5 ms·
New model may explain emergence of self-replication on early Earth
- kanzure 11y agoAlthough not a chemical mechanism, it seems that a randomly generated set of initial operations once executed tends to develop into self-replication: http://diyhpl.us/~bryan/papers2/ai/The%20evolution%20of%20self-replicating%20computer%20organisms%20-%20A.%20N.%20Pargellis.pdf http://diyhpl.us/~bryan/papers2/ai/The%20evolution%20of%20se... Ligation (append) is a necessary precursor operation, I think.
- Gravityloss 11y agoSo once we go deeper into computer generated programs, we might accidentally start creating self replicating programs...
- mangeletti 11y agoAccidentally?
- Gravityloss 11y agoYes, that was the point of my post. I think it's obvious that everyone on Hacker News is aware of purposefully created computer viruses and worms.
- lgas 11y agoWe've already intentionally created self replicating programs: viruses.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hodwik 11y agoShoot, I was hoping this was going to be about Jeremy England.
- sciencerobot 11y agoOf course! The Earth is a giant thermocycler.
- dekhn 11y agoI've seen every single detail in the phys.org previously described, including the quantitative part. THis is spectacularly unoriginal reporting on really duplicative science.
- fcharchtn 11y agoSpeaking only for myself, I have not read about this specific research before, so I thought that the article was fascinating. It is unfortunate that you though that this article about a proposed mechanism for the origin of life on Earth was spectacularly unoriginal.
- dekhn 11y agoI wouldn't have a problem with it if the authors didn't claim it was novel or original. As an introduction to the concept, the article is fine.
- java-man 11y agoSelf-sustained Replication of an RNA Enzyme (2009) Tracey A. Lincoln, Gerald F. Joyce http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2652413/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2652413/
- spiritplumber 11y agoI'd like to see a creationist response to this. They tend to either reduce to "No, because the book says otherwise" or be legitimately inventive. Wonder what a creationist lab would look like...
- valine 11y agoAs a creationist who has a very rudimentary understanding of chemistry and biology, I can tell you that my first reaction to this model is to look at its apparent reliance on a fairly complex template and assume (correctly or incorrectly) that this template is too complicated to be derived by chance in a single, finite universe. I then decide that I would rather believe in an infinite God rather than an infinite number of theoretical universes, and at which point I stop reading hacker news and go back to work. Please note that this comment is intended to provide a creationist's initial reaction to an article for anyone curious, not to debate the origin of the universe.
- Cogito 11y agoWhat leads you to think that the templates are necessarily very complex? In my reading, the models requires the presence of polymers, let's call them A, B, and T; and a cyclical mechanism that causes these polymers to alternately bind to each other and release each other (through chain to chain ionic or hydrogen bonds). The polymers themselves are formed of chains of smaller monomers covalently bonded to each other. A, B, and T are floating around, and occasionally bind to each other. The nature of our template T is such that both A and B can bind to it at the same time. Importantly, T doesn't need to be much larger, or more complex, than A or B, just able to bind to one of the ends of each. So we have our polymers floating around looking something like (this is my purely made up notation): *A*: AAaAaA *B*: BbbBbBB *T*: TTaAabBBT They move into the night cycle, causing them to bind to each other with ionic or hydrogen bonds: AAaAaA BbbBbBB ||| ||| TTaAa-bBBT Due to the ends of the A and B chains now being so close to each other, they form a covalent bond, resulting in a new polymer chain C: *C*: AAaAaABbbBbBB |||||| TTaAabBBT The day cycle comes around and the template breaks away from the newly created chain. Thus the template is acting like a catalyst, able to create many identical copies of this polymer C. C is a more complex polymer than either A or B and could easily become a template itself. It's not much of a stretch to then consider a polymer which either was a template for itself, or was part of a sequence of templates that produced each other. To your complexity point, it doesn't seem obvious that these templates are necessarily "fairly complex" - indeed if you admit the existence of polymer chains in the first place the ability for one of them to act as a template seems trivial.