3 ms·
Well, I think I'm starting to understand your take on the subject. Thank you for putting in the effort to explain it (where I agree or not). It seems like the
by joe_the_user 17y ago
Well, I think I'm starting to understand your take on the subject. Thank you for putting in the effort to explain it (where I agree or not).
It seems like the issue is whether the case of D not being a subset of T is "interesting" or not.
I think Manin has a point in sense that if we know that D is not a subset of T, then we are in a rather pathological case.
But I can see your point in the sense that if it's impossible to prove within an axiomatic system that the system itself is inconsistent, then one has to keep a situation like D not being a subset of T in mind.
It's very roughly speaking, the computational versus the syntactic view of logic...
- anatoly 17y agoThank you for the kind words. Understanding is always more valuable than agreement.