5 ms·
Today copyright protection is in fact much longer than 75 years in the US. For personal works, it's life of author + 70 years. So if you write a poem today and
by pavlov 11y ago
Today copyright protection is in fact much longer than 75 years in the US.
For personal works, it's life of author + 70 years. So if you write a poem today and live another 60 years, your poem will enter public domain in the year 2145.
For "works made for hire" (which includes most commercial works), the term of copyright is either 95 years from publication or 120 years from creation, whichever is shorter.
So the movie "Ant Man" will enter public domain in 2110... Assuming that the US Congress doesn't extend the deadline indefinitely (which the Supreme Court has permitted).
Law text: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/302 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/302
- danieltillett 11y agoNothing will ever enter the public domain while Winnie the poo is bringing in the billions.
- pavlov 11y agoSince long copyright term exists solely to protect media companies' IP brand families, there could be an exponential tax on copyright extension. The first nine years of copyright are free. After that, you pay $100 to renew for the tenth year. At year 20, the price is $1000 / year. At year 30, the price is $10,000 / year, which is still perfectly reasonable for profit-generating IP. The 70th year of copyright will cost a billion each year. At that price, it becomes a major board room decision whether to keep milking the same IP or rather come up with something new. The profits from this tax could go to culture and education, similar to what is done with gambling profits in many European countries that have a state-owned gambling monopoly.
- ChuckFrank 11y agoIdeas like this is what we need.
- richmarr 11y agoI'd like to upvote this twice.
- sireat 11y agoI am generally very anti-copyright ( I hold that ten- to twenty years should be enough for the creator/their family) but I really like this exponential tax proposal.
- phaemon 11y agoThat's an odd shifting of the Overton Window. I would generally think that someone who was anti-copyright would start from the position that copyright shouldn't exist at all. And that someone who was very anti-copyright would be actively protesting against the law.
- mcv 11y agoIt's a compromise. If copyright really is so important to your business model, then you can afford to pay for the extension. Once it stops bringing in money, it becomes public domain within a decade. As it is now, all art that does not generate money is forgotten and remains inaccessible forever.
- TillE 11y agoIn particular, there's a ton of interesting non-fiction (eg, niche history books containing original research) that's out of print but not out of copyright. Nobody benefits from this. If we had a reasonable "orphaned works" law, the internet could contain much much more useful information.
- nmrm2 11y agoOr, more likely, publishers would allow print-on-demand ordering of any book in their collection. Either way, it's win-win.
- kagamine 11y agoLife of the author unless the author dies within 20 years of start of initial copyright in which case immediate family can extend by 20 more years, giving offspring, spouse etc, a chance to gain income from a deceased's work. (i chose 20 years because that would be baby to adult in the case of offspring). Companies: 20 years then stfu. Remember, they can still sell their product, and they could come up with a scheme to mark it original or authentic, like wines and foods now do.
- notahacker 11y agoThe flip side of this is that the boardroom decision will come down to can the billion dollar tax be passed onto the consumer or competitors? If you apply that to some other forms of IP like patents, the answer is "quite possibly yes" The individual creative will relinquish copyright after 20 years, even if they're still hoping somebody might one day make a film out of their work and are kinda keen on having some sort of creative control. On the other hand, Disney will potentially still be shifting enough videos and merchandise to be renewing copyrights up to year 49. It's not exactly unprecedented for major studios to create high value brand families out of 20 year old books either, but in this case they'd rarely need to cut the author in on the profits. Other than the revenue raising potential, that actually seems worse than the current situation for skewing copyright in favour of the brand families.
- qznc 11y agoI like our german version "Urheberrecht". It is different from copyright because it cannot be transfered. Some comic character cannot be owned by a corporation which milks it for decades and centennials. An author can only give a licence to a company. I always wonder what really happens whenever I transfer copyright for my papers to some publisher. It probably has no effect here in Germany, but is it valid in the US? Then I also wonder if TTIP might change anything about this?
- fluidcruft 11y agoOh, please. That's a distinction without a difference unless you're saying that German authors can't hire legal representation or assistants and must actively negotiate and manage each license solo.
- mason55 11y agoThe distinction is that once the author dies the work falls into the public domain. For as long as they are alive they can license it to a company, and the company can defend it or do whatever, but when the owner dies the copyright dies with them.
- pjc50 11y agoIt's a great idea - if IP is property, it should be taxed like property - but then you realise how few places have a property tax because property-owning money dominates the political process.
- jameshart 11y agoAre those fees 'per work'? Is it one fee per episode of a TV show? One fee for every issue of the New York Times? You'd be incentivizing IP creators to combine as much content into one conceptual 'work' as possible. Bring it closer to home. Would it be one fee per source-file in, say, the Linux codebase? Much of that code is over 20 years old. When you modify one of those sourcefiles, you're creating a new derivative work which has its own copyright date and author, so do you need to pay to extend copyright on every version of every file, lest they fall into the public domain and then lose the protection of the GPL?
- Retric 11y agoEvery new update under GPL get's it's own copywrite date. So, having a 20 year old Linux codebase enter the public domain would do little.
- indymike 11y agoI like this thinking.
- fatman 11y agoI think this was Larry Lessig's position at one point. I think it's a a nice, practical solution that acknowledges that copyright is a political animal - let Disney keep Mickey forever, but the public gets everything of a lesser order of magnitude in value faster.
- cgriswald 11y agoThe problem with copyright is one of corruption, which a copyright tax does not solve. At the point of billion dollar renewals the board decision becomes, "How can we best spend our marketing and lobbying dollars to gain an exemption to or remove this tax?" It also is very imbalanced. The average IP holding corporation will be much more able to pay $1000 or $10000 fee to hold onto a copyright, as well as able to determine which copyrights will be profitable in the future. They are also better able to leverage marketing power to make content profitable more quickly. In contrast the average individual content creator is more emotionally attached to a work, less able to pay fees, and less able to market it effectively in order to make it profitable so he or she can afford the fees.
- mattlutze 11y agoPatents I can understand needing often to be shorter than they end up being, but personal copyright I'm not so disturbed by. When should people be able to publish derivative copies of For Whom the Bell Tolls on self-published Amazon accounts without royalties going to Hemingway's estate? Works made for hire, 100 years feels like a really long time.
- XorNot 11y agoBecause the idea that one individual - who is now long dead - can create a work that then should be protected for several generations of descendants is a wealth stratifier. What implicit societal value are it's modern beneficiaries creating that entitles them to that revenue?
- mattlutze 11y agoIt's social status and worth are that value. At creator's life + 75 years, the existing law is the lifetime, sort of, of the creator's offspring, not several generations. Should I be able to take his bibliography, self-pub it on Amazon with flashy covers and take the profits from it? I'm not sure.
- jo909 11y agoIf you are able to figure out how to make a profit with a public domain text, you are very entitled to them.
- mattlutze 11y agoIf he wrote the books half a lifetime ago? What's a reasonable time, then? 10 years? 20? From when it was published, or when it was written? It can take years for a manuscript to move through editing, and many of our beloved classics did terribly their first run or two. Is it anymore fair should a publishing house go all 90's Star Wars on works their stable of authors wrote a few decades after first publication, with the authors not seeing a penny from them? 75 to, what, 150 years may indeed be too much, but the answer is not so clear as to what the alternative should be.