5 ms·
WebRTC is being singled out as it leaks user information that wasn't leaking before. AFAIK, the conspiracy-minded people are claiming that this is a move by 'a
by madeofpalk 11y ago
WebRTC is being singled out as it leaks user information that wasn't leaking before.
AFAIK, the conspiracy-minded people are claiming that this is a move by 'advertisers' to collect more user-identifying data.
- jnbiche 11y agoWell, websockets introduced a massive new opportunity for advertisers to exfiltrate user data that wasn't even subject to the normal cross-site restrictions until recently in most browsers. But nobody proposed eliminating Websockets, or requiring explicit user approval for connections. Instead, they fixed the problem.
- kuschku 11y agoThe issue is that, for example, the New York Times actually used WebRTC to gather data for exactly that purpose. https://webrtchacks.com/dear-ny-times/ https://webrtchacks.com/dear-ny-times/
- anfedorov 11y agoAnd by "exactly that purpose" you mean preventing ad fraud [1], right? They weren't using WebRTC to put you in a "VPN user" advertising segment. 1. https://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/3dgwee/how_the_new_york_times_uses_webrtc_to_gather/ https://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/3dgwee/how_the_new_...
- monstruoso 11y agoDoesn't matter. Privacy is not about right or wrong, it is about privacy.
- anfedorov 11y agoPrivacy is not an absolute to be maximized at all costs. Do you have blacked out windows, or do you concede that the practical day-to-day infringement of your privacy is so minuscule and so easily mitigated by window shades that it's not worth the trade-off?
- 1stop 11y agono, but I have windows with curtains on the inside. Not the outside. The distinction is both important, and blatantly obvious. Privacy control must remain with the one whose privacy is at stake.
- anfedorov 11y agoAnd sometimes you have these curtains open? But what about privacy? Do you agree that sometimes people being able to look into your living room is not a big deal, even if it decreases your privacy by some definition? Great, then you agree that maximizing privacy at all costs isn't your or people's tradeoff point. Same with WebRTC - your internal network's IP is not the kind of privacy most people care about, nor should they. That said, WebRTC from behind a VPN exposing your personal IP is a bit different. That's kind of like a light you installed rendering your curtains translucent. I'm not sure if it's the curtain's fault, or the light's, but it's certainly not what anyone had expected! Given that OpenVPN somehow works in a way that doesn't expose your personal IP [1], I'd blame the VPN providers for saying that their VPN anonymizes web traffic when it actually doesn't. 1. https://tlog.anfedorov.com/vpns-webrtc https://tlog.anfedorov.com/vpns-webrtc
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- anfedorov 11y ago> a random guy on the internet says something and you think it is true? Yes, if they identify themselves and their company and what they say aligns with my personal experience. > You don't have the foggiest idea what they are really doing with the data. All we know is that they are collecting the data without user's consent. You never have any absolute certainty what anyone does with your data - all you have are hypotheses and probabilities. Who are "they" and what do you think they are doing? If adtech companies cared whether you're behind a VPN, they would make or buy a list of IP's that are provide VPN services and match that list. That's a ton easier than implementing a STUN server that scales to handle traffic from every single person who views one of their ads.
- glass- 11y agoIt's not only about the VPN leak. WebRTC also leaks internal IP addresses which provide additional entropy that can be used for fingerprinting.
- anfedorov 11y agoEntropy that changes when your local IP does? That's worse than useless for ad targeting. Even if it were useful, I don't think there's much of a chance that adtech companies will build out STUN servers to handle the kind of traffic they do just track down the 0.001% of users who do not accept third-party cookies. Can you even do WebRTC from an iframe? Browser fingerprinting is absolute FUD. It makes no sense for advertisers, and it's pretty useless for anyone else, too. Every time I visit the EFF site that checks my fingerprint, it tells me I'm still unique. That's perfect anonymity! Revealing a user's personal IP when they're using a VPN is a real problem, though, where the computer isn't doing what an even an experienced user would expect.
- madeofpalk 11y agoAlthough NYT shouldn't get off scott-free, I think it's worth pointing out that they probably had very little to do with this and more than likely had no idea about it. The WebRTC 'tracking' was from a script from an ad network[1] used by at least Ars Technica and The Washington Post. As someone who works on sites implementing display advertising using these sorts of networks, I have nothing but contempt for the developers that are writing these JS. I've lost count of all the JS errors they cause (currently I see a lot of `Can't find variable: _body`), or just errant console.log messages (one on every browser scroll or resize was fun). [1]: Edit: Amusingly I found a developer arguing for this WebRTC-punching, who says he's from White Ops (whiteops.com) working on anti-bot tools https://github.com/EFForg/privacybadgerchrome/issues/431#issuecomment-120668684 https://github.com/EFForg/privacybadgerchrome/issues/431#iss...
- JupiterMoon 11y agoThere's quite a lot of case law that says that companies can be held responsible for their subcontractors. See e.g. Deepwater Horizon I am not a lawer. This is not legal advice.
- madeofpalk 11y agoOh yes. I agree. > Although NYT shouldn't get off scott-free Legals aside, ultimately you're (where 'you' == 'the company') responsible for what ends up on your website. What I'm saying that this is more nuanced in practice. If you look at the JS console on some sites I work on at my company, you could come to the conclusion that we're bad developers because of all the JS errors you would see. Unfortuantly, they're made by others and we (developers) get little choice in the matter.
- kuschku 11y agoAnd this, everyone, is why using pay-per-view or pay-per-click ads online is so destructive.
- GrinningFool 11y ago> I have nothing but contempt for the developers that are writing these JS I have nothing but contempt for the companies that accept advertising from untrusted third parties who can offer no assurance as to the security or even the content of the code their platforms allow to run on client browsers. That doesn't even get into the tracking that the advertising platforms themselves have access to. Host your advertising yourself and I let it through with very little exception. If it comes from another server, it's blocked.