8 ms·
Unicode skin-tone modifiers
- BudVVeezer 11y agoI think this is a good step in the right direction, but still falls short. For instance, it's heavily gender binary, and has odd cultural mismatches such as "man with turban" but no "woman with hijab." However, major kudos to the Unicode consortium for their work on this -- it's a very challenging set of subjects to get into!
- drdaeman 11y agoWonder what was the decision to make color set fixed to Fitzpatrick scale and not use something generic to allow non-natural/non-realistic/not-human tones[2]. Something like language tags[1] but for color codes. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unicode_control_characters#Language_tags https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unicode_control_characters#Lan... [2] The Internet is primarily about cute kitties, not humans. And there are still no means to mark whenever U+1F431 (🐱) is black, or, say, silver spotted tabby.
- kps 11y agoWell, I think we should get the humanoids done first. U+1F400 EMOJI MODIFIER SMURF U+1F401 EMOJI MODIFIER NAVI U+1F402 EMOJI MODIFIER GREY U+1F403 EMOJI MODIFIER GRAY … the last two being particularly useful for 1F47D EXTRATERRESTRIAL ALIEN; and U+1F404 EMOJI MODIFIER REPTILIAN SHAPESHIFTER whose rendering is implementation-dependent but will be visually identical to one of the FITZPATRICK MODIFIER set if you know what's good for you. But the real, important work will come with the modifier modifiers, e.g. U+1F500 EMOJI MODIFIER MODIFIER EMBARRASSED U+1F501 EMOJI MODIFIER MODIFIER SUNBURNT U+1F502 EMOJI MODIFIER MODIFIER CHOKING U+1F503 EMOJI MODIFIER MODIFIER DEAD … to be used in conjunction with the EMOJI MODIFIER set. These will need to be stackable if we are to be able to distinguish embarrassed dead white males from regular arrogant dead white males. Another commenter mentioned the requirement for facial hair, U+1F1330 EMOJI MODIFIER ANCHOR U+1F1331 EMOJI MODIFIER BALBO U+1F1332 EMOJI MODIFIER CHIN PUFF U+1F1333 EMOJI MODIFIER CHIN STRAP U+1F1334 EMOJI MODIFIER DUTCH U+1F1335 EMOJI MODIFIER FIVE O'CLOCK SHADOW U+1F1336 EMOJI MODIFIER GOATEE U+1F1337 EMOJI MODIFIER HACKER BEARD U+1F1338 EMOJI MODIFIER IMPERIAL U+1F1339 EMOJI MODIFIER MUTTON CHOPS U+1F133A EMOJI MODIFIER NECKBEARD U+1F133B EMOJI MODIFIER SOUL PATCH U+1F1430 EMOJI MODIFIER BOX CAR MOUSTACHE U+1F1430 EMOJI MODIFIER CHEVRON MOUSTACHE U+1F1430 EMOJI MODIFIER DALI MOUSTACHE U+1F1430 EMOJI MODIFIER HANDLEBAR MOUSTACHE U+1F1430 EMOJI MODIFIER PENCIL MOUSTACHE U+1F1430 EMOJI MODIFIER PYRAMIDAL MOUSTACHE U+1F1430 EMOJI MODIFIER TOOTHBRUSH MOUSTACHE U+1F1430 EMOJI MODIFIER WALRUS MOUSTACHE which in turn requires the development of headgear modifiers, so that it's possible to distinguish between U+1F468 MAN, U+1F3FB EMOJI MODIFIER FITZPATRICK TYPE-1-2, U+1F1430 EMOJI MODIFIER TOOTHBRUSH MOUSTACHE (Hitler) and U+1F468 MAN, U+1F3FB EMOJI MODIFIER FITZPATRICK TYPE-1-2, U+1F1430 EMOJI MODIFIER TOOTHBRUSH MOUSTACHE, U+1F1849 EMOJI MODIFIER BOWLER HAT (Chaplin). (Edit: I'm at 1338 internet points right now, so somebody needs to downvote me for this.)
- krick 11y agoAlso we could discuss ordering of these characters. Like why, for instance, white males should be standing before black females after sorting? Seems like inequality! Maybe they should be sorted randomly every time? Same applies to beards, of course.
- golergka 11y agoBecause Unicode standard is so simple and boring as it is already.
- gutnor 11y agoAs far as complexity go, this is quite simple. Unlike a lot of latin accentuated characters, colour modified emoji do not have evil twin brothers that look the same with a different series of code point.
- weinzierl 11y agoI'm not sure it's that simple. To quote from another reply: "Can't wait to bring up this edge case the next time someone asks me to reverse a string in an interview."
- masklinn 11y agoThat's a problem which has existed since Unicode 1.0. That you weren't aware of it before does not make your past code correct. Hell, now, 24 years late, you finally know about that issue and with a bit of luck you may not fuck it up next time you're doing that. That sounds like a great result to me.
- frou_dh 11y agoThanks for sane commentary throughout this story. It's a bit tiresome how people are so quick to tar orderly additions to technical things as "complexity".
- golergka 11y agoBut you're talking about this feature, isolated. You should be thinking about how this feature interacts with every other feature implemented in Unicode. And how, for example, this feature will be brought into an existing Unicode parser. There's always a straw that breaks the camel's neck. Or just leads to camels' quality to gradually deteriorate, leading to increasing bug rates and camel maintainers' depression.
- sidarape 11y agoAm I the only one that find the whole emoji thing a bit ridiculous?
- mercora 11y agoNo.
- drdaeman 11y agoYup, you're not alone. In my personal opinion, that's more of rich text formatting (text with images), not extra characters anymore. That's debatable (and the debate's lost already, huh) but I still believe pictures (emojis) should've been a separate encoding, independent from Unicode, as there is a distinction between a grapheme and icon (yes, the distinction's very blurred by pictograms and ideograms - and I'm not sure I get all those things correctly, but still...)
- bane 11y agoYeah exactly. Emoji might charitably be called an extension of punctuation, but some of the stuff that ends up in the Unicode spec seems pretty crazy. I mean, there's a Moai head in this set.
- weinzierl 11y agoNot ridiculous, but I think Unicode consortium's resources could be spent better. This is my opinion about including emoji in Unicode, not the skin color modifiers. I can only think of it as a case of bike-shedding. Han unification, indic scripts or the lack of differentiation between umlaut and diaeresis are difficult and require experts to be solve satisfactorily. Emojis are easy and anyone is able to contribute a little bit. What is the scope of Unicode? Unicode covers all the characters for all the writing systems of the world, modern and ancient. [1] Sure, emojis are used for communication, but so are images, logos, emblems, coats of arms. Will we have company logos next? Hopefully not. [1] http://www.unicode.org/faq/basic_q.html http://www.unicode.org/faq/basic_q.html
- liquidise 11y ago
- weinzierl 11y agoThis was news to me (the UTR is dated 2015-06-09) but I found that it had been discussed on the web previously. A good overview is [1]. Another thing I learned is that there is a scale for skin tones, the Fitzpatrick Scale [2]. [1] http://blog.emojipedia.org/2015-the-year-of-emoji-diversity http://blog.emojipedia.org/2015-the-year-of-emoji-diversity [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fitzpatrick_scale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fitzpatrick_scale
- amelius 11y agoWhat is next? Unicode Afro-hair? :) Thinking about it, I want a Unicode hacker beard :)
- pavel_lishin 11y agoPlease specify whether you would like a EMOJI MODIFIER NECKBEARD, an EMOJI MODIFIER STALLMAN, or a EMOJI MODIFIER ROCKSTAR.
- jameshart 11y agoCan't wait to bring up this edge case the next time someone asks me to reverse a string in an interview.
- peteretep 11y agoHow's it different from any other combining character?
- masklinn 11y agoIt's not, jameshart just learned about something which has been an issue in reversing unicode text since 1991. So yay for unicode skin tones I say, just as emoji brought to light all the broken handling of astral characters out there, skin tones might finally bring some light to combining characters for all the anglo-centric developers out there who couldn't be arsed to learn about the issue when it didn't affect them.
- jameshart 11y agoWell thanks for assuming ignorance rather than amusement on my part. I've always found the entire concept of reversing a string amusing enough, now I get to add another example of why the entire problem is ill-defined. What is the reverse of the 'white woman hearts black man' emoji? Is it a 'black man hearts white woman' emoji? The realistic string handling problem this will at least bring to light is probably more likely to be an issue with strong truncation than with ill-formed interview questions. As you say, if this brings the risk of splitting combining characters to the fore maybe more software will handle it in the future.
- peteretep 11y ago> What is the reverse of the 'white woman hearts black > man' emoji? Is it a 'black man hearts white woman' emoji No, because when denormalized it consists of codepoints joined by U+200D ZERO WIDTH JOINER, which suggests it's a single grapheme, which means you shouldn't break it apart when reversing.
- Kenji 11y agoI don't understand why unicode needs emojis. I am perfectly happy with ASCII smileys :D This introduces a lot of complexity with little payoff; not a good engineering practice. Also, let us not forget what Bruce Schneier said: "Unicode is just too complex to ever be secure." Maybe it would be a good idea to stop spiraling the complexity out of control??
- weinzierl 11y agoI agree with your point, just wanted to add that from the Unicode perspective emoticons (=ASCII smiley) and emojis are not the same. Q: Are emoji the same thing as emoticons? A: Not exactly. Emoticons (from “emotion” plus “icon”) are specifically intended to depict facial expression or body posture as a way of conveying emotion or attitude in e-mail and text messages. They originated as ASCII character combinations such as :-) to indicate a smile—and by extension, a joke—and :-( to indicate a frown. In East Asia, a number of more elaborate sequences have been developed, such as (")(-_-)(") showing an upset face with hands raised. Over time, many systems began replacing such sequences with images, and also began providing ways to input emoticon images directly, such as a menu or palette. The emoji sets used by Japanese cell phone carriers contain a large number of characters for emoticon images, along with many other non-emoticon emoji. [1] [1] http://www.unicode.org/faq/emoji_dingbats.html http://www.unicode.org/faq/emoji_dingbats.html
- bane 11y agoOn the plus side, this is really great work. On the minus side I sometimes think people working on unicode, a system intended to allow for all the world's written languages to be represented by a single encoding, have lost their minds sometimes. I understand that emoji are used in-line with text, but they aren't text. Once you start going the path of encoding pictures into a text representation you're going to start missing things that people need in these kinds of pictoral representations. I'm sympathetic in a sense, I wrote a paper in college demonstrating why emoji/emoticons are a natural extension of text (to a point), because they can allow encoding emotion and intent, which natural language punctuation don't really allow for. But at the same time, is it really necessary to have half a dozen fish, trains, several food items an alien head, a full set of numbers from 1-10, squares of different sizes, and other non-emotional iconography? And then the argument is that this is just intended to encode Japanese carrier emoji. Great, let's spend brain cycles building into unicode icons used by phone carriers in one country. I'm already bothered by the separate encodings I've seen from time to time for the exact same script, but in slightly different font variations. That's supposed to be handled by the font that's representing the script, not by the encoding. This really needs to be a separate encoding that's not unicode. I figure at some point, unicode will simply turn into a generic image format with a bunch of extra character encoding baggage that people will complain about.
- aw3c2 11y agoDo emojis always look the same or are there different sets? I often wonder if the emotion that I feel some icon perfectly shows, will be displayed the same way at the recipient. I know that fonts and icon sets are usually different per app. Is it just as unpredictable here?
- masklinn 11y agoEmoji are like letters, they have a basic meaning but the exact representation depends on the font. So there are "different sets" in the sense that U+1F46E "POLICE OFFICER" may not look the same across all systems, in the same way "A" will not always look the same unless you specify the font to use.
- 11y ago
- jgalt212 11y agoThe more they add to, or mess with (depending on one's perspective) Unicode the more it risks becoming an attack vector. And if this becomes true, then we have to lock everything down, and we're back to ASCII. And then we have to start all over again.
- krick 11y agoYep, and because ASCII is strictly not enough to write text in most human languages — or, well, even in English, if you would like to use proper punctuation — we have to use some other non-unicode encoding. And because it won't be enough to type in several languages at once and will cause all problems with collation we still have — we are soon building our own Unicode. Let's hope it will turn out better…
- overgard 11y agoSo, uh, what's the actual use of this? Think about it, normal emoji are pretty neutral since their features are abstract and they have a skin color (bright yellow) that doesn't exist anyway. If I send a smiley face with a skin tone attached I'm suddenly making a political statement with a smiley face. That just seems weird.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoI believe Black people were not really represented. Yellow can be interpreted as white or Asian but possible not African/black skin colour. For example at the "Princess" emoji it appears to be a blonde girl. So I want my princess emoji to look more like my girlfriend maybe. This is prevalent all over the world, here in South Africa for example If you look for example at childrens books and toys there is also a lack of representation of black skin colour.
- overgard 11y agoShould emoji "represent" anyone at all though? I always considered them an abstract representation of an emotional state, not a person. I guess the advantage of the old school method (punctuation marks, like ":-)" ) is that they're so abstract that they obviously represent an idea rather than a group or a person.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoI hear your argument, we do need to abstract away from race. That said with the black guy I can do a like a cool brother emoji, just need the comb in the hair ... the white man with the moustache can represent my dad from the 70's. ha ha ;-) Anyway there's that Microsoft grey emoji too, but it looks a bit bland.
- colllectorof 11y agoThat's my take on it as well. I guess it can make some sense to add skin color to emoji that represent people. But a lot of them represent emotions and mental states: "I'm happy" "I'm surprised" "I'm listening" Things that are universal to all humans. Will adding skin color to those emoji really enable better communication, or just create issues?
- mschuster91 11y agoI'm missing fur color modifiers for dogs and kittens!
- tomp 11y agoAgain, no one cares about gingers.
- krick 11y agoI see many people here (somewhat surprisingly) didn't know about that yet, so here's the thread about how the whole thing started: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8558022 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8558022
- makecheck 11y agoThe basic problem with emojis is the use of color of any kind, because a text string alone cannot specify the background that would make the emoji look good. (And besides, the look of each icon varies across platforms!) This to me is why emojis in fonts are so weird. Normal glyphs can be given a color (e.g. you have a red background so you make all your text white). Everything in Unicode can be reasonably changed to another text color, except for emojis. Heck, even old dingbat icon-fonts look good in any color! Emojis don't; they clash with practically everything that isn't a white background. For example, on my iPhone, I tried using an emoji such as "📞" (telephone receiver) in an entry from my contacts list, and sure enough that is allowed. The problem is, this string is used in many contexts: during an outgoing call, names are shown in white on an arbitrary image background; in the contacts list, names are black; and there are probably other renderings too. The plain text looks fine in every case because the OS simply changes all the glyphs to the appropriate color; yet the "📞" icon looks terrible on the call screen because its appearance is unchanged and it looks a blob of goo that's hard to distinguish from the background. There are usability reasons to have black-and-white icon designs, too. Mac OS X does this; such icons are less distracting and it's easier to see details at small sizes. Basically I think they should've taken a close look at what dingbats fonts were doing, and just extend that concept further to have a host of new black-and-white icons.
- Grue3 11y agoAll this bullshit, and we still can't have separate Chinese and Japanese characters that were Han-unificated.