications, and moving images: They all show a departure from a books-internet toward a television-internet. (...) When I log on to Facebook, my personal television starts. All I need to do is to scroll: New profile pictures by friends, short bits of opinion on current affairs, links to new stories with short captions, advertising, and of course self-playing videos.
Never had thought about it that way.
- jacquesm 11y agoWhen I first put video on 'the web' I got a really nasty email from one of the backbone maintainers that what I was doing was 'improper use' of the internet. I actually agreed, but it was an un-stoppable thing from a technology point of view. We've been trending away from the 'web as a collection of books' to 'the web as a series of TV channels' for many years now. The ease of consumption is a very large factor in this, video is much more passive than reading.
- catshirt 11y ago"When I first put video on 'the web' I got a really nasty email from one of the backbone maintainers that what I was doing was 'improper use' of the internet" not trying to pry but i can't even imagine a context under which that is an appropriate response.
- jacquesm 11y agoWell, look at it this way: at the time the intercontinental backbone was an absolute straw compared to the gigantic capacity that we have today. Within a few weeks of launching I took over a good chunk of that capacity and with the trend being what it was I would have saturated the backbone within another couple of months without even trying. This eventually led to relocating my company to Canada where we had access to a half decent connection to MAE-East and MAE-West through Front 151. It was either that or be seriously penalized. At the time a European start-up getting the majority of its visitors from the US was not a common thing and that start-up being video related was unheard of entirely.
- udfalkso 11y agoThere's similar behavior today with the Bitcoin network. People are guided by community norms alone to stop doing things that are destructive in the short term but with which there's nothing theoretically wrong (e.g. Tons of tiny transactions). As the network overcomes the technical limitations, people will start to do those currently problematic things again without the need to use the work-arounds they're currently resorting to.
- e12e 11y agoKind of want reply both to you and @pjc50: I think moving images with sound as part of hypertext/hypermedia is a given -- and has been since (at least) the 60s. That's not just "TV". And "TV" isn't just video. We've only recently entered the era where users can reasonably make live and recorded video, and use that as a form of expression (from video chat, to youtube/vimeo to snapchat etc). And just like you could take a tv camera and use that for video conferencing in the 60s[1] -- video-the-medium is much more than "TV". "TV" is indeed very pacifying. For myself, I can on days off, do two very different things that are very immersive: watch tv series, or play Star Wars: Online Galaxies. Now, I mostly play SWTOR solo, so for the purpose of this discussion, lets just use "play a single-player computer game". I enjoy both, but if I read a book or play a computer game -- I'm mentally invigorated. If I watch a TV series, even something interesting like "Humans"[h], "Mr. Robot"[r] -- or more interesting drama like "True Detective"[t] -- I always end up more passive. Even watching documentaries, or news -- TV ends up a very passive medium. And that's (IMNHO) just the good "TV". I find that a good movie is usually between "book" and "TV" -- something with the format/runtime that drives a different expression both in writing and directing. > We've been trending away from the 'web as a collection of books' to 'the web as a series of TV channels' for many years now. I don't think the web has ever been much like a "collection of books". It might have been "a collection of essays" -- and I don't think we're really trending towards "a series of TV channels". I think we'll still see video expression and communication evolve, and I think user generated communiques ("content" is more something that oozes from a (corporate) organization) will continue to dominate. It is my impression that young people (~3-20) are much more inclined to use video than I am -- I don't much like it. But I expect rich media images/sound/video will continue to increase, as bandwidth/storage gets cheaper. I think that trend in media is different from the trend in centralization, commercialization though. There's nothing wrong with videologs (other than that I prefer a well-written text...) -- as long as we can host them in a more distributed manner than we do today. I think we'll see interesting times ahead, as the people that are now 5 years old grow up to master both rich media and various forms of programming/automation as a natural part of their life. We've seen nothing yet. Nothing. A post-script on quality: I think many of us want quality. And I think we'll continue to make it, and find it. Be that small Internet radio-stations that do curated music (as opposed to things like soundcloud that I also like, but unfortunately is just as hopelessly centralized as youtube) -- or "real" blogs -- or whatever. It remains to be seen how/if this will all be funded. Maybe we won't have as much paid-for content/art -- maybe we'll all have more free time -- assuming we don't kill each others as jobs are automated away, and those who own the robots keep all the riches. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY [h] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humans_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humans_(TV_series) [r] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mr._Robot_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mr._Robot_(TV_series) [t] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/True_Detective_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/True_Detective_(TV_series)
- pjc50 11y agoI think the sheer volume of content plays a part too. In the early days of blogging (2000 to, say, 2005) there weren't many bloggers, and while they didn't quite all know each other they crosslinked from sidebar to sidebar into communities. There wasn't much content, it was all generally high quality, the discovery process worked well as a result, and few people were monetising it. Now we have to ask an awkward question: do people actually want quality, as we define it? Does the undiscriminating mass consumer result in a low quality market, or is it the other way round? To what extent is media there to support identity/belonging needs rather than informational ones?
- InclinedPlane 11y agoYa know, I can't help but think of MTV. Back in the late '70s all of the radio stations in the US were turning corporate, being bought up by chains and switching to boring, top 40s styles, playing the same songs all the time in order to rack up the ad revenue. MTV was launched at this same time but when it hit the air it had a problem, most songs didn't have music videos. So they ended up playing a lot of songs they wouldn't have otherwise, and accidentally played an eclectic mix of music. Which was like a breath of fresh air to the youth of the day, who had been abandoned by radio. MTV became hugely popular and helped gain popularity for a wide variety of different music that might not have become nearly as popular otherwise. In general, corporate interests will result in less risk taking and thus less diversity and less eccentric content. You see the same thing in hollywood, where there is massive risk aversion. Which reminds me of the Space Shuttle. People thought that the Shuttle was well tested near the end of its run of 130-odd flights, but it really wasn't. Because those were operational flights, not test flights, every single one of them attempted to stay as much in the center of the performance envelope as possible. So the performance envelope of the Shuttle was not actually well known, despite having flown over 100 flights. The vast majority of content producers who rely on ad revenue make the same estimations about risk, and try to stay away from the edges of the "risk envelope" for profitable content, with obvious implications for diversity and quality. The only real solution is to greater enable individual content creation. In some respects the modern web is great at that, but for content such as existed back when the web was young and weird it is less so.
- thenomad 11y ago
- kristianc 11y agoIt's a line of argument explored in 'Television is the New Television' by Michael Wolff; it more or less demolishes the narrative that television 'lost' the Internet. http://www.amazon.co.uk/Television-Is-New-Unexpected-Triumph/dp/159184813X http://www.amazon.co.uk/Television-Is-New-Unexpected-Triumph...
- mfringel 11y agoAye. When I hear people talking about "watching less television" (including myself), I substitute in "surfing social media" one-for-one with television time.
- treelovinhippie 11y agoI've got notes/ideas from 2011 that revolve around building a personalized online TV station. YouTube leanback from 2010 was the first major attempt at that. Load it up, videos start playing. Though it looks like they've opted for the choose-your-thumbnail layout now. Once we're able to nail recommendation algorithms such that near-100% of all suggested content is perfect and desired by that user, game over. Just show them a stream of content. Don't let them pick and choose or require scrolling. Would be like turning on the TV and just getting constant dopamine triggers with no downtime. Videos, photos, text, whatever, perfectly tuned to your desires in that moment. Internet drugs.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIt's basically just a BCI short from wireheading.
- phlandis 11y agoThe internet becomes more mainstream and the more average person begins to engage. There will still be places like HN and the DW, just don't expect your article written for HN to get 50 likes and 7 shares. This just makes me treasure the opinions of those that actually make it to HN.