21 ms·
My Life as an Autistic Wikipedian
- comrade1 11y agoI've jokingly referred to Wikipedia moderators as autistic for, for example, diligently reversing changes to articles even when done by experts in that field. I guess I'll try to come up with something else...
- mahouse 11y agoIf you spent some time editing Wikipedia in a serious way, you would notice how a high % of the regular editors/admins are more than obviously affected by a wide spectrum of mental problems. Although I guess this topic is a taboo because of how the society has been trying lately to “normalise” mental illnesses.
- anc84 11y agoIt is the same in many other contribution run online communities. It can be a fantastic content & quality fuel to have people obsessed with a topic. I hope that does not sound exploitative though.
- DanBC 11y agoIt's a little bit frustrating that you describe behaviour you don't like as either mental illness or neuro-diversity. Sometimes an asshole is just an asshole.
- rangibaby 11y agoI agree with you, but after the whole retard business yesterday, calling people assholes doesn't seem right. It's kind of like saying "sometimes people are just retarded".
- mahouse 11y ago"Neuro-diversity" just means "mental illness". And I don't believe there are many assholes around. Most people that act like assholes regularly are just affected by some illness, even if it's only a depression. Nobody wants to be an asshole, believe me.
- DanBC 11y agoHang on: Autism is not a mental illness! > And I don't believe there are many assholes around. okay, I don't have any research so I'll accept this for a moment. > Most people that act like assholes regularly are just affected by some illness, even if it's only a depression. Neither of us have any research, so I wonder how strongly you feel that? And maybe if you swap "depression" for "stress" I guess I'll agree. > Nobody wants to be an asshole, believe me Wait what? Plenty of people who don't have anything like a diagnosable mental illness enjoy being assholes just because. I guess we're disagreeing about definitions of asshole and mental illness here though.
- mahouse 11y ago> Hang on: Autism is not a mental illness! "A serious developmental disorder that impairs the ability to communicate and interact." Would you not call that an illness? > Neither of us have any research, so I wonder how strongly you feel that? I feel it very strongly, as someone who has been affected by it. > And maybe if you swap "depression" for "stress" I guess I'll agree. I agree on that too. > Wait what? Plenty of people who don't have anything like a diagnosable mental illness enjoy being assholes just because. I guess we're disagreeing about definitions of asshole and mental illness here though. I don't believe in that. Someone who is a chronical asshole is probably depressed, stressed, an autist, a psychopath, etc.
- RobertoG 11y agoA very interesting read. One question comes to my mind: If autism is a spectrum, and Rain Man is in one side, what is there in the other?
- reitanqild 11y agoIn the middle are, by definition I think, neurotypical people. In other directions/dimensions you find extroverts, ad(h)d-ers etc.
- JohnBooty 11y agoI generally agree. Additionally, there's a lot of overlap between autism and the various subtypes of ADHD. Whether they share a common cause or if they're two unrelated things that just sometimes happen to the same people, I don't know. A lot of the more impulsive ADHD'ers have trouble reading social cues in many of the same ways as autists. A lot of the more inattentive-type ADHD'ers (hello, this is me) can read social cues well but share other traits with those with autism - being overwhelmed by social situations, hyperfocusing, being overly literal at times, etc. Every time I read an article written by a high-functioning autist I find that I strongly relate to some of the traits but not others.
- k8tte 11y agosnow man?
- roel_v 11y agoIt's an n-dimensional spectrum, but just the concept of 'spectrum' as already too difficult for many people to grasp, hence a generic use of 'spectrum'.
- JohnBooty 11y agoThank you! I've never seen/heard this expressed so well and so succinctly before.
- guard-of-terra 11y ago
- reitanqild 11y agoWould not consider myself an autist but this seems like a very good explanation: By autistic standards, the normal human brain is easily distractible, obsessively social, and suffers from a deficit of attention to detail.
- luck87 11y agoSo all of us are a bit autist :-)
- kushti 11y agoWhat's the official diagnosis? Cant' find it in the article. Unfortunately, we have a lot of freaks calling themselves "autists" (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bram_Cohen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bram_Cohen "Cohen claims he has Asperger syndrome[3] based on a self diagnosis.[4]") just because that's trendy amongst infantile social media consumers.
- badpenny 11y agoYou seem to be familiar with Wikipedia so I'll draw your attention to the article on there dedicated to the subject.
- kushti 11y agoThe question remains the same: are we talking about "self-diagnosis" or a real problem.
- programLyrique 11y ago"It took a bit longer (and a few tests) to get a confirmation from experts" and "the current prevailing hypothesis to explain this, based on an IQ test taken as part of the evaluation process". So not a self-diagnosis.
- kefka 11y agoYes, because it's most certainly required to upload and "prove" all claims about oneself on the internet. Oh wait, it's not. It was a claim about his self. You don't like it? Quit reading.
- badpenny 11y agoI'm not sure I understand your question, or rather it seems to be more than one question. Yes, Asperger's is a real problem. Yes, some people self-diagnose themselves. Yes, some of these people would not be diagnosed with Asperger's were they to undergo diagnosis by an expert.
- Jemmeh 11y ago
- irremediable 11y agoVery well-written. It's funny... I've never thought I might be anything other than neurotypical, but reading the article makes me realise how many of those traits I have. I've always defaulted to taking people literally, to the point that friends joke about it. As a child, I got bullied a bit for speaking in a "weird voice" (monotone), and to this day people sometimes say my voice sounds weird to them. My motor coordination is dreadful, and I've always been fascinated by categorisation and ontologies. My family have remarked that I seem unemotional, which I know is untrue, but a lot of it seems to be their alienation by what I consider to be logical behaviour. I suspect this is just hypochondria, or something like it, but I guess it illustrates how subtle the idea of a spectrum can be.
- badpenny 11y agoI think it's fair to say the most important/relevant/defining trait is quite severe difficulties in social functioning, usually characterised by a lack of friends. This is also the one that I nearly always see left out by people who "think they might have it".
- DanBC 11y agoAnd importantly it's not because people with autism do not want friends. They are often desperately lonely.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoAre there usable self-tests that have reasonable error rates?
- DanBC 11y agoProbably most relevant is the work of Simon Baron Cohen, a respected researcher into ASD. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon_Baron-Cohen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon_Baron-Cohen There's a test for "Empathy Quotient", and there are probably self test versions around. (I found a few using Google, but I didn't try them so I don't know if they're harvesting email addresses or need payment) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empathy_Quotient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empathy_Quotient He also developed an Empathizing Quotient / Sympathizing Quotient test, and there are probably self-test versions available. http://personality-testing.info/tests/EQSQ.php http://personality-testing.info/tests/EQSQ.php See also this (heavily caveated) test http://psychcentral.com/quizzes/autism.htm http://psychcentral.com/quizzes/autism.htm These tests are probably better than reading DSM / ICD diagnostic criteria, but still a proper diagnosis should be done by a proper doctor with some experience in the topic. That does have a couple of problems. 1) It can be hard to find a doctor prepared to give you an assessment and diagnosis. 2) It leads some people to think there's an industry of doctors diagnosis bogus conditions in order to prescribe medication. (See for example how dismissive some people are of ADD / ADHD).
- guard-of-terra 11y agoI don't think there's such thing as neurotypical. "Neurotypical" means "person who haven't got enough attention to be examined nor a name for their specific neural features". Because everyone got some.
- badpenny 11y agoIs that really what it means or did you just decide that's what it means?
- AndrewDucker 11y agoNeurotypical seems to mean a mixture of "Near the centre of the bell curve, for all attributes" and "Is able to mentally cope with the world without unusually large quantities of external support".
- badpenny 11y agoOr, in short, somebody who doesn't have Asperger's.
- AndrewDucker 11y agoOr Schizophrenia. Or ADHD. Or any one of a massive host of things that can affect the brain and make it harder to cope.
- badpenny 11y agoI thought this was a discussion about Asperger's, not every single mental disorder under the sun.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoNot many people are neat the centre of the bell curve for ALL attributes (statistically, since attributes are aplenty) and those who are become a small and interesting subset on their own.
- 11y ago
- Udo 11y ago> the English How are you? or the German Wie geht's? As a cultural aside, I would like to point out that the German "wie geht's?" is used to actually prompt a superficial answer about one's state. It's perfectly acceptable to reply with information like "meh, I'm having some trouble". The same goes for almost every other country. But the (US) American "how are you?" does not afford this. Like the article describes, anything but "fine, thanks, and you?" is not considered a valid response. This still trips me up when talking with Americans...
- smacktoward 11y agoHere's a trick: if asked "how are you?" by an American, and you're not fine and/or don't want to pretend to be fine, shrug your shoulders and say: "Same old, same old." (As in, it's another day full of the same old problems as yesterday.) This will prompt the American to make a generalized expression of sympathy over the countless petty indignities of life, without feeling a need to inquire as to exactly what specific problems you're dealing with.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoIt's pretty similar in the UK to your description of USA [I assume you mean USA when you say Americans and not any of the other 41 American countries? Bugbear, sorry]. In the UK in many areas we say "[Are you] Alright?" and the response is "[Yes,] [Are you] Alright?". You are not supposed to say whether you are "alright", just answer "Good" or an equivalent. It's analogous to the traditional [middle/upper class] "How do you do?" to which the response expected was "How do you do?". The follow up is usually what the weather is like or something about traffic ...
- acheron 11y ago[I assume you mean USA when you say Americans and not any of the other 41 American countries? Bugbear, sorry]. Which of those other 41 countries have "America" in the name? Let me know and I'll be sure to consider them when using the word "Americans".
- 11y ago
- noir_lord 11y agohttp://archive.wired.com/wired/archive/9.12/aqtest.html http://archive.wired.com/wired/archive/9.12/aqtest.html no idea on it's accuracy but interesting nonetheless (For the record I scored 37 and I'm not (afaik) autistic).
- pmelendez 11y ago> (For the record I scored 37 and I'm not (afaik) autistic). The "AFAIK" is key here. These days there is an "increase" of ASD cases mostly because the diagnostic was extended to cover Highly Functional cases. The thing is that individuals with High Functioning Autism can live normal lives and go undetected (Just as the author) which begs the question... Should it be detected at all?
- SolaceQuantum 11y agoI received a 35 and I'm actually on the schizophrenia spectrum with a disorder that actually requires ruling out ASD. I wouldn't give this or any other online test anything more than extreme skepticism.
- pmelendez 11y ago> I wouldn't give this or any other online test anything more than extreme skepticism. Completely agreed.
- robhack 11y agoI did 37 too. I'm not officially autistic, but I think I have some of the traits, or maybe it's just that I'm a big introvert.
- zamalek 11y ago> One way to illustrate this is to use a computer analogy: in a way, my CPU runs at a higher frequency, which has allowed me to emulate with software the hardware that I'm missing. I'm convinced that there is something here. One notable thing out of my childhood is dyslexia. It has taken some things away from me. Some of which I've figured out the 'emulator' for (handwriting, spelling). I'm still working on other things (messiness, forgetfulness). However, for as much as it has taken away it has also given. I'm absurdly good at solving incredibly complex problems (both logical and sociological) and good at making fast high quality decisions. I think the reason is simple: most people naturally see "J" and "T" as different things, I struggle to do the same. That being said, while many people see two problems as different things, I can see the similarity: solving N problems with 1 solution. Another dyslexic once called it "intuitive reflection and rotation" - a name that I strongly agree with; the dyslexic mind automatically reflects and rotates both images AND concepts. I strongly believe that many (likely not all) learning 'disabilities' are not actually disabilities. They are merely trade-offs. Children who have these 'conditions' should really learn how to capitalize on their unique abilities instead of being told that and treated like they are mentally disabled. So the kid can't spell, who cares?
- Kenji 11y agoYou are lucky. There are plenty of people with learning disabilities and no such obvious upsides. I think your case is the exception, rather than the rule.
- Varcht 11y agoReally? Do you have some examples? What are these disabilities measured against other than the "norm"? Some of the most learning challenged I've known were incredible streetwise for an example.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- saint_fiasco 11y agoThat may be a selection bias. You just don't hang out with people with severe disabilities as much. Maybe they just stay home, with a family member to look after them. Some of them are in institutions, cared by professionals. A learning challenged person who was not streetwise would probably stay away from the streets.
- nraynaud 11y agoFunny, I clearly have some troubles, and every times I read a description of a head condition, I wonder if I don't have that.
- 10dpd 11y agoWhat are you describing is 'confirmation bias', a tendency to search for or interpret information in a way that confirms one's preconceptions.
- nraynaud 11y agoLet's say it's a confirmation bias from someones who has 2 shrinks (and no clear diagnostic appart from depression), some medicines and not been employed for 3 years.
- ktallett 11y agoAs an autistic who has experienced shrinks over many years, some can be extremely wary about labelling a mental health condition whilst others can be the complete opposite, it can depend on many factors from where they gain funding, to their own area of expertise. I wouldn't rule anything out nor say you have anything but I have to say getting diagnosed helped me come to terms with a lot of things that happened to me or that I did earlier in life. Therefore I would certainly consider a new view on the subject if I was you.
- socrates1998 11y agoThis makes a lot of sense, because Wikipedia editors have a lot of problems with flexibility. They don't like newer sources even when they are clearly better and more accurate than older sources. They don't like people who are experts to contribute to articles because it infringes on their territory and they don't like to admit they know less than the professional. The wikipedia editing system is Byzantine and there are a lot of layers you have to go through. This eats up a lot of time and prevents a lot of experts from contributing because they don't have the time to deal with it. Wikipedia is good for basic definitions, but it needs more flexibility.
- genericuser 11y agoWhile I agree with your criticisms of Wikipedia, I do not think it is appropriate to make the connection, which your post seems to strongly imply, between Wikipedia editors with these traits in general and Autism.
- luck87 11y agoReading the article, I find some analogy as the writer, but I think I am not the only one. The writer said that he discovers to be an Autist, but he didn't say what kinds of exams or diagnosis he performed. Google result about ASD: "There is currently no medical test that can confirm a diagnosis of autism. A diagnosis of autism is based on observed behavior." Because (I think) the following reasons are not sufficient to say that you have a sort of autism: having social disease, linking Star Trek novels, feel always alone, high IQ level, bad childhood, love pc, no sense of fashion.
- i14ng 11y agoProfessional diagnosis would involve a standardized set of questions, like ADI-R http://www.wpspublish.com/store/p/2645/autism-diagnostic-interview-revised-adi-r http://www.wpspublish.com/store/p/2645/autism-diagnostic-int... or ADOS module 4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autism_Diagnostic_Observation_Schedule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autism_Diagnostic_Observation_... Often the clinician would also want to interview parents, spouses, friends to get a third-party perspective on a person's behavior or ask about their behavior as a child. It is a relatively objective process - it does screen out 99% of people, and clinicians usually (80%-ish of the time IIRC) get the same yes-or-no answer for the same person. There's no medical test because (like most of the DSM) autism is a description, rather than an underlying cause. That is, if you diagnose flu using a set of symptoms, you're using the symptoms to predict that the virus exists. If you diagnose autism using the checklist in the DSM, you're simply saying that you saw the stuff on the list - there's nothing said about cause. See also here: http://intellectualizing.net/2015/03/31/not-explaining-autism/ http://intellectualizing.net/2015/03/31/not-explaining-autis... This is a fundamental difference between DSM diagnosis (which is putting people in descriptive categories, without explaining "why") and medical diagnosis of many conditions with a known cause (which means identifying an explanation such as a virus).
- gpaumier 11y ago(I'm the author.) You're right that there isn't (yet) a medical test like a blood test or an MRI to detect autism. In France, the official "diagnosis" is established by a psychiatrist based on interviews and questionnaires with the person, and some of their family members if possible. That's how it happened for me, and at the end of the evaluation process, they said I met "the criteria (CIM 10 and DSM IV) for a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder, and in particular for Asperger syndrome (CIM 10: Axis I, F84.5)". I haven't looked into what those numbers refer to exactly, and I don't like all the medical connotations, but that's how it's done in France. There's a screenshot of the report in an post I published earlier this year (in the "self-discovery" section: https://guillaumepaumier.com/2015/02/22/2014-in-review/ https://guillaumepaumier.com/2015/02/22/2014-in-review/ ).
- moron4hire 11y agoMaybe stuff like "inability to focus" is not the fault of the person but of the task. What if there are truly boring tasks that one would be better discarding than forcing themselves to focus on? Maybe there really are people with whom you can't have a well-adjust relationship. Maybe it's not your fault you can't empathize with what that person is feeling. Maybe it's their fault for getting bent out of shape over stupid stuff. What if it's okay to get angry in bad situations and is not an anti-social disorder of some kind? What if, when someone screws you over, it's completely legitimate to yell at them and not trust them again? Who got to decide that not wanting to work on boring work, not wanting to socialize with vapid people, not wanting to be nice to awful people, equaled mental disorders? Especially when it comes to work, our culture sees it as "more normal" to bottle up your emotions at work and act them out in self-destructive ways at home. Yes, we criticize such people--as Mitch Hedberg pointed out, alcoholism is a disease, but it's the only disease that you can get yelled at for having--but we don't criticize them anywhere near as much as we criticize the people who quit their toxic jobs to become artists or to travel the world. Maybe it's the world that is sick. Maybe it's the world that belongs in a mental institution.
- soneca 11y agoI often see people ridiculing diversity recognition among human beings as "this political correctness is going too far". But i think is kind of ridiculous assuming that 7 billion are essentially the same. I know now that I am a neurotypical heterossexual cis white male (and I hope to learn more ways in which my characteristics differ between humans). And it is important for me to recognize this in me and others. Recognize is the keyword here. I am not sayingn what is right ir wrong in actions after this recognition (like affirmative policy and etc). This is to be debated as a society. Also, not all these characteristics are the same. Some of these, like gender and race, should affect our interactions less than they currently do. Others, like sexual orientation and identification and mental model , should affect our interactions more than they currently do (imo of course). But, as individuals, we should all recognize our diversity. And spend some time reflecting about this should or should not affect our interpersonal relations.
- cubancigar11 11y agoEverytime I read such articles I am reminded of my stay in Germany. In those 5 years I behaved exactly the way the author behaves, and shared same thoughts as the author. And then I came back to India and I am so totally different man now, I wonder if the whole autism spectrum has society as an influential input too. Being in India I just have so many friends with whom I can discuss very intimate doubts or facts about life that you can arrive at a peaceful state of mind very easily and function as a normal member of society without ever having a doubt about yourself, while in west in general the focus on individualism means most people don't talk to each other and are always expected to behave a certain way otherwise they will get 'what is wrong with him' look all the time.
- drewolbrich 11y agoI am not autistic, but for me, maintaining eye contact is like trying to stare at the Sun.
- brobdingnagian 11y agoGuillaume, I do not think you are autistic, I think you are probably an ISTP. Rodney Mullen, also an ISTP, thinks he is autistic. No - that's just normal human variability. There's no use in unnecessarily psychopathologizing yourself.
- jpatte 11y agoReading the article I was also wondering if most traits weren't simply due to the author's personality rather than to a form of autism.
- Raphmedia 11y agoThe thing is, this is not a self diagnostic. See: https://guillaumepaumier.com/2015/02/22/2014-in-review/#attachment_8324 https://guillaumepaumier.com/2015/02/22/2014-in-review/#atta...
- greggarious 11y ago>Most of those issues arise because you don't have a way of knowing that the person in front of you is different. At least Spock had his pointed ears to signal that he wasn't human. His acceptance by the crew of the Enterprise was in large part due to the relationships he was able to develop with his shipmates. Those relationships would arguably not have been possible if they had not known how he was different. That can be a problem since telling people you have a mental illness is usually a career limiting move at most companies.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoTo say nothing of the people who want to limit one's rights based on mental health. (While it sounds like a good idea in theory, in practice it will lead to people hiding any issues.)
- Jemmeh 11y agoFor Spock, he's supposed to be different, he's an alien. So it's ok. If Spock had a tentacle, it's fine, he's an alien. When humans are different, you're doing being human wrong. If a human has a tentacle, something's definitely off. At least that's most people's view of psychology as of current. I think the field is changing and embracing difference a little more though. But! Big pharma wants everyone to think they're broken so they can sell more pills, so that is counteracting the progression towards accepting diversity.
- ktallett 11y agoAs an late professionally diagnosed (diagnosed at 21, now 26) Aspie (Aspergers Syndrome) who also contributed to Wikipedia for a long while. This gentleman's story really resonates with me. Even the tale regarding someone noticing it in me. I for my whole life until I was around 16-17 thought everyone felt the way I did, constant cramps in limbs, hatred of social situations, brain constantly racing, extreme attention to detail. But I have since realised that is not the case. I used to love to build websites at home despite my mum not allowing the internet. So I ran my own internet of sorts that I would update with news and facts from memory. I would read these articles back and also print them out so I could read them when we went on bus journeys or I stayed at my nans. I created networks of fake people who emailed and messaged each other through an application I developed. This may sound lonely but it wasn't to me. I moved away from tech to gaming just trying to fit in at school and work for many years until painful myalgia/dyspraxia (common I've found in aspergers sufferers) forced me to leave. Now these many years on I am slowly making inroads and doing the things I love (I am making a site that will contain drawings of every single room I have been in since I was a toddler, remembering each room is my special skill (I shall have to remember that to tell my Psych lady)) but felt I shouldn't be doing. I have wanted to become active on the hacker news site for a few years yet was always to scared and anxious to join yet I couldn't ignore this post. I understand imposters syndrome is fairly common in tech and I have seen many people mention it. I feel like an imposter as a human at times so it feels super uncomfortable even considering anything else. Anyway thanks for reading. (A little thought, the colours on this site are so bright for my eyes which are more sensitive than most I know, perhaps a second colour option may be useful)