10 ms·
Note that the upgrade will remove your Windows built-in DVD player. The right to play DVDs must be paid for every computer. You paid it when you bought the Wind
by acqq 11y ago
Note that the upgrade will remove your Windows built-in DVD player. The right to play DVDs must be paid for every computer. You paid it when you bought the Windows 7 or 8 that you'll maybe upgrade to 10. Now the upgrade to Windows 10 takes that feature away from you.
They apparently (the twitter message isn't actually the company statement) plan to return it "sometime in the future" and "if it might be free or if it will cost" is TBA:
http://www.windowscentral.com/windows-10-will-include-option-play-dvd-movies-sometime-future http://www.windowscentral.com/windows-10-will-include-option...
The Media Player capabilities, if you have them in your Windows edition, will be for ever deleted. Just so.
Moreover, note that the upgrade can reduce the functionality of your notebook: Microsoft made the deal with the hardware producers about integrating hidden partitions to allow the recovery from the hard disk, but the upgrade process will just make sure that the Windows runs, not that your recovery from the hard disk functionality, managed by each hardware vendor independently (based on the recommendations from Microsoft) would be preserved.
I don't use the recovery mechanism, but I do use backup. When the recovery partitions aren't right, the built in backup (which was kept from Windows 7) doesn't work on Windows 8.1.
The same story happened with the transition from Windows 8 to Windows 8.1 (I have such a notebook).
Anybody knows if the "Windows 7" style full disk backup survived in Windows 10?
- sergiotapia 11y agoCan you not use VLC or MPC?
- acqq 11y agoIt's not about what "can" be done, you can also install the pirated software too, the thing is, by buying legally Windows 7 or Windows 8 Media Pack or Ultimate I have really paid the DVD playback functionality to Microsoft as well as the other features I've mentioned. Also read about the legality aspects of the Microsoft's DVD solutions up to now and of the open-source DVD players: http://www.zdnet.com/article/if-vlc-can-ship-a-free-dvd-player-why-cant-microsoft/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/if-vlc-can-ship-a-free-dvd-play...
- sergiotapia 11y agoI don't get it... are you complaining that you were revoked a license to a software that came bundled with windows?
- acqq 11y agohttp://www.windowscentral.com/windows-media-center-gets-laid-rest-wont-appear-windows-10 http://www.windowscentral.com/windows-media-center-gets-laid... "Microsoft confirmed to ZDNet that Windows Media Center is indeed finished, and users who upgrade to Windows 10 will no longer see it." http://www.windowscentral.com/windows-10-will-include-option-play-dvd-movies-sometime-future http://www.windowscentral.com/windows-10-will-include-option... "In a statement on his Twitter account, Windows Insider leader Gabriel Aul provided this tidbit of news: "The main scenario people used WMC for was to play DVD. We'll provide another option for DVD playback in the future." Exactly what this option will be, and if it might be free or if it will cost Windows 10 users extra, has yet to be announced."
- waterlesscloud 11y agoWhy wouldn't someone complain about a reduction in functionality in software they paid for? Do you somehow feel that's out of line?
- acqq 11y agoIt's not only that Microsoft removes the features, they also don't tell you clearly they'll remove them but they put almost "malware-like" request on your system for which you already paid to them to "just upgrade it's safe."
- Someone1234 11y ago> they also don't tell you clearly they'll remove them Yes they do. The upgrade assistant warns you during the upgrade process[0] and specifically has you confirm it. [0] https://i.imgur.com/ekSbGOL.jpg https://i.imgur.com/ekSbGOL.jpg
- 11y ago
- shocks 11y agoYou can use VLC. After your comment, I wasn't sure why that was the case. Apparently: > Neither French law nor European conventions recognize software as patentable (see French section below). Therefore, software patents licenses do not apply on VideoLAN software. From http://www.videolan.org/legal.html http://www.videolan.org/legal.html
- acqq 11y agoBut see also this (on the same page) if you're using VLC in the US: "libdvdcss libdvdcss is a library that can find and guess keys from a DVD in order to decrypt it. This method is authorized by a French law decision CE 10e et 9e soussect., 16 juillet 2008, n° 301843 on interoperability. NB: In the USA, you should check out the US Copyright Office decision that allows circumvention in some cases."
- shocks 11y agoAh interesting! I missed that.
- noinsight 11y agoThat is actually illegal in Finland because it's illegal to circumvent the copy protection. Technically you need a licensed player. A few people have turned themselves in for watching a DVD on Linux and they received a token fine.
- shocks 11y agoHow much is the fine?
- noinsight 11y agoIt's hard to find working links for old stuff (this was in ~2007), but... The law made "organized discussion" about breaking copy protection illegal so they also created a website with the title "organized discussion" and displayed code for breaking the protection and someone also paid 5 cents for it after which they turned themselves in :) Apparently the lower courts acquitted them but that was reversed and the supreme court didn't take the case. So the end result is that it's illegal but they didn't receive any penalties. Apparently the European court of human rights didn't accept the case either. http://mjr.iki.fi/eucd/ http://mjr.iki.fi/eucd/ (discussed here in Finnish) http://www.digitoday.fi/yhteiskunta/2008/05/26/dvdn-katselu-linux-koneessa-muuttui-rikolliseksi/200814212/66 http://www.digitoday.fi/yhteiskunta/2008/05/26/dvdn-katselu-... (news article about it)
- gambiting 11y agoVLC plays DVDs just fine for free, by decoding CSS on the fly. One might argue that that "The right to play DVDs must be paid for every computer" but I have never signed such agreement with anyone, ever. If I legally bought a DVD then I can legally watch it - maybe in US people would argue that decryption of a legally bought DVD is "hacking" but fortunately I don't live in that beautiful country.
- pki 11y agoIt's probably/usually inclusive in your OS or computer purchase
- toyg 11y ago> I have never signed such agreement with anyone, ever Until Windows 8, Microsoft did this for you behind the scenes. From Windows 8 onwards, Microsoft stopped doing it; you could either pay them to do it again, or OEMs would do it for you. With 10, Microsoft just won't do it. I expect OEMs will still do it on new devices, but upgrades are anybody's guess.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- toyg 11y ago> Note that the upgrade will remove your Windows built-in DVD player. That's bonkers. Ok, it was never a great player and every half-decent geek uses VLC or better, but still, plenty of people use MediaPlayer every day. Tech support hotlines will be overwhelmed by furious customers.
- gambiting 11y agoWindows 10 still supports music and video playback just fine, through applications called Xbox Music and Xbox Video: "Xbox Video supports all the video files you’ve probably been downloading the VLC Media Player desktop app to watch." http://www.gottabemobile.com/2015/01/25/windows-10-vs-windows-7-what-you-need-to-know/ http://www.gottabemobile.com/2015/01/25/windows-10-vs-window...
- acqq 11y agoBut not the DVD playback, which has to be licensed additionally. Being the person who also legally bought the DVDs (all of them are DRMd nowadays) it really hurts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_Scramble_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_Scramble_System
- gambiting 11y agoTo which I already replied in the same thread - use VLC which decodes CSS on the fly, unless you live in a country that doesn't believe in your freedom to play legally purchased content and prohibits doing that(United States of America). Of course, it would be nice if Windows 10 just included that and saved everyone the trouble.
- acqq 11y agoIt's not only the US, see the post from the user noinsight here.
- tw04 11y agoIf you upgrade from a version that supported DVD playback rather than do a fresh install, the DVD playback will still be there.
- Freaky 11y agoYep, Control Panel\All Control Panel Items\Back up and Restore (Windows 7) Exact same old craptastic System Image backup stuff. Still can't only backup my C drive, got to include my TB's of bulk data on non-system drives too, grr.
- acqq 11y agoSo it's not improved but at least they haven't removed it. Thanks.
- Amezarak 11y ago? On Windows 7, I can deselect non-system drives. Did that change on Windows 10?
- acqq 11y agoThe target drive on Windows 7 and 8 has to be at least the size of the previous one, which includes even the partitions which aren't copied. It seems nothing changed on 10 regarding that.
- Freaky 11y agoNo, like I said, it's exactly the same. If it decides it's a system drive, you can't unselect it, and it's very easy to make something a "system drive" when it's really entirely non-critical (a drive with some games on it, for example). I at least found the one tiny non-critical service I had installed from my downloads drive - a PS3 controller driver. Ironically having removed that, the drive in question is now impossible to include in a backup. WTF. It's all very frustrating when you just want to make an image of a single drive.
- hwh 11y agoIn the specs in the section "Feature deprecation" (http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/windows-10-specifications http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/windows-10-specificat...) Microsoft mentions that removal and that eligible Windows versions will get a free DVD player app after the Upgrade.
- acqq 11y agoHas anybody seen that Microsoft's free DVD player app for Windows 10? What's actually "a limited time (the “eligible period”)" they talk about? (all the quotes from your link http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/windows-10-specifications http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/windows-10-specificat... ): "For a limited time (the “eligible period”), on systems upgraded to Windows 10 from one of these older versions of Windows (a “qualified system”), a DVD playback app (“windows DVD player”) will be installed." And I've actually paid for the Media Pack upgrade. It goes away now for sure: "Windows Media Center will be removed."
- stefanix 11y agoDVD? What is that?
- doodpants 11y agoIt's a technology that allows you to watch movies without an internet connection.
- sudioStudio64 11y agoBackup was there in the last CTP. Assuming it's still there.
- sasaqqq 11y agoThis shouldn't be discussed.. We ALL ARE Linux/Unix Guys, Right?
- inversionOf 11y agoNote that the upgrade will remove your Windows built-in DVD player. Windows 8.1 had no built in DVD player. Nor did Windows 7 Starter or Basic. Further, I suspect it's a feature that the vast majority of people have never used, exactly why Microsoft decided that they wouldn't subsidize the licensing for no reason. This is a very 2002 discussion. Not that your point isn't valid -- at least for those users who ever actually tried playing a video DVD, and who had a supporting version of Windows -- it's just pretty odd that such a comment sits at the very top of an enormous technology event. The Tesla doesn't come with a holder for my buggy whip.
- thachmai 11y ago> it's just pretty odd that such a comment sits at the very top of an enormous technology event. Tech people like you and me love to nitpick. It's quite "logical", measurable, and it generalizes complex issues into nicely formatted bullet points.
- acqq 11y ago> it's just pretty odd that such a comment sits at the very top of an enormous technology event. What you call "an enormous technology event" I call a disaster, showing perfect "we don't care for the current users" attitude, even after the public demonstrated what it thinks about the "improvements" in Windows 8. The commenters here rightly point that the returned Start menu is even worse than it was during the tech preview. And I have actually paid for my copies of Ultimate and Pro with Media Center versions and I actually need the features I note are now quietly removed. It's your right that you don't need them, but I do need them and the people who consider installing 10 should know about it too.
- inversionOf 11y agoOkay, so I hope others see your real motives. Don't upgrade. You paid $0 for Windows 10, had absolutely no expectations about it when you apparently bought Windows 7, and now it's a "disaster" because an unused feature was openly and clearly removed. Give me a break. This sort of "take a shit on everything" attitude is one of the worst facets of HN, and your comments in particular exemplify them. Don't upgrade. Move on.
- tw04 11y agoHonest question - who cares? Someone actually used the built-in media player? Step 1 for me on any new desktop/workstation install (regardless of OS) is to install VLC. I have to believe the number of people who actually use that can be counted in the tenths of a percent of their user base.
- DanTheManPR 11y agoAmong people I know, I can think of a few who rent DVDs from Redbox and watch them on their laptops (we're out in the country, so the internet isn't fast enough for streaming video). They're not technically adept enough to know that they would need something like VLC after this update.
- vmarsy 11y agoI would care if tbe Xbox one, which will soon be on Windows 10, stopped playing DVDs. But I don't think this would be the case, there is probably a specific player for it.
- ascagnel_ 11y agoYou're correct on the latter point; the Media Center functionality (not to be confused with Media Player) was used by very few. That said, if you have cable TV in the US, it was the best way to use your own hardware to watch cable TV.
- hyperbovine 11y agoAs long as they left in pinball
- Aldo_MX 11y agoYou can always extract it from NT4, just run this in the i386 folder: EXPAND.exe PINBALL.IN_ C:\PINBALL.INF Take the list of files from there, and expand them, ex. EXPAND.exe PINBALL.EX_ C:\PINBALL\PINBALL.EXE EXPAND.exe PINBALL.HL_ C:\PINBALL\PINBALL.HLP REM etc. If you don't have an ISO at hand or if you prefer to avoid extracting/expanding the files: https://archive.org/details/pinball.7z https://archive.org/details/pinball.7z
- pearle 11y agoI upgraded to Windows 10 Home from Windows 7 Home Premium and I have a Windows DVD player installed.
- Eyas 11y agoRE DVD, they just rolled out a DVD app for those that used Media Center[1]. [1]: http://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/insider/forum/insider_apps-insider_other/getting-the-windows-dvd-player-app/6c94b519-8b05-462e-a864-b7ad67d5c834 http://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/insider/forum/insider_app...
- bri3d 11y agohttp://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/windows-10-specifications http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/windows-10-specificat... For a limited time (the “eligible period”), on systems upgraded to Windows 10 from one of these older versions of Windows (a “qualified system”), a DVD playback app (“windows DVD player”) will be installed. They aren't stealing anything from you, and they're not causing it to be "for ever deleted." I just checked with my Windows 7 Ultimate machine I upgraded this morning and sure enough, I have a Windows DVD Player there. Like many users, I have no DVD drive and no DVDs, so I can't confirm it works. Also, Windows 8 didn't come with a DVD license, you had to buy it separately as part of the "Pro Pack" or "Media Center Pack." The base editions of Windows 7 (below Home Premium) also didn't include one.