7 ms·
Teeth Whitening and the Hygiene Hypothesis
- comrade1 11y agoWhenever I'm in the u.s. I think people look bizarre with their super-white teeth. I mean, my teeth aren't yellow or anything, but they don't glow in the dark either. There are some things that don't transfer so easily between where I live (switzerland, but I think germanic europe in general) and the u.s.: super white teeth, visible tattoos, and piercings. (although I'll see a small nose piercing on women every now and then) (and if you're German, you should probably leave your puma track suit and aviator glasses at home when you go to the u.s.)
- marincounty 11y agoI don't like the super white teeth either. Every person I have known, on a personal level, who had very white teeth; had a mouth full of cavities, extensive bridge work, or a bunch of money wasted on veneers? Good teeth don't have to look flashy?
- pllbnk 11y agoI think teeth whitening is a bit like steroids or liposuction. It is mostly for people who have insecurities and/or lack discipline to get quick, visible results at the expense of their health. I'm adding health here because these procedures, although deemed safe, are certainly harmful in some way.
- o_____________o 11y agoThere is a natural yellowing from coffee, tea, smoking and aging that even disciplined hygeine doesn't combat. Whitening (via oxidation) is nothing like surgery, being a meager, inexpensive, 5x5 minute habit that has a pretty big impact on perceived health and grooming. The downside is some temporary damage to your enamel, but it's less than a single cleaning at the dentist. If anything, I'm wary of whitening toothpastes, which are ubiquitous and tend to work via abrasion.
- arrrg 11y agoReally, no visible tattoos or piercings in Switzerland? I think you may be going a tiny bit too far if you want to generalize that as an European thing. Any decently sized city in Germany will have certain parts of it or just places where you will see plenty of people with tattoos and piercings. It's no big deal and has been this way for years now. On the other hand I have never seen the specific tracksuit+aviators combination you mention. In fact, while I have seen plenty of aviators in the wild (usually combined with jeans and t-shirt or maybe even a proper shirt), I don't think I have seen many tracksuits at all, much less Puma tracksuits. (I think if you wanna go for tracksuits you should definitely go for some authentic Adidas.) I mean, aviators are kind of a thing like, say, Chucks are a thing (you see them often enough to notice that quite a few people seem to wear the same sunglasses/shoes, but it's not as though a majority of people wears them) but tracksuits are not even that. Or maybe we just travel in different subcultures. Germans living in Switzerland are probably quite unlike Germans living in Germany. And maybe we can generalize this even more: There can be quite a lot of diversity in different groups of people and our simplistic differentiation along nationalities is just not precise enough and our stereotypes fall short. I'm willing to bet that there are certain groups of people in Germany and Switzerland who are absolutely crazy about teeth whitening and for whom no shade of white can be white enough – both of us just don't know any of those people. And maybe it's not yet as popular here as in the US – but that's as it usually goes with these trends. I mean, the future is already here, it's just spread around unevenly – and the same is probably true for our teeth whitening future. (Or maybe we will leapfrog the trend and jump right beyond to the next trend of super-natural looking teeth-yellowing or something like that. Or maybe a competing trend will be adopted by different subcultures or something else altogether. I bet there are also plenty of people in the US who would never ever whiten their teeth.)
- allendoerfer 11y agoGermany is not quite Italy, but tracksuits in public are not common either. It is just a thing in certain subcultures. When I visited Ireland, I saw not a single child, who did not wear one.
- talideon 11y agoWhat part of Ireland was that? I don't think I've seen that outside of more deprived urban communities.
- allendoerfer 11y agoIt was in Dublin a few years ago '11 or '12, I think. To me it seemed to be like there was an age threshold at which people start to wear regular clothes. To say something nice: People were extraordinary friendly and walked up to us from 20-30m (100 feet) away to help us when we looked even remotely disoriented :)
- talideon 11y agoWell, it makes sense that it'd be Dublin. More than likely you were seeing people who live in more deprived parts of the city. I can't say I've seen many children around Dublin dressed like that, mainly teenagers and younger adults. I hope you'd a good time while you were here! I recommend you see some other parts of the country. For instance, Cork and Galway are great cities.
- chmars 11y agoIn my experience, tattoos and piercings are very common in Germany and also in Switzerland. They are certainly no longer limited to certain groups of the population and very visible, especially now in the summer …
- EliRivers 11y agoHow common is it, really, in the US? I genuinely don't know. On the one hand, I hear that medical (and thus presumably dental) insurance costs a fortune, and even then the "co-pay" means that many hesitate to seek treatment. I can't imagine that "my teeth aren't as white as I'd like" is something insurance companies like paying for (or rather, they don't like paying for anything, but something purely cosmetic seems easy to deny), so how are people affording this? is it just the wealthy? If I wander around poorer areas, will I start seeing ordinary teeth?
- hodwik 11y agoTeeth whitening is very cheap, you can buy teeth whiteners over the counter in the US, and most toothpastes you can buy in the store have whitening agents in them.
- MrBra 11y agoAre you talking about those that last just a couple of hours or different ones?
- o_____________o 11y agoWhat treatment lasts a couple hours? You can get very effective peroxide gel kits on EBay for under $20 USD that whiten for many months.
- tabio 11y agoThose whiteners don't create the super-bright almost-blue color you get from the dentist.
- hodwik 11y agoAre you sure? The handful of times I've inquired to an acquaintance about freakishly white teeth, they've always said it was just because they took really good care of their teeth, didn't drink coffee or soda, used whitening toothpaste, and had good genes.
- sago 11y agoI grew up with people having natural colored teeth. People with artificial teeth color were those with false teeth. I find myself gradually getting used to it, but initially it did look like these people had quite serious dental problems: a problem bad enough to require all their teeth be replaced by artificial dentures. This is not attractive. I have the same reaction to perfectly straight teeth or teeth without canines. It looks like false teeth. Crooked teeth isn't a good look either, of course, but forcing out all natural variation just looks like someone's had a problem. Uncanny valley: like someone with a synthetic flesh on their artificial hand.
- amelius 11y agoI usually only notice how yellow my teeth are when I brush my teeth, by the contrast with the toothpaste that is usually whiter than white.
- allendoerfer 11y agoAn aspect worth noting is, that our society is more and more redefining the meaning of "health" from the absence of illness to perfection of some universal subjective standard, which disregards factors like age or sex. White teeth have at least some roots in biology - generally the younger you are, the whiter your teeth - still it makes no sense to compare the whiteness of different aged people and judge their health based on them. Ethically we are on a dangerous path: Orthodontics for children are standard in Europe and the US, countries like Japan are catching up quickly. Teeth-whitening is common in the US and is becoming more popular in Europe, too. Orthodontics includes oral surgery more and more often. Korea is all in and full blown plastic surgeries are becoming the standard [0]. These surgeries cause pain and hinder you to eat properly for months. Still we are on a path to include them in our definition of health. In Korea parents often pay for them as a present for graduation. People who the majority perceives as disabled or even just ugly are not necessarily unhealthy. We should make a clear distinction between body modifications and medicine. Unfortunately our ape brains see a high status individual and cluster these things together. This lets us worry about health problems we previously did not even know we had, making us psychologically and often physically unhealthier in the end. Another big problem is, that we ignore the fact that we age. I do not think that care for the elderly should be an area of medicine. When your body breaks apart at 80 years old, that does not make you unhealthy, you are just old. You should not get the needed social interaction from doctors, who try to fix something that is perfectly natural to fall apart. Some of the plethora of pills an 80 year old takes surely increase his or her life expectancy, I feel like others might not be worth the hassle. I surely do not want to ruin my last moments on earth organizing my calendar of doctor appointments trying to squeeze out the last couple of days I can possibly get. [0]: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/03/23/about-face http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/03/23/about-face
- hessenwolf 11y agoThe NHS approach of putting monetary value on a year of life and comparing the drug costs to that is a good approach to reducing the spend on tired old bod's.
- to3m 11y ago
- dschiptsov 11y agoWhiteness of teeth and eyes are biological markers of being a good potential mate with [currently] good health and [presumably] strong immune system (evolutionary "hints" of having "good genes"), an analogy of peacock's tail. Breath is another important hint, btw. These are just hard-wired to our brains. People are mere monetizing these "heuristics" into absurd.
- golemotron 11y agoYes and the author tells a story about Western culture but I kept asking "how do you know?" Eastern cultures may have the same bias but without enough technological development over their history to actualize it at the same rate that we have.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hodwik 11y agoA lot of Asian cultures actually have a culture around teeth blackening. http://www.traveldudes.org/travel-tips/tooth-blackening-forgotten-tradition/14811 http://www.traveldudes.org/travel-tips/tooth-blackening-forg...
- tabio 11y agoAnd some American subcultures have a cuture around teeth goldening!
- IkmoIkmo 11y ago> "how do you know?" Maybe he doesn't. If I tell you a story about my culture I don't necessarily imply to know about everyone else's, too. For example I've got no clue how whitening plays a role in much of the world as a beauty standard, but I know how it plays a role where I'm from. And indeed standards may not be the same. For example in much of Asia it's often a beauty standard to have the lightest skin colour possible, for light-skinned people. While this exists in the west for dark skinned people, light skinned people generally have the opposite and getting a tanned skin is considered better than a pale one. How that works for teeth I don't know, although I'd imagine in most cities white teeth as a beauty standard are probably fairly common but it's just an assumption.
- cpncrunch 11y agoLink doesn't work on mobile devices. It redirects to the issue homepage.