7 ms·
In every work environment which has an clear gender imbalance we see the same stories of the minority group being pushed out by the majority group. The minority
by belorn 11y ago
In every work environment which has an clear gender imbalance we see the same stories of the minority group being pushed out by the majority group. The minority group feel pressured to be more majority-like to fit in, receive comments like "you are good for a minority person", and feel a social expectancy to be more like the majority group. Those who don't behave correctly report of being silenced and treated in a very hostile way and normally end up leaving the profession shortly afterward. This kind of gender inequality is then seen in 90% of all profession (Swedish statistics from SCB in 2010) where the top 3 have less than 1% of a minority gender.
When reading this kind article I wonder how useful it is to pitch it as a fight between badgers and squirrels. 87% of squirrels work in a profession hostile to badgers, and 88% of badgers work in a profession hostile to squirrels. Having been personally in both environments once, even if it was a very short time, I can't help to see a big lack of common understanding of each sides plight when they are a minority.
- Kalium 11y agoIt's always easier to pitch it as "Those ABCs are mean to us DEFs". It comes with a neat moral clarity that is lost when you have to consider that DEFs treat ABCs similarly in analogous situations. I was going to use X and Y before I thought about chromosomes.
- Udo 11y agoI'm also not so sure if it's productive in the long term to portray it as a fight at all, but short-term it probably helps to give these initiatives a little bit of personality (people like to partake in things that feel competitive). Watching the presentation, however, 'escalating conflict' does not seem to be a core message here. It would certainly feel more natural if the squirrels and badgers were equally well represented. When we reach that point squirrel identity will become just as diluted as badger identity. As long as you're a minority, you can stick together by defining it as a common trait, but that sort of thing will dissolve very quickly in larger numbers. Being a squirrel (or being a badger) is not an identity, but it may seem that way as long as you're the only squirrel in a badger forest. This is all a bit long-winded way of saying "I think it will be alright in the end".
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoThere is also the problem that we are talking about certain subsets of badgers and squirrels. Consider that many of the badgers that originally grew the forest that they now enjoy only did so because they were shunned not just by the squirrels, but by many other badgers. Look closely and you'll notice that some of these badgers, or those of the same subgroup, are resistant to both squirrels and other badgers coming into the forest. It isn't due to some sense of greed or superiority, but from a trained desire of self preservation. And then you have the issue that in this forest, the job of maintaining the forest and the hobby of playing in the forest merge together, so groups that formed by badgers who play together carry over their group behaviors, including the exclusion of outsiders, into their work of maintaining and growing the forest. They likely don't even mean to do this most of the time.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Kalium 11y agoThis sounds very much like the central thesis of "When Nerds Collide". Is that intentional?
- d883kd8 11y agoMy guess is no ... "When Nerds Collide" is a great piece of exposition but I doubt it's the source of the idea.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoNot intentional. When many people describe a similar phenomena, trends will appear, independent of if they are well constructed entries or once off forum posts.
- wisty 11y agoAre these squirrels and badgers resistant to other squirrels and badgers coming in, or just resistant to changing their behavior to fit in with the newcomers? And do we really believe that squirrels and badgers are fundamentally that different?
- ZenoArrow 11y agoIf you get a chance to watch the presentation, do. It's pretty clear from the tone of the presentation that hostility towards badgers is not the aim, they are clearly grateful for those that supported them, badgers and squirrels alike, and even make fun of the hostile turnips among us!
- pdabbadabba 11y ago> 87% of squirrels work in a profession hostile to badgers, and 88% of badgers work in a profession hostile to squirrels. This is a good point, and I think this mindset could go a long way towards avoiding the sort of demonizing that often undermines conversations on this topic. Surely a large part of the dynamic is that the statistical majority can naturally come to regard itself as "normal" (in the normative as well as statistical sense). I do think we miss something, though, if we overlook the fact that, taking a step back, the vast majority of professions (especially lucrative ones and those that come with a substantial amount of social power) are badger-dominated. This is probably not an accident and, whatever the cause, there are good reasons to think this situation is systematically unfair to squirrels. And while it doesn't doesn't come about because badgers are all jerks, we also need to remember that personally exonerating all the badgers is not really the point, and will not solve our problems.
- sliverstorm 11y agoAnd while it doesn't doesn't come about because badgers are all jerks, we also need to remember that personally exonerating all the badgers is not really the point You may have "exonerate" backwards in your head? absolve (someone) from blame for a fault or wrongdoing
- pdabbadabba 11y agoNope. That is exactly what I meant. Whenever workplace discrimination comes up, I get the sense that a certain portion of the community concerns itself primarily with establishing that most (maybe all!) of the people involved are not Bad People. My point is that they may be right, but whether the people involved are Bad People is really not the point.
- belorn 11y agoThe list tops with profession which are all blue collar jobs. Midwifes had highest with 99.7% majority, following with dentist nurses and floor carpenters each having above the 99% line. After that we got motor mechanics, thin-metal worker and nurses for children hospitals which are 99%, 99%, and 98% respectively. If we only look at CEO/president professions in different industries, the highest majority was in CEO for minor construction with 96% majority, followed by CEO for electric installation at 92% and CEO for health and child care at 84%. Badger, Badger, and Squirrel respectively.
- tomp 11y agoI find it baffling everytime someone refers to men and women as separate groups. What's the point of equality then if we're still so different? (In my experience, if you want to talk about "groups" in programming companies, it's mostly geeks vs. non-geeks, with men and women in both groups.)
- untog 11y agoWhat's the point of equality then if we're still so different? To make two separate groups equal? I don't understand what is complex about that. They are separate groups according to how they are often treated in the workplace.
- sliverstorm 11y agoIt's an idealogical struggle that goes back and forth. For example, from my very rough memory: - People were upset there weren't more women in the armed forces. - The armed forces lowered PT requirements for women so that more women could make it in (less pushups, slower mile times, can sit down in formation) - Currently people are mad because that treats women differently. Among other things, it gives a sense that all women are weak and need extra accommodations, and that can hurt them in the eyes of men in the force. So we have this struggle of wanting to include more women, but we have to figure out how to do it without favoritism.
- bayesianhorse 11y agoThe point is that the armed forces don't need the PT requirements, and they are mostly a way of selecting recruits. There are good reasons for increasing diversity, and if that means women, with their naturally lower muscle mass get a lower PT requirement, that is not really favouritism.
- robertfw 11y agoIt's easy to say that we're all one group if you're in the dominant group...
- yummyfajitas 11y agoIn every work environment which has an clear gender imbalance we see the same stories of the minority group being pushed out by the majority group. This isn't true at all. Lots of fields had clear gender imbalances and explicit hostility, and yet the minority gender had little trouble entering. For example, medicine, law, pharmacy, HR, advertising, professor of subjects which don't use math, etc.
- keypusher 11y agoAre you sure about that? I think the difference is that the pioneering women who opened the doors of fields such as medicine and law did so over 100 years ago. The minority gender had lots of trouble entering, and up until recent times suffered from many of the same things that women complain about in the programming community.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoSoftware is well past the point that medicine was at in 1915. In fact, computing specifically had lots of women in it's early days - probably more than medicine had at the same time. Any theory which predicts that math/physics/cs/EE has few women is inherently flawed if it doesn't also predict that medicine/law/advertising have plenty of women.
- pron 11y ago> Any theory which predicts that math/physics/cs/EE has few women is inherently flawed if it doesn't also predict that medicine/law/advertising have plenty of women. I am not sure where you're going with this, but you can't make such a comparison at a given moment in time. The reason is that struggles usually follow power, and so it is likely that at any point in time, a marginalized group would concentrate its efforts to penetrate positions that imbue power. As the power structure shifts, so does the struggle. You can't equate professions that hold different amounts of power at different times. Certainly up until some decades ago, law and medicine carried much more prestige and influence -- and hence, power -- than math and the physical sciences. In fact, software's gain of prestige correlates quite well with the drop in women participation. It is quite anomalous in that the existence of the field long predated its power. Law and medicine, OTOH, are professions that have been seats of power for almost a millennium. A model that correlates low female participation with high power -- and later, increased participation after a struggle -- predicts both observations. It is not such a surprising or sophisticated theory; historians have seen this pattern so often that it is almost banal. This pattern is so regular, that it's relatively easy for us to predict the future: fifty years from now, assuming the power wielded by software remains high, women participation will equal men's, and it will be hard for people to believe that that hasn't always been the case. Unfortunately, even though the result of the fight is certain, we still need to fight it. That is the price history exacts from us.