6 ms·
David Axe has a great, thorough writeup on how F-35 became the worst, most expensive, plane in our arsenal and will probably just get our pilots killed. https:
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
David Axe has a great, thorough writeup on how F-35 became the worst, most expensive, plane in our arsenal and will probably just get our pilots killed.
https://medium.com/war-is-boring/fd-how-the-u-s-and-its-allies-got-stuck-with-the-worlds-worst-new-warplane-5c95d45f86a5 https://medium.com/war-is-boring/fd-how-the-u-s-and-its-alli...
I was extra mad that they're moving to get rid of the A-10's in favor of this garbage. Originally learned about them with the A-10 Tank Killer games on PC. Later read how they shredded the opponents' vehicles in one campaign after another, even recent ones, despite being highly exposed to enemy fire. They're beasts. And that's just one example of something that does its job more effectively and at better cost than F-35... which is also being decommissioned to support F-35 program. There's quite a few more that each could've been updated with less money than F-35 took.
- ethanbond 11y agoWhich highly mechanized army are we fighting?
- protomyth 11y agoThe A-10 is an absolute beast against the people we are currently fighting. It also can hang around and provide cover for a much longer time than the F-35.
- ethanbond 11y agoI don't know enough to have a solid opinion, but at a surface level I can see enormous value in the F35. The growing threat against western militaries are asymmetric threats, and the US's modus operandi for quite a while has been to empower the carrier strike groups to project power over wherever these threats may start heating up. If a carrier has to carry a bomber and two escorts and now an F35 can be 80% as good as each of those at their respective task but take up < 33% of the space, that seems valuable. How does this whole F35 thing pan out when logistics like that are taken into account?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThe easy way to do it is to just ask, "When have we been unable to destroy enemy vehicles or structures due to extra planes?" We did it in Iraq faster than ever with our current configuration of various, specialized aircraft. What you're mentioning can be done with F-18's and A-10's against most countries. The top opponents are investing in, again, aircraft specialized for certain types of missions that will dominate F-35 in any performance test. China's F-35 is already better than ours for instance. I'm not sure if they sent Lockheed a thanks for all the free R&D. ;)
- threeseed 11y ago> China's F-35 is already better than ours for instance Where is the evidence for this ? Everything I've read about the J-31 has said that it isn't a match for the F-35 at all and actually isn't even a program yet (just a prototype has been built).
- nickpsecurity 11y agoMight be true. There's little to draw on for either side of the argument. Original article I cited was the basis for my claim where it showed they had eliminated weaknesses in F-35 in their clone. That's already better for short-range. Whether it's better for long-range will depend on their detection and missile tech. Or how much of ours they stole and improved on.
- engi_nerd 11y agoTheir only evidence was their own claims. Unsubstantiated in any public source. Please please stop taking "maybes" and speculation and presenting it as fact. That's what irks me about David Axe. I'm really confused, because I have read through some of your other commentary here on programming and security issues and you seem quite intelligent and solid there. So why spread so much FUD about something that's outside of your wheelhouse? You're certainly allowed and encouraged to ask questions, investigate, etc, but you're presenting yourself as an expert on this sort of thing when you aren't.
- PaulHoule 11y agoThe A-10 is built around an absolutely awesome cannon, but it is vulnerable to shoulder-fired missile launchers. I don't know how many of these ISIS has, but there are plenty of them out there in the world, and they are designed to be used by irregular forces.
- douche 11y agoAny low-flying, slow ground-attack aircraft that is designed to strafe is going to be vulnerable to shoulder-mounted missiles. I would have more faith in the survivability of a flying tank like the A-10 (the thing is built with a titanium bathtub enclosing the pilot, redundant hydraulics, manual cable control backups, and the engines mounted in a configuration that somewhat confuses the thermal signature of the exhaust), which has demonstrated the ability to fly home after being shot full of more holes than swiss cheese, than in most other ground-attack craft. Helicopters, even a similarly over-armored model like the Russian Hind, don't have that kind of durability. Maybe we'll have close-air support drones eventually, but I would imagine a drone that has the flight characteristics to be a good gun-platform for strafing is still going to be vulnerable - this is flying in at altitudes where aimed small-arms fire can do damage.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoIt's a risk. However, it worked in our last two conflicts where enemies had both those and surface-to-air.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoCase in point: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nUXmqpRhTjQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nUXmqpRhTjQ And against ISIL targets: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tn8R8ne9Pd0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tn8R8ne9Pd0 That it can take tons of gunfire, counter missiles, rapidly disable targets (bombs/missiles), and selectively/cheaply do it (bullets) makes it ideal for current battles. Gotta imagine what beast would've come out of $1-5bil in improvements to that.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoThat first video is terrible.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoMost of the A-10 videos were terrible despite how cool a video its capabilities could make. I went through half a dozen of them looking for good runs with avenger and bombs. That was the most "exciting" one that popped up. I should've posted footage of the PC game (A-10 Tank Killer) as it did it more justice lol.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoSadaam's had trucks, tanks, and planes IIRC. Most Middle East targets don't operate entirely with shoes and camels. There's plenty of machinery to target. Remember, though, that these programs exist to put money back into Congressional districts more than anything else. That's why they do nothing about Pentagon being a financial sinkhole with broken accounting. So, they have to do upgrades, need a lot of money to move, and everyone wants a piece of it. Option A: invest small amounts to upgrade a few proven planes with their contractors and subcontractors; Option B: invest as much as a war into an unproven one with cash across many districts and capabilities a compromise across various branches. Option A is best for taxpayer but Option B is best those paid with taxes. Washington and Pentagon 101. ;)
- engi_nerd 11y agoDavid Axe exhibits poor engineering understanding of the aircraft, which results in him interpreting the reports that he reads in ways that are simply not supported by the source material. As someone with detailed knowledge of the program, I consider his reporting to be misguided at best and potentially malicious at worst. At the very least I wish he would consult someone with flight test experience as he writes.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoActually, the test pilots tell him it's such a poor design that they lost to F-16's in the mock battles: http://www.popularmechanics.com/military/a16248/test-pilot-f35-cant-dogfight/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/military/a16248/test-pilot-f... Rather than denying it, Lockheed's response was that it was intended for "long range" dominance. Axe's claim was that it would fire off its payload and be destroyed in dogfights by any planes that survived. The pilot's remarks and Lockheed's support that this is true... even if they have their older planes. ;) Far as long-range, there's concerns even if we take Lockheed's word their stealth is great. Their word hasn't been reliable so far but let's pretend it is. That leaves two problems: engine being picked up by upgraded infrared sensors on next-gen aircraft; fact that tests showing long-range dominance were done with weapons it doesn't even have and still aren't in the program. Both mean it might not perform as well as expected with one being straight-up deceptive. So, the evidence in dogfights, Lockheed's response, and their cooked tests show this plane is worthless. Upgrading proven designs that are each great at their respective missions would've been a better investment. Far as aircraft engineering, I haven't met one engineer that in private will endorse F-35 or existing VTOL aircraft. They all mock both while praising their choice of prior aircraft. F-15's, A-10's, and F-18 Super Hornets get my vote for upgrade dollars. That's air, ground, and multi-mission. Maybe try to make the F-22 cheaper while they're at it. Improve some drones or human, recon craft. Throw in improvements on an ECM craft. All adds up for most bang for buck. Collective capability would rival a bunch of F-35's. Military with with the F-35's. Should've chosen Option A.
- douche 11y agoThe whole long-range dominance idea reminds me of early-Vietnam era F4 Phantoms - they were supposed to use the early models of Sparrow and Sidewinder missiles exclusively for air-to-air combat. So when they actually got into combat, the armorers started strapping externally mounted gunpods on them, so that they could have a chance to dogfight with the mostly cannon-armed MiGs they encountered.
- Spooky23 11y agoThe A-10 worked because the Soviets didn't export man portable SAMs.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoOther sources I've dug up showed the A-10's lack of thrust hurt it in Iraq and other places. They used it to mop up less-equipped front of line troops. I might need to re-evaluate it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]