3 ms·
> We will access, disclose and preserve personal data, including [...] files in private folders I don't see any language that restricts that to their cloud off
by the8472 11y ago
> We will access, disclose and preserve personal data, including [...] files in private folders
I don't see any language that restricts that to their cloud offerings. It's in the privacy statement that covers windows too.
So unless i'm missing something they're granting themselves the right to disclose your harddrive to government agencies or their own legal department on a good-faith basis.
- sudioStudio64 11y agoEvery company that has access to your encryption keys can be prompted to give them up with a warrant. You can keep them from having the key. That's one way around it. Using hardware of some kind (and there are multiple.) You are also free to use another solution that might meet your strict requirements to personally review the encryption, filesystem, device driver, and memory management code of your operating system to verify it's operating to your specifications. There have literally never been so many options for the privacy minded person with the time to pour through a metric ton of C code.
- the8472 11y agoI'm not talking about encryption keys. I'm talking about the data itself. Sitting on my harddrive, as it is. As I understand it microsoft is saying that they could siphon data from my computer if they deemed it necessary. Maybe that's an adversarial reading of their privacy statement[1]. But it clearly speaks of accessing files in private folders. [1]: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/privacystatement/default.aspx https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/privacystatement/default.asp...
- sudioStudio64 11y agoI believe that you are mistaken. Could they turn over your BitLocker recovery key to the authorities that would then use it to decrypt your HDD that they have already taken from you? Yes. Are they going to reach out over the internet and take your data? No. They are not going to do that. I follow this stuff really closely. I promise I haven't seen or heard of a capability where they can remotely take data from your machine and turn it over to the government.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoThere are two approaches: give someone a pile of power over you and trust them not to abuse it, or never give them that power in the first place. Given the repeated demonstrations of what can and does go wrong with the former...
- sudioStudio64 11y agoThose aren't even remotely the only two choices here. There have never been more options for an end user of technology. You don't have to use agree to it. It's a trade off. If you have different requirements they are more than willing to come up with a different arrangement with you. (Yes, for a fee.) They aren't the government. They are an overblown bubble gum factory. It's up to you if you chew or not. And there have never been so many flavors!
- Dylan16807 11y agoWhat kind of fee do you have in mind for not using their contract of adhesion? Unless I'm buying thousands of copies of the OS I doubt I can even get that negotiation started.
- sudioStudio64 11y agoSome of it's pay as you go, oddly enough. But you are largely correct that more money equals more access to these kinds of things. There is a company in China that paid them to install Office 365 in their data center. There is an amount of money that will make them install it in your data center, too. I just think that there has never been more choice for end users and a lot of this stuff about privacy is disingenuous. There are a group of people that wouldn't be happy even if MS released their own version of TAILS and hosted part of the Tor network. (It would be "embrace, extend, extinguish!"..."Tor is part sponsored by the Navy...I be MS gives your Tor traffic directly to the NSA."...It's really not hard to imagine the BS.)
- sudioStudio64 11y ago