4 ms·
One flaw comes to mind when the thought of using prizes to fund pure science is discussed. It's actually an issue that is even larger than prizes. The people w
by justin66 11y ago
One flaw comes to mind when the thought of using prizes to fund pure science is discussed. It's actually an issue that is even larger than prizes.
The people who go down the wrong path in science are often performing an important service. It is obvious enough that we cannot know beforehand how to solve all of science's hard problems (they wouldn't be hard problems...) and of course the people who don't succeed still need to be paid.
The other, maybe less immediately obvious thing, is that a person or group who demonstrates the ways a previously plausible line of thought just doesn't work is performing a valuable service. Progress in science depends on what they publish, even if their work ends up being a dead end.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoMy father researched semiconductors at Cornell his entire career. One time he told me of a way he and his colleagues envisioned producing semiconductors that would have radically shrunk the cost of solar panels. After months of research, they found that the physical realities simply did not permit the hypothesis to function. Dead end. In the eyes of Congress, this whole affair was a waste of money, but for every scientist with the same idea, it means one less path to waste time and money on.
- apo 11y agoIf the negative results weren't published, then it was a waste of money. Sadly, this happens all the time. Incentives in science publishing generally work against the publication of negative results. The publication-based economy lies at the heart of most of what's wrong with science today. It's not clear to what extent prize-based funding could change this culture. I'm not sure I agree with the size of the initial trial, but I do support experimenting with new models of government funding for science research.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThe results were published. Dad was disappointed that it didn't work but he was content to know that he saved someone else from trying the same.
- dwc 11y agoMore than that, I'm guessing that it also shone some light on those physical realities and therefore advanced the field in general. Maybe not in a big way, but much of science, technology and manufacturing is build of many small advances.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>It's not clear to what extent prize-based funding could change this culture. It'll make it worse.
- amelius 11y agoReproducing the work of others is also important in science.
- evanpw 11y agoNo one is suggesting that all grants be replaced by prizes. Even research projects which are ultimately unsuccessful are valuable and need to be paid for. But does it really seem like a bad idea to pay the research team a bonus at the end if they manage to actually _solve the problem_ definitively? And if we're already doing that, then why not also offer the bonus to everyone else who can solve the problem, regardless of whether we gave them a grant in the first place? This is a tiny fraction of the budget, and it seems to me like it's worth doing some experimentation to see what works.
- rebootthesystem 11y agoIf the results of taxpayer (not government, no such thing, it's our money) funded research is hidden behind paywalls and made difficult to use freely through patents the net effect is that we are bound to repeat many mistakes or waste a lot of time and money reinventing wheels invented and patented using our own money.