6 ms·
Silicon Valley is perhaps the most productive and innovative place in the world
- comrade1 11y agoBased solely on stock value. Which, I guess if you had to take a measurement based on something it may as well be that. Assuming we're not in a bubble. The last two crashes the stock value dropped 50%. Does that mean Silicon Valley productivity drops 50%?
- adventured 11y agoNot based solely on stock value. Just those 99 companies, referenced in the article, account for 6% of all US corporate earnings. Intel + Apple + Google + Cisco + Oracle = ~$95 billion in net income.
- spacehome 11y ago> The last two crashes the stock value dropped 50%. Does that mean Silicon Valley productivity drops 50%? Um. No?
- garry 11y agoThis is the kind of armchair comment that misunderstands how Silicon Valley works. You're right that stock value is disconnected from actual value (or productivity), but it's not right to connote there is no value at all. The first crash was lack of startup fundamentals. By all means it was a Valley-induced bubble. But the second was an external liquidity crisis uninfluenced by the fundamentals of startups. In the aftermath of both crashes, billions in value were created by small teams of software engineers in Silicon Valley, and that's real earnings/cash flow.
- lispm 11y agoIt's just that much of the 'innovation' is in a selection of domains with an emphasis on get-rich-quick pyramid schemes. Pressing problems like clean energy, clean water, peace, livable cities, energy saving, waste reduction, climate protection, ... are usually not among these domains of 'innovation'. Machine learning for Internet marketing or mass surveillance though is.
- krasin 11y agoThere's evidence for the opposite: * clean energy: http://blog.samaltman.com/energy http://blog.samaltman.com/energy plus Tesla / Solar City * clean water: https://angel.co/water-purification https://angel.co/water-purification * peace: (not sure what would fit here) * livable cities: self-driving cars, Uber * energy saving: Nest and similar smart home efforts * waste reduction: very diverse topic; Project Ara is one of the efforts to reduce the consumer electronics waste * climate protection: affordable sattelite imagery (Planet Labs, Skybox), and clean energy efforts (see above)
- lispm 11y agoSelf-driving cars are the solution to nothing. We need much less cars and much more efficient transport in the cities. if you look at the list, it just shows how much more REAL progress is needed. Most on that list is fake progress.
- natrius 11y agoTransportation network companies have immediate origin and destination data for so many users that they will be able to create far more efficient "public" transportation systems than have ever existed. UberPool and Lyft Line are baby steps in that direction.
- gherkin0 11y ago> Self-driving cars are the solution to nothing. For better or worse, they are the solution to the continued employment of drivers of various kinds.
- seregine 11y agoHere's one problem self-driving cars can help with: http://www.iihs.org/iihs/topics/t/general-statistics/fatalityfacts/state-by-state-overview http://www.iihs.org/iihs/topics/t/general-statistics/fatalit...
- Cthulhu_ 11y ago
- codeshaman 11y agoIt might be the most innovative and most productive place but how does it affect the rest of the world ? Let us not forget the other side of the coin. (1) On one side - tech has magically enhanced the world and our lives. Socially, it has freed us from opression and gave us all a voice, ...etc (2) On the other side - tech has disconnected us from nature and has negatively affected the environment, by making us much more efficient at extracting and transforming nature (raw materials) into goods. Socially, even though everyone has a voice, it's lost in the cacophony - everyone tries to out-shout everyone else; we're constantly fighting for each other's attention, we're walking around looking at screens while our children are pulling our hands and screaming for our attention. And so on.. So is 'innovation' good or bad ? The answer is some union between (1) and (2). Only the future will definetely answer this. It so in our nature to look at the extremes and ignore the other side of the coin that some are only going to see (1) and some are only going to see (2). And for those who see only (2), Sillicon Valley, with all the good intentions, might just be the most destructive place in the world.
- michaelochurch 11y agoIt's rich. There's a difference. It's not innovative but incremental and cowardly. It's productive, but not all that it produces is valuable. Whatever piece of human garbage instituted stack ranking at Google is almost certainly living in a nicer house than 95 of that company's engineers. The VCs add little but are kingmakers who decide who can buy the talent and who can't. For historical reasons, they're geographically concentrated. Also, most of the Silicon Valley "innovation" is a joke. Clinkle? Snapchat? Uber I will give high marks for potential, but it was founded to facilitate date rape (to give young sociopaths in San Francisco the experience of being a "baller", to use a direct quote) and it was only later that its investors took note of its long-term possibility to be something more.
- CaiGengYang 11y agoWhy do u say Uber was created to facilitate date rape ?
- michaelochurch 11y agohttp://www.businessinsider.com/why-travis-kalanick-founded-uber-2013-11* http://www.businessinsider.com/why-travis-kalanick-founded-u... In this sort of context, "baller in San Francisco" (or any city) is code for "guy who plies women with alcohol until they can't say no". It has nothing to do with sports.
- dang 11y agoYou said Uber was "founded to facilitate date rape". That's shocking and disgusting, and you entirely made it up. That link has nothing to do with what you said. I've asked you countless times in public and in private not to do this on HN. If you won't or can't stop, I'm going to ban your account.
- michaelochurch 11y agoDo you really think that by "baller" he meant "basketball player" and not the colloquial, IBD, meaning?
- MichaelCrawford 11y ago"Everyone I know masturbates at work." -- Beth Shreve FTFY
- bettyx1138 11y agoI moved there from NYC and couldn't last a year. It's deathly boring to live there.
- omarforgotpwd 11y agoAgreed. Having grown up in LA the valley is really boring. I guess that's how we get so much done.
- tibbetts 11y agoAll that and so modest too.